AA*** F8 June 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Paper was ok...I had time issues towards the end...couldnt write/explain many points that i knew :/ Will i pass ?
hopefully you will pass. hope for the best
I hope i will pass inshah allah
how else had issues finding deficiencies in the first question ?
benefit of audit document... cant recall during exam
that was easy 4 marks for me lol
what was that @ Ali ?
Straightforward enough.. Pretty easy and similar to previous paper..
Alot nicer than f7 :-)
documenting for audit evidence, for supporting audit evidence, supervising..directing and reviewing audit teams work...
i wrote all these points..hope they were enuf lol
foreign ex risks were good :)...but that dint pop up in my head while i was writing,,,
and regarding goods in transit...wasnt it mentioned in the qstn that they were recorded properly
paper was ok but couldnt have proper time management..
about the good in transit thing i dont think there was a risk as they specifically said that goods were recorded as received but i mention that the goods may be damaged since there is no evidence that the goods are checked when received which could overstate inventory figures and other audit risk i mentioned are- about revaluations, is the expert valuer qualified enough?
and does the accountant have experience and knowledge enough to do the proper accounting treatment since a revaluation affects various accounts.
also the increase in sales could be a manipulation by employees to obtain the bonus or they are selling products below cost price which could explain the sudden increase.
levels of receivables have also increased and some customers have been identified with credit concerns which means that there are no credit worthiness check which could results in a lot of bad debts thus misstating accounts.
and i forgot what i wrote more lol
doesnt business risk form part of audit risk? since inherent risk which can be considered as business risk x control risk x detection risk = audit risk
Paper was Easy I think but it was extremely lengthy, I really Hope to pass this paper with good marks Insha'allah
It was clearly stated in question 3 that goods are CORRECTLY recorded as received so there was no answer was there. However, the examiner is very lovely and this was the best F8 paper I have ever seen. Cheers to Pami Bahl, you are the best!
yea i agree with you maybe its her gift to us before the exams changes structure that is mcq based lol
hope f9 will b similar
however straightforward paper, cannot say anything further cause f8 is an unpredictable paper, u may be shocked when results are out
Wish everyone goodluck
Haha true her 'gift' to us, I wish she could also be the P7 examiner. I just love her and her answers. I didn't have any support, all I had was her answers and that helped me a lot.
All I had a problem with was question 4. The scenario on corporate governance was quite tricky. I wrote about the 'close friend' thing but don't know if it's right. It was quite tricky. Question 4 (a) was good.
Yap you are right. The more you think you are going to pass in F8, the less your chances are. I heard that from my lecturer, in the end it boils down to personal preparation.
@tommy they are both inter-related so this may not be a concern
and the definition of audit risk is the risk that the auditor expresses an audit opinion that the
financial statements are fairly presented when they are materially misstated.
yea the close friend relationship is an issue as non executive directors are expected to be independent and should challenge the board views. So if the friend is hired he may not be objective and independent as he may not want to tamper his relationship with his friend ,the chairman.
other cg issues i remember was that the finance director was responsible in determining the salaries of all directors including herself. the problem was that she could award herself and other directors huge remuneration package. So a remuneration committee should be set up to resolve this issue
the balance on the board was not right, the cg code state that at least half of the board should be neds and out of 8 , 3 only was ned
bonus of directors was based on profit which could be subject to manipulation, their bonus package should be related to performance such as using share options
the chairman was previously the chief executive. there is a lack of accountability since he weill be reviewing his own work
in q5 what were point that company was going concern or not going concen?not sure if i write the opposite
In Q5 one of the requirements was about audit opinion on the assumption made by the director about going concern.
I write that if the assumption is appropriate-modified opinion with emphasis of matter paragraph after the opinion paragraph.
If the assumption is not appropriate and director refused to make amendments - adverse or disclaimer of opinion, including basis of adverse/disclaimer opinion paragraph before the opinion paragraph.
Is that correct ?!
loss of major customer, loss of revenue
loss of specialists, cannot improve or launch new products thus difficult to compete in the market
shareholders not wanting to invest, further lack of funding
reputation risk due to customer incurring severe losses, losing other customers
the legal claim by the customer if successful could have adverse financial consequences on clarinet and one more i forgot
i thought the paper was fair, but time mgt, time mgt!
if i recall correctly the question asked what should be done if auditors find out that the going concern status is correct then i forgot the end of the question xD
Zubainrhira I think we have to write about audit procedures about going concern - analytical procedure, review cash flow forecast, review board minutes etc, but I am not sure.....
@rostica i think shes talking about last question which was worth 4 points
Ooo please excuse me!
Thank you icedawn:)
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

