AA*** F8 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@sarahblundell1985 said: the exam went so well for me i had about 45 mins to spare to check and double check answers... then only in the last ten minutes noticed there was a question 6 for 20 marks!!! did anyone else make this foolish mistake?! i think after a week of doing past papers that all only have 5 questions i wasnt expecting a 6! also the fact that the question isnt part of the booklet its on the back sheet! very frustrated with myself! mcq's i can remember: 1c 2c 3c 4a 5a 6b 7d 8c 9? 10? 11a 12aYour MCQ's and mine are pretty same !! :D
excellent news! :) feeling better already!
@sarahblundell1985 said: excellent news! :) feeling better already!Cool !! MCQ's were easy though !!
I found this exam to be pretty fair, i struggled with four factors influencing the audit evidence, but just used common sense to answer all questions. I spent too much time doing Q5 so left the audit procedures after identifying the deficiencies and recommendations.
Moved quickly to Q6 as had only 15 mins to answer it. answered it all as the question was divided into parts so easier to gain few marks in each part.
Overall the questions seemed to make me use more common sense and overall knowledge of Auditing than testing testing a particular topic in detail .
The results will decide how well i performed. I THINK i performed really well
OMG i am so glad, to see people getting C's! I was stressing out! I thought it was out of the ordinary lol
I put C on first 4 mcqs
The time pressure in this is ridiculous. 6 questions, q4 the question about the audit risks and responses took me AGES. It nearly killed me!! If I only I bothered doing a mock I would have copped to do questions 5 and 6 first :(
Basically if you don't do 5 and 6 first you are dead!!
Well not entirely but I reckon doing them in the wrong order cost me 15 marks minimum
Well guys for Question 6 my answers were like this (sorry for spelling mistaks)
6a) Reliability depends on whether information is: Written, Original, Obtained directly by Auditor and Entity controls over generating it.
b) Audit procedures before count: Review previous year instruction documentations, and inqure management regarding any significant changes in policies, determine whether Auditor Expert is required and to determine which locations to visit and from where returns or representations are required.
Audit procedures during count: Observe that counters adhere to polices, Conduct test counts, make sure that returns from sites not visited are obtained, conclude the value/condition of inventory to determine whether inventory in F/S is reasonable.
Procedures for Capitalising R$D: Inquire techincal stuff on their views aboyt feasbibilty of the projects, view budgets and management expertise, recalculate amortisation for project already commenced and other few procedures...
c) didn't answer out of time...
Mult choice:
- First three were Cs.
Nummer 4 was b I think as the changing sales mix may alter the gross profit margin. For example when you sell more high profit margin products than expected and only few low profit margin products.
Number 5 was b.
The last was c.
The auditor is never directly involved in counting of inventory to my understanding. What they do is perform audit procedures in order to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence so as to reduce the risk of material misstatement. The points I gave need good explanations to I guess. For example -ascertain that work in progress in separated from finished goods to facilitate correct valuation of inventory. Obtaining procedures and instructions for inventory count. Inspect the warehouse and ensure that inventory is marked and labelled before the count. To ensure that all there is no possibility of inventory missed. This procedure comesback during counting :for all inventory counted ensure that the counted shelves or places are marked as counted. In order to avoid double counting or missing certain lines......
@tinaboy said: The auditor is never directly involved in counting of inventory to my understanding. What they do is perform audit procedures in order to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence so as to reduce the risk of material misstatement. The points I gave need good explanations to I guess. For example -ascertain that work in progress in separated from finished goods to facilitate correct valuation of inventory. Obtaining procedures and instructions for inventory count. Inspect the warehouse and ensure that inventory is marked and labelled before the count. To ensure that all there is no possibility of inventory missed. This procedure comesback during counting :for all inventory counted ensure that the counted shelves or places are marked as counted. In order to avoid double counting or missing certain lines......I'm not saying your wrong you do have valid points of course ! but I guess u didn't notice there were no WIP !!
Hey guys, in the question about a company producing small fast moving items did you ask yourself why the research and development costs for the new production lines were capitalized and then amortized under intangible assets? What kind of intangible assets are these? I thought it was awekward!
It gave me hard time too. What made it ridiculous was identifying and explaining deficiencies, recommend controls and perform a test of controls. The only way to do it was to put a deficiency, control and test of control per paragraph until you reach six points
Maybe I missed it. I thought it said there was an immaterial work in progress. I don't remember. However I always give at least 2 extra procedures since there is no negative marking
@tinaboy said: Maybe I missed it. I thought it said there was an immaterial work in progress. I don't remember. However I always give at least 2 extra procedures since there is no negative markingThat's cool !!
Cheers buddy!
first 3 i put C
4th I put C as well (Thought increase trade discount may affect gross profit :(
last one cant remember I guess it was something like second option (Something called Batch reconl) and 4th option (cant remember)
deffo remember first choice was 1 and 4
Found the MCQ the hardest part of the paper. finished with 30 minutes remaining just going over everything again
How do ye remember the a b c d for the Mcqs do ye swipe the exam paper out of the exam Hall? Mine always gets taken off me?
@drice99 said: How do ye remember the a b c d for the Mcqs do ye swipe the exam paper out of the exam Hall? Mine always gets taken off me?noting down on hand i guess :p
therefore you have 15 minutes reading time to check how points are allocated, mate. :)
I remember first 6 Multiple choice questions and they were
1. C
2. C
3. C
4. A
5. A
6. B
7. B
:)
12. D
For question 5 audit risk!
One risk is that directors are determing assets useful live this should be checked by external valuer.
Depreciation charge has decreased risk of understatement so need to recalculate..
Reconciliation outstandings are immaterial by directors point of view so obtain reconciliation for arithmetical accuracy and reconcile it at year end to consider whether outstandings are cleared.
Charging Insurance cost (risk....) inquire management on what basis they think it is recievable and inspect after year end payments or correspondence regaring claims.
Hello all,
From my memory my answers were as follows:
1) I used the ASSIF mnemonic - I found that:
Familiarity due to playing at local tennis club and engaged with firm for 7 years. Requires a 2 year period to rest?
Self Interest - Contingent audit fees are against regulation and should be declined as they provide bias
Self Review - Valuation work at year end was to be reviewed by the same audit firm. They should consider using another partner to conduct the firm or decline the work overall. I guess this could all be seen as advocacy if it was also used to sell the WIP at any point.
b) I can't remember this question
2)
a) I took a punt and said if the shareholders ousted the audit firm then they should the engagement should be re-evaluated.
If a change of management meant the business had a new objectivity then the audit firm would need consider the new business practice and agree to a new engagement.
b)
I used the CREST mnemonic here when considering a new engagement. So that was the Criteria, Report, Evidence, Subject Matter and Third Party relationship. I seem have got this totally wrong as well!
3
a) Cash flow
Threats to going concern status (from what I remember in summary):
Customer facing financial hardship - small amount of key customers indicate that the business may face signifiant loss of revenue. Risk here.
Break down in relationship with Payables - Shorter credit periods and cash demands reduce the working capital cycle. As such the business was at risk of becoming insolvent due to extended periods of receivables and shorter payables. Without deep reserves to cover the losses in the short term, the business was facing difficulty. Appropriate risk here..
Contingent Court Case - Discuss with appropriate legal professionals to consider the likelihood of the outcome of the court case the fees required relating the ongoing litigation to defend against the claim. Risk here..
Forecasting - Figures were not for the next 12 months. I think they were 9 months and so should be extended to 12 months post the engagement.. Also failed to include the legal claims etc..
I can't remember the rest of the question!
4)
Audit Risks
Inventory - Located at many sites also selling magnets that seemed to be fashionable, potential they were overstated due to obsolesce.
Bonus related performance
Insurance provision
etc
5)
a) I thought there is a duty for the auditor to look into the direct impacts on the financial statements. Ultimately it is the managements reasonability to make sure it's all legit but I thought the auditor should evaluate if there are any penalties outlying that might indicate there is an impact on the financial statements??
b)
Deficiency
Friends and family discounts
Petty cash passcode and banking
Inventory order by restaurant manager
Tips
Payables, Purchases and Inventory accounting sent late
Recommendation
How to improve the above..
Test Of Control
A ToC using AEIOU
Any input on this would be great for peace of mind!
@dunkthefunk said: Hello all, From my memory my answers were as follows: 1) I used the ASSIF mnemonic - I found that: Familiarity due to playing at local tennis club and engaged with firm for 7 years. Requires a 2 year period to rest? Self Interest - Contingent audit fees are against regulation and should be declined as they provide bias Self Review - Valuation work at year end was to be reviewed by the same audit firm. They should consider using another partner to conduct the firm or decline the work overall. I guess this could all be seen as advocacy if it was also used to sell the WIP at any point. b) I can't remember this question 2) a) I took a punt and said if the shareholders ousted the audit firm then they should the engagement should be re-evaluated. If a change of management meant the business had a new objectivity then the audit firm would need consider the new business practice and agree to a new engagement. b) I used the CREST mnemonic here when considering a new engagement. So that was the Criteria, Report, Evidence, Subject Matter and Third Party relationship. I seem have got this totally wrong as well! 3 a) Cash flow Threats to going concern status (from what I remember in summary): Customer facing financial hardship - small amount of key customers indicate that the business may face signifiant loss of revenue. Risk here. Break down in relationship with Payables - Shorter credit periods and cash demands reduce the working capital cycle. As such the business was at risk of becoming insolvent due to extended periods of receivables and shorter payables. Without deep reserves to cover the losses in the short term, the business was facing difficulty. Appropriate risk here.. Contingent Court Case - Discuss with appropriate legal professionals to consider the likelihood of the outcome of the court case the fees required relating the ongoing litigation to defend against the claim. Risk here.. Forecasting - Figures were not for the next 12 months. I think they were 9 months and so should be extended to 12 months post the engagement.. Also failed to include the legal claims etc.. I can't remember the rest of the question! 4) Audit Risks Inventory - Located at many sites also selling magnets that seemed to be fashionable, potential they were overstated due to obsolesce. Bonus related performance Insurance provision etc 5) a) I thought there is a duty for the auditor to look into the direct impacts on the financial statements. Ultimately it is the managements reasonability to make sure it's all legit but I thought the auditor should evaluate if there are any penalties outlying that might indicate there is an impact on the financial statements?? b) Deficiency Friends and family discounts Petty cash passcode and banking Inventory order by restaurant manager Tips Payables, Purchases and Inventory accounting sent late Recommendation How to improve the above.. Test Of Control A ToC using AEIOU Any input on this would be great for peace of mind!except or CREST part which in my opinion doesn't answer the required question\? may be I'm wrong !
CREST was invalid
rest very similar to mine!
i use reading time for the mcq, it was enough time to finish it, then i have more time for writing questions, just finished on time. The mcq answers i wrote on my hand, i think half of them may correct, f8 is the exam that more difficult than you think, hope finally can pass this time.
1,c 2,c 3,c 4,b 5,a 6, b 7,d 8,b 9,a 10,c 11,a 12,b
guyss!! could anybody tell me what are the six factors for the engagement letter ? thx
engagement letter i got:
- basis of fees
- auditors responsibilities
- management responsbililities
- need for use of entity internal audit team & other staff
- timings (interim & final audit)
- the requirement for representations from management
@arman90fy said: guyss!! could anybody tell me what are the six factors for the engagement letter ? thxAuditor responsibility Management responsibiilty Applicable Reporting frame work Nature Objective and Scope of Engagement Communication medium between auditor nad mangement any letter submitted by auditor to managment... its reference I guess if I'm not wrong anybody CONFIRM!!!
@sarahblundell1985 said: engagement letter i got: - basis of fees - auditors responsibilities - management responsbililities - need for use of entity internal audit team & other staff - timings (interim & final audit) - the requirement for representations from managementGR8 it was for 6 marks right??
mcqs options
1 c
2 c
3 c
4 a
5 a
6 b
7 c
8 a
9 a
10 c
11 b
12 a
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

