AA*** F8 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Thought they went pretty well...
Can somebody confirm me question 3 ( all parts)
Going concern??
Stupidly spent more time on the 10 mark questions than the 20 ones. Had 13 minutes to do question 6.Ridiuclous. Still probably passed but I didn't make it easy for myself .
Mcqs maybe 14 marks on lowside
10 mark Qs maybe 25 marks on low side
20 mark Qs maybe 16 marks on low side
Overall maybe 55 at least
Was there any question regarding understanding entity and its environment?:(
There was understanding entity, the technology company, it was a new client so permanent audit file not an option... I said I would contact the old auditor.
Going concern was asses reasonableness of cash flow estimates, examine board minutes etc etc
Aww I mentioned permanent audit file, previous year financial statement, Internet, previous year audit team and engagement partner
except for permanent file all are relevant... u will definitely check previous year statments.. internet website and also publication etc.. thats really how you will understand entity..
Sounds like you nailed the rest of the options ;)
What did ye do to the opinion in question 6 at the end? I modified it qualified.. Except for.. I didnt think it was pervasive?
you never know it's subjective paper
couldn't answer that out of time.. what about 6th part b? before counting and after.?
my first MCQ's were C and there were a lot of C's
Pretty fair exam I thought:
MCQ's can't remember! Thought they were okay.
Q1: Threats to Independence.
Went for Familarity (7 years)
Self Interest (Profit Shares)
Self Review (Completing reviewing/WIP
Few points about other things Internal Audit can do.
Q2:
State reasons to change an Engagement letter.
Went for change of fees and a takeover.
Six parts of an engagement letter for 3 marks.
5 ways of understanding a new client.
Review Previous FS, Audit report, Controls of client, Website and something else:
Q3: Going Concern.
5 reasons they were not a GC, pretty straightforward lots to go at.
5 audit procedures again thought that was Okay. Check bank terms, check how possible the obsolete sales is with lawyers.
Q4: Audit risks
Said how they were mistating the insurance possibly, check to see how the scrap value is accounted correctly, how directors get a bonus on profits and others,
Q5:
Six deficinces with test of control and responses. Said about Cash not banked enough, Reports not sent to head office, Too many people can open safe, No receipts for petty cash purchaes, Inventory didn't match and one more
Q6:
Reliability of evidence - How external is better, depends on various factors.
Inventory Audit procedures, research and development AP too.
Then effect on Audit report:
Would be a modified report, modified opinion.
Qualified opinion except for... Intangible mistatement. Material however not pervasive.
Use a paragraph in report to state this etc.
For question one... Self-interest threat- low fees.... (lowballing) again Self interest threat (contingency fees as it will be linked to Profit before tax) and self review threat valuation and there was also familiarty threat but didn't include that.
I also stupidly spent much time on 10 mark questions.
If I luckily pass with 50,then F8 would be my most fortune exam
Before counting involved organisation of inventories, marking and labelling, separating any damaged, obsolete from the rest, obtaining a list of counting procedures and instructions from management, obtaining pre numbered inventory sheets etc
@tinaboy said: Before counting involved organisation of inventories, marking and labelling, separating any damaged, obsolete from the rest, obtaining a list of counting procedures and instructions from management, obtaining pre numbered inventory sheets etcisn't management suppose to do that??? except for obtaining instructions
its material but not pervasive. i guess.
so modified qualified opinion.
The time pressure for this paper was unexpected and surprising. Before I knew what was happening, I had run out of time without even reading two of the Section B questions. If I had managed my time better, I would have been happier with my performance. My advice to future candidates - for section B, you probably will be better off if you start with the two 20 marks questions.
Chris, I suggested a qualified opinion. I don't agree with the director 's opinion that $980, 000 was immaterial. Whether it is material or not, I depended on the fact that there was no evidence of pervasiveness. Therefore I thought it was a modified report with a qualified opinion
@ehsanshah said: isn't management suppose to do that??? except for obtaining instructionsYes the auditor observes and checks, enquires and does test counts,the client does the actual counting, organising and labelling
It's pretty easy for those who did past years. My advice is to understand the question structure. I think it went well for me. I was nervous that would run out of time. Thankfully that was not the case
MQC - i found them easy, got lots of Cs too
Q6) it is material not pervasive, similar issue is in BPP practice kit.
lots of questions around inventory, quite annoying.
overall it was a standard exam. no surprise I would say. :)
@drice99 said: Yes the auditor observes and checks, enquires and does test counts,the client does the actual counting, organising and labellingI said how: Review Past years before the audit to see the common mistakes errors Review stocktakes during the year to ensure the adjustments posted Observe the stocktake Recalculate a sample etc Things like that
I couldn't answer the question about how auditor should consider laws and regulations DIRECTLY affect the financial statement. I think the fact that the word directly was highlighted made me think that there must be something very special :(
there was a question about, the responsibility of the auditor regarding compliance with laws and how that affect the f/s??
@karinaq said: I couldn't answer the question about how auditor should consider laws and regulations DIRECTLY affect the financial statement. I think the fact that the word directly was highlighted made me think that there must be something very special :(Just stated that auditor responsibiltiy is to obtain sufficient appropraite evidence regarding compliance with Laws and regualtions that have direct effect on FS !
the exam went so well for me i had about 45 mins to spare to check and double check answers... then only in the last ten minutes noticed there was a question 6 for 20 marks!!! did anyone else make this foolish mistake?! i think after a week of doing past papers that all only have 5 questions i wasnt expecting a 6! also the fact that the question isnt part of the booklet its on the back sheet! very frustrated with myself!
mcq's i can remember:
1c
2c
3c
4a
5a
6b
7d
8c
9?
10?
11a
12a
i struggled with that question too.
good thing is, its only for 2 marks.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

