FR*** F7 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
I am really struggling to understand why everyone is so caught up on the multiple choice questions.... What is done is done and cannot be changed. Enjoy your time off from studying until the results are published... surely?
Perhaps because we're keen to ascertain whether we've passed or not and attempt to "score" ourselves. I have commenced study on F6 and F9 today in preparation for December sittings as I still feel confident enough to have passed but if I could see the MCQ's again this would provide more clarity. Judging by the amount of responses on this subject Chris, I'd suggest I'm not alone...surely?
Agree with Chris (baby) than Chris (suit), appreciate folks like to vent their frustrations on her re the exam, but the real value added is when the answers are released and you can assess whether you've passed or not.
Did exact same process with F9, which gave me some assurance that I'd passed.
Come on ACCA, we want some consistency and the release of the answers.
Having said that I'm sure we could figure out the answers by referring to textbooks/internet, can't say I'm that keen to sort myself though...
Couldn't agree more Guy. I just think it's really poor show by ACCA by virtue of us even having to spend time wondering why MCQ's aren't released. My BPP distance learning tutor seemed to think they (the ACCA) were stopping this to prevent the same questions arising in future years. All seems like guesswork to me when all we require is definitive guidance. Doesn't seem to much to ask for all the hundreds of hours we put into this.
PS - I think all this confusion over the depreciation charge has been blown out of proportion having reviewed the question. I think most of the information on the TNCA was for Cash Flow requirements part of the question.
I still maintain that dep'n for the year was simply 85/5 = 17. They were just telling us no equipment older than 4 years of age to ensure no confusion over residual values etc. In actual fact, this seemed one of the more simple TNCA sections of any ACCA paper for some time with them adding the curve ball of Cash Flows into the equation.
Just my thoughts though and I'm still happy i put 17k in for depn!
I did exactly the same but was confused Howcome the balance didn't agree with the $4200 in the trial balance ?
@chris1975z said: PS - I think all this confusion over the depreciation charge has been blown out of proportion having reviewed the question. I think most of the information on the TNCA was for Cash Flow requirements part of the question. I still maintain that dep'n for the year was simply 85/5 = 17. They were just telling us no equipment older than 4 years of age to ensure no confusion over residual values etc. In actual fact, this seemed one of the more simple TNCA sections of any ACCA paper for some time with them adding the curve ball of Cash Flows into the equation. Just my thoughts though and I'm still happy i put 17k in for depn!I think that's pretty much it Chris. I think the confusion was it included a lot of information, all I did was break the assets down into 3, items 1 2 and Remaining, think I made a slight miscalculation but still hope to get most marks. Going through Q1, 2 and 3 depending how well my written is which is difficult to mark don't think I dropped many more than 10-15 so I think I'm fairly certain I've passed, better than the debacle F9 exam. Can't see assets worth more than 2 marks as there was lots of other things do do, the beauty of a published accounts question. In hindsight, I actually thought this was a pretty fair paper, it's really disappointing about the MCQ's as I'm hopeful I've got 15/20 on these as I thought they nicer than previous paper. I may email my tutor and see what they say too. Good luck for F6 and F9 (just done F9, the MCQ's were ridiculously tough) are you doing the September sitting?
@alexanderrobert1989 said: Curious to know if anyone can balance the q3 on here. Seems the fair value adjustments and operating lease prepayment are tripping me up when I try to rebalance the question? Just to confirm most people added the 4000 provision onto the plant getting 18000, then deviding that by 5 gave the depreciation. 14400 plant 4400 provision 400 finance cost 3600 depWhy is the plant 14,400? Should it not be 4000 x1/1.08 to the power of 5? Double entry between Environmental Provision and Finance Costs. Whilst the plant is depreciated at 18,000/5 leaving 3,600 per year.
Hi James
Thanks for your comments - I'm sitting the F6 and F9 in December. Learning material for the online distance learning courses for Sept sitting aren't available until beginning of July and that's just way to quick turnaround (2 months) for a paper for me! I'd rather have 5 month lead in to F6 and F9.
I think the comments above in respect of environmental provision above are more complicated that I worked out! The question states it's already at it's present value (i.e. the $4M is already discounted at 1st April 2014 but no finance charge yet). Therefore, £4m x 8% is $320,000 - and as James rightly states, journal between finance charge and provision for unwinding of this discount.
That's how I went about it. In the past they've usually wanted a student to ascertain the prevent value discounted for future cash flows - on this occasion it was given to us. Just my thoughts.
PS - Did anyone get an EPS figure? From memory I had 17.7c?
Like James, still not sure where you get $14,400 for plant. The question says the provision has been accounted for properly. In other words, included in the $85m cost at 1.4.14 is the asset and capitalised provision. The double entry for the initial provision of this nature would be;
Dr TNCA
CR Provision
with the present value of future cash flows (in this case $4M).
Each year you then just charge depn on the asset and unwind the discount (thus increasing provision). Therefore, depn remains per my initial comment - 85k/5 = 17k. I didn't split the asset pool as no need to do so. All info was for cash flow part of question later on in the "wordy" parts.
I see what you mean in splitting down the asset pool now Robert - I would have come to the same if I'd broken it down into the existing pool and individual assets so that looks good to me?
The question stated the provision had correctly been account for - in other words it was already incorporated in the 85m cost b/fwd. You've added another 4m on top - the only adjustment required was finance cost - you've doubled up on the 4m provision in my opinion. As you say, at max 1 mark dropped I'd suggest.
If I am being completely honest (and I hate to say it), I thought the exam was pretty fair. Going by all my exam preperation using previous papers it was relatively standard. I was gutted that there was no cashflow question and had to leave the potential 4 marks for a cashflow on question 3 as it was hemeridging my time.
The only adjustment I would have LOVED to have seen is Question two having either less marks on interpretations or being a cashflow question. When it comes to interpretaions I have a tendancy to write a model answer... Then find that very little of what I have written is even close to the model answer lol.
Fair exam paper in my opinion. So if I don't pass I will be kicking myself!
how did you all account for the investments through p&l ? :)
The MCQ's were definitely tough - there was too much workings to do which took up a lot of your time - time which could have been spent on the section b questions. Question 3 was a killer - I didn't do well in this area because time ran out.
Very disappointed with this paper
@alexanderrobert1989 said: So basically instead of me taking the full value of 85k and dividing by 5. I worked out each individual PPE for my workings. Plant and Provision = 18000/5= 3600 Finance Lease = 8000/5= 1600 Remaining PPE = 63000/5= 12600 So the total I got was 17800. Based on what you have been saying James it looks like maybe the provision was included. So our difference is 800. 17800 vs 17000 Hopefully it wont be too much of a problem but alot of past exams have never included the provision in PPE so went with my gut in the exam.Actuallly, this is how I went about doing this. I got the 3,600 and 1,600 as I also assumed the 14m was the cash cost for the purchase and the 4m we had to add so I got $18,000/5. My problem was I did: 85,000 - 18,000 - 8,000 and for some reason did reducing balance on the last bit so only had a depreciation charge of 8,000 for remaining plant! But I agree with 17,000 as Chris had got. Again, my prediction is 2 marks for Assets so I'd imagine Robert and myself would get 1.5/2 so not really an issue.
@lauracam said: how did you all account for the investments through p&l ? :)Cr TNCA 6500 Dr P/L Investment Income 500. B/FWD was 6,000 with an income of 500. Leaving a CV of 6,500 and a gain in P/L
@alexanderrobert1989 said: James, Yeah I agree you are probably right but you just don't have time to second guess in this exam. On another note, How did you deal with the £5000 in the suspense account? Can you remember how you dealt with the investments through the P&L/B.S And finally did you expense the full 2k through PandL for Op. Lease and create a prepayment in CA? Thanks, RobWith the suspense account, I credited suspense and Dr Loan Notes, reducing the loan. In the exam I did: B/Fwd Loan notes 20000 8% Interest 1600 Less Repayment (5000) Dr of 2 x 800 to Finance Costs. In the exam, I rushed this so I think it is partially wrong, but I again would imagine 1 out of 1.5 perhaps.
@chris1975z said: The question stated the provision had correctly been account for - in other words it was already incorporated in the 85m cost b/fwd. You've added another 4m on top - the only adjustment required was finance cost - you've doubled up on the 4m provision in my opinion. As you say, at max 1 mark dropped I'd suggest.I think I overcomplicated the Finance Cost! Again, the unwinding is worth 1 mark (half for finance cost and half for provision) For some reason I did 1/1.08 to the power of 5 to get the present value in today's terms, dividing by 5. I got 200 something. Still as there's so many adjustments, it is not an issue making small mistakes as we'll each still get 18/19-23 for everything else, these adjustments which we are querying are worth few marks as I'd anticipate most of the steps have been done correctly meaning a 3/4 marks tops lost.
Just had a quick look at Q3, my predicted marks for each are:
Revenue 1/2 Mark
Cost of Sales 3
Admin 1/2
Distribution 1/2
Tax 1.5
Finance Costs 3
SOCIE:
S.Cap: 1m
S.Premium: 1m
R.Earnings: 1m
SFP:
Assets 2
Inventory 1/2
Payables 1/2
R'ables 1/2
Overdraft 1/2
Loan Notes 1.5
Enviromental provision 1.5
Leases 1.5
Deferred Tax 1/2
Operating Lease 1
There's one mark in the balance sheet not allocated but I'd say that's a rough guide you can use to calclulate marks for the question. I've got to around 18-20, even though I felt I made some really silly mistakes you can gain more marks than you think in my opinion.
Regarding investment through P/L.
Opening – 6000
Sold – 1400
Closing – 4600 but closing at FV 6500, thus surplus 1900 goes to P/L as well as income (300 dividends, 200 profit on sale)
@sis00 said: Regarding investment through P/L. Opening – 6000 Sold – 1400 Closing – 4600 but closing at FV 6500, thus surplus 1900 goes to P/L as well as income (300 dividends, 200 profit on sale)Isn't it just 500 to investment income, 6500 to NCA? The sale information was for the cashflow I thought as it was a 200 gain with 300 dividends received, therefore investments have gone up 500.
I agree with James on investment income. What happened in year is irrelevant in respect of closing balance as it's simply $6.5M - given to us!! The movement in the year is for the cash flow part of the question only. It already tells us the movement on the $1.4m to $1.6M has been recorded in investment income too. In other words - nothing needs doing with it as it's been recorded correctly.
I am with you right there Chris .
Hi All,
i'm actually just looking for a bit of advice here in relation to potentially having to sit F7 for a THIRD time. i'm hoping I passed it 2nd time round but just in case I didn't...I'm just already thinking ahead slightly and deciding whether it's best to re sit in September and maybe start through questions and revision in about a month just to prepare (as a just in case) or just attend classes again and properly repeat this from scratch and sit in Dec. Has anyone else had to sit this 3 times in an attempt to just pass the damn thing?
Also, has anyone else just studied this themself at home? This time round as I was repeating it I decided not to go to classes and do it myself at home (my course was paid upfront by employer so e ach time I repeat it's taken from my allocation).
Any suggestions anyone?
Hi Erin, i have sat it 3 times, and it doesn't get any easier, its a joke!!! i think its one of the toughest papers on the course and at this stage I seem to have a mental block with it, so much is throw at you in the exam and as someone else said they just try and trick you instead of testing your knowledge, its so dishearting. I thought the paper in December was better and i got 47% so i'm not sure about this attempt and could gauge it better if i knew where i stood with the MCQ's. This is my final paper having passed all my professional stage papers first attempt, you would think if i passed P2 that F7 would be easy but its not??? I would advice you to resit the paper in September but hopefully you will pass. I think its all about luck on the day of the exam and time is crutical. I really put in the effort this time having done the mock exam and QBR sessions and no amount of extra study would have made any bit of difference. I think this is a hard one to study at home yourself but if you have gone to evening lectures before i don't think there is much point in paying for the course again, just do the revision and practise question after question. best of luck Erin and glad I'm not the only one struggling to pass this paper.
Dear Chris i will salute you if you got that right .you had to obtain a correct earnings figure from profit or loss first before you can think of any correct EPS.i think correct number of shares ,THERP and bonus fraction were enough to boost a couple of credits.
@michelleberry28 said: Hi Erin, i have sat it 3 times, and it doesn't get any easier, its a joke!!! i think its one of the toughest papers on the course and at this stage I seem to have a mental block with it, so much is throw at you in the exam and as someone else said they just try and trick you instead of testing your knowledge, its so dishearting. I thought the paper in December was better and i got 47% so i'm not sure about this attempt and could gauge it better if i knew where i stood with the MCQ's. This is my final paper having passed all my professional stage papers first attempt, you would think if i passed P2 that F7 would be easy but its not??? I would advice you to resit the paper in September but hopefully you will pass. I think its all about luck on the day of the exam and time is crutical. I really put in the effort this time having done the mock exam and QBR sessions and no amount of extra study would have made any bit of difference. I think this is a hard one to study at home yourself but if you have gone to evening lectures before i don't think there is much point in paying for the course again, just do the revision and practise question after question. best of luck Erin and glad I'm not the only one struggling to pass this paper.Erin, Michelle F7 is one of those papers which is a question based paper, like you've said it's just question practice. For me, having sat the exam last week, I feel it is all about proforma layout and taking the easy marks where possible. Such as on the published accounts we're told not to waste time adding up, working out gross profit or profit and I feel we had various other little tips which meant the exam wasn't time pressured at all. Once the proforma is laid out, do the profit (make a figure of 10,000) retained earnings and the tax. The proforma and those take approximately 5-10 minutes and you have perhaps 7-8 marks there and have 40 mins+ to work on the other adjustments. I study through Kaplan and to be fair I think they are superb with the in classroom teaching, if I pass that'll be the reason. If you need any tips, I'll be happy to help with any queries, I can email if need be and best of look to you both!
I totally agree with your comments @andrewmc
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

