FR*** F7 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@jamesuk19 said: Discounted the 12,635 at 1/1.1 power of 2, got A in that answer I think.For assets I broke them down into item 1 (new plant) and item 2 (finance lease) depreciated those separately over the lifespan, then took the rest remaining and depreciated a fifth.Q3 - I have done the same. I had to read multiple times the last part of note iii)..why, oh why, do they have to play so much with the English language... The operating lease - total failure... I took 1.000 as a current asset...as it was a prepaid expense and i have expense in the Finance costs the other 1.000. Anybody can asses the number of marks on that one? I know the tax i calculated correct. Thank you Sir Mike!
Tax was 3,400 - 200 + movement in DTax which was something x 20% less b/f DTax?
@gdjay said: Yes on insurance, surely that implied its already provided for so no adjustment required. I put that down too.Good. Do you remember the NCI question at all? I think I put C for Q2.
@gianina said: I have added some additional figures per above. I did not impair the GW since the question asked for the GW at aquisition...i hope.. *with the rush of finishing everything i probably forgot what my name was if you would have asked me during the exam :|*Yeah it was def goodwill at acquisition. I can't remember much else but I remember the goodwill - it was the last point in the exam I felt confident!!
Yes, goodwill at acqn
Seperate extracts for Revenue, COS, Finance Cost and NCI share profit.
I presumed impairment loss to went admin costs - which wasnt one of the requested extracts
hi did any one get a current tax for year in P&L receivable rather than payable?
and how did you treat the borrowing costs that needed to be capitalised under IFRS?
i adjusted the FV of net assets at acqn to include 3 months capitalised borrowing costs.
I reduced finance cost by the remainder of the years capitalised borrowing costs which carried into my finance cost extract
Doh! I missed the capitalised net assets on acquisition part thanks for your reply
It was a from memory!
Substance over legal is faithful representation? I need to see questions again as can't even remember mcq 1 now!!!!
I did not include borrowing costs in the FV adjustments since the question said that it should be capitalised in March 2015 - such an ambiguous paper with so many ways to confuse the student.
q3 was a disaster! i mean finance lease premium?.. and yea q2 5 marks for 8 ratios with adjustments! what the heck was he thinking
Tax was current estimate £3400
Over provision -120
Increase in deffer tax 300
Pl £2900
CL 3400
NCL deffer tax 1200*25%= 3000
Finance lease premiums come up a lot in bpp distance learning. Haven't seen a prepayment adjust for years (operating lease) if it all. Seems like examiner wanted to test assumed knowledge on that. Very different paper to those that have gone before. Not one construction contract either which surprised me. Lots of curve balls thrown in and I'll be interest to see overall pass % for this sitting!!
@chris1975z said: Substance over legal is faithful representation? I need to see questions again as can't even remember mcq 1 now!!!!Sounds right.
Imad, the tax liability for the year was 3400, pretty sure this is right based on question practice so you have calculated tax paid in p&l incorrectly.
A said legal over substance which is not faith rep
@chris1975z said: Substance over legal is faithful representation? I need to see questions again as can't even remember mcq 1 now!!!!
@ Chris... though the ROSE as you said was tricky, but i think the answer to your question is $7m i.e. $8m selling price less the gain of $1m.
Seriously I'm fed up of this paper... Q3 was a total disaster...hoping to scape 50%..
Wasn't the statement the exact opposite: Legal over substance? That is why I didn't choose A as an answer.
@chris1975z said: Substance over legal is faithful representation? I need to see questions again as can't even remember mcq 1 now!!!!
Yep, it said legal over substance.
MCQ were fine but some of them are awful for just 2 marks... Lots of calculations... I practised so many past papers and literally all questions from the revision kit and still believe this paper was insane.
@itgel said: Wasn't the statement the exact opposite: Legal over substance? That is why I didn't choose A as an answer.
@jamesuk19 said: For the adjusting events I selected B. You wouldn't adjust for an insurance claim settled in the year after? I think so anyway.My logic for the insurance claim is that you don't provide for an income unless you are virtually certain you will receive it? God.. this new format. It's like you have to read the examiner's mind. We're just given figures with little information and they want us to decide what to do with it. I thought the framework says as accountants we should make things more understandable? If in our audit working papers we wrote info down the same way the examiner does, who would understand any of it? What about the cash flows for the impairment question in the MCQ? Was it cash flows for that period or the period after the year end? F**k.
I feel very dissapointed and being treated unfair. This exam was not like other past papers, mcqs were very tricky and demanded a great deal of reading the task, which was time consuming. Q3 was very overwhelmingly complicated, and I also first time saw the lease premium concept.
Will be resitting for sure, have to study more of a complex questions. Would be great if open tuition could support in this case by devoting more workshops on q3 type questions.
one of the most difficult papers i have come across u can study but getting into an exam and seeing what i saw yestadae was just a joke, paper was just extracts ,extracts goshhhhh
That exam sucked balls
I am with you on this one... I got through the paper ok actually (multiple choice was hard) I got to question three and I poo'ed myself! I couldn't work out the depreciation to start off with. The wording of the question was very strange, I tried to do the Profit or loss and then I attempted the changes in equity to try to gain some valuable marks but like the majority of the people on this forum, I think it shall be a re-take unfortunately.
This exam was very hard compared to december 2014 past paper which i practised and scored quite well. The MCQ question was so confusing and seemed to have 2 correct answer of which now you'd have to guess the correct one. Q3 was realy hard considering the time presure we had and all of its requirments not to mention the confusing notes. The one for NCA said that 'depreciation should be charged on a straight line basis asuming the asset had 5 years useful life. No asset is more than 4 years old' what was it with that last part? Were we suppose to calculate depreciation for the other ppe by dividing the acumulated depreciation of 19000 by 4? Or the cost by 5? Crap. It was too confusing...
MCQs consume too much time
assume all PPE is depreciated on straight line basis over life of 5 years and no PPE is more than 4 years old..... it took me ages to understand what the hell this means....tried dividing accumulated dep by 4...got a wierd no....finally screwed up by depreciating the balance of PPE (after deducting cost of two new items) in trial bal amount over 4 years....
Can't help but feel the straight line depreciation requirement was an error by the question setter, as many have said on here for the life of me I can't see how it's possible to calculate accurately without the historic cost detail.
Should hope ACCA see the error of their ways and award a mark just for calculating depreciation excluding the additions, as that's all you could do! Really threw me in the exam too tying to figure a way of doing it, so frustrating.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

