Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FR*** F7 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments***

Oopentuition13y ago
Post your comments about December 2012 F7 exam.

Please vote in our Instant Poll
*** F7 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments*** poll results



Please note: The ACCA has requested that no postings must be made in this forum before 15:00 GMT on the day of the exam - any postings before this time will be deleted.
Remember that you are studying for a professional qualification - do not make postings that are abusive or threatening. Anyone breaking this rule may be reported to the ACCA disciplinary committee.
Former userFormer user13y ago#61
suni6419, I did the same with realised surplus on depreciation, credit 1mil Retained earnings and debit Revaluation Surplus.

I see that a lot of people calculated goodwill of 6mil USD. I had 5.55mil USD. I believe, contingent liability should be disregarded. It does not have any effect on the balance sheet and this information should only be disclosed as a note to finanacial statements.

In general I think the exam was quite easy. I even managed to close the balance sheet and it has never happened during my preparation to the exam.

Hope we will all pass;-)
Former userFormer user13y ago#62
Look, the contingent liability is not even a valid item of statements, it is a disclosure in the notes, and on the other hand, it is a liability, and you have to deduct the ASSETS against the consideration paid, and not liabilities. In that case, you should add the Cont Liab.... No?
Former userFormer user13y ago#63
:)) Actually, I think it was not very fair, because, a time-pressured exam like this should not include items that require heavy thinking and dual-interpretation. For instance, now when I m home, I could figure out that discounting the deferred consideration for 9 months was a silly mistake, but I would not be able to do so in the exam room, in panic and hurry
Former userFormer user13y ago#64
were we suppose to deduct impairment when calculating goodwill
Former userFormer user13y ago#65
But do you deduct all liabilties, when calculating goodwill? I also do not think, that the company takes into consideration contingent liabilities or assets, when agreeing what should be paid. No one wants to pay for something, what is uncertain.
But I might be wrong, since I am in the minority..;)
Rrebsta13y ago#66
A contingent liability is always recognised in an acquisition, as long as there is a reliable estimate of amount. This wasn't in the book, I found it in a previous exam question... which I got wrong!

A transfer of realisation of revaluation is just transferred from one to the other...through equity I think? Also not in the book (BPP).

obiora06 - the goodwill question was 'on acquisition' so no impairment was deducted for part A.

I couldn't balance the Q2. I spent about 1/2 an hour just looking at the figures, couln't work out how it was so wrong... Then realised I had put the Equity asset into equity (It's an asset.... it should be with the assets), so I moved it but then ended up with a negative revaluation on financial assets through equity... then I ran out of time, but the SFP was only out by $1,500 then... Does anybody know the proper treatment for the Financial Asset? It's gonna bug me :(
Jjodianww13y ago#67
Seriously, this paper was so easy, especially question 3, calculate ratios, do an analysis and comment on the limitations. I was so happy with the paper i froze. :( I am hoping i can get 50. But no surprises on the paper or anything. I couldn't remember a lot of stuff that i really knew.
Former userFormer user13y ago#68
I don't think impairment was meant to be deducted as we were asked to calculate goodwill at acquisition and the impairment was in the post acquisition period
Ttriniaccountant13y ago#69
Well well...either this paper was too easy to be true or I missed out a lot of things I should have done cause I finished with 15mins to spare which I took back to question 2 cause I had run out of time for that q. I forgot the associate share of profit and couldn't balance so "ratched" a fig. for retained earnings so that it balanced...softly chuckled to myself in the exam room cause of this. :p
"Done bun can't be undone" so...
I am simply hoping for a pass!! :(
Former userFormer user13y ago#70
Did the split for impairment when calculating goodwill. 90% and 10%.
Former userFormer user13y ago#71
Q1 I initially calculated by splitting 90% and 10%, after realising i was getting a negative goodwill for NCI, I didn't want to confuse myself further, so did it again by combining them together, anw the question is asking for a consolidated goodwill. Took out the contingent liability in my opinion that a company shld be prudent. Answer was the same as what some mentioned 6000.

Q2 was driving me nuts especially the 1st adjustment. My mistake to spend so much time trying to find out the right Dr Cr. In the end i took out 600x3 years and the profit of 25% out of the sales and made a provision for servicing(i thought it was similar to warranty). Revaluation reserve was 18mil, of which 2 was for land. I also calculated depre based on the new F/V. Added a line in Statement of changes in equity to show the transfer from RR to retained earnings. not sure if this is what they want. didnt balance as usual.

Q3) was relatively easy, but i think i wasn't well prepared. I did this question last.

Q4) construction contract, change is accounting estimate should be treated prospectively. so i used Rev method to calculate the percentage of completion, not sure if i did this right though...

Q5) first 2 parts on the I/S and SFP was too easy i couldn't believe they are giving marks for free! didnt have time to finish the last 4 marks though :(

*cross fingers*
Ddan1liy13y ago#72
The goodwill answer should be before impairment, since they want g/w on acq. I think I got 8 and pointed this out in my answer, and then separately showed impairment. Otherwise I can't think why else they were giving us the impairment amount.
Not sure if Q 5 was as easy as everyone says. Did you amortize the gov. grant?
Former userFormer user13y ago#73
@dan1liy said:
The goodwill answer should be before impairment, since they want g/w on acq. I think I got 8 and pointed this out in my answer, and then separately showed impairment. Otherwise I can't think why else they were giving us the impairment amount.
Not sure if Q 5 was as easy as everyone says. Did you amortize the gov. grant?


shouldn't we be amortizing over the useful life of the asset? I think i got 1200 per year. Showed in my SOCI as grant amortised and in SFP the reduction.
Ddan1liy13y ago#74
Yes, that's what I did too
Ooluwamayomiwa13y ago#75
WAS ANYBODY ABLE TO BALANCE ASSET AND TOTAL EQUITY AND LIABILITIES IN THE BALANCE SHEET STATEMENT IN QUESTION 2 AS THE ADJUSTMENTS WERE MUCH?
Former userFormer user13y ago#76
I think Statement of financial position was balance at $171400 in question # 2. Goodwill was something around THREE THOUSAND SOMETHING.
Former userFormer user13y ago#77
@mansari 171400 u also got dat....sign of relief...transfer of revaluation was treated in a past question,Q5 was tough 4 mi may be cos i had lyk 2minutes to read n answer d question.Q3 did anyone comment about the development cost(an asset in the SOFP) for the examiner to put a note on dat item i guess it must be relevant
Ssuni641913y ago#78
@mansari... even i got SOFP assets side as $171400. what we had to write about ratio limitations?
Ssuni641913y ago#79
do we need to take contingent liability in goodwill calculation at acquisition?
Former userFormer user13y ago#80
Contingent liability might result in increase of goodwill but should be shared in NCI increase as well.
Bban12313y ago#81
I did at least 25 practice examples for consolidation, and none of them had that cont. liab. stuff, one had a decrease, the rest increase, so I messed up....., I got 5 550 k usd, I showed it separately before and after impairment, so they can pick whatever they like
Rrazraz13y ago#82
Just wondering why would anyone bother if the sfp balanced or not if someone is just aiming a pass?? Looks like there are prize winners in the house. Will see in feb..:)
Bban12313y ago#83
not so great idea to put a finance exam on to the 3rd working day of the month, I was closing until 9 pm the day before...
Former userFormer user13y ago#84
All I can say is thank you so much to Mr. Michael Little for the revision lectures. I could practically hear his voice as I was doing Qn1.
Ssazmaz113y ago#85
The question asked for goodwill to be calculated at the date of acquisition. Therefore the impairment charge did not require deducting in this part of the question. I got £8000 for my answer for this part.
The contingent liability I used when calculating the value of subsidiary net assets at acquisition, ie a fair value adjustment just as you would if plant etc had increased in value from what was stated in subsidiary's balance sheet. Except because its a liability you deduct it instead of adding.
Wwingwing13y ago#86
Can i know when the f7 dec 2012 answer will be uploaded?
I need it before new year coming because i need to decide what paper for me to take next semester
Ssazmaz113y ago#87
Answers usually come out a month or so before results so you're looking at early to mid January
Ssuni641913y ago#88
normally the results are out by feb 8th... this time it can be early since the exam started early.
Former userFormer user13y ago#89
How did you guys account for Retained Earnings in goodwill calculation..was it R/earnings b/f of 35000 and time apportion the sub profit by 3/12? and what was the intra group profits deducted from revenue and cos of sales? was it 800* 9 months?
Wwingwing13y ago#90
But, my enrolment for next sem will have to settle before 1 of jan 2013...
Can any1 share your whole f7 answer??
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.