PM*** F5 June 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Did anyone write their mcq answers on their hand to compare?
I guessed I'd say half of them as found them difficult compared to past papers but got as follows:
C
D
D
C
C
A
B
C
B
A
D
B
D
A
C
B
C
C
B
A
I got 75$% buh I did a quick test of d percentages in d qtn instead of using any formula... It seemed faster for me
Absolutely bang on!!!
But one slightly bit problem.
Yours heading are other way around though.
It was size planning & share operational.
@karanpreetrobin said: Absolutely bang on!!! But one slightly bit problem. Yours heading are other way around though. It was size planning & share operational.LOL,yes you are right,had them right in the exam though,, how did u find the exam?
@shehzadhussain said: Well just hope so Do u know about mkt share & mkt size question ?
@shehzadhussain said: Can anyone pls tell his / her views on Q1 part B market share and mkt size pls pls plsplanning variance for product 1 one favourable nd product 2 adverse. operational was the same 1st fav nd 2nd adverse but amounts were decreased.
It was a tough exam as usual. I managed to attempt all questions. I misread question 1. In my opinion question 4 was a bit tricky.
School question - first I subtracted head office expenses and got net running costs of each school. Then I calculated all expenses connected with shutting down of each school and found the difference between running and shutting. It turned out that it was more expensive to shut down School 1 then to keep running it, School 3 was on the second place in ranking but it had a capacity of 1000, which means that school 1 and school 2 did not have enough place for 80% of its pupils, so my suggestion was to close school 2.
June 2016 session was my second attempt to pass F5. First time I was in progress with my studies and failed to finish on time.
MSQs were challenging because of theoretical questions. The LR was 75%. Target mark-up I suppose was about 35% (if x - cost, than price =1.5*x; after changes 0.9*0.98*1.5*x = 1.323x so attainable mark-up is about 35%)
ROI = gross profit/(non current assets -depreciation+inventory) I suppose
Q1 I calculated total sales volume variance (Adverse) than Sales planning variance HDD Adv, SSD Favourable, as a whole adv, Market share variance adv (used standard contribution)
Q2 Breakeven 300 athlets 90000$ revenue, profit for 500 is approximately 24000 as I remember, described the change in fixed cost, variable cost is constant up to 400 athlets, than decline from 200 to 100$ per athlet
Q3 I calculated ABC full cost as I remember 70+smth and 80+smth and suggested that using ABS is time consuming and expensive and current price 110$ is in compliance with competitive market (lower than rivals')
Q4 I was short of time and calculated current profit of each division and organisation as a whole and profit after accepting the offer. I defined that the offer shoul be rejected because of loss for the whole organisation and Division L's capacity shoul be utilised to produce and transfer the same volume as it is, but transfer price can be negotiated to minimum external market price (37)
Q5 was a fail but I wrote that school 2 should be chosed (minimum loss of fee income, minimum incremental cost of decision, minimum profit foregone)
after reading everyone's comments i know for a fact that i have failed....sigh
@burhansalah said: It was a tough exam as usual. I managed to attempt all questions. I misread question 1. In my opinion question 4 was a bit tricky.what did u think about Q1?
@saajan said: planning variance for product 1 one favourable nd product 2 adverse. operational was the same 1st fav nd 2nd adverse but amounts were decreased.Thanks for that I did the same Any idea about ABC question I add those 22.20 and 22.40 for boath services and both were under about nearly 70.00 and nearly 60 i Think Any idea for that
F5 was a nightmare really to me it was a disaster, i never so this kind of CVP question before also question 5 was tough. MCQ a mess.
@shehzadhussain said: Thanks for that I did the same Any idea about ABC question I add those 22.20 and 22.40 for boath services and both were under about nearly 70.00 and nearly 60 i Think Any idea for thatYes i also included the cost without overheads bcoz we were asked to calculate full cost per unit. but the ans u r saying is differnt from mine.?
@saajan said: Yes i also included the cost without overheads bcoz we were asked to calculate full cost per unit. but the ans u r saying is differnt from mine.?Ohh what were they to nearly ? And sorry but last question what was your school choice clousier I did the School 1 to be closed. And also suggested 24 to 37 transfer pricing in question 4.
need some clarity on question 4 - the profit we had to calculate was at the current transfer price of $40 and not the external supplier price of $37???
March June hybrid paper is out - https://www.accaglobal.com/content/dam/ACCA_Global/Students/fun/f5/j16_hybrid_F5_q.pdf
We take profit before interest and tax, I suppose gross profit is closer to this definition, but may be this is not appropriate for the question...For waste processing company I am not sure on details of task now, I don't remember exactly, but it seems to me that the price negotiated was for the first item which was cheaper under ABC.For mark up if original cost is defined as x and than original price is 1.5 * x so reduction of market price is 0.9, reduction of cost is 0.98 so 0.9*1.5*x*0.98=1.323x and current mark up is 32.3 so I chose 35% (the nearest above this figure)
That's my point of view, but I doubt that I won't fail the exam
@shehzadhussain said: Ohh what were they to nearly ? And sorry but last question what was your school choice clousier I did the School 1 to be closed. And also suggested 24 to 37 transfer pricing in question 4.li'll different than u in ABC. yes transfer price i also suggested the range of 37 ad 42. school question, i clearly don't recall but it was i think either 1 or 3.
@dnobleone said: need some clarity on question 4 - the profit we had to calculate was at the current transfer price of $40 and not the external supplier price of $37??? March June hybrid paper is out - https://www.accaglobal.com/content/dam/ACCA_Global/Students/fun/f5/j16_hybrid_F5_q.pdfi Calculated profit per unit if we buy component from external at 37 and calculated current profit (contribution less fixed cost) and then their differnce was the incremental profit if we chose to buy from external.
@shehzadhussain said: Ohh what were they to nearly ? And sorry but last question what was your school choice clousier I did the School 1 to be closed. And also suggested 24 to 37 transfer pricing in question 4.In variance question part B we had to explain the sales planning nd operational variance and then had to discuss on performance, right? i supposd explanation of 2 marks and discussion on performance of 3 mrks.
my exact view
God the tansfer pricing question gets me so confused...and I really should review the examiner's report as the last MCQ is almost identical to the one highlighted on the report!
@mhtacca said: God the tansfer pricing question gets me so confused...and I really should review the examiner's report as the last MCQ is almost identical to the one highlighted on the report!yeah it was too identical nd i chose D in that mcq. However, transfer price ques was not that much difficult as compare to the last one.
The objective part was very difficult, most of the answers i was guessing,. but the theory part was okay, i always use to close school 3.
This was a weird one. I felt prepared after hours of question practice and revision, was comfortable walking into that exam and felt confident enough that I could get half of it correct. I came out so disappointed as I have certainly failed. I felt that the questions were harder than any previous year (except the ABC one and the graph with revenue, fixed costs and total costs). I spent a good deal of time on the last question trying to work out what part of the syllabus it was testing. The multiple choice questions were v theoretical and guessed many of them. Didn't like the variance question either, have they ever asked for these before, market size and share? Some parts of the syllabus were ignored completely eg linear programming.
I guess you can feel prepared but then the examiner can test you in such a way that it exposes that you actually aren't.
Oh well, will try again in September.
sure BED 24000
@isaacfieh said: sure BED 24000Hey, which question is this from?
@sarahb1985 said: Did anyone write their mcq answers on their hand to compare? I guessed I'd say half of them as found them difficult compared to past papers but got as follows: C D D C C A B C B A D B D A C B C C B Ai think i did the same almost but can i ask you about question 1 and 3 or part B what was your approach pls
Question one in part b for the market size and market share variances isnt this just sales quantity variances?
I did the sales quantity variances x standard contributions. I got favorable for first and adverse for second about 15k adverse I think. Same for operational I got a
Favorable and an adverse. Overall favoritable.
Question three which was this?
Questions 4 and 5 and the share and size variances trow me out of the hall and before i could find my bearing in side the hall time up. the MCQ dont go there. God have mercy
T

