PM*** F5 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Hey did anyone get the maximum transfer price as $820 and minimum as $800? And the maximum units that M would sell to be as 30K units to B? And for the Abc question did you guys multiply the total number of procedures with the denominator before finding the driver rate? If it weren't for this question and transfer pricing I'd have aced the paper.
@kanika01 said: @acca145 said: i took learning rate on 460 units and my hours were 1268 something what about you? And me ditto. Dint consider 1000 at allI have done the same thing but showed working for for 1000 and 999 units and also showed working for 460 so I am hoping either way to score some marks for working plus I think 460 was more appropriate and I have based my working on it and I have not taken marginal in this case as like 449 and 450 as learning didn't stop. Let's see....
999*
@melitachester01 said: Oh right, I get you now, yet I added materials & labour separately, I didn't, bulk them together, is that ok to do that? I did like a statement at the end ????It doesn't matter whether you included labour and material costs into High/low or just added them at the end, you end up with £21 total variable costs either way. I forgot to take fixed overheads off the final profit figure at the end oops. Q1 ABC I recommended not to implement as costs were so similar and implementation costs would likely outweigh benefit. Q2For transfer price question I got the transfer price as £740-£800 and stated that for overall company profit the actual transfer price is irrelevant so long as it's between that range, e.g. higher divisional profit for one division = lower divisional profit in equal measure for the other division. For the same reason I got Div M to supply full quota of 35,000 to Div S and 25,000 to external customers. My understanding of Transfer Pricing is that by improving Div M's profit by supplying external customers you would be reducing Div S's profit by forcing them to buy externally, therefore reducing overall company profit. Q3 Was this the learning curve/variance questions? I can't remember my calculations but consequences included: - incorrect selling price due to cost-plus pricing method so will affect demand. - negative affect on sales manager performance as harder to sell it higher price so he may not achieve bonus. - production manager rewarded with bonus incorrectly - appointing of temporary workers unnecessarily resulting in higher costs - demotivated workforce due to easy task - workforce and fellow managers may question production managers judgement in future. Q5 - just gave text book answers, rambled on and didn't particularly link it to the organisation.
@tothornton said: It thought it was an ok paper, but made a mess of questions, hopefully get attempt marks on most. Attempted transfer pricing and variance question very poorly. Hopefully sec A i got 30% out of 40%, if not i'll struggle to pass.I'm same as you Tomas ;(
Is the minimum transfer price 740+extra cont lost 30=770.max tp 800?
155.5 as far as i remember
why i can only view 1-20
little hope for me to pass the exam yesterday, i feel really frustrated,
For the learning effect. To calculate the revised hour, which should we used, 460th or 1000th unit? So confused with this number 3 questiom
I did a lot of crossing over like 2-3 pages as I had time and I just rewritten the answers so that it is neat. Will I be penalized?
I think this exam is challenge, and obviously more difficult than previous in Dec2014.
Q1: Using ABC, overhead allocated to procedure A increase while to procedure B decrease because each procedure B require more activity.
Don't remember exact number
Q2: internal sales first => profit of Div M 5,85 mil something
External sales first, take maximum external sales demand => profit of Div M 5,7 mil sth, however Div S would save 250k cost => total profit of group 5,95 mil sth
recommend change sales policy of div M to take maximum external demand
Q3: don't remember exactly
Q4: MC = 21$
P=310-0.001Q => MR=310-0.002Q
=> profit maximising selling price 165.5 sth
Q5: terrible for me
@Barcelona said: Q5: terrible for meAnd me :)
I am very disappointed with the exam. thought was well prepared. especially in B with the transfer price & ZBB questions.
The questions in part B were very tricky.
I think part A (test section) was diffcult, do you remember questions?
@drice99 said: Is the minimum transfer price 740+extra cont lost 30=770.max tp 800?I believe minimum transfer price is the higher of suppling division's lost contribution (850-770=80) or marginal costs (740), therefore I got it as 740.
When section A answer will uploaded...i though i saw F5 suggested answer one day after Day 1 of Dec-14....that time I was doing F6 so I saw F5 results the night of the day I wrote F6...................
part b is quite difficult but I hope I will be passed because part A minimum 15 mcq,s surely give right ans
zahid do you remember what you mark in questions
I need to know , about shadow price, enviromental questions , also current/quick ratio question , question one , minimax regret 350?
Minimax regret the answer shoulb be B right ?
Do you remember the question on what caused the learning rate to decrease from like 80% to 75% ?
@lesbella said: Minimax regret the answer shoulb be B right ?Can't remember which letter it was but I vaguely remember something around $80 ish. We had to find the max regret (highest of each column) and then choose the lowest of these so the selling price was whichever one corresponded to that.
@kainosvik said: Do you remember the question on what caused the learning rate to decrease from like 80% to 75% ?Can't remember exactly the options but have a feeling it was none of the above. The learning rate is faster than expected and think all the options suggested slower?
I remembered the minimax regret answer was 375 from the loss table. Anyone gets the same?
I agreed with the learning rate question as all the options are suggest slower rate.
Please correct me if I'm wrong
in section b, when there was discuss about skimming ,I wrote that it's not suitable decision ,
because as they mentioned the demand was elastic (2 $ change in price change demand)
so if they set high price there will be demand fall if they set price 310 demand will be zero , as we calculated
@bryanip3a1b said: I remembered the minimax regret answer was 375 from the loss table. Anyone gets the same? I agreed with the learning rate question as all the options are suggest slower rate. Please correct me if I'm wrongI honestly can't remember what the options were but think I got it right. That's the problem with the MCQs - you can't remember them afterwards. I know there were two that I wasn't convinced of my answer but I can't remember what they were - apart from the fact they weren't calculations ones. Can't wait to see the exam go up so I can try and figure out how I did.
I got same answer except that Fixed cost I multiplied by 4 to get total fixed costs of the whole period
@nikaacca said: in section b, when there was discuss about skimming ,I wrote that it's not suitable decision , because as they mentioned the demand was elastic (2 $ change in price change demand) so if they set high price there will be demand fall if they set price 310 demand will be zero , as we calculatedI think I said that it MAY be suitable because met some of the conditions (short life cycle, high development costs, new and unique product) but no info on barriers to entry and demand was elastic so needed further info/investigation before making recommendation. I noticed that the questions like this in the revision kit all sat on the fence so I did too!
I had the same answer as 375. I hope we are right
Lilit , your answer makes me sad :(
because you are right
now I remember that there were 0 , because it was already constructed,
hate test , if it was in part B I would get 0.5 point , despite my wrong answer they would mark me for knowing of minimax regret
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

