PM*** F5 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Hi, should the ROI be calculated using the gross profit or the operating net profit times the asset turnover? That's one of the mcqs
My BC was 21, fix cost 800000. Profit 20 mil something
Vc*
@ Naila normally question papers r released de following week iff im right
It was a easy question but i did't answer well :(
The 2nd and the 1st question was little tricky. This two killed my valuable time. Don't know what gonna happen. My pass depends on MCQ. :( :( :(
@ Bryan u wr given profit margin and asset turnover so u hd 2 multiply those 2 get ROCE
Hi Gladys, we were given both gross profit margin and operating net profit margin so was not 100% sure but having googled it just now the ROI should be calculated using the operating net profit margin times the asset turnover. Agree?
Roi net profit×asset turnover
Hi, question said company policy may change so to max profit as a whole the variable cost should only be the price charged to division S and 500 bought from the external supplier, correct?
@jarekw85 said: Fixed cost were 800'000 USD - I got them by high- low method from the total overheads, then the variable o/h were as far as I remember 3$ per unit. Overall profit very high, 23mln contribution minus 800k USD fixed costs. Looks should be all right :)Yes I got the same as you using Hi Lo method. $3 variable cost & $800,000 fixed.
Truly, the exam was fair....all areas were covered except financial/non financial performance management... I our invigilator upset us and I dont know how to complain this to ACCA Admin.....I told us to start after 30minute gone....and We asked him to allow for extension but refused...it became take it or leave it!!!!!!!!!!!
My expectation is high...I have done, all parts except Question three on variance analysis which I did partly..... The ABC question was big but okey...i concluded that ABC is the best approach for the Company,,,,,
q2, pricing was okey....got variable 3/unit and 800K Fixed cost....optimum price calculated was $156.5 AND quantity demanded was 153500 units...then used all this to find total profit=$ 22,762250. part C of q2....Market skimming...after much detail concluded that its okey tO adopt because the product was new and innovative and company can charge high prices and carry out strong market campaign to boost the sales and convince customers that product is worthwhile though the demand was 2/2000 elastic.....
question 5-- ZBB was okey...and mostly got the idea of telling benefits and limitations of ZBB linking it to the sceneria.
Transfer pricing was tricky.....after explaining the approach of transfer pricing I said that division M should supply 30000 units to Division S because division M had only 30000 for external and external is more beneficial for her, therefore sell 30000unts to external, 30000units to Division S and then S can get the 5000 units remaining from external.... the price that should be set between divisions should be the marginal cost of division M less internal selling cost which was $740(770-30) and market price of $800 that S can get else where.....
Question 4- labour variance---- efficiency planning variance--- Original (460*7*12)-revised(2.756H*460units *12)=$23426.88F and labour operational variance= revised(2.756H *$12*460-1860H*$12)=$7107A...... the part b did not worked, because of time......
Yes, i also did overall profit using the quantity that we were asked to work out.
Yes brain you are right...each division would want to maximize profit so Division M will sell 30000 to external and 30000 to S, so that S can get the remaining 5000 from else where....I tried to calculate the effect on this to the group but could not because Divison S selling price was not told and hence though the question should be discesive rather numeric..... and the ltranfer price should be set should be between $740 to $800
Yes my profit was also 20.8 million something like that..
Exactly same for me.
Hi All,
Found this paper to be well prepared,however,I needed to put in more work.Transfer pricing is by far the most challenging.The worst thing is to realise you changed your right answer.**Headache**...Does ACCA go through crossed out workings???Feeling so depressed right now....
for me at Q1(ABC) one of procedure's ABC cost is higher then the original, and the other's is lower than the original cost.
Hi
I think paper was fair.
For transfer pricing the right answer was to transfer motor to s at 30000 x800 and sell externally at 30000 x 850.
Division s was allowed to purchase 30000 at 800 from M and 5000 at 800 from market.
For q 4 fixed cost was 800000 and variable cost was 21.
Can any one confirm that on question 3 labour effect on timin was given for 1000 unit but only only 450 was made so what was the solution to that.
I totally messed up my ABC question by changing it.....But for my answer which i was confident with but crossed outtttt....*screams*,my ABC results for both companies were lower than original...so i stated the company should go with ABC.
Q1. The costs under both systems were close so adopting ABC may not be worth it. However, they could go ahead and adopt for other merits of ABC but based on the calculations,NO.
Q2. First 30,000 units will be at V.C plus opportunity cost minus cost saved. V.C was 770(I think), opportunity cost, 0 as there was spare capacity and cost saved 30. I then did a little profit statement. However,profit could be maximized if each division is allowed autonomy. Division M will sell at full market price of 800(I believe), and Division S will have a cost savings of 50.
Q3. Don't remember now
Q4. Revised rate was 2.45 based on average hour for 1,000 units.
Implications of not considering the learning effect are 1. Standard/budgeted hour for labor will be higher than normal. 2. The price of the product (which is based on material and labor will be high. 3. There will always be a huge adverse labor efficiency variance. 4. There will always be a huge overhead efficiency variance if overhead is labour hours driven. 5. The negative variances would lead to de motivation.
Wow, I can't believe how much you guys remember, impressive ????????
Section A:
I too messed up the ROI & RI so I'm hoping for some lucky guesses.
The majority of questions were reasonable & there was only a few a really had to guess.
Section B:
Q1 - ABC, thought this was a decent question. I got similar prices to the costs in the question (think one was $30 odd out & the other $50 odd) I therefore recommended that it was not worth implementing ABC.
Q2 - Total horror, made a right mess of this one, basically 3 pages of scribble. Somewhere I mention the contribution of $80 & also state M should do 30,000 each to internal & external, also that S should buy 30,000 internal & 5,000 external, apart from that I just made a mess so fear I have scored very low here.
Q3 - ok (ish), think I got 2.42 on learning curve though, & not 2.08 like you guys mention, perhaps I'll pick up a few marks for my workings. Not confident on the variances either.
Q4 - Pricing. Did ok on a) I think (is this the Hi Lo bit), I got $800,000 fixed & $3 variable, don't understand where sone have you have got $21 variable from?? Didn't answer b) if that was the formula bit as I didn't have a clue. & I think on c) I may have waffled some rubbish??
Q5 ZBB - my mind went blank here but we did implement this last year at my work place so I based my answer around my personal experiences, I think I may have picked up some marks here?
Overall realistically I'm hoping I've got 8+ on Q1, 2-3 on Q2, 4-5 on Q3, 4-5 on Q4 & then 8-10 on Q5.
So if I can scrape around 25 on section B really hoping I've done good enough on A to get 25/40? Guess I'll have to wait & see eh?
Good luck everyone, really enjoy reading your thoughts on the exam.
@acca145 said:
i took learning rate on 460 units and my hours were 1268 something what about you?
And me ditto. Dint consider 1000 at all
@lynnecart said: Q4 - $3 was the variable overhead per unit. Materials & labour per unit came to $18, hence the $21 total variable costs.Oh right, I get you now, yet I added materials & labour separately, I didn't, bulk them together, is that ok to do that? I did like a statement at the end ????
@lynnecart said: Q4 - $3 was the variable overhead per unit. Materials & labour per unit came to $18, hence the $21 total variable costs.Oh right, I get you now, yet I added materials & labour separately, I didn't, bulk them together, is that ok to do that? I did like a statement at the end ????
@lynnecart said: Q4 - $3 was the variable overhead per unit. Materials & labour per unit came to $18, hence the $21 total variable costs.Oh right, I get you now, yet I added materials & labour separately, I didn't, bulk them together, is that ok to do that? I did like a statement at the end ????
Thts wat i got 21 vc and 80000 fc
Q5. ZBB steps- quite easy
Part B. Problems that may arise when changing to ZBB are
1. Resistance from staff as they are already used to the current system and may have even built in slack so may not want to change to another system.
2. Training will be needed
3. Information for ZBB may not be easily available
4. Management may not have the skills to rank decision packages
Part C. Benefits of ZBB.
1. Leads to better allocation of resources
2. Difficult for employees to add budget slack as the decision package will be rejected if too expensive
3. Present errors and inefficiencies will not be perpetuated in future
I messed up with Part A of the question on pricing. My high low was funny.
Part B. b was .001, a was 310 or so. The profit maximizing qty was about 14,600. I got my price. Can't remember what it was now.
I did a profit statement. Sales revenue was the profit maximizing price multiplied by the profit maximizing quantity. Then less material costs 12 and labor of 6 and variable overhead.
Part C. Market skimming was a suitable option for the company because
1. The product is differentiated and people would like to own it immediately after its launch to be one up on those who do not have it
2. The company had invested heavily in R$D and to recoup the investment,they could use market skimming
3. The product life cycle is short;3 years,therefore market skimming would be a good pricing strategy
4. I tried to calculate the elasticity of demand so as to comment because it seemed that the product had inelastic demand and that meant a further suitability, but unfortunately,I ran out of time.
Sorry, don't know why that's gone on 3 times??? Don't know how to delete, sorry peeps ????
It thought it was an ok paper, but made a mess of questions, hopefully get attempt marks on most. Attempted transfer pricing and variance question very poorly. Hopefully sec A i got 30% out of 40%, if not i'll struggle to pass.
@dskinner83 said: I did overall profit too, so hoping that was the question! Now I'm starting to doubt myself and wondering if I misread the question!I also thought it was overall profit based on optimum price and quantity.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

