Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

LW*** F4 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments***

Oopentuition13y ago
Post your comments about December 2012 F4 exam.

Please vote in our Instant Poll
*** F4 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments*** poll results

Please note:
Remember that you are studying for a professional qualification - do not make postings that are abusive or threatening.
Ccaptmario13y ago#61
@timcfo said:
I thought it was an offer, the question actually had the word offer twice on it.
1. The first guy wrote in and letter didnt arrive till monday, so no offer as postal rule wasnt in contemplation
2. the second guy who offerd a cheque, no offer as advert stipulated cash only,
3. third guy offered to pay but had to arrange bank loan so no offer as the guy didnt give consideration for ali to wait.
4. the fourth guy paid 2K
DO YOU GUYS AGREE, NOT REALLY SURE ABOUT GUY NO.3 WITH THE BANK LOAN SITU


guy no 3 sort of had an option period, but it should be supported by partial consideration or something, if no consideration its not considered binding. so yea he had no right to legal action against ali.
MikeLittleMikeLittleTutor13y ago#62
I think question 9 has nothing to do with bribery - it's a directors' duties question. David Kelly specifically pointed you AWAY from bribery. It isn't even clear that Fay was being bribed. She simply sold the secrets to lx in exchange for money - when information is sold for money, is that always necessarily a bribe? And, if it is, does that mean that the BPP / Kaplan / etc tutors are the recipients of bribes?
MikeLittleMikeLittleTutor13y ago#63
Hi Dierdre - I have done on the forum pages. The question 8 in the December 2012 exam is virtually word-for-word an earlier exam question set by David Kelly. It is, without a shadow of doubt, an offer which is being made. The wording "this is a serious offer", "cash only", "valid for one day only", "first person who accepts it" all indicate that this is an offer.

Partridge v Crittenden is a distraction, I'm afraid. In that case, the words "offered for sale" were used but the Courts held to the principle that an advert is an invitation unless the advert makes it 100% clear that it's an offer or it's a reward case

Sorry!
MikeLittleMikeLittleTutor13y ago#64
Still on question 8, the third guy, Das, asked for time to arrange finance. Ali agreed to give Das time and that, apparently, is enough for Das to be able to rely on Ali's word. The act of "having to go and arrange finance" is consideration and Das should therefore be able to rely on the contract.

I suppose one could begin to make a case about whether the rug was a specific rug or simply one out of stock. Given that Ali's business "has been rather slow" it makes you wonder why he doesn't simply sell "the rug" ( in the event, ANY rug ) to Bud, Cil, and Das ( only Cil inspected it and probably wouldn't remember it anyway! ) :)
Ccaptmario13y ago#65
Will we get some marks if we treated it as an invitation to treat? i thought advertisement is always an offer unless an offer for reward, and there was no such case as reward here.

@Mike, will we get some marks if we treated it as an inv.to treat?
Vvusincube13y ago#66
Very tricky, hope i passed anyway
Former userFormer user13y ago#67
mike, when acca examiner releases his answers for f4 and f6
Ffoxman13y ago#68
@mikelittle
Question 8? If the advert had been, "Handmade antique Persian rug - £1500!" How would the reality of the invitation be any different to the offer?
The first person to offer/agree £1500 cash would have bought the rug, if someone made a lower offer Ali would have been free to accept or reject it. To distinguish it as an offer the only difference I can see is that if someone agreed to pay £1500 and Ali refused which defeats the purpose of the advert.
It then begs another question:
If I offered £1400 for the rug and it was rejected would I then be able to accept his offer and pay the £1500?
And finally, if an item is on display in a shop with a sign, "Special offer today!" Would that be an invitation to treat or an offer?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.