Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

LW*** F4 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments***

Oopentuition13y ago
Post your comments about December 2012 F4 exam.

Please vote in our Instant Poll
*** F4 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments*** poll results

Please note:
Remember that you are studying for a professional qualification - do not make postings that are abusive or threatening.
Hhamzaharoon13y ago#31
@vipin: Same thing I did, Totally Same brother

@latoyah : Q8 Contract question it was invitation to treat not an offer "Partridge v Crittenden"

And Thank you so much mike and OpenTuition team, Hats off to you all :)
Ssgear13y ago#32
I thought it was a fair paper, not sure if I have done enough to pass but a month ago I was on the verge of giving up prior to discovering OpenTuition, so thank you OT for getting me into a position where I have a chance of passing!
Former userFormer user13y ago#33
The advertisment was an offer, 'offer open for one day only' it stated it was an offer in the advert wereas Partridge v Crittenden did not.
Former userFormer user13y ago#34
Guys,
The last three scenario questions were:
Q8, Invitation to treat, Partridge v Crittenden, Postal Rule, Breach of Contarct
Q9 Bribery Act 2010
Q10 Insider dealing
I messed up question 1, and I did not answer Q4 as I run out of time.....

On top of your heads is there any way to pass this paper if one of the questions have not been answered. Pls advice......

Thank you
Former userFormer user13y ago#35
It was not a bribery question- it said to ignore bribery in answer as it related to directors duties and how to remove the director as she had a third of the shares.
Former userFormer user13y ago#36
Guys I am positive that it was a Bribery as it gave you the clue in the scenario, where it said that she had passed some some research information for a substancial amount of money.

Also, they advised not to use Bribery against the LX PLC.......
Former userFormer user13y ago#37
Thanks OT for this great site and all the tips.. Special thanks for the exam tec article, it was perfect advice for me in breaking up my answer and good to learn that ACCA has no negative markings. I failed last time after thinking It was perfect! This time, breaking up the answer I can see how many points I actually made. I filled an entire extension booklet, made 15 points per question ha and finished with 1min to spare but just couldn't be bothered to use that min for spelling errors!
Ddarkangel513y ago#38
@dituribeqaraj1973 said:
Guys I am positive that it was a Bribery as it gave you the clue in the scenario, where it said that she had passed some some research information for a substancial amount of money.

Also, they advised not to use Bribery against the LX PLC.......



I feel it was Bribery too..
Former userFormer user13y ago#39
The last question on directors duties is identical to mock exam 2 in bpp where two directors are asked what action can you take against the other who had accepted personal commission. The answer based it on directors duties and using ordinary resolutions to remove them as two directors had enough shares to pass it. Did others go down the directors duties route?
Former userFormer user13y ago#40
Thank You MIke and Opentuition! you guys are life savers, for me this paper was relatively passable, and its all thanks to the video classes and Mike amazing lecturing skills, I Think Mike deserve an award! and in relation to the contract question it was an offer, in the advert it stated it was a serious offer, specific "cash only'....there was certainity, the was intention to be bound. In relation to question 9, it says u may ignore the bribery Act, "u may ignore' not that u should,
Former userFormer user13y ago#41
May/should, it's all the same. It was pretty clear that they didn't want you to discuss bribery. 'You may not trespass on this land' signs are not giving you an option.
Former userFormer user13y ago#42
hmm, dint think about it like that, neways wouldnt hurt to have some extra points in there anyways, i was thinking more like it was optional, so when i finish answering the question i add it in at the bottom.
Former userFormer user13y ago#43
what kind of marking does da f4 examiner do ?? easy or hard checking ?
Former userFormer user13y ago#44
@stephdav82 said:
It was not a bribery question- it said to ignore bribery in answer as it related to directors duties and how to remove the director as she had a third of the shares.


The question was about bribery ....we had to ignore the other company implications in it- the bribing party- and refer in our essay only to the director's duty and he's offence of bribery
KKoukla13y ago#45
Q8 - I treated as an offer as well..hmmm now not so sure. Anyway hopefully have passed!
Former userFormer user13y ago#46
I also treated Q8 as an offer considering that he nake refference to good in question , price and quantity. I also considered that other parties have no right to any claim because their response are considered an counter offer ( they change the conditions of the offer) . Now I not so sure if it is right. hope I'll pass.
Former userFormer user13y ago#47
Q8 was an offer, not invitation, for certain. The whole reason that adverts aren't usually offers is that they don't extend sufficient terms to be legally binding. Ali's offer pretty clearly did, time frame, value, type of consideration. Q8 was the easiest question in there for me, but I did go heavy on contract law.

Overall a pretty easy paper, Q3 (fair/unfair dismissal) was a gift too, and Q1 and Q2 were also nice. I hadn't gone over administration well enough but I don't think the question was difficult if you had, and Q9 on director's duties was my other uncertain one. I did mention bribery on the part of the director since the question only said to ignore it on the part of the competitor company, but mainly because I ran out of things to say about director's duties!
Mmaes13y ago#48
@darkangel5 and @dituribeqaraj1973 I was sure it was bribery too. I did discuss that Fay could be removed and disqualified under the CDDA 86. The did say not to discuss the actionas against the company but I'm sure we still had to discuss the consequences for Fay for accepting the bribe. (For some reason I can't quote lol)
Iincepaul13y ago#49
The december Eng variant paper is now available on the ACCA website for any one who wishes to look over it
Aameesha13y ago#50
Is marking of the f4 paper strict coz i didn't remember the name of the cases n didn't have time to finish the paper..n i went..blank on the question for doctrine of capital maintenance..
Former userFormer user13y ago#51
Gutted, only 4 areas that I remembered by heart, sources of law, law of tort, remoteness of damage and measure of damages and dismissal, did I gain full marks on those don't think so. Missed half of sources of law quesiton because of my stupidity, thought finish the question not til on my way home that I did'nt say anything about the Acts of Parliament, didnt mention anything about statutory interpretation, Argggggg.

Capital maintenance. no Idea so put somthing down like capital buffer that cannot be used to buy shares, pay dividend, must be kept for liabilities in case of liquidation.

Administration alternative way of winding up, no Idea how to stretch it for 10 marks, only core principle that I wrote. 2 marks if that.

Application of registaltion, haha stanley davis. anything else, very basic. so gain no marks I think.

Overall its a fair paper, but just not enough time to give it my best go, on the things that I know.

hope for a pass but who knows.
Sserra13y ago#52
Director question said ignore the bribery.
Directors have a duty of not accepting benefits from 3rd parties too. Something different than bribery act in this context.
Former userFormer user13y ago#53
I agree Serra. We had already had a question on section f on insider dealing but nothing on directors, it could also include then removing directors by passing ordinary resolutions. It they wanted bribery they would not specifically mention in question to ignore it. It could be mentioned obviously as an outcome of accepting benefits
Oohemant13y ago#54
Thanks Mike for your free Online Lectures. They are very useful for someone like me who has no college. The pilot paper covered most of the scenario questions asked on Monday's exam. I should pass scoring good marks.
Former userFormer user13y ago#55
just hope we should get a pass.. wasnt that tough a paper.. but all you guys comments are confusing me as to was it a director duties question or bribery? i went for the directors duty cause it clearly asked to avoid bribery..

fingers crosseddd!
Former userFormer user13y ago#56
I just checked the downloadable revision guide on here and one of the practice questions is the same as q8. Unfortunately I went down the advert- invitation to treat but the precise wording according to the practice question says it is an offer. That bit was only two marks but the rest of the question is identical as well
Llukedavidizard13y ago#57
Lord Parker CJ commented that it did not make "business sense" for advertisements to be offers, as the person making the advertisement may find himself in a situation where he would be contractually obliged to sell more goods than he actually owned.
Aali6313y ago#58
Mike, could u PLEASE let us know what u think of Question 8 and Question 9...

Offer OR Invitation To Treat???
Director Duties OR Bribery???
Former userFormer user13y ago#59
I thought it was an offer, the question actually had the word offer twice on it.
1. The first guy wrote in and letter didnt arrive till monday, so no offer as postal rule wasnt in contemplation
2. the second guy who offerd a cheque, no offer as advert stipulated cash only,
3. third guy offered to pay but had to arrange bank loan so no offer as the guy didnt give consideration for ali to wait.
4. the fourth guy paid 2K
DO YOU GUYS AGREE, NOT REALLY SURE ABOUT GUY NO.3 WITH THE BANK LOAN SITU
Former userFormer user13y ago#60
i took a look at the exam on ACCA website...

now, trust me if you are like me, those who say this exam is very very easy, in two years time you will look at these papers and think... ouch! :) I got 65% in my exam about two three years ago and i no longer have a clue! lol.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.