AFM*** ACCA Paper AFM September 2018 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
The total value of acquiring company'share is 50 mil ( with 0.5$/ share ) so the total share is 100m shares, bro. The remaining of your answer i think were correct.
Question 1 was bad news. However thanks John I used your lectures and notes for this exam only that I started late.
@kanchandhankar said: Estimating current future /spot price is step for both interest rate and currency risk. For calculating under hedge over hedge you need spot rate on transaction date but when it is not given you estimate it by calculating unexpired basis and calculating lock in rate. Thats what my understanding is. How did you do it ?Estimated lock in rate by calculating unexpired basis and for option I got a perfect hedge of the full amount, hence no need to calculate under/above hedging...? And the way you did it?
Q1 - Took mainly my time. I concentrated first on theory parts. Left calculations when time was finished allocated to Q1.
About Q2 : was a nice surprise. but I had only Hour to finish Q2 & Q3 - 30 mins each.
In Q2: As far I remember, they asked for financial review and Business aspect review. Quickest way to do was to calculate change ( increase/ decrease ) in three years for Revenue, net profit, gross profit, . Debt to equity ratio. Increase in EPS , Share price, Cash equivalents and Current assets. Increase in revenue by product etc.
The companies financial performance seems better as it showed increase. However for some reason Cash was decreasing in line with PAT increase. I.e. As remaining Cash goes into Cash reserves generally.
Working Capital was improving as current assets seems to reduce, because it looks like debtors were being paid.
Lastly the institutional investor concern can be valid, as she seems more concern about business aspect of company. i.e. continuous growth of product line, such as P3 - Product lifecycle future strategy. Although CEO said they have competitive edge product, but no external market research to back it up.
Q3: I attempted only theory, no time for calculations
Thanks
My feedback to ACCA:
I'm sure the ACCA have heard the same thing already from many other students. The syllabus was not tested fairly for P4 in this session. I don't mind there being difficult elements to a question, and the odd minor curve ball that will throw students but there should be some balance to allow students to prove their knowledge in other areas, this was not the case in this session. Q1 was difficult and had some odd twists which is fine but Q2 and Q3 didn't test the syllabus at all. The value of the combined company in Q3 required quite a lot of on the spot thinking about the scenario and didn't test any of the conventional cost of equity metthods. Q2 was the easiest but most students, like myself, would have left it until last and ran out of time. My comments are supported by the fact we didn't need to use the formula sheet hardly at all! Whilst the examiner kept his word on the fact there would be a focus on syllabus sections B and E, they were tested in an unfair way, for instance getting 640 contracts would have confused many students and made them doubt themselves and waste time because anyone that has revised the past papers will only have ever came up with between 10 and 50 contracts, having to calculate forward exchange rates indirectly using another currency as a proxy in the same question was also a complication that was a step too far. When the examining team proof read their exams they should also check to make sure the paper is fairly balanced and the syllabus is fairly spread. Q2 and Q3 were not sufficient to allow students to prove their knowledge of the syllabus in my opinion.
I agree with Darren's comments + having to use JPY currency when values are in the billions and you have to use a calculator which does not display thousand separators just makes the question unnecessarily confusing when surely ACCA's aim should be to test the student's knowledge and skills?
It does seem like it was a waste of time studying the BSOP, WACC, RAWACC, CAPM, M&M, DVM, DPP, MIRR, Macaulay duration, islamic finance, VAR, Unbundling, dividend decision, corporate failure & reconstruction, trade barriers, Tobins, levs, Greeks...etc
Yeah did the same thing , Missed converting it to the Mid year Spot ie 6 months . Thus discounted the Cash flow using Year 0, 1, 2 ,3 4 spots instead of 0.5,1.5,2.5,3.5 , 4.5 spot rate
@yogeniem23 said: In the Q3a I think it should go like: Value of acquiring co.= 50m shares × 6.5 = $325m Fcfe of acquiring co.= $325m/8=$40.63m Value of victim co. = 7(1+0.03)/(0.15-0.03) = $60m (using gordon growth model) Fcfe of victim=$7m which is given Value of combined =(40.63+7+5)*8=$421m Gain in value = $421-(325+60)= 36m Offer of 5 shares for 1 of victim gives 10m shares to victim. Share value of new combined company= $421/(50+10) = $7.02 Gain by victim= $7.02*10m shares - $60m = $10.2m (17% gain) Gain by acquirer=$7.02*50m shares - $325m = $26m (8% gain) Anyone dome this. Correct me if i m wrong. Let me know if anyone has done it this way.Boom!! I got the same answers
@accastudent1986 said: I agree with Darren's comments + having to use JPY currency when values are in the billions and you have to use a calculator which does not display thousand separators just makes the question unnecessarily confusing when surely ACCA's aim should be to test the student's knowledge and skills? It does seem like it was a waste of time studying the BSOP, WACC, RAWACC, CAPM, M&M, DVM, DPP, MIRR, Macaulay duration, islamic finance, VAR, Unbundling, dividend decision, corporate failure & reconstruction, trade barriers, Tobins, levs, Greeks...etcI agree, we don't expect to be tested on everything we've revised, but there should be some of the above in the exam. Q1 was difficult and an unusual layout and complexities, FX hedging and international NPV which had odd parts in itself like not starting for a year, and adjustments to operating profit etc. When I skimmed through the requirements at the beginning of the exam I was fairly confident but by the time I got to Q3 I was horrified to see there was a whole page of text and only one small paragraph that actually contained any financial information, I was expecting Betas, ungearing, regearing, CAPM, WACC etc. Q2 was easy enough but that's not the point, we've all been revising the core syllabus for all these weeks if not months, so why not text us on that? I could have honestly almost sat this exam without studying P4. I think the only real P4 content was the hedging.
When you say the project started in 1 year's time is that the part where the question said to calculate NPV excluding the T0 investment? Hope that's what it asked! I remember NPV being around 18,000m JPY excluding the initial investment :(
@accastudent1986 said: When you say the project started in 1 year's time is that the part where the question said to calculate NPV excluding the T0 investment? Hope that's what it asked! I remember NPV being around 18,000m JPY excluding the initial investment :(I actually can't remember exactly what the question said, I don't think it was very clear at all, but I took it to mean the initial investment would be made in 1 year from now. Actually that makes sense now because they said they were waiting for the Euro receipt and then would invest 6 months later. Although saying that I don't think I discounted the initial investment amount. The ACCA might argue this was only 9 marks and students should not waste too much time on it. That's true in some cases, however it then impacts the other elements of the question, we need to finish the NPV and come up with some kind of sensible answer so that we can comment and discuss it in the report. How can we be strict with time and move on with an unfinished NPV if we're then expected to discuss it in the report.. discuss what if we haven't managed to get the NPV??
I found the exam challenging, and difficult but that was to expect, but I think that question 1 was unnecessary long. With so much calculations, I made calculation mistakes that I had to amend and by the time I finished question 1, I had no much time left to go through the others...
The exam didn't seem very difficult in terms of technical stuff, but time management was very challenging due to Q1's simple but uncomfortable complications (billions of ccy, cross exchange rate, one year offset of CFs, additional tax in Japan, lost contrib...etc) - for relatively not so many marks (btw I got negative NPV). Hedging part was standard.
I caught myself near to 2 hours on Q1 and then didn't have time to properly finalize Q2 after doing Q3 in a rush.
Q3 was relatively straightforward in terms of equity valuation and Q2 seemed easy (although didn't study that part of the syllabus, it seemed more of a common sense question on fin. analysis, probably F9 level).
Overall I agree it was not so interesting in terms of core AFM subjects like gearing/ungearing, WACC, APV, real options, FCFF or FCFE with complications or redeemable debt valuation, but it could have gone a lot more ugly in those areas where it's a lot easier to get lost or make silly mistakes.
Anyone knows when exam answers will be posted on ACCA website?
I agree, it could have been worse but at least it'd feel like we had a chance.
If they do publish any of the questions from September's exam it'll probably be in January because they don't publish all exam questions anymore. So after we get our results.
Good luck
Here are the questions posted, but it says coming soon for answers...
https://www.accaglobal.com/gb/en/student/exam-support-resources/professional-exams-study-resources/p4/past-exam-papers.html
Maybe we could ask John to do Q1 before ACCA publishes official answers?-)
Thanks denp :)
So on Q1 it says calculate NPV based on the end of year 1 being the start of the project (year 0) did anyone else interpret that to mean ignore the year of investment?
@kanchandhankar said: I did calculate the receipt using futures and options but unable to compare those with estimated spot price so failed to calculate profit/ loss which will give net receipt so all in all I left it unfinished due to time issue.Okay... calculating over/under hedging we can use the forward rates when given right? If i remember well we did have a six months forward rate and a spot rate? Besides, if you have a perfect hedging there's no adjustments needed as in under or over hedging right? Premium costs obviously but that's all? And then based on the three hedged receipts decide which one gives highest, combined with risk appetite of the company and so on? That's my understanding but I may be wrong as well.
@denp said: Here are the questions posted, but it says coming soon for answers... https://www.accaglobal.com/gb/en/student/exam-support-resources/professional-exams-study-resources/p4/past-exam-papers.html Maybe we could ask John to do Q1 before ACCA publishes official answers?-)Oh that's interesting, thanks for sharing this, I wonder when they started doing this? (publishing the exam so soon afterwards) and how that fits in with their "sample" exam questions stance.. Unless they've reverted to publishing all past papers, I didn't realise.
Did we need to convert our exchange rates for hedging ?
https://www.accaglobal.com/gb/en/student/exam-support-resources/professional-exams-study-resources/p4/past-exam-papers.html
John air please give us the answer for this question paper
Agreed!
Overall, the exam was too hard, the 1st question was too lengthy and the last was had many interpretations. Lot of information was hidden and time pressure was enormous. !st question had just so much to do and was just not possible to complete within the available time.
The equity value calculation of the last question puzzled and needless to say could'nt complete it!! Lets see, what comes out, fingures crossed!!
Please upload answes asap ?
I agree as per you said. I think AFM (P4) exam quite tricky different what you have learnt for the content especially for Q1, it spend me around 2 hours to do it, I even no time to finish the remaining parts.And Q1, the essay too lengthy and hidden some important information. This is my 3rd attempt, i think will be my 4th attempt again for my last ACCA paper!!!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

