AFM*** ACCA Paper AFM September 2018 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Studied every day for 2 months. Luckily no option pricing or APV this time. Attempted 96 marks, lets see. Worst question for me was on the equity value generated for each shareholder in q3.
Thanks John & Opentuition team for the materials and lectures.
Remember you can say thanks also by donating to opentuition, if the materials/lectures were useful.
Exam was horrendous in my opinion! Completely lost track of time on question 1 and spent 2 hours on it then struggled with questions 2 & 3. ACCA really isn’t helping it’s students by forcing them to take paper based exams especially for a paper like AFM where you need to lay out lengthy calculations and have to scribble your work out all the time to correct mistakes and makes answer look poor! Plus on every paper exam my tennis elbow flares up after about 15-20 minutes of writing! Putting question 1 in Japanese Yen when dealing with huge numbers and it a time controlled exam is just completely unnecessary and it makes the question more difficult than it needs to be! I guess that my score for this exam is probably around 40, either way I’m 99% certain I’ve failed the exam which is really disappointing ?
Question 1 was a complete disaster for me I cant even remember the other two because of it at one point during the npv computation I forgot which currency I was working with it completely confused me am glad I did it last. I am definatly not getting those professional marks.
Guys just want to know what was the number of contracts in que one
Can any one remember question 2 part b
Was it really a strange paper compared to past exam papers or me not being well prepared and a lack of practice.
I did look at currency risk mgt questions but none of those I worked was that lengthy! 2 bloody hours and 25 minutes and only wrote whatever I could for question 2 a... I was tired already after question 1... felt like it was never going to finish that damn question! Anyway, might just be a lack of practice... if I do get a pass good, if not... Dec exam.
640 contracts... that's what I got
0.57 that's right only I messed up the formula and had -0.57 . Did it correctly (i hope?) but then scratched it and added a damn minus in front of it...
What was the npv if anyone remembers? I had (JPY546m) ... I do not know what exchange rate I had.. can't remember it...
And currency option! Was there even an over or under hedged amount?! Jeez... that threw me off and I started questioning all my calculations I had done so far!
Oh well... let's hope so... but the lock in rate differs then right?
Anyway, what's done is done but what a draining paper. They removed the choice and made it lengthier... I wonder what's the sense..
Only after returning the paper I realised perhaps that's why there's the additional debt finance.. but still... I don't think I ever worked a question with no under/over hedging?
For question 1 I can remember putting that futures was the best approach and to sell 640 contracts and then close out the position by buying 640 contracts i think i had the gain at something like 10,051.36 million yen then after investing in treasury bills for 6 months came to 6 million yen. For the NPV part did everyone calculate working capital requirement? To get the ARD to JPY rate i took the mid point of the spread for ARD to EUR to JPY and x by (1 + hc/1 + hb) for the future years. For the additional sales at 25% contribution i just included this in the NPV after converting ARD to JPY then applied 30% tax. For the lost sales piece (110m JPY x inflation) did everyone put a tax saving on this?
Q1(C) was very bad for me. Had to leave it in the interest of time. I did Q2 and Q3 well enough, I hope. Just hope it's enough to pass. Estimating I completed around 70%. Last paper, 3rd attempt.
@sawalkhan11 said: Can any one remember question 2 part bI think it was behavioral finance.
how did u guys calculated the basis since the 6 month spot rate wasn't given?
It is so hard paper. I don't have enough time to read q3. So I left it blank paper. I don't know why acca try to lengthy question???
Thanks.. that's at least one mark or so then...
Npv I deducted the loss in sales... I'm not very sure that was good now...
1) adjusted the sales, deducted tax and deducted the amounts from translated
2) contribution , adjusted with inflation, calculated tax on it. Added after tax figures
3) calculated 15% adjusted tax on remitted cash flows
The exchange rate I don't what cross multiplication I did ... omitted that part of explanation while revising and was trying to recall what it was... blank moment for that.
1. It is forward. Not future contract.
@accastudentz said: Q1 I got Futures giving me the highest net Receipt. NPV was such a head F**k, but I think I had logic to what I was doing, just don't have that closure as we have never seen a question like it. had to translate the figures from ARD to € to then get them to YEN. took a few reads, serious head melter. Q2 Ratios & Trends for 20MARKS?? madness, straight out of P7 Q1 Analytical procedures type question, think I performed ok, the owner was window dressing as gearing was increasing along with Interest cover reducing , be difficult to continue Constant payout ratio Div Q3 FCFE for combined entity, one was FCFE with growth and the other was using a Multiple. a bit of guess work, but couldn't ram home the final part. all in all a very difficult unusual paper
To be fair, I was beginning to question my calculations midway. What I was doing in Q1 wasn't really making sense to even me anymore. I got completely confused at converting JPY to EUR and then to ARD and then to JPY.. It was just so confusing. I wasn't too familiar with how the examiner structured the exchange rates this time
It's quiet surprising to see a whole 20 marks on ratios and application though.. didn't see that coming.. managed to calculate and apply 5 ratios.
Thank God I finished ALL the theory questions before looking at any of the numbers. Would have lost some easy marks..
If I still don't pass, roll on APM!!
Additional debt finance, it seems I've got it completely wrong... Only said the difference in amounts... pfffft.
Options had the lowest receipts and forwards had a slightly lower receipt than futures but after writing about company's risk appetite, if they want to avoid any risk of fluctuations in premium forward contracts would be recommended then at the expense of a higher additional debt required than futures.
Spot rate minus the seven month contract rate given? And from that calculate the unexpired basis?
I was sooo upset about that 20 Mark question on ratios???
Of all things - I even studied Islamic finance, but was not expecting that...
I poured my heart out about how horrible this exam was the on ACCA feedback - do they want us to pass???
@skyisthelimit said: Spot rate minus the seven month contract rate given? And from that calculate the unexpired basis?but what do u subtract the basis from? u need the spot rate in 6 months time right?
Spent way too long on Q1. I calculated 160 contracts but clearly gone wrong somewhere as I can see most of you got around the 640 mark for contracts. But did find Futures to be the best out of the 3.
Exchange rate also confused me for NPV just had to go for the spot rate in the interest of time. Didn't even get round to answering the Treasury question.
Q2 seemed okay but felt my detail could have been more and Q3 on FCFE was a complete disaster. Attempted 89% but not hopeful.
@goeswhatever said: but what do u subtract the basis from? u need the spot rate in 6 months time right?You use the spot rate given and subtract the basis from it... because you are given spot and seven month rate but you need to find six months' rate so that's how you calculate the lock-in rate... or am i wrong?
I used the alternative way. I calculated the unexpired basis (1/7) then added it to futures.. so effectively I should get the same answer as you.
I believe you're correct
@skyisthelimit said: You use the spot rate given and subtract the basis from it... because you are given spot and seven month rate but you need to find six months' rate so that's how you calculate the lock-in rate... or am i wrong?oh yes, theres lock in method to use...I totally forgot about it. damn...
options would have got most receipt if there was no premium. the premium was for 300m alone
You forgot 4 month given? 7 subtract 4 x 2/3
@mjibola said: I used the alternative way. I calculated the unexpired basis (1/7) then added it to futures.. so effectively I should get the same answer as you. I believe you're correct
Overall not too bad a paper. I managed to have a decent go at every question. Hopefully I did enough and have just APM left!
Question 1 was pretty tough with a lot to do in the time given. I got the futures hedge as having the highest receipt, using the unexpired basis (1/7) to find the lock in rate.
To get the JPY-ARD exchange rate you had to use the 2 sets of euro spot rates given to you, then use the inflation rates to roll it forward. I'm not sure I used the right ones out of the 2 sets of rates to do this though!
The project had a negative NPV after factoring in the lost sales, extra contribution and the 30% tax on those plus 15% additional tax on the Airnone profits.
I was running out of time and didn't put much in my report for 1c. There wasn't much information to go on for non financial factors I didn't think. I talked about seeing if there were any follow on options which could be valued and might make the value positive. At this point I'd used up the allotted time so concluded my report to get the professional marks. 1d was a little waffling about centralised vs individual treasury teams.
I too was surprised by 20 marks for ratio analysis.This seemed more like a P3 question to me. Even though there were past exam questions like it, I assumed it wouldn't come up and didn't practice it much.
However there was plenty of information in the figures to use, including some that contradicted the CEO's comments. 2b was behavioural finance, I talked about herd instinct, confirmation bias and anchoring.
Question 3 I calculated that Chris Chawon gained about 64m and the current owners actually lost money so the deal should be renegotiated.
In 3b I said there were quite a few reasons as to why the synergies might not be achieved such as the different staff culture and the different financial and operating gearing approaches, and that Chris Chawon wasn't a suitable person to lead the transformation.
3c was something about what factors would the board consider in deciding what kind of finance to issue, I waffled a few points for this and then time was up!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

