Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

APM*** ACCA P5 September 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin9y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA P5 September 2017 Exam

*** ACCA P5 September 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** ACCA P5 September 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about the ACCA P5 exam below (comments will open after 5pm UK)
VVasilis9y ago#31
@anastell said: I also received 300 cost gap per engine. The paper was fair in comparison with the previous! Hope for a pass. What about the quality costs. The casus stated that the CEO has calculated the prevention costs and is aware of them but wants information for the other three categories of quality costs. Then the Q requirement was calculate and determine by group the costs of quality. The Appendix contained data for training costs which are prevention costs. I was a little bit confused between the casus text and the Q requirment. However, decided to group the prevention and appraisal quality costs in one column with commented of my assumption. What about you guys?
Well anastell, that was a confusing question... as many times in acca you are not pretty sure about what are you are being asked for...(at least this happens to me the last 4 years in many differene acca papers). in that list in the appendix...there were for sure external failure quality costs...so taking into account that i assumed that the ceo wanted to categorise all those different types of costs into the 4 different q.costs categories... so i did that.. and then gave some proposals for extra cost categories where quality costs can be hidden
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#32
@vaskont7 said: We have exactly the same results in all figures… for target cost gap its good cause i spent a lot of time on that during the exam date so i think that it cant be wrong for both of us… for roce (i caclulated the average capit employed (beg+clos)/2) and ebitda we have the same results as well…however i did them super fastly..so i dont know if there are so simple as what i wrote down…
What if we use closing figure for ROCE?
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#33
@vaskont7 said: Well anastell, that was a confusing question... as many times in acca you are not pretty sure about what are you are being asked for...(at least this happens to me the last 4 years in many differene acca papers). in that list in the appendix...there were for sure external failure quality costs...so taking into account that i assumed that the ceo wanted to categorise all those different types of costs into the 4 different q.costs categories... so i did that.. and then gave some proposals for extra cost categories where quality costs can be hidden
I did the same for last part of q1, there were fault finding costs, potentially lost revenue, PR costs, Rework costs in both external and internal failures. And I believe quality control is an appraisal cost as you train your staff to control quality (checking) rather than assuring it
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#34
What did you guys write in Target Costing with TQM?
VVasilis9y ago#35
@sa1pw said: What if we use closing figure for ROCE?
well I calculated the avg capital employed, because somewhere in the scenario it was mentioned that the ceo was cared about average capital employed, or something like that.... i really dont remember what exactly it was mentioned...but it was a phrase like that...
DDebbie9y ago#36
It definitely said the CEO used average capital employed so you had the Opening Balance and the Closing balances and then divide by 2 to get average Cap Empl.
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#37
@debbielynch said: It definitely said the CEO used average capital employed so you had the Opening Balance and the Closing balances and then divide by 2 to get average Cap Empl.
I missed this part of CEO. Although used correct operating profit figure and made comments on ROCE like it favoring depreciated equipment, discouraged investment like the benchmark company had made, both were listed company so ROCE may show returns but will not evaluate long term value companies are creating for investors.
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#38
@vaskont7 said: well I calculated the avg capital employed, because somewhere in the scenario it was mentioned that the ceo was cared about average capital employed, or something like that.... i really dont remember what exactly it was mentioned...but it was a phrase like that...
Am I likely to loose whole marks for not considering average but closing figure for ROCE?
OOleksii9y ago#39
I added back impairment of goodwill for EBITDA calculations. Was it correct?
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#40
@oleksiiponomarenko said: I added back impairment of goodwill for EBITDA calculations. Was it correct?
Nope, you had to consider only amortization and not impairment.
OOleksii9y ago#41
But i found examples of ebitda calculation with adding back goodwill :( maybe someone made the same calculations as me?
Former userFormer user9y ago#42
Yes capital employed=Total assets-current liabilities=(the same as)Total equity+Long term liabilities (balnce sheet equation)
Former userFormer user9y ago#43
@sa1pw said: How did you calculate ROCE? I deducted current liabilities from total assets. And EBITDA I think was same, although I may have screwed up in totalling by calculator
Yes capital employed=Total assets-current liabilities=(the same as)Total equity+Long term liabilities (balance sheet equation)
Former userFormer user9y ago#44
@oleksiiponomarenko said: But i found examples of ebitda calculation with adding back goodwill :( maybe someone made the same calculations as me?
I also added noting this as "one off event adjustment". In this case EBITDA was 51 (and 27 before adding goodwill).
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#45
@olshevskiy said: Yes capital employed=Total assets-current liabilities=(the same as)Total equity+Long term liabilities (balance sheet equation)
But I did not use Average Capital Rather Closing Capital.
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#46
What did you guys write in benchmarking part?
AAhmed9y ago#47
There was no impairment costs, it had given depreciation costs in notes i gues
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#48
@khalilm said: There was no impairment costs, it had given depreciation costs in notes i gues
Impairment was given in first paragraph
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#49
@sa1pw said: What did you guys write in benchmarking part?
Anyone?
OOleksii9y ago#50
I wrote about different economy, accounting practices in countries, scope of the products, grants from the government as factors influenced on benchmarking results which should to be taken into account
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#51
@oleksiiponomarenko said: I wrote about different economy, accounting practices in countries, scope of the products, grants from the government as factors influenced on benchmarking results which should to be taken into account
I wrote: -Customers difference, they have adopted the electric cars and if now business tries to flow up and do something similar to improve (as board using results to move to electric cars) they need to consider that customers may not have electric cars here which may devalue exercise of benchmarking -Economy is different, one is going up other is depressed. So ultimately that will show up on results also if any management steps are to be carried out economic scenario of our country must be considered -Non financial figures are not available, so we can't actually see what other company is doing better and what we actually be required to do -Reliability of figures, the figures maybe manipulated and not giving fair representation so any decision taken upon benchmark basis maybe inaccurate! -Political difference, Government is encouraging the development in benchmark company country, but it's not the case here. Also there are issues like different treatment like capitalization of development so comparability is an issue and how fair the figures represent -The industrial difference like components availability and cost, veeland has low cost components available to produce, this will not only reflect on profits aslower cost but also if business are to take better decision for performance management and follow up benchmark company and it's activities, they need to consider industry, components price and availability -The debt market is different, loan are easily available in benchmark company country from which they have invested including new IT system but we may not have such access to debt like benchmark company to invest and make use of opportunities which may cause trouble despite us knowing what to do from benchmark results Anyone else?
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#52
@vaskont7 said: well I calculated the avg capital employed, because somewhere in the scenario it was mentioned that the ceo was cared about average capital employed, or something like that.... i really dont remember what exactly it was mentioned...but it was a phrase like that...
@vaskont7 what did u write in benchmarking problems in performance management? I think we had to comment on non availability on non financial data, govt. encouraging the investment in electric car sector so obviously Different performance itself by nature, customers had electric cars in other country and other company was investing in that sector to provide them fuel but our country had no such point like use of electric cars by customers so we can't take use of such opportunity like other company had, other industrial factors were encouraging other company such as loans being available and lower components cost but no such area of prospect available in our country to improve performance so we will face issue to plan returns by implementing a similar approach to improve which benchmark company has
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#53
@vaskont7 What did you mention in Benchmarking Problems for Performance Management? Let's see if points reconcile: -Only financial data given but it's non-financial data that shows difference between the two business and what board should really plan for -There were issues with benchmarks such as the choice of measures for benchmarking, Also one company was capitalizing development so by nature will be tough to evaluate them using certain financial measures and then use figures to assess -Benchmarked company's customers had moved to electric cars while in our country there was no such trend so benchmark and all these figures will be useless if we can't manage by carrying these operations and going ahead in operations -Economies of both countries were different so by nature their performance will be different making it rather tough to evaluate if benchmarking will provide value and how can business take account of varying environment in our country to manage(Developing economy vs an economy on low) -Govt and other such factors were clearly in favor of of electric cars and development expenditure (Benchmarked company hd even made expenditure on new IT Systems), So due to such external issues performance difference will arise and provide trouble in managing performance -Reliability of data can be questioned which will make further issues when managing performance using the data which in first may not be reliable (profits and capital can be manipulated figures)
Former userFormer user9y ago#54
@sa1pw said: Anyone?
Yes Impairment was given in the 1st paragraph but how did you treat it? I didn't add it back to arrive to EBITDA....
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#55
@lucamucciaccia said: Yes Impairment was given in the 1st paragraph but how did you treat it? I didn't add it back to arrive to EBITDA....
Deducted impairment from p&l expense, and add answer to operating profit
VVasilis9y ago#56
@lucamucciaccia said: Yes Impairment was given in the 1st paragraph but how did you treat it? I didn't add it back to arrive to EBITDA....
more or less we have the same points... i think I have 4 points as you....most of them are comon sense points....i just had an extra point (but i am not pretty sure whether its a good one), telling that the benchmarking exercise is better to have been performed against a company that is on exactly the same phase and not on a company that has already moved to the new electr sector 2 years ago..and that due to the fact that it could be seen as a "manipulation" of benchmarking exercise to select a company that has performed a shift to a new Indurstry and the results are already known...
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#57
@vaskont7 said: more or less we have the same points... i think I have 4 points as you....most of them are comon sense points....i just had an extra point (but i am not pretty sure whether its a good one), telling that the benchmarking exercise is better to have been performed against a company that is on exactly the same phase and not on a company that has already moved to the new electr sector 2 years ago..and that due to the fact that it could be seen as a "manipulation" of benchmarking exercise to select a company that has performed a shift to a new Indurstry and the results are already known...
And what did you mention for ROCE and EBITDA as performance measures for benchmark? I suggested, For ROCE: -Considers company size (both companies were of different size so different capital base) -Considers returns for shareholders as how much profits made against capital, measuring business efficiency -Can be very much encouraging dysfunctional behavior by supporting company that uses old depreciated asset (it was evident that the company with old assets had higher ROCE) -Discourages Capital Expenditure and does not consider long term value for SH -Company in veeland was capitalizing development costs, so it was likely to have lower ROCE as it's capital base got higher EBITDA: -More closer to cash as removes assumptions like depreciation, so shareholder perspective better evaluated -Less subject to manipulation with a assumptions like depreciation that can be easily manipulated by accounting treatments -Better shows earnings and returns, As removes uncontrollable factors, so better evaluated performance of both companies With respect to their earnings -But does not take account of finance costs and WACC, nor the capital invested, So potentially investors could be seeking a very high return and coat of capital for company( Veeland company had invested alot in debt) -Also does not take account of size of the companies as evident that one company had significantly higher capital base so, A larger company is bound to generate more profits/earnings (It's a nominal measure)
Former userFormer user9y ago#58
Did someone noted, that for benchmarking exercise financial data was given for different years for both companies? If I remember correctly, that for second company it was Y2015, but for first one it was Y2016 or half of Y2017, something like that.
HHamzaSupporter9y ago#59
@pecukinjsh said: Did someone noted, that for benchmarking exercise financial data was given for different years for both companies? If I remember correctly, that for second company it was Y2015, but for first one it was Y2016 or half of Y2017, something like that.
I didn't notice this.
VVasilis9y ago#60
@sa1pw said: @vaskont7 What did you mention in Benchmarking Problems for Performance Management? Let's see if points reconcile: -Only financial data given but it's non-financial data that shows difference between the two business and what board should really plan for -There were issues with benchmarks such as the choice of measures for benchmarking, Also one company was capitalizing development so by nature will be tough to evaluate them using certain financial measures and then use figures to assess -Benchmarked company's customers had moved to electric cars while in our country there was no such trend so benchmark and all these figures will be useless if we can't manage by carrying these operations and going ahead in operations -Economies of both countries were different so by nature their performance will be different making it rather tough to evaluate if benchmarking will provide value and how can business take account of varying environment in our country to manage(Developing economy vs an economy on low) -Govt and other such factors were clearly in favor of of electric cars and development expenditure (Benchmarked company hd even made expenditure on new IT Systems), So due to such external issues performance difference will arise and provide trouble in managing performance -Reliability of data can be questioned which will make further issues when managing performance using the data which in first may not be reliable (profits and capital can be manipulated figures)
Well we havee some reconciling items...hehe. :p :p. just kidding... more or less is the same .. we are the same at 4 from your points (i didnt write down the 1st one..but i saw that most of you did...so itt was a kind of clisee, but my practise at exam kit book wwas poor)... i also mentioned that it was not a good choise to benchmark against a company that its on a different b phase... (the had already moved into electr cars 2 years ago) cause is a kind of "manipulating" benchmarking exercise...it would be better to benchmark against a company that is exactly on the same phase....however i dont know whether that was a good one. it may be stupid...anyways..just wrote it down to have 5 points ( it was a 7 points question, isnt it?)
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.