APM*** ACCA P5 September 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
I found the paper to be a difficult one, the main issue for me was that the optional questions were too long giving all the complications that existed in the scenario and the time available to read and plan how to appropriately answer the questions.
Hi all,
Interesting hearing people's thoughts about the wording of the questions causing confusion. Is it possible the confusion is because you haven't fully studied and understood the subject rather than the examiner's grammar?
IMO the questions themselves were not confusing but looking at the past ten papers, you gotta say the scenarios were all comparatively lengthy. Typically, one out of 3 questions in section B would be shorter.
I implore the markers to be flexible in assessing the candidates knowledge. For example in 1a, if I wrote on the prisms advantage over the BSc, I shd be given marks for it because they are the facts. Just because it's "out of the sylllabus" does not mean the argument isn't valid. And why the abrupt change in syllabus? September candidates are usually June 16 failures so the sudden drop of topics isn't very helpful IMO.
I did same as most of you. Q1 and then q2 and q 4 - I taught myself home study. And found it ok although forgot stuff as large syllabus and did my best with what I knew. I thought fair but difficult paper but all acca exams are hard- otherwise everyone would do acca if it did challenge ! We are clever to get to this stage. I will resist if I fail this paper as thought mostly a fair paper.
Question 1... i) Problems of BSC...The cost paid to the consultant may outweigh the benefit obtained as the same performance metrics recommended by the consultant. second Bsc is a time consuming exercise. Third BSC may be difficult to understand some measures. Fourth BSC gives too many information so that information overload. and so on
ii) The current PM is helpful in measuring performance specially the profitability of the company. Financial measures are easy to calculate and understand. Most of the objectives measured except on strategy. But all metrics are Financial and not including Non Financial measures that can measure important performance areas. Second all measures internally focused.
The Proposed performance measures:- Looking at critical areas of companies strategies by devising BSC. The learning and innovation perspective is additional area by the proposal. But, The PM metrics are the same as the current PM metrics. It doesn't come up with non financial measures. Financial measures like EVA are more important than ROCE as they provide information on value creation for shareholders.
iii)The FOUR different computations of ROCE. This can be calculated from the given profit figures and CE figures. and Net profit divided by Total Capital employed 11% is more appropriate for the whole company not for the division. The first computation (operating profit divided by Total CE) good for measuring division performance that are controllable profit figures.
iv) TQM and Current Quality management.
Current quality management has a 47% failure costs from the total quality cost that can be avoided if company works on quality. (Computation of quality cost is easy as given in the scenario.
TQM..Modern philosophy of manufacturing and Continues improvement of quality and zero defects. if implemented the 47% defect can be avoided.
v) Lean...Avoiding wastage and reducing cost and information flow become more flexible and timely with more reliable fashion. The scientists can update themselves and can be innovative and efficiency may be obtained if implemented.
These was my answers for Q1 shortly. am I on the right truck? please comment on my answer.
The first question asked about the problems with implementing the BSC in the company, why would you be given marks talking about the prism?
Depends on how the arguments are framed. Anyway the prism was only used to highlight the weakness of the BSc in determining stakeholder demands and contribution. If I fail it would be question 2 which I should have done first in hindsight.
Do all of you always start with q1? For all the level 3 papers I start with the optional ones. It's back to the drawing board for me. Sigh
would like to ask about question number 4 part a i and ii
what was the question about ? I don’t remember the exact requirement. I linked how the proposed kpi (bying internally) would help achieve the objectives (4 objectives given in the scenario). do i make sense ?
for the first part i again wrote how focusing on csf would help achieve the objectives (again took the 4 objectives in turn without taking any csf into consideration)..
Lastly, what are some of the issues in taking market price as the transfer price ?
Should we base the answer on division C solely or should we also consider other division B ?
@danielglover said: Hi all, Interesting hearing people's thoughts about the wording of the questions causing confusion. Is it possible the confusion is because you haven't fully studied and understood the subject rather than the examiner's grammar?For most people taking this course English is not our mother tongue. That said there is something about the way P5 questions are asked that leaves most wondering what does the examiner really want.
@maineventqk said: IMO the questions themselves were not confusing but looking at the past ten papers, you gotta say the scenarios were all comparatively lengthy. Typically, one out of 3 questions in section B would be shorter. I implore the markers to be flexible in assessing the candidates knowledge. For example in 1a, if I wrote on the prisms advantage over the BSc, I shd be given marks for it because they are the facts. Just because it's "out of the sylllabus" does not mean the argument isn't valid. And why the abrupt change in syllabus? September candidates are usually June 16 failures so the sudden drop of topics isn't very helpful IMO.JUST BECAUSE IT'S "OUT OF THE SYLLABUS" DOES NOT MEAN THE ARGUMENT IS INVALID. Thank you!!
I cannot imagine doing these exams in another language! It must be hard.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

