APM*** ACCA P5 September 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
sorry for slight delay :) you can post your comments now, thank you :)
All in all it seemed okay, time being the most critical factor again!
Left 8 marks because of time.
I struggled with profit and capital measurements. Anyone got that?
Did question 2 and 4. There were hardly any calculations. Or maybe I didn't do it :s
I did the same 2. What was Q2 about?
I did some calculation while doing VFM for Efficiency, Effectiveness and Economy. Was this required to prove that they did not achieve Value for money?
I did the same conclusion. But I couldn't do a lot of calculations. I took the number of calls not answered as a percentage of total number of calls. I compared the company with the other two on a couple of pounts. Couldn't do in detail though.
Also I think I spent too much time doing part one of question two. For the KPI identified I concluded that it was not a good KPI.
Ahhh I thought to myself the VFM was the 3 E's but then convinced myself it wasn't...
That's so frustrating!!
First time sitting P5 for me, so not entirely sure how harsh the marking is.
Q1 was tough. I'd hope for some decent marks for the Lean Info and CoQ/TQM. BS weaknesses wasn't really an area I had revised, so just went with conflicting info and excludes external stakeholders whilst rambling on about the model. Capital Measurements was tough. Just made an educated guess. The performance measurements used / proposed didn't really apply to maximising S/H wealth. I just threw out EVA and RI definition and moved swiftly on.
Q2 was Benchmarking, and it was basically the NHS vs Bupa from what I could make out. Some of the measures were relevant, but didn't really have much time to suggest alternatives. The Bupa type firm was a poor fit, but the tax office call centre was obviously a good comparative - hopefully some easyish marks there.
Q4 was Transfer Pricing. I just applied the GAP mnemonic and tried to link to scenario. Then explained the weaknesses with a Market rate. Part (a) I'm convinced was missing a verb as the sentence didn't read clearly. Was to do with CSF's and KPI's. Just threw whatever I could get down with 6 minutes to go.
Not super confident, but sitting P7 Monday was definitely to the detriment of this. Just praying it's good news in October, sick to death of exams.
Good luck everyone.
@ryansm05 said: Ahhh I thought to myself the VFM was the 3 E's but then convinced myself it wasn't... That's so frustrating!! First time sitting P5 for me, so not entirely sure how harsh the marking is. Q1 was tough. I'd hope for some decent marks for the Lean Info and CoQ/TQM. BS weaknesses wasn't really an area I had revised, so just went with conflicting info and excludes external stakeholders whilst rambling on about the model. Capital Measurements was tough. Just made an educated guess. The performance measurements used / proposed didn't really apply to maximising S/H wealth. I just threw out EVA and RI definition and moved swiftly on.Was lean info system about The 5 S model? For CoQ I wrote about cost of prevention, detection, internal failure and external failure. I wrote random stuff about the BSC too. Also mentioned EVA and market share. I compared all the profits under the part that mentioned return on investments. And I wrote that taking just equity is not appropriate for the calculation of ROCE or ROI. As cost of equity is higher and secondly if debt is completely ignored the company might be tempted to take even more loans which will make its gearing position bad. For this same part I also mentioned Residual income. I mentioned about VFM and 3Es somewhere in question one as well. :S
@Minaa said: Was lean info system about The 5 S model? For CoQ I wrote about cost of prevention, detection, internal failure and external failure. I wrote random stuff about the BSC too. Also mentioned EVA and market share. I compared all the profits under the part that mentioned return on investments. And I wrote that taking just equity is not appropriate for the calculation of ROCE or ROI. As cost of equity is higher and secondly if debt is completely ignored the company might be tempted to take even more loans which will make its gearing position bad. For this same part I also mentioned Residual income. I mentioned about VFM and 3Es somewhere in question one as well. :SThere will be people on here better placed to answer that. I just thought Lean info was the Right Info > Right People > Right time by focusing on end-user, avoiding info overload and one other I've forgotten. I then linked it to an ERP system as I'm sure there was something on this in the Q???
Oh!!!
For the capital question in part one i basically said it should be the profit before tax/(equity + long term debt) as PBT is the most accurate controllable profit answer. Gave few examples of using different profit figure or without including debt and how it can mislead investors and grossly overstate the ROCE perecentage
Its like all you chaps avoided question Q3.What was Question
three all about
It was about ABC. I thought of attempting it but didn't have much to write about EMA.
Time time time!!!!the paper was not bad but time cannot permit me...information overload was the weakness found in the paper!
Thought Lean Management was about TQM, Kaizen costing and Just in time... All 3 used at once control and improve performance.
Didn't do enough calculations and wasted too much time on number one.
Answered 2 and 4.
I always compare Benchmarking with Performance prism in my head, almost similar but BM doesn't not take into account stakeholder satisfaction and contribution. So mentioned that as a negative.
I think so too. As I used same approach.
Time pressure was an issue.
Question 1:
Problems to implement BS
Problems with given KPIs
Profit and capital employed - different calculations implications
TQM
Lean system
Question 4
Benchmarking in healthcare call center answer to meet objectives
VFM
Comparision state-owned and private call center performance.
Question 2
Transfer pricing oriented to external market
Current transfer pricing policy
Impact of new CSF (buy almost internally)
Question 3
ABC + KPIs
As question 1 took most time, I had to skip question 3 only because it looked lengthy.
Completed 60% of question 2.
My second attempt. After exam, it seems not as difficult as seemed before. But as usual it was difficult what the examiner wants.
The paper was overwhelming. After u attempt Question 1 u left drain. Too muchard to do and do little time. U really have to earn every mark in the paper.
I am very disappointed not in myself but the way the examiner are setting these papers.
Time pressured paper, part 2 questions scenarios are long.
Does anyone else think that June 16 was way easier than this? And I only got 46. Am I screwed this time or what. Might as well start preparing for December now.
The jokes on me. I actually failed to read up on syllabus updates and assumed prism and beyond budget were the sure bets this time. Don't do silly sxxx like me.
So in q1 I wrote two points on how prism is better than BSc! You think I'll get any marks?
@tinusunit said: Thought Lean Management was about TQM, Kaizen costing and Just in time... All 3 used at once control and improve performance. Didn't do enough calculations and wasted too much time on number one. Answered 2 and 4. I always compare Benchmarking with Performance prism in my head, almost similar but BM doesn't not take into account stakeholder satisfaction and contribution. So mentioned that as a negative.I don't think mentioning performance prism was a good idea as it was taken out of the syllabus for this sitting
@ryansm05 said: Q2 was Benchmarking, and it was basically the NHS vs Bupa from what I could make out. Some of the measures were relevant, but didn't really have much time to suggest alternatives. The Bupa type firm was a poor fit, but the tax office call centre was obviously a good comparative - hopefully some easyish marks there. Not super confident, but sitting P7 Monday was definitely to the detriment of this. Just praying it's good news in October, sick to death of exams. Good luck everyone.You mean the benchmarked call centre was a tax office one? I must have missed read it completely. I thought it was another govt HEALTHCARE centre. Must have been the panic button. I only left 35 min for that qn. Btw you are P7 student, can you compare the difficulty of P7 to P2 and P5? I'm struggling with P5 but hated P2 which is why I never thought about P7.
@vinai said: I don't think mentioning performance prism was a good idea as it was taken out of the syllabus for this sitting@vinia, I said "in my head".. I didn't mention performance prism. Mentioning Stakeholder satisfaction and contribution however was probably not a good idea. Here's the downside of not reading the based on syllabus and might be penalised for that.
This paper was not bad to me at all, I just didn't have enough time to articulate what I wanted to write properly in the allotted timeframe.
@harsh444 said: Left 8 marks because of time. I struggled with profit and capital measurements. Anyone got that?I just think, the ROCE should reflect the primary objectives of the organisation, eg maximize the shareholder returns, therefore the Profit should be : Net Profit ( residual value available to shareholder) and Captial is Equity, the solely contribution from Shareholders, anyone think like me?
What was question 4 part a trying to ask? The requirement didn't make any sense, I talked about how csfs focus the organisation but couldn't really come up with much else!
The scenarios were too long, when I picked up the paper I thought it felt thicker than usual (this is my 4th sitting)
I felt really prepared for this sitting but just could digest the scenarios quick enough, seriously thinking of switching to P7 now!
The question 2 part b VFm I got they were good VFM. They had saved 433000 people from going to hospital rather than directly going to hospital which is 40 times costlier than this service. They had saved about $40m as opposed to their $4m cost.
also they had lower cost per call and cost per saved hospital visit?
Am I wrong????
And for benchmarkING I wrote it was absurd to compare the health service which provide 24/365 to tax 9 to 5 260 days and already had info on their computers while medical had to analyse the info given by caller to make decision...?
Will I get any marks???
i felt this paper was very time pressured. Spent too long on q1.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

