APM*** ACCA P5 March 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Well i answered in a different way
Define target costing
How it works
Relates to scenerio
And then its benifits
Thts it
Is that wrong? ?
Tommy, right i also suggest stuff like yours.. ?
I think I messed it up again.
First question was a disaster. I had no idea about the theory the paper had asked. I had no idea about the "other performance measures" question it had asked.
I think I'll not Waite for the results. I am going to study for the same exam again. ?
Too bad they don't even upload past question papers online ?
i thinking the same too... why no one did Q2....
Guys/Girls..
I think I have figured out what they actually wanted in question 4 part b where it said calculate whether she should get the bonus.
I reckon they wanted us to calculate ROI (and suggest this was a better measure as it captures controllable profits) and/or residual income as otherwise why would they have included the debt/equity betas etc and capital employed?
I don't think I did very well in this question as I just inflated the revenue to take account of the depreciation on the domestic currency..
It makes sense that they would have wanted ROI calculated as the last part was EVA so i think it wanted us to cover this whole part of the syllabus but the revenue adjustment through me..
Hope we all done enough in the other parts to pass..
I have the very same frustration. :(
I also answered question 2 and 3. Question 3 I did not really get into it there was no time left.
@chullbulla said: If primary currency weak you receive more money means revenue increased by 15% for six months 4000 X1.15 = 4600 for six months and 4000 for first six monthsI did it this way: x = per month cost 6x + 6x(1.15) = 4800
Why are u people discussing what u did for your answer and get ur blood pressure up? i find that very foolish. We all studied and did our best now lets wait in 6 weeks time for teh results.
I found this paper very tricky...all the questions required one to think a lot and that resulted to me running out of time.
If i happen to pass this paper - i shall praise the Almighty God - with God anything is possible.
Meanwhile i have started studying the same paper ..so that if i don't make it - June 2017 will be my another exams session.
For those of you who are in the United Kingdom, please be my study buddies - i need help to go through this paper. I need to do alot of mocks and other exams materials.
Please help a brother.
I wonder how realistic is it to gain the four professional marks awarded in q1. I understand the criteria for this i.e. structure, tone and professional report writing style. It would be interesting to see how many people actually gain the full four here.
I wonder also if you will gain marks in Q2 for identifying that the business processes were weak and could be inflating costs i.e. this is something they should look to fix or improve.
Thoughts?
For Q4a, I said she does not deserve any bonuses, as:
1. The total revenue should have been adjusted by 600 (4000 + 4000x(1-0.15) = 7400), so a (600) c.u. less to profit;
2. Depreciation - I've adjusted 350 c.u. as (385 - 350), assuming that purchase and put in service of new equipment has impacted significantly the npm, whilst took 35 c.u. charge from domestic unit as a reference point. Anyway, it's an assumption;
3. As for HQ costs' allocation - i did nothing, however I was very clear in supposing that both domestic and export divisions are in the same conditions (same split structure, based on revenue approach), so even if not controlled by the manager, it's more or less fair to charge the Export division, also considering that Domestic division has been charged too, however it has reached the 8% threshold. I can't recall the exact figures, but I got around 5% npm. Anybody followed any of my steps?
Hi vitalbutnary to summarise:
1. I agree with revenue recalculated being @ 7400
2. I left the depreciation into the controllable profit (even if the investments are decided by head office) because there are benefits in efficiency (eg cost of good sold)
3. I removed the HQ cost allocation, not controllable.
overall the she doesn't deserve the bonus
The domestic currency depreciated, and the firm sells overseas. Therefore the revenue is INFLATED as the foreign currency earned has appreciated. Therefore 600 additional revenue (and profit as cost in domestic currency) meaning she does deserve the bonus.
This is very topical, and probably based around brexit. Anyone with any business knowledge will know the £ has recently tanked against all world currencies by c. 15%. The effect of that has been a boom in revenues and profits for exporters, such as dometically based manufacturers) which was the case here.
This is also partly the reason why the FTSE 100 rallied so strongly after brexit. The £ tanked, and many firms like shell pay dividends in $. A weakening domestic currency led to an appreciation of the dividend yield making it more attractive for uk investors when it was converted to £- exactly the same concept as for the firm in the question who was selling abroad and their domestic currency tanked 15%.
@vitalbutnaru said: For Q4a, I said she does not deserve any bonuses, as: 1. The total revenue should have been adjusted by 600 (4000 + 4000x(1-0.15) = 7400), so a (600) c.u. less to profit; 2. Depreciation - I've adjusted 350 c.u. as (385 - 350), assuming that purchase and put in service of new equipment has impacted significantly the npm, whilst took 35 c.u. charge from domestic unit as a reference point. Anyway, it's an assumption; 3. As for HQ costs' allocation - i did nothing, however I was very clear in supposing that both domestic and export divisions are in the same conditions (same split structure, based on revenue approach), so even if not controlled by the manager, it's more or less fair to charge the Export division, also considering that Domestic division has been charged too, however it has reached the 8% threshold. I can't recall the exact figures, but I got around 5% npm. Anybody followed any of my steps?
Mark you are funny :)
did you vote for the brexit?
I don’t think I did very well in this question as I just inflated the revenue to take account of the depreciation on the domestic currency......
:)
I also love the explanation brexit/rally of FTSE100
More seriously did you ask yourself in which currency does the company sell abroad?
This is the central point I am afraid
SO I can remember what was in the March exam (as I will undoubtedly be resitting it):
Q1 Based on a Facilities Management Company (not a business I'm familiar with)
KPI's (operating profit margin, secure orders, manager retention, order book)
mission statement was to maintain profit for shareholders and retain staff to become world class and maximise efficiency (or something like that)
Q was to evaluate assumptions & definitions built into KPI's, how do performance indicators link to mission statement/strategy, evaluate rewards of staff (2 options)
Q2 target costing & Kaizen
Q3 Geeland - Jayland KPI suitability
retail store & rewards for staff (bonus)
Part A) 5 marks B) 8 marks Part C) 12 marks
Pick 3 social performance indicators for Jayland to measure against mission (mission to take advantage of increasing incomes & population movement into Jayland)
and to increase brand, promote quality products in right geographical areas of Jayland
Q4 Net profit (divisions) export manager (reward/bonus) & EVA
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

