Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

APM*** ACCA P5 March 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin9y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA P5 March 2017 Exam

*** ACCA P5 March 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** ACCA P5 March 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about the ACCA P5 exam below (comments will be opened after 5pm UK)
CChris9y ago#1
Question 4 I adjusted revenue for exchange rate movement (down by 7.5%). Removed head office allocation, bad debt expense (noted I was assuming this is finance's fault) and depreciation as they are not controllable by the manager. That gave a controllable margin of 11%
CChris9y ago#2
Time managed pretty badly. Expecting a fail for the second time sadly. It's frustrating when I have passed the other 13 exams first time
Ssh9y ago#3
Hi guys, I did questions 1, 3 & 4. I generally found I struggled to have enough points for most of the questions to go with the mark allocation. Q1) part i - I think was to comment on the kpi's and did they fit with the mission statement. I think I picked up 3 parts to mission statement a) profit b) staff training c) to be the best (my memory is a bit hazy now). I didn't think any kpi's measured the first part. Manager retention sort of for the middle part and there were some that did measure the first part. ii - can't remember this part iii - I pointed out points about the dashboard eg.no nfpi, no narrative, iv - I remembered the building block parts but struggled to link it to the question v - I said scheme 2 was best couldn't find many positives about scheme 1 Q4) I said she deserved the bonus. I said she was right as npm should not include head office costs struggled to say much else so said roi and right should be used for the import division - don't know if this was going off track b - I calculated npm adding back head office costs, calculated the wacc but can't remember why now, calculated roce. Said she deserved the bonus but felt I was clutching at straws to make valid points c - I said Eva should be used in import division not export tho. I listed some Eva adv and disadv not sure if this is what was wanted??? Q3 came up with some random kpi's for part course struggled with the q
CChris9y ago#4
I think we've got to assume that they treated the machine purchase correctly and put it in fixed assets and hence it won't affect the P&L so no adjustment is needed for this. I also added that once we removed the uncontrollable costs, hitting the 8% target becomes significantly easier so the company may wish to raise this threshold
Kkhizrak9y ago#5
I did question 1 3 and 4. Question 1 was fairly easy but lengthy. 3 was easy too but i got stuck in the last requirement of 12 marks which had part of KPIs of political situation of Jayland. In the q 1, I used the reward management system (strategic focus, reward objective, reward options, reward techniques and reward competitiveness) for the analysis of scheme 1 and 2. Did anyone else do this? Pleaasee tell me! :)
Kkhizrak9y ago#6
What was the NP Margin level after the adjustments? My answer was 11%. I adjusted the cost of sales with the exchange rate for the last six months and first six months. Used algebra to get to the answer: 6x + 6(1.15)x = 4800 then inputted the cost of sales ajusted. Sales remained 8k. I did not take the overhead adjustments cuz needed to make the profit controllable. Did not include machinery cost cuz it was supposed to be added in balance sheet. Took the other overheads and also took the depreciation expense. With this my profit figure was around 900 something and the NP margin was 11% so bonus should be granted.
CChris9y ago#7
Q1 reward system appraisal I did this badly but I tried to relate the two bonus schemes to the building block model described in the previous part of the question. Basically scheme 1 was had no clarity and appeared to be unfair and uncontrollable so would not motivate employees. Only good thing was it involved shares Scheme 2 involved employee participation so was more motivating and basically agreed with all other points of the building block model Also the 50% bonus size should be a sensible amount to align the risk attitudes of the employees with the owners who wanted to see growth
SShahim9y ago#8
For question no 4 i wrote she deserved the bonus since she has considered the long term objective of the company and has purchased the machinery which has in return has improved the overall efficiency of the division by jeopardizing her bonus pay. Where as the other division has postponed their decision to purchase the machinery since they will not achieve their short term objective of maximizing divisional performance.
CChris9y ago#9
I think it said the domestic currency had weakened and hence the revenue in the overseas currency would translate to a larger amount of domestic currency. Therefore we need to reduce the revenue figure to get a fair comparable
Rrasib9y ago#10
Q1 was easy.. part a b n c was related to mission Part d building block model explain n relate to scenerio Part e scheme was also fine drawbacks n good points for both Why dont anyone attempt part b I thought it was damn easy Target costing and its implication Kaizan costing and its implication simple Relate to scenerio Why u guys dont attemp this question Am worried did i done something wrong??
GGreggie9y ago#11
A bit baffled by the EVA part of q4. It gave most indicators for an EVA calc, but then specifically said not to calculate it.
MMark9y ago#12
Yep- spot on, that is exactly what I did which boosted profits by the additional 600 too as costs were in domestic currency. That took the margin to well over the 8% level and meant the manager should have got the bonus (as the exchange rate was out of her control).
@chullbulla said: If primary currency weak you receive more money means revenue increased by 15% for six months 4000 X1.15 = 4600 for six months and 4000 for first six months
Former userFormer user9y ago#13
the price (and the FX rate) was set at the beginning of the year for one year therefore the Export division is taking advantage of this for the second half of the year. The turnover should have been 7400
GGreggie9y ago#14
I thought it more 85:100 as opposed to 100:115?
SShaheen9y ago#15
Same thoughts. Q2 was the easiest, so am wondering why many did not attempt it. For Q1 (b), a Q worth 12 marks asking to assess the assumption and description of the KPI - well I was struggling with this question. Can anyone help here? For Q3,I was struggling in answering the questions relating to technological factors and the other one regarding political factors on Jayland compared to G..land. Any ideas regarding the answers?
MMark9y ago#16
I don't recall it saying the FX rate was set at all, I can only remember it saying the selling price was set and thus revenues would vary with the exchange rate.
@lucamucciaccia said: the price (and the FX rate) was set at the beginning of the year for one year therefore the Export division is taking advantage of this for the second half of the year. The turnover should have been 7400
SShaheen9y ago#17
@Tommy. Thanks, thats clear. I was not sure. For the profit margin, guess I will score. I also said that the basis for calculating capital employed was correct. Same for management retention (it excludes contract employees, so it is good). @Chullbulla. That was an easy one. Most of the criteria in the mission could not be linked to the indicators as indicators was mostly financial. The mission says something about staff development and being able to offer world class service: those were not reflected in the KPI. If I am right.
MMark9y ago#18
Can anyone remember what part B was for question 4? I am trying to think but I can't even remember! For part C on the EVA, I wrote as many of you have said already EVA was excellent in aligning the business with shareholder wealth maximisation objective but that it wasn't really a good measure to compare divisions because it gives an absolute value and these values are meaningless when compared as the markets and asset bases are so different. Trying to think what part B was..
TTatiana9y ago#19
Hello guys! I also choosed Quesion #2. I am not surprized by fact that it was not so popular question as it needs to have quite deep knowledge about target and kaizen costing.. usually these topics are not on first place when you are in your preparation study. Anyways, I would like to know, how did you structure your answer in part b, about implementaton of target costing? It is worth about 12 marks.. Too much! Did you provided real ways of problem decision like: decrease number of suppliers in order to get volume discount for price of sub-components? Or to introduce training for workers in order to improve quality of assembly work, as a result quality cost (cost of non-conformance) will be reduced? Just my examples.. Tell me please your way to this question.
Ssh9y ago#20
Hi, Part B was using calculations should the manager get a bonus? I think it was along those lines.
Ssh9y ago#21
I said calculating Eva for the export division might not be worth it as it was a profit centre not an investment centre and it was a complicated calculation so only the import division should use it as they are an investment centre. I don't know if that was right. I feel like it wasn't really a hard exam but I didn't answer the questions enough. I made no adjustments for fx in part b. It never even crossed my mind to :(
Ssh9y ago#22
I feel I kept myself down today as my attempt was poor. I did q3 last and I had to rush it as ran out of time :(
MMark9y ago#23
Im getting confused over what the otherbpart to question 4 was.. One of part a or b was the bonus and part c was the eva.. Can anyone remember what thebother part was whether it was a or b? Thin a was 7 marks, b 8 and c 10?
Ssh9y ago#24
Hi, I thought 4a was that the manager of export division thinks she deserves a bonus does she? and 4b was to use calculations maybe it was to say if she was above the npm target with calls? I'm not sure now :( I just know I did a calculation and got approx 11% and said she should get a bonus. For part a I said the npm shouldn't include head office costs as out of her control. What I wrote was not enough for the marks.
Ssh9y ago#25
What did people do for q3? For part c I came up with some weird kpi's as just couldn't think of anything
Ssh9y ago#26
@chullbulla said: Yes It was not easy to find KPI's. I just mentioned about how many people visiting superstores and what parentage of young people buy and blah blah.
I can't remember 3a or 3b tho
Ssh9y ago#27
For q1, I used the mission statement and said what kpi's in the dashboard measured that the mission was being achieved. That was for part i). I can't remember part ii) for part iii) I commented on the dashboard, I think I said stuff like there was no nfpi etc I struggled with building blocks and linking it to the scenario. Part v) I commented on the reward scheme. I felt I struggled to make enough points for the marks on every question in the exam. Anyone what was q1 part ii please? thank you
Rrasib9y ago#28
Sorry dear am confused.. u talking about confermance n non confirmance cost this relates to TQM.. target costing is somthing else... Am i right?
Rrasib9y ago#29
Q3 part c.. Suggest KPIs for taking advantage of growing economy people getting richer n moving towards.. something like that What should be KPIs plz suggest
TTatiana9y ago#30
Rasib, yes this relates to TQM. However TQM here is used as an instrument to reduction of cost gap which is target costing issue. Guys, how do you answer to this question #2, part b? I just want to know the main idea :)
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.