AFM*** ACCA P4 March 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
same I also got 11% for wacc
Why did yourl calculate WACC for Q4? Dont yourl have to discount using an all equiity Ke?
Can you kindly remind me why and for what you people used WACC for APV calculation? Dont we have to use an all equity discount factor to get the Base Case NPV?
@abdul .... thats what i meant all equity Ke was 11%...
I think the 11% WACC was for Q1??
For APV I did the same, calculate the ungear beta and CAPM to get the Ke which is the discount factor, can't remember it was 10% I think..
APV question was okay, I got a little disrupted in the residual value where it says to assume it is $3,000, so I assumed that the equipment would be sold at that price giving a small profit for taxation..?
Does anyone remember the requirements of Q1 and Q2 along with the marks allocation for each? Can u type it down
How can you get negative Finance effect when all money is being saved there for 4 years?!
Dear p4 examiner what u think who r we¿????? Its seems u think dat we are cfa qualifid and jst giving p4 for the sake of enjoyment
How can u do this to us i you dont want to pass us jst write a technical article telling dont sit for p4 in this session otherwise you are resposible for the Consequences
? if your calculations showing negative npv and you put positive in error how much marks will u lose
I cant believe i made such an error....so upset. Because of time constraint didnt even get to look over properly
Dont know i messed up really bad with 1st question. Had no clue till the end about the calculation. but i wrote all the assumptions/approach /implication and general understanding about after restructuring effect, further, i also wrote about reverse takeover for listing its advantages and disadvantages
rest did well in question 2 and question 4. in question 4 as per my working , NPV was marginally negative but APV was positive due to interest saving in subs. loan (less tax saving lost).
question 2 was all theory so am not expecting anything good!
OMG....
I thought March sitting would be fair compared to the Dec 16 exam but its the reverse instead
Hope the examiner has got all this feedback & makes the June exam fair for us..
I really struggled to do much on Question1 as it was damn difficult. Moved to Q2, I could not keep with lots of theory, found about two questions in Q2 not really making sense to me. Shifted to Q4, much better than any of the questions. Got a negative NPV and a positive APV. Issue costs messed with my mind. Overall a 50 won't be possible at this point in time. Will have to go for a second attempt.
Q1 was very difficult but Q2 and Q4 was ok.. hope for best result..
I got 80% in f9 so thought P4 would be ok for me...it was the hardest exam I've ever sat and it'll be a miracle if I scrape 50... worst exam of my life... for everyone else that thinks they've failed... do you wait for the result and then start studying? ... or start studying again now?
Q1 was so confusing! I ended up valuing using FCF, and throwing a SOFP together, not sure it made much sense though :( I think it is a lot to ask for 18 marks.
Does anyone remember how many marks were allocated to the discussion of MM theory in Q4? I understand MM theory but I was so stressed with time pressure I wrote about traditional theory! So mad at myself
I was afraid of that! Did anyone else get FCF and extract of SOFP? 90% sure I've failed anyway ?
@d019452 said: I got 80% in f9 so thought P4 would be ok for me...it was the hardest exam I've ever sat and it'll be a miracle if I scrape 50... worst exam of my life... for everyone else that thinks they've failed... do you wait for the result and then start studying? ... or start studying again now?Same here, F9 was probably my best exam of the lot and I genuinely found it interesting. But I'm confident I failed this and I now don't know whether to go ahead with my studies for p2 and resit P4 in September, or to wait and resit p4 in June. Has anyone got any advice? Are there likely to be any major syllabus changes before September?
I would resit p4 in June while your knowledge is still fresh.. Looking at past pass rates for p4, I thought March exam would be difficult after a fair December one, and it was.. So, I would expect an easier one in June. Maybe I am wrong, but I believe in this pattern)
Personally I am sure I will have to resit in June, part B was OK, but I failed the Question 1 - was expecting investment appraisal or M&A not this restructuring mess.
Question 1 was a disaster , i think this is the hardest exam paper i ever sat. I failed in December but i can attribute that fail to poor time management but this time it was the difficulty of the paper.
I'm going to prepare for a fail and start studying P4 again for June.... I don't want to risk forgetting everything I've learned.
I didn't end up sitting this exam. I did not feel prepared the night before so I did not attempt it. So glad after reading comments as it seems like it was a difficult paper.
I think M & M had 7 marks
Can anyone remember what question 2 (theory) was and it's mark allocation?
@michellep said: Can anyone remember what question 2 (theory) was and it's mark allocation?IT company investing in new application development, -sources if finance (listing or debt, not sufficient own funds) -current risks and controls -behavioural aspects and impact on the company (share price after the listing) Only this I remember...
Thanks Olga
I just briefly read Q2 and thought that it is very new topic so I choose Q3. Now I realized at least I can still write theory a bit but Q3 is disaster for me :(
Very true.. Even after seeing and revising the past exam questions and the revision kit.. this exam was like totally too different from all the settings,
its like, u start doing thinking u r on right path and in the middle way u seem like no its all wrong... really a tough time.. the only number that seems easy was qn 4 and i couldnot even complete the npv table, just because of the tough time the other two questions gave
I know a feedback survey has been mentioned somewhere in this thread. I don't seem to have had this emailed to me, is there a link to complete this - does anyone know?
This paper was way too difficult. I saw blue like a donkey through out! Better start revising all over early and prepare for next exam.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

