AFM*** ACCA P4 March 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Question one was loaded with so many things to sort out, doubt if one can finish well in such high pressure exam. I attempted to the best of my ability. Question two purely written and did some part but my best was question four APV.Hope a marginal pass comes through.
very unexpected .... 50 mark question for restructuring and reverse takeovers??.. give me a break....
and cuurency swaps???????????????//
i will fail!
same feeling as yours, why should a 50 marks question like this! Part a is not so surpised as it is a recent technial article, but what the part b for? So much issues to do!
Just ignored the part b iii for discussion and part c……no time to finish……
I couldn't complete the paper but other than being lengthy, I dont think it was very hard. But I hadnt written for around 10 marks :(
What figures did people get for the APV?? My base case NPV and APV were both negative...
This paper appeared to be very different to the style of previous papers I have seen. What's the need for extra complications, like inflation becoming higher and lower than the other country? Looks like they are trying to maintain a 30% pass rate. Hard to feel confident after this exam.
I also got npv and apv negative about 2800 for npv and 3200 for apv
Definitely FAIL. DON'T JUST DO THE RAVION KIT. TAKE THIS ADVICE VERY SERIOUS GUYS... You can't cope with the tricks if you have proper grip on the underlying theory. Learning jus call n put options is jus not enough. Commercial awareness is must too....I am so lucky I sat this today time to come back with proper kit in next session
still don't know if the paper was in English or German?
very tricky. Q1 was different than any Q1 before from past papers. Q3 was again very tricky, looked simple, but it wasn't. too many uncertainties, and Q2 all theory question in P4 exam?! and Q4 was only question that looked ok. It was still not that easy, some tricky bits, but atleast was doable.. hard paper this time
I also got both negative
Exam was....argh!!!!
Second attempt and I feel like I could have done worse than the first time.
Time management was better - did option questions first then section A. Got lost on what to do on 1. part (b) so made up a few things...not advised!
Good luck everyone, I know I need a miracle x
@anisom said: Question one was loaded with so many things to sort out, doubt if one can finish well in such high pressure exam. I attempted to the best of my ability. Question two purely written and did some part but my best was question four APV.Hope a marginal pass comes through.
Me too.. Base case Npv was (-) and APV was also (-)
About Chairman mssg for Year 2 profits = 0 ? what method you used? Sensitivity, IRR ?
@carol24.. i used sensitovity....got something like 8%
Sensitivity duhhhhhh...
I just received an email from ACCA for exam survey, I'm ranting my a** off for what an unfair paper this was.
Question 1 and the options bit in question 3 were not like old questions although the latter was manageable. Two new ideas in one paper, very unfair!
Would suggest all to protest through the survey...
Despite being very angry coming out of that exam, I have an overriding feeling of disappointment more than anything. I revised really hard covering a vast range of topics with particular focus on 'core areas' - international investment appraisal, BSOP, options & futures, acquisitions etc. Only for hardly any of these topics to show up in the exam.
Whilst I appreciate we can't 'question spot' all the questions barring the APV question seemed to cover niche areas of the syllabus. B1 seemed to want far too much writing for a 45 minute question and B2 was an absolute mess of a question.
This was meant to be my second to last ACCA exam and I've managed to pass all the others first time with decent scores so its fair to say I've always been pretty confident going into exams and that was the case today but I just feel that paper was not a fair representation of the P4 module at all.
I hope the ACCA pick up on this and do something about it because it's not fair on the students who work so hard for 3/6 months only to be presented with a paper like that.
@lloyd777 said: Despite being very angry coming out of that exam, I have an overriding feeling of disappointment more than anything. I revised really hard covering a vast range of topics with particular focus on 'core areas' - international investment appraisal, BSOP, options & futures, acquisitions etc. Only for hardly any of these topics to show up in the exam. Whilst I appreciate we can't 'question spot' all the questions barring the APV question seemed to cover niche areas of the syllabus. B1 seemed to want far too much writing for a 45 minute question and B2 was an absolute mess of a question. This was meant to be my second to last ACCA exam and I've managed to pass all the others first time with decent scores so its fair to say I've always been pretty confident going into exams and that was the case today but I just feel that paper was not a fair representation of the P4 module at all. I hope the ACCA pick up on this and do something about it because it's not fair on the students who work so hard for 3/6 months only to be presented with a paper like that.TOTALLY AGREE WITH EACH AND EVERY WORD YOU WROTE CAN'T ADD ANYTHING TO TO IT MUCH
@Jack I hear you bro, I covered the syllabus in its entirety and finished the entire kit. Only didn't do the last two sittings past papers. This paper was very difficult and set to fail students. I too passed all in first attempt and this is my last paper but most likely to be a fail or marginal pass at 50 or 51 max if a miracle happens.
Exactly my point why we should inform ACCA through the survey.
So much to do and so little time!!
Agreed. It was very hard paper. Of all ACCA paper I sat, this was hardest, and of all P4 attempts again this was hardest.
The first look at the question demotivated me but I left that for later, went on to q2 and found a whole theory paper in P4, full theory and last two bits of that were out of nowhere?!
Next go to q3, it looked simple at first, but when you get to it, there were many uncertainties, many things left to assumption, tricky.
Finally Q4. APV calculation, something that was still doable. And all that in the time frame given by ACCA, very challenging!!
The only question paper that comes close is this sitting of P4's is Nahara Co. Question from Dec 2014 and Cigno Co. Question from Dec 2015 Hybrid
Yep, I'll be having my say through the survey for sure.
The paper seemed to bare no resemblance to any of the recent past papers or the syllabus paper. I also went through the Kaplan exam kit and can't say B1 and B2 resembled any questions I covered!
The qualification is hard enough to obtain as it is without papers like this being set. It's so deflating and after this I'm even contemplating shifting across to take P6 instead.
Same to same bhai
Unfair a lot ... so disappointing
Lol! Again same here bro but to P7.
The thing is, it's a time pressured exam and leaving candidates to figure how to tackle the question in its entirety is unfair. Complications and tricks are fair because if your concepts are clear, which is the whole point of the exam, you should be able to deal with them.
Like the OTC options although completely new style were manageable...
@mustafa Sad to hear that :( lol
Q1, although the debt restructuring seemed complicated, was very much like prior questions asked. Discussion about RTO was easy marks, if you read past article. BUT currency swap? Well I read the article twice... But I doubt it will earn more then 5 out of 20 marks on currency swap. The style of question was like for the people who already do currency swaps in real life. I did not see any past exam question on that. And article was just a bit of a theory....
Q4 - both base case NPV and APV were negative in my answer. This was a familiar question, so I hope for a marginal pass. Calculating all past exam questions seemed NOT to be enough preparation this time... And that is unfair.
Q4: i got wacc=11%
I also got 11% for Wacc in Q4.
I got 11% too I think..
I completely agree with all that has been posted guys. Please write feedback to ACCA on survey and complain about it.
I've studied entire revision kit questions and did past papers and this exam paper was completely different to all questions I have taken, except question 4.
Even if this was a pass for me, I am still disappointed with the exam questions. I was confident on the topics and yet was so demotivated as soon as I read the requirements of all.
I've attempted all 3 questions with options Q3 and 4.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

