Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AFM*** ACCA P4 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin9y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA P4 December 2016 Exam.

*** ACCA P4 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** ACCA P4 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results

Post your comments about the ACCA P4 exam below

Ssameinng9y ago#61
Anyone remember question 1 first director proposal sell off the repair part how u deal with the asset beta i regear the equity beta 1.2 and to get the asset beta of the whole business and then directly minus the asset beta of the repair. Is that right i feel a bit weird here i think wrong somewhere anyone can enlighten me your explain in this part?
MMichael9y ago#62
I thought that the question stated use market values for debt? I used The Rf +spread to calculate PV of the 4 year redeemable debt to calculate mv. Think it worked out about 1.04 * 120m. Did nobody do this?
Ssameinng9y ago#63
@md4vies said: I thought that the question stated use market values for debt? I used The Rf +spread to calculate PV of the 4 year redeemable debt to calculate mv. Think it worked out about 1.04 * 120m. Did nobody do this?
1.04? how did you get it? i thought is 105.34? using 6.2 as int rate and yield is ba2 4.7%
Former userFormer user9y ago#64
Sorry but the option to hedge against payment in USD is a put option, you cannot buy a USD call option as there isn't one so you have to sell your EUR therefore you buy 'Put' Option. I think the FX hedge question was easy but I think I made a mess on my convertion net outcome calculation. I also used the two future rates for 3 months and 5 months to calculate Future outcome instead of spot hope that was correct.
QQuy9y ago#65
I think 20% used to add in share price to determine capitalise value of Findon flight
Former userFormer user9y ago#66
I thought it's the lock-in rate you use to get your futures outcome?
Former userFormer user9y ago#67
@fard786 said: Did any one changed market value of equity for any of the propasal for ques 1 it was i think 360m i thought none of the proposals would affect it so i assumed it remain constant.any feedback on this would be appreciated.Thanks.
Hey, yes I did the same, Market value of equity was not changing only the debt due to proposal 1 and 2 stating either increase or decrease debt. The tricky and annoying part was calculation of Cost of debt as I felt it was quite confusing especially depending on the proposal different interest rate was paid and the calculation were extremely repetitive by the third time I did it I was exhausted! lol Anyhow, I think the correct recommendation to directors was that even though more debt was taken in Proposal 2 the WACC of company has reduced further. This is in line with M&M theory, where it states debt is good for company as they have to pay tax and increases their income. I can't think from top of my head what were my WACC but I think proposal 2 had the lowest, hence I recommended that.
Former userFormer user9y ago#68
@hpanchoo2206 said: Silly mistake from ny side...didnt calculate any asset beta....assumed kd same as coupon rate of 6.2%. Any idea how many marks i could lose? ?
I don't think its a silly mistake, I also was thinking the same. If you have put don't your assumptions that the bonds were issued at 6.2% and no matter what the credit rating it will stay the same I don't think that's wrong, is it? I applied changed the interest rates based on credit rating which took a lot of my time on repetitive calculations but like others I felt the credit ratings were given for a reason, perhaps it was simply for discussion purpose? I hate this type of ambiguous question where it is not clear exactly what the examiner wants us to approach the question.
Former userFormer user9y ago#69
I recommended proposal 2 as well. Also the EPS under the proposal was higher
CCastells9y ago#70
@prad41 said: Hey, yes I did the same, Market value of equity was not changing only the debt due to proposal 1 and 2 stating either increase or decrease debt. The tricky and annoying part was calculation of Cost of debt as I felt it was quite confusing especially depending on the proposal different interest rate was paid and the calculation were extremely repetitive by the third time I did it I was exhausted! lol Anyhow, I think the correct recommendation to directors was that even though more debt was taken in Proposal 2 the WACC of company has reduced further. This is in line with M&M theory, where it states debt is good for company as they have to pay tax and increases their income. I can't think from top of my head what were my WACC but I think proposal 2 had the lowest, hence I recommended that.
Same answer!!! However, I stated in the conclusion that the assumption of not change in share price was not realistic. Also that the increase in gearing was risky in real life.
Former userFormer user9y ago#71
@sameinng said: Anyone remember question 1 first director proposal sell off the repair part how u deal with the asset beta i regear the equity beta 1.2 and to get the asset beta of the whole business and then directly minus the asset beta of the repair. Is that right i feel a bit weird here i think wrong somewhere anyone can enlighten me your explain in this part?
you can't subtract directly; the question stated that the proportion of the businesses was the proportion of non-current assets. It was like a weighted average thingy. 70%X + 30% Y = asset beta of the whole company. The part that was disposed was 30% based on the question since the non-current assets reduced by 30%.
Former userFormer user9y ago#72
@ninhvanquy said: I think 20% used to add in share price to determine capitalise value of Findon flight
the 20% was supposed to be used to increase the PE ratio of the combined firm. The "multiplier" in the question was a PE ratio of some sorts. you then multiply the new PE ratio by the combined FCFE of both companies. the multiplier was calculated as (9*1000)/1500=6 then increase by 20% thats 7.2 you then multiply 7.2 by the combined FCFE i.e 7.2(1500+170) = $12,024m before adding the synergy benefit.total for scenario 1 was $12,074m for me.
Former userFormer user9y ago#73
No one is talking about how they evaluated the impact of proposals 1 and 2 on after tax profit and the financial position. Truly its impossible to answer these questions well under the examination pressure except you've over pracriced under stricter time constraints. should have calculated gearing ratio for this part probaly and compared for each and discuss risk.
Ddewan9y ago#74
I think for proposal 2 cost of equity actualy increases and wacc decreases i said due to increase in debt risk of company may be increasing an thus shareholders demanding more in return to compensate extra risk and wacc decreasing due cheap debt in the financing mix.i said in overall both of the proposals were not making much difference to the original cost of equity and capital and said before taking any decisions they must consider the assumptions i mentioned above and said that proposal 1 is slightly better overall than proposal 2. any feedback For my answer would be much appreciated
Ddewan9y ago#75
Increasing debt was proposal 2 is not it? Please enlighten me on this.
Former userFormer user9y ago#76
@ninhvanquy said: I think 20% used to add in share price to determine capitalise value of Findon flight
@prad41 said: Hey, yes I did the same, Market value of equity was not changing only the debt due to proposal 1 and 2 stating either increase or decrease debt. The tricky and annoying part was calculation of Cost of debt as I felt it was quite confusing especially depending on the proposal different interest rate was paid and the calculation were extremely repetitive by the third time I did it I was exhausted! lol Anyhow, I think the correct recommendation to directors was that even though more debt was taken in Proposal 2 the WACC of company has reduced further. This is in line with M&M theory, where it states debt is good for company as they have to pay tax and increases their income. I can't think from top of my head what were my WACC but I think proposal 2 had the lowest, hence I recommended that.
for the 2nd proposal I think the risk free rate plus spread came to 6.2 so I concluded that the the market value was the book value. I may have been wrong in any case.
Jjoashbill9y ago#77
i believe the question specifically said that an assumption was amde that the value of equity wouldnt change however my cost of equity changed ... i got an increas of cost of capital from 10 to 10.7 i think and from 10 to 9.4 for the second ...did anybdy else get the same?
Jjoashbill9y ago#78
i did ..only in the second proposalw as the mv of debt equal to its book value because the coupon and cost of debt was the same
MMichelle9y ago#79
Does anyone remember the Mark allocations especially for sections A?
Former userFormer user9y ago#80
@michellep said: Does anyone remember the Mark allocations especially for sections A?
The 1st question was for 8marks (biz risk and financial risk and how they are related then risk mitigation vs diversification the second was 17 marks Ke and WACC for the current and two proposals Third was 8 marks.... effect on earnings and financial position fourth was 7 marks which was about recommendations and assumptions for b(i) and b(ii) then there was a separate question about discussing the third proposal about first evalauting the current status blah blah for 6 marks. I may have mixed up the marks from the third but I think the margin of error is small.
MMichelle9y ago#81
Thanks @kolkeen that sounds right.
NNoneofyourbusiness9y ago#82
I did the report for question one something like this: For proposal one, ungear equity beta with current capital structure to get about 0.85 I think. Then use the asset beta in proportion to the assets that were sold for the manufacturing division by using simultaneous equations. MV of debt was about 105, discounting at credit rating plus risk free rate. Anyway, under this proposal, the wacc was higher cause of the higher weighting of equity. Proposal 2 increased debt and assets and the overall income. Wacc was lower, and CoE was calculated simply by using the equity beta given of 1.21. Cost of debt was 6.2% tax adjusted (same as proposal 1), and we had to find MV by discounting at risk free rate plus the rating given which gave a MV of debt to be 100.01, so rounded to 100. I believe wacc came to around 9%. I recommended to either staying as is or choosing proposal 2 if their intention was to take on more projects, although prop 2 increased gearing to 49%. I think I went on to screw up part a and b considerably. They weren't hard, I just wasn't expecting them and they threw me off. For part a I explained the relationship of volatility of cash flows inherent to a business and the increased risk of defaulting from financial risk, but it was all rubbish I made up, doubt it's worth 2 marks.
Former userFormer user9y ago#83
@drey7000 said: I did the report for question one something like this: For proposal one, ungear equity beta with current capital structure to get about 0.85 I think. Then use the asset beta in proportion to the assets that were sold for the manufacturing division by using simultaneous equations. MV of debt was about 105, discounting at credit rating plus risk free rate. Anyway, under this proposal, the wacc was higher cause of the higher weighting of equity. Proposal 2 increased debt and assets and the overall income. Wacc was lower, and CoE was calculated simply by using the equity beta given of 1.21. Cost of debt was 6.2% tax adjusted (same as proposal 1), and we had to find MV by discounting at risk free rate plus the rating given which gave a MV of debt to be 100.01, so rounded to 100. I believe wacc came to around 9%. I recommended to either staying as is or choosing proposal 2 if their intention was to take on more projects, although prop 2 increased gearing to 49%. I think I went on to screw up part a and b considerably. They weren't hard, I just wasn't expecting them and they threw me off. For part a I explained the relationship of volatility of cash flows inherent to a business and the increased risk of defaulting from financial risk, but it was all rubbish I made up, doubt it's worth 2 marks.
The discussions were more difficult than the calculations; could only briefly explain the implication of each value but didnt have enough time to conclude. I wonder what the marking scheme is like
JJay9y ago#84
@fard786 said: Increasing debt was proposal 2 is not it? Please enlighten me on this.
Hello. I guess we are on the same page. I recommended proposal 1 because proposal 2 increases the financial risk, & also increases the cost of equity for investors,that would be it's downside. Also proposal 1 would yield an additional 6% return because 30 % reduction in assets would have lost 9 % of after tax return but the 30% reduction would have been sold at 15 % after tax, that was my justification. I screwed up wacc under proposal 1, I used the right method, but didn't consider the 70:30 ratio to calculate asset beta. Hope that doesn't cost me too much.
Jjoashbill9y ago#85
can anyone remember what proposal 3 dealt with and what we had to discuss? how many marks was this for?
AAnna9y ago#86
Can't remember for how many marks, but the third director proposed to assess the whole organisation and all its divisions on both types of risk (business and financial). I have mentioned director one focusing on financial risk (reducing debt) and director two on business risk (entering new sector) while actually both should be considered..
Jjoashbill9y ago#87
i missed this part of the question...i only remember answering about financial and business risk in part a of the question
Former userFormer user9y ago#88
Same here i also calculated growth
Former userFormer user9y ago#89
But for the futures calculation how did you find the expected spot rate to be able to calculate gain/loss on futures?
Former userFormer user9y ago#90
If i may ask how did you find the closing futures price when no expected spot rate was given?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.