AFM*** ACCA P4 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
I think you will only loose a mark
Obviously you multiply with the $ payments which was the main trick.
But again i choose the wrong option so do you still think i am going to get some marks mate.
I think you should as long as you calculated premium with spot rate and $ payment @ both strike prices (one after another). There was no contacts involved in this bit. You just had to show the worst outcome.
I used the premium for put options though or premiums were same for both put and call option as i cant remember
Did any one find the asset beta for hotel and holiday package department using 70% proportion to work out the equity beta using new capital structure after selling repairment department.
karen are you positive that we had to buy calls? i would have thought it was the same as an exchange traded except we had no under and overhedge... also how were we supposed to calculate the sensitivity of the price to a zero npv? i didnt know where to start for that part
I calculated the maximum price as the MV before to Mv after acq. I believe that that I missed something out as the figures I got did not look right as they were below the premium required by the company.
Not feeling confident with my answers as I felt I was rushing each question. P4 is a tricky customer.
Did anyone else use the growth rate g=bre for this?
As the question said 65% paid to divs, I assumed 35% reinvestment=b
Then used the free cash flow to equity formula FCFE(1+g)/(re-g)
I think i got g as 4.9%??
was the NPV above $7million ? as well as the futures? $6.7million or something close?
And the current WACC 11.06% , first proposal 14.67% and second proposal 9.88% ??
Please anyone will be clear is it a put or call option to use?
@mick299 said: Did anyone else use the growth rate g=bre for this? As the question said 65% paid to divs, I assumed 35% reinvestment=b Then used the free cash flow to equity formula FCFE(1+g)/(re-g) I think i got g as 4.9%??yea
@fard786 said: Did any one find the asset beta for hotel and holiday package department using 70% proportion to work out the equity beta using new capital structure after selling repairment department.something like that; the part to be sold off was 30% and they gave the asset beta. the part to be retained was 70%. you first find the asset beta of the company as a whole then find the asset beta of the part of the business retained. you then find the equity beta using the capital structure. then ke and wacc. I think the marks were small for all that number crunching
It was a put option. Similar prev ques in rev kit CMC Co
Paper was not hard at all u r right bro time ruined me in Q4 i only put the discount rate and time was over arthmatics consumed all my time in Q1 and then in Q2 examiner was very unfair in marks allocation may pass at 50 or fail at 49 god knows
@karanpreetrobin said: At least for me, Easy exam but very poor time management. Correct me if I am wrong? Question 1- A) Business risk and finance risk relations B) Proposal 2 recommended due to it was bring WACC down. C) Huge saving on proposal 1 due to less interest payments but still suggested proposal 2 because of future investments and growth etc. Lots of assumptions like CAPM, New beta Calculation Risk free rate, Tax rate, Market value of assets on sale etc. Question 2- GOD!! I wasted hell a lot of time, Made so hard for myself. Part-A)Futures-I divided $payment/future rate, and then divided by LOCK in Rate. Sell/Short futures 55 contracts 5 months one OTC Options- Nice and easy- Premium were already calculated :) Buy Call options 6month expiry then showed the worst outcome. This time I multiplied the strike price with $payment. B) Advantages using OTC options over future-GIVE AWAY Flexibility, No binding, If things goes wrong we can always throw the options C) Easiest question in the exam- Mark to Market- Futures trading Open daily and close daily, Open next day again etc etc Calcuate the profit/loss accordingly-first 2 days was a loss and then 3 day was profit (I think) Question 4) F9 Level Straight forward NPV Sensitivity analysis Selling price to decrease 9.33% to bring NPV down to zero. Few other recommendation like IRR, MIRR and VAR Please correct me if you think anything mentioned above is wrong?? Thanks Kaz
Q2 i think it is put option where you will sell € in order to buy $ for the payment of $7.7 m
@kolkleen said: something like that; the part to be sold off was 30% and they gave the asset beta. the part to be retained was 70%. you first find the asset beta of the company as a whole then find the asset beta of the part of the business retained. you then find the equity beta using the capital structure. then ke and wacc. I think the marks were small for all that number crunchingHello I have actually followed the same method of calculating asset beta of the whole company & then the asset beta of the business retained, but I have deducted 0.65 beta asset which was given , directly from the beta asset of whole company without considering the 70:30 ratio there. What's ur take on that ? I was actually getting a higher wacc because of this.
Hi guys,will acca penalise me? Had started with the hedging question before realising the NPV was more straighforward so I started on that but couldn’t finish? Will they pick the worst two or best two? I’m really worried here.
@singh25a said: Hello I have actually followed the same method of calculating asset beta of the whole company & then the asset beta of the business retained, but I have deducted 0.65 beta asset which was given , directly from the beta asset of whole company without considering the 70:30 ratio there. What's ur take on that ? I was actually getting a higher wacc because of this.may just miss 1 mark on that. Your follow on calculations and conclusion will be marked based on the own figure rule.
does anyone remember the marks available for each requirement?
Silly mistake from ny side...didnt calculate any asset beta....assumed kd same as coupon rate of 6.2%. Any idea how many marks i could lose? ?
The paper was fair and with good time management one will easily score a pass mark.I did question 2 and for some reasons failed to see that premium was already calculated because I am used to see scenarios where premium will need to be calculated.
Question 4 was straight forward I did my best and was left with less than 1hr 30 mins to do question 1.
However I am hoping for the best.
the cost of debt is already mentioned in question, valued at face value ($120m) for cost of capital calculation. Nvm, under pressure , read it fast and come out with calculation.For me, I have burnt 10 minutes on NOTHING just read through the first question and find it difficult.
@munpong96 said: the cost of debt is already mentioned in question, valued at face value ($120m) for cost of capital calculation. Nvm, under pressure , read it fast and come out with calculation.For me, I have burnt 10 minutes on NOTHING just read through the first question and find it difficult.I also thought about that but then I considered that they gave all those credit ratings for a reason. The 6.2 was the coupon rate but if your credit rating worsens then it will probably cost more to raise debt.
It looked to be a fair paper but too time pressured to the extent that I did not take advantage of some easy marks in Section B questions
For section A, I was confused with the whole scenario.
But just wrote as per my instincts.
I think I did lots of silly mistakes
Keeping fingers crossed for a pass.
Anyone know how to deal with the q3 market capitalisation fcfe increasing by 20% i blur when i see this i cannot find the combined value of both company anyone still remember
i remember angmering current share price is 9, 1000millon share fcfe 1500m
findon flight current share price is 3.8 500millon fcfe 170 ke 14 g 0.049 as the ke and growth rate are related to findon itself right?
@sameinng said: Anyone know how to deal with the q3 market capitalisation fcfe increasing by 20% i blur when i see this i cannot find the combined value of both company anyone still remember i remember angmering current share price is 9, 1000millon share fcfe 1500m findon flight current share price is 3.8 500millon fcfe 170 ke 14 g 0.049 as the ke and growth rate are related to findon itself right?I think we were supposed to get the current P/E ratio which was market value divided by FCFE (9000/1500 = 6). The P/E ratio was to increase by 20% in scenario 1 and 10% in scenario two. The value of the combined company would then be the new P/E ratio per each case multiplied by the combined FCFE. That was my logic anyways.
@kolkleen said: I think we were supposed to get the current P/E ratio which was market value divided by FCFE (9000/1500 = 6). The P/E ratio was to increase by 20% in scenario 1 and 10% in scenario two. The value of the combined company would then be the new P/E ratio per each case multiplied by the combined FCFE. That was my logic anyways.How did u get the combined company free cash flow to equity? I also had a problem with valuing the combined company. Still regret why i didn't do question 4
Did any one changed market value of equity for any of the propasal for ques 1 it was i think 360m i thought none of the proposals would affect it so i assumed it remain constant.any feedback on this would be appreciated.Thanks.
I used 360m for both proposals as it did not change
share price remain the same as the question mention that the director unable to determine a suitable price for the effect of the proposals.
I chose put option in Q2, do you explain your choice?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

