Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA P3 March 2017 Exam
Post your comments about the ACCA P3 exam below
(after 5pm UK time)
SBL*** ACCA P3 March 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
I mentioned a focused differentiation strategy could be used to create a niche market for the Employer Funded students. That they could offer large firms discounted rates based on the number of places they took and package it together with their star tutors and quality materials as a premium product. This would give them an edge on the other providers.
In Q1, I also mentioned an opportunity would be to sell the building and move out to the suburbs but keep a smaller premise in the city for the part time employer funded students.
As somebody said earlier there's no real right or wrong in this paper. So any sensible approach it going to score.
Surprised so few people used the figures ... think this is up on 6 marks based on past papers. It was fairly easy to bang out 6 ratios.
I think this sesion was a bit easier than Sep 16 :
Q 1 a) strength
Mentioned: reputation (incl. trainers , materials) , location due to safety to the students, dissatisfied students from other collegues
weaknesses
cash balance drastically fallen along with gross profit over 2013-2016 , target for didvidends has not been met (from $ 10 to $ /share) along with the pay rise below inflation rate , old building with energy ineffiency
opportunity
e-learning, lobbying legislation for more robust rules for the accrediation of the traning providers to kick out from the market the rivals
threat
new rivals with low cost base due to almost illegal cheep subcontractors , bank with the intention to buy ExCO building , tutors potentially leaving to the competitors
b) time : not much time due to deteriated financial performance & rivals activisation along with the new green energy legislation proposal
capability : the senior mngt was not capable to implement changes as they failed to bring someone who can
readiness: the trainers enjoyed the long stable employment and are even resistant to the idea to bring more female into IT , so not ready
c) it seems that I am wrong
wrote about acquisition ( not suitable for Exco due to lack of resources for initial investments )
JV is not available to due to other colleagues weak reputation
franchising seems to work
d) no frills would not work as they have pretty expensive tutors
differentiator - ExCO would be ok due to the services provided and consequently price should be higher
focussed differentiator - my teacher told me that it is available for companies like hotels between 3 stras and 5 stars, so not for ExCo.
Sorry for lentghy write up on Q 1 . If anybody wants answers to Q2, Q3 I might do it.
focussed differentiator - it is not for ExCO
Kelkar, could you give Your answers to q2&3?
Dear Mark I thought it was reconstruction..because exco was already in financial difficulties and they need bigbang change/quick change but of minor nature.
It is a fair question paper.
I had to think a lot. I finished writing just on time.
Q1. all questions were based on change management.
part a is on swot for 18 marks. I had confusion on identifying the Swots.
part b. 10 mark question.( readiness, time, compatiblity, persevation) . struggle a lot to write for 10 marks. may not score well.
part c.7 mark question on scope and nature of change. i dont understand what they expecting to write. which theory to apply. i wrote blah blah.
part d. startegy clock. wrote fairly I guess.
q2. was based on absorption costing and related. got scared. dont remember f5 topics. so bye bye.
q3. harmon process.
i wrote both were complex and low strategic importance. i wrote my rational to classify so. these processes couldnt be automated by software. so i classified it as complex.
q4.
slightly complicated scenario. they made me to think a lot. applying and writing my opinion and structuring the answer was too difficult. somehow I managed. I completed the answer, the inviligator announced only one minute left.
a guy runs a website to sell retail branded items. he has complicated supply chain. too confusing.
@kelkar said: b) time : not much time due to deteriated financial performance & rivals activisation along with the new green energy legislation proposalWith regards to Time: I had that they had some time available as they still were profitable and had reasonable cash reserves. The legislation proposal said that afterwards that it was in the consultancy stage but also there was a large activism group lobbying against it, so surely that will take a fair amount time if that change will be brought. The new competitors had negative feedback about poor product so I feel that they had time overall. I agree with the rest and is why I went for Evolution too. Anyway, hopefully will get some method marks throughout the exam. Good luck all.
i applied 6i s in question 4a, is it appropriate?
@faizanhussainansari said: i applied 6i s in question 4a, is it appropriate?I applied few of 6Is in this question too just to write about something, I am not sure if its right though
@kelkar said: I think this sesion was a bit easier than Sep 16 : Q 1 a) strength Mentioned: reputation (incl. trainers , materials) , location due to safety to the students, dissatisfied students from other collegues weaknesses cash balance drastically fallen along with gross profit over 2013-2016 , target for didvidends has not been met (from $ 10 to $ /share) along with the pay rise below inflation rate , old building with energy ineffiency opportunity e-learning, lobbying legislation for more robust rules for the accrediation of the traning providers to kick out from the market the rivals threat new rivals with low cost base due to almost illegal cheep subcontractors , bank with the intention to buy ExCO building , tutors potentially leaving to the competitors b) time : not much time due to deteriated financial performance & rivals activisation along with the new green energy legislation proposal capability : the senior mngt was not capable to implement changes as they failed to bring someone who can readiness: the trainers enjoyed the long stable employment and are even resistant to the idea to bring more female into IT , so not ready c) it seems that I am wrong wrote about acquisition ( not suitable for Exco due to lack of resources for initial investments ) JV is not available to due to other colleagues weak reputation franchising seems to work d) no frills would not work as they have pretty expensive tutors differentiator - ExCO would be ok due to the services provided and consequently price should be higher focussed differentiator - my teacher told me that it is available for companies like hotels between 3 stras and 5 stars, so not for ExCo. Sorry for lentghy write up on Q 1 . If anybody wants answers to Q2, Q3 I might do it. focussed differentiator - it is not for ExCOPretty close to me. with regards to the contextual features I said the training staff are ready for change, they are demotivated in their current position and need change to happen, the Senior management is probably not but I would ship them out anyway and put a proper board of directors in place that can facilitate the change and promote better corporate governance. I said that currently they were pretty much a focussed differentiator with the majority of students male under 30s, they need to be a differentiator but to the broader market as technology appeals to all ages and genders. Question 3 was fairly straight forward, discuss Harmons strategy mix, the training and development is high on complexity and strategy due to the advisors having to deal with many situations and it is their core business. This is process re-engineering. The legal team needs to be outsourced as it is complex but not part of the strategic plan. The COTS system is easy to find 7 benefits.The 8 marker was tricky though, can't really remember that. Q2 and 4 were tricky, went for 4 but should have done 2 as would have got decent follow through marks but I was in a wordy frame of mind so ignored it. I just went through the scenario and came up with ideas that would help, eg, stop all the distribution to warehouses across the world, go with one logistics firm that can store everything and distribute it, have the logistics firm put Red Nile's logo on it so it is recognisable, that sort of stuff. I think I lost a few marks with boundaryless organistions, I couldn't remember them, just said stuff about links with suppliers across the world. Overall a decent solid paper with a nice Q1. Just need to get 50% and i'm happy.
1. Question
a) SWOT
i. Strengths - good reputation, good tutors, good location
ii. Weaknesses - high real estate tax, low energy efficiency
iii. Opportunities - legislation, that energy efficiency will be improved
iv. Threats - elearning platforms, competitors, key employees would leave company
b) Contextual features
. Time - not lot of time - competitors
i. Capability - management not capable due to no experience in private field
ii. Readiness - management & staff ready for changes
c). Nature and scope of change
. I worte scope - transformation as it transforms all layers of organisation
i. Nature - big bang - as change needs to happen fast
Altogether it is - Revolution
d). Strategic clock
i. Low price, low service - no because they have good reputation, tutors and location
ii. Low price, high service - right way, in order to maintain students and stay competitive, hard strategy to apply
iii. High price, high service, no because students not able to pay high fees
2. question. Not written
3. question. About DHS - social house provider for low income families
a). Harmons process strategy
i. Legal service - outsource as they are high complexity and low strategic importance
ii. Training- automate (videos), high strategic importance, not complicated
b). Software package
i) Commercial solution advantages
1. Update
2. Time
3. Bugs
4. Cost
ii). Commercial package risks
1. Scalability
2. Individualisation
3. Data security
4. question. About red neal
a) . Supply chain management
i). Incoming - Wrote about additional quality checks for manufacturing of watches (not sure)
ii) Outgoing - wrote that branded goods can go straight to customers from their own warehouses, not going through central warehouse
b). Boundary less organisations- didn’t know term, but written about independence of location
Guidance on how to answer Q2 can be refer from P3 latest article at ACCA website. After reading the examiner report about December sitting where the examiner clearly said that student are not paying attention on their technical articles thus failed to answer those questions. So i was taking that as a hint that reading the articles are very crucial for March sitting too.
P3 was very very tough for me, and I really hope I can make a pass out of it. I may have to take tuition if I need to resit it. The exam made it look like I didn't prepare well when in fact I put in my best.
@teslims said: P3 was very very tough for me, and I really hope I can make a pass out of it. I may have to take tuition if I need to resit it. The exam made it look like I didn't prepare well when in fact I put in my best.@Teslim that's exactly how I feel ...
For q3, i wrote process 3 as high complexity and strategic importance because of the complexity of the law and its changes with the ruling political party and any breach of law can lead to punitive fines damaging reputation and its funding..but suggested to outsource the legal function to cut cost..valid or not??
This is about the Q2.
Is any one have idea whether the full capacity of the factory was given? As I messed up with this question due to time pressure.. I put a note in option 1 assuming BBS will be undertaking the special contract in each month that would utilise the available spare capacity.. So there will be no spare capacity available for fired bricks. In that case labour cost will turn relevant..
@mha88 said: For q3, i wrote process 3 as high complexity and strategic importance because of the complexity of the law and its changes with the ruling political party and any breach of law can lead to punitive fines damaging reputation and its funding..but suggested to outsource the legal function to cut cost..valid or not??If you suggested to outsource it then surely that implies it's of low strategic importance? The fact that they must follow the laws and regulations is important but it isn't integral to the company's strategy; it's not something that creates value for the consumer. But either way as long as you explain your answer then you should be able to pick up some marks.
@arfan54 said: This is about the Q2. Is any one have idea whether the full capacity of the factory was given? As I messed up with this question due to time pressure.. I put a note in option 1 assuming BBS will be undertaking the special contract in each month that would utilise the available spare capacity.. So there will be no spare capacity available for fired bricks. In that case labour cost will turn relevant..I worked out the full capacity by dividing the number of un-fired bricks currently made per month (800,000) by the number of un-fired bricks they make in an hour (70) to get 11,429 hours and added the spare capacity (2,400) to this to get 13,829 hours. Being such an ugly number I'm not sure it's correct but at least I gave it a go!
Thanks @Tim, hope to scrape through this seating.
I used the same model but it appeared to me to be a reconstruction. Since the company did not have to change its core processes. But it needed fast change as it had upcoming competitors
@stanicarazvan said: Very tough, the scenario for Q1 was not so easy to follow and for SWOT analysis, you have to read many times again the scenario in order to correctly allocate the SWOT attributes. For Q2 and Q4, again both scenarios were very time consuming to correctly understand and lot of work to do in order to gain some points. I have failed in Dec'16 with 45pcts, but it can not compare with Mar'17 which it was a disaster for me.for me this was much better than Dec 2016. What was needed was much clearer. December was very complicated
@markgibbons said: I'm not sure about your C Q1 was that how much the company needs to change? Me thinks they were looking for Adoption, Evolution, Reconstruction, Revolution theory, In this case structure needed to change but ideas remain the same hence I believe evolution seemed most appropriate, also mentioned used to a bureaucrat organisation being government owned and should really go towards a more professional structure as its the senior lecturers who bring the most value. Would be curious to know others thoughts on this?I used the same model but it appeared to me to be a reconstruction as the core processes of the organisation did not need to change. However the change had to take place fast due to the fastly emerging competitors
Thanks Tim.
Your number is supported by the other way to compute it.. Labour cost per unit/Labour cost per hour * Total Number of units... 0.15/10.50*800,000= 11,429..
I might have messed up with this straight forward question..
@rahma13 said: Was I the only .... I had no idea what to do with the figures in q1hahaha I thought so too but I knew I had to use then somewhere so I pointed out the liquidity issues and the falling ratios in roce and npm as a weakness under the swot analysis.
my answer is reconstruction.because it need to change fast.
Can 75% attmpted paper be expected to get 50?
Q 2 was really messed up by me . Numbers are wrong as I realise it now - opportunity was added up instead of deducting and other many erros.
Hope only to get marks for advantages and disadvantages :
1. advantages - ABC is better to set up the price
2. it allows the mngt to apportionate o/h based on the relevant drivers - not sure it's correct for ABC.
3. disadvantage- ABC may lead to wrong decision , ex. close down a division when add o/h even it's profitable under marginal method
Q 3 - did not put the importance just said that process 1 is simple and can be automated
process 2 - complex, core business and can not be outsourced . it may not be automated as well due to each individual circumstances of each resident . Put a lot on training both operational ( manuals are primary importance) and HR (hiring, motivating, retaining) due to numerious complains. Seems was intentionally misled by the examiner as HR should not be mentioned I guess.
process 3 - not core business , but complex and to be outsourced. Laweyer are under -utilised and costly to keep on payroll.
COTS is much cheaper than bespoke due to the budget constraints. Less training needed as advantage
Disadvantage - one size does not fit all.
Risks - supplier may not be reliable financially if it's small company
Mitigation of risks - tendering for at least 3 suppliers , well written technical specifications from the customer.
Seems not done well this time , may re-sit in future.
Very lengthy paper. Impossible to finish it within 3:15 mins. It was a resit for me as I failed it in Dec. and I have a feeling that I will resit it again in June lol
Yea I chose reconstruction too. I guess giving good reasoning for your answer would gain the marks. In my opinion change had to be done quickly due to teachers leaving for other colleges, that's why i chose that
Topics that came up in March 2017 for future reference.
1) Case study
a) SWOT Analysis - 18 Marks
b) Contextual features - 12 marks
c) Scope / type of change matrix (choose from Adaptive, Evolution, Reconstruction, Revolution) - [8] marks
d) Appropriateness of Strategy (using 'suitability/acceptability/ feasibility'), Porter's Strategic clock ([8] marks)
e) Professional marks - 4 marks
Q2
Was to do with budgeting and relevant costing but I don't recall the detail as I did not do this one.
Q3
a) Harmon Process Matrix - 10 marks
b) Benefits of an off the shelf software package - 7 marks
c) Problems of using an off the shelf software package - 8 marks
Q4
a) Suggest Upstream / Downstream supply chain improvements to the case (Porter value chain) - 15 marks
b) Boundary-less organisation - 10 marks
Topics that came up in March 2017 for future reference.
1) Case study
a) SWOT Analysis - 18 Marks
b) Contextual features - 12 marks
c) Scope / type of change matrix (choose from Adaptive, Evolution, Reconstruction, Revolution) - [8] marks
d) Appropriateness of Strategy (using 'suitability/acceptability/ feasibility'), Porter's Strategic clock ([8] marks)
e) Professional marks - 4 marks
Q2
Was to do with budgeting and relevant costing but I don't recall the detail as I did not do this one.
Q3
a) Harmon Process Matrix - 10 marks
b) Benefits of an off the shelf software package - 7 marks
c) Problems of using an off the shelf software package - 8 marks
Q4
a) Suggest Upstream / Downstream supply chain improvements to the case (Porter value chain) - 15 marks
b) Boundary-less organisation - 10 marks

