Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBL*** ACCA P3 March 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin9y ago
Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA P3 March 2017 Exam *** ACCA P3 March 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** ACCA P3 March 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about the ACCA P3 exam below (after 5pm UK time)
GGuddo9y ago#1
it was very tough and long
Mmshstudent9y ago#2
Isn't part b balogun contextual feature of change?
MMark9y ago#3
I'm not sure about your C Q1 was that how much the company needs to change? Me thinks they were looking for Adoption, Evolution, Reconstruction, Revolution theory, In this case structure needed to change but ideas remain the same hence I believe evolution seemed most appropriate, also mentioned used to a bureaucrat organisation being government owned and should really go towards a more professional structure as its the senior lecturers who bring the most value. Would be curious to know others thoughts on this?
Bbereank9y ago#4
I found it very hard. I could identify what the examiner wanted but I couldn't get into the questions for some reason. I had to do a lot of thinking and found it hard express my thoughts in writing so it's a June retake for me, I'm afraid ...
Ssamir9y ago#5
@markgibbons said: I'm not sure about your C Q1 was that how much the company needs to change? Me thinks they were looking for Adoption, Evolution, Reconstruction, Revolution theory, In this case structure needed to change but ideas remain the same hence I believe evolution seemed most appropriate, also mentioned used to a bureaucrat organisation being government owned and should really go towards a more professional structure as its the senior lecturers who bring the most value. Would be curious to know others thoughts on this?
I went for evolution too, I explained that the nature was incremental as the were still profitable, only just but it was likely to be transformational as if they went to e-learning it is a fundamental change of business strategy so it is likely to be evolution even though it could be implemented over time.
MMark9y ago#6
Thoughts on Exam Part I) SWOT Analysis 18 Marks - Lengthy but a lot of easy marks /18 Preserving, Readiness, Capacity - Not too sure how this will be noted /12 How to manage change - Me thinks Evolution or adoption /7 Frills, Differentiator etc- Me thinks differentiator, students no money + Exco had quality senior staff, clearly differentiator /9 Prof Marks Who knows how to get a good mark here /4 Q3 Harmon Process Training, simple and important - automate /10 Legal, complicated, not imp, outsource Bespoke vs on shelf program Show benefits of off shelf easy /7 Risks to scenario Not so easy thought of duplication of bookings /8 Q4 Upstream / Downstream Altho sounds nice though hard to apply a lot of information in scenario with very little time left to think and apply /15 Bounder less company, never heard this term before but I assumed it meant feeding information from company to supplier in live? was out of time will see /10 Overall compared to December I thought this was a far nicer P3 exam, the 50 marker was lovely and covered most of the core topics of P3, the trap here was getting caught on time which I can imagine happened to most of us, fingers crossed, anyone else got some opinions>
MMark9y ago#7
I duno if we're right but I'm so happy we're on the same page, it's always a good feeling when someone has the same opinion and answers along the same lines especially in P3 where anything goes :p
TTim9y ago#8
Yeah Q1 part C was Balogun Hope Hailey I believe, scope of change vs nature of change. I also had it down as requiring evolution. On the whole I didn't think Q1 was too bad as long as you followed the models. For Q2 I'm not 100% sure I got the definition of relevant costing correct but I'm hoping that as long as my analysis and conclusions were sound that I should be able to pick up some marks. Second part was talked about the advantages and disadvantages of absorption costing vs relevant costing. Kinda waffled my way through that one. For Q3 I had process 2 down as improvement and process 3 as outsource. Regarding process 1 I just talked about benefits of COTS vs bespoke then general risks of COTS and software in general and how to mitigate them.
AA9y ago#9
Harmon process 2 has to be process improvement not automate, owing to the fact that providing care to vulnerable people and low income families is the reason for this public body in the first place. It's strategically important to them. Also the people on the panel should not be doing the visits either which was a clue that the process needed an overhaul
RRoisin9y ago#10
Q1 c I suggested B& H.H Reconstruction thinking that they needed to do something fast but not changing the overall business of the organization.
RRoisin9y ago#11
Q4 seemed like it was going to be straight forward but by the time I got to it I was already exhausted and even though I had the time I just seemed to get blocked in this question, Ended up not really writing very well and just picking bits from the scenario and commenting Very lengthy exam. More time needed on all the P papers please.
FFati9y ago#12
Was I the only .... I had no idea what to do with the figures in q1
RRoisin9y ago#13
I think the exam was fair, except for the boundary less oragnaisation I was familiar with all the questions I chose. The problem I find is trying to express all that in the time allowed. There is too much reading and really it is frustrating because I know that I can answer all the questions in normal circumstances.
Ssamir9y ago#14
@chullbulla said: Any one can tell the answer for Q1 part b? i was clueless how to use it
For time: they were just profitable and the legislation for the building was only in the consultanting stage, so I discuss that change could be done incrementally. For preservation: tutors were star performers and student choose building providers based on tutors so had to preserve them. Additionally central location was key to attracting customers as long as good transport links so they should preserve them. For readiness: explain senior management unlikely to be ready for change as they had a lot of benefits with current method. But tutors and staff were demotivated and didn't receive the benefits they were promised and few of them were going to move to competitors so they are ready for change.
CCee9y ago#15
I agree. I only got to attempt 82% was pressed for time
SShahbaz9y ago#16
It was long but not very tough than December exam. Q1 was easy this time while it was very tricky in December exam. I chose reconstruction and differentiator. Q3 process2 train staff and process3 outsource. Q4 central warehouse was not adding any value and increasing cost, branded companies can deliver to require country. For Customer deliveries should choose fast delivery service
SShahbaz9y ago#17
I only attempted gross profit margin as it was given for sector as30%
Former userFormer user9y ago#18
@ Roisin & Mark Hi - I am with you with the reconstruction. Mark made a fair point that the NC was still profitable so no need for urgency - perhaps... My thinking was that in 3 years they managed to plunge most of the indicators (especially worrying was for me the magnitude of the dice they took). Which is why I did not figure that it was possible to really do other than Big Bang. Add to that the threat of competitors pouching their start tutors who were already demotivated and I did not think they could afford to go incrementally. Regarding scope I could find arguments for both realignment and transformation depending on change that would be implemented. 75% of their student base is price sensitive so if they go for any other strategy than differentiation and it would be a change in business model that may not be possible within the current cultural paradigm.
Aask2489y ago#19
I didn't know what to do with the numbers and didn't have much time for them. All I said was that the acid test ratio went from about 2 to 0.9 which means they could not bay the bills. Based on this I said that time critical as they could soon go bust. I also said that they were ready to change since profit had plummeted so badly. Other than that I didn't use ratios. I said the changes needed to be quick but not so big because they were preserving a lot, but I named it adaptation by mistake. Hope I don't get penalised. Q4 was hard as I was very tired by that point. I hope I got enough to get by on that one. I basically said that they should manufacture in one location and ship from there. Buy more than once a month and deliver straight to the relevant country. Better yet, manufacturers should deliver to the customers. Being border-less meant using divisional structure not regional, and can sell more easily to anywhere in the world. Plus, they can focus on videos and music.
Aask2489y ago#20
How did you use 3 lenses?
Ssamir9y ago#21
@maurachiriac said: @ Roisin & Mark Hi - I am with you with the reconstruction. Mark made a fair point that the NC was still profitable so no need for urgency - perhaps... My thinking was that in 3 years they managed to plunge most of the indicators (especially worrying was for me the magnitude of the dice they took). Which is why I did not figure that it was possible to really do other than Big Bang. Add to that the threat of competitors pouching their start tutors who were already demotivated and I did not think they could afford to go incrementally. Regarding scope I could find arguments for both realignment and transformation depending on change that would be implemented. 75% of their student base is price sensitive so if they go for any other strategy than differentiation and it would be a change in business model that may not be possible within the current cultural paradigm.
Could it not be a focused differentiation as for differentiation to be useful it needs no reinvestment of margins and high barriers to entry but both of these weren't followed by the training provider.
RRoisin9y ago#22
From the practice questions I think if you write something valid and justify it with some logical thinking it should be ok. Some models might be more relevant than others and make it easier to pick up marks, but if you apply a different model you can still get marks, maybe more difficult to get the marks and not as many. I applied Focused differentiation too.
Former userFormer user9y ago#23
@salmirrules, I am not sure that I take your point. Ny thinking was for q1 c. I think you are referrencing q1 d. For that one I believe both differentiation and focus could work with more inclination towards focus. Did not see the no frills taking off at all.... Apologies if I missunderstood you...
Aakm98259y ago#24
@Mark: i think you'll pass this paper man. i got totally out of time and was just scratching on the booklet for Q3 & Q4 (i hope i get some marks for that) pffff...very lengthy one in terms of question requirements. boundary less orgs - hollow, modular and virtual. but could not write anything as they had already snatched my booklet...sure i'll see a much trickier exam paper in June...lol... i think Q1 d asked for implications of all options to Exco, although Focused diffn was not applicable to it and but talked on all of them...i think i missed it completely missed Q1c. i talked about all types of change when the qs requirement was to discuss the only one that would apply to exco....missed it...agn...
JJackie9y ago#25
I found the risks part of q3 quite hard, I couldn't relly think of the many!! Q1, c I did reconstruction, but couldn't think of the name in the exam, called it Big Bang, but explained it!! I really stuggled with time and my hand writing towards the end was horrendous!
Aakm98259y ago#26
@Mark, i spoke abt both reconstruction and evolution but anyone of these two options will depend on what type of change is effected (by the govt of course as they are the major shareholder). if the senior mgt team is to be changed, then it will be an evolutionary change which will impact its culture. i also spoke abt reconstruction, which is quick, but does not impact exco's culture nor need sacking the mgt team. this will need the hiring of a senior team member having experience in the private education sector (marketing). oufff, so lot to say in so little time...i am planning on making a formal request to acca to send me the paper at home to complete cuz my 3 hrs got lost in planning and analysis - thats what the paper is - business ANALYSIS...my god how will the new p3 case study be in Sept 18 (around 13 pages case study)...
Ssamir9y ago#27
@maurachiriac said: @salmirrules, I am not sure that I take your point. Ny thinking was for q1 c. I think you are referrencing q1 d. For that one I believe both differentiation and focus could work with more inclination towards focus. Did not see the no frills taking off at all.... Apologies if I missunderstood you...
Thanks maura, I have the same as you have and mentioned that focus would be preferred. Thanks for your response.
Former userFormer user9y ago#28
Overall I thought paper was hard. Definitely seen easier papers for P3. Realise I made few studie mistake on the contextual features in Q1. Missed out boundaryless organisation question at end sonnées to hope scraped enough for Pass. For Q1 differentiation i I said online/distance learning model for low cost. Differentiation I said focus on premium product (high quality) with star performers, location, printing materials, buillding etc for focused differentiation or cost I said same as stated but focus on one training area e.g banking and financial sector training The figures were off putting for Q1 as many have said - I really just looked at GP margin and net profit margin compared to industry average of 30%. I made the point under possible threats could be that poor financial performance continues could damage image of company since it is still public owned 51% share so accounts will be available for press etc the see. I said plenty retained profits so even if loss making for few years no imminent financial threat. I think for much of P3 there is no right or wrong as such / providing you answer sensibly and make valid points you should get some sort of credit. I hope so for my sake. GLA!
MMark9y ago#29
@samirrules said: Could it not be a focused differentiation as for differentiation to be useful it needs no reinvestment of margins and high barriers to entry but both of these weren't followed by the training provider.
Hey, I think you're making this sound more complicated than it is, to begin with focused differentiation is based around the fact that you pay a massive premium for extra benefits to aim for a niche market, it was made very clear in the scenario that most students have very little disposable income hence I don't see how focused differentiation could work or the company would have to seriously consider downsizing
Aaffan2k19y ago#30
In Q # 1, I did not relate Contextual model and H & B matrix with scenario but I explain concept of these models so still, can I gain marks on these parts ?