SBL*** ACCA P3 December 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@acca6578 said: 6 marks for calculation and elabroation of each company by using bcg and ash model, identify the correct segment will grant you 0.5 or 1 mark i guess6 mark for calcultions? Thats nice
Not only calculations, elaboration too, and if you could identify the correct segment will get extra marks
@acca6578 said: 6 marks for calculation and elabroation of each company by using bcg and ash model, identify the correct segment will grant you 0.5 or 1 mark i guessseems not realistic to have 6 mrks for calculation.its too much.
Hey guys, did anyone do question 2b? I did not know what to write.
@anastassiya777 the farm couldn't be a question mark. it was acquired in 1994 and performed very well from then. it had a high market share and the market growth was negative. It also was generating alot of cash inflow. That can only be a cashcow.
@jsmp said: Hey guys, did anyone do question 2b? I did not know what to write.what the question was about?
@vervemj said: Hi- can you recall what you.wrote for strategy moving forward for these ? I wasnt sure what to say but said to get rid of the dog lol and perhaps the star to reduce price a little and try to take a bigger market share, kill off comp?for dogs i wrote harvest whatever profits possible and improve cashflows by reducing the investment.
I don't know if I will pass. Surprise element of costing in Q1 and furthermore it's more of time consuming and I only managed like 70 to 75% of the paper. Don't know if I will pass. Really disappointed ?
For all of those saying Farm was cash cow? What was the gross margin and turnover in year 2016? anyone remember? I tell u
Turnvoer: 90
Gross margin: 4
4.4% GP, how this company can be profitable? You guess by yourself.
Oh boy, I think u got little mess up with BCG matrix, it will never refer to gross profit margin, gross profit is used to comment on the co figure......
@streetgold said: Oh boy, I think u got little mess up with BCG matrix, it will never refer to gross profit margin, gross profit is used to comment on the co figure......Can you please elaborate your point? Gross margin or gorss profit, what's the difference?
It a mistake bro, just wanna tell u BCG matrix would never refer to gross profit margin, but u can use it to comment on the co performance.
@streetgold said: It a mistake bro, just wanna tell u BCG matrix would never refer to gross profit margin, but u can use it to comment on the co performance.Ok fine, BCG matrix questions normally have four lines Sector TO Company in Q TO GP NP In this paper, there were three lines Market TO Company TO Net Profit or Gross Profit (Can anyone confirm)? I'm saying it was GP, streetgold is saying it was NP. Anyone else can please weigh in?
Since when I mention anything related to net profit
@streetgold said: Since when I mention anything related to net profitOk let me put simply, what was the other financial figure given in BCG question other than Turnover of the comany?
@tayyabom said: Ok let me put simply, what was the other financial figure given in BCG question other than Turnover of the comany?You had to calculate all ratios like gpm but then for bcg only market share for each year and the industry growth is relevant
@mumbaikar said: You had to calculate all ratios like gpm but then for bcg only market share for each year and the industry growth is relevantOk fine. Understood your point. So if I say, Company X's GPM is just 4.4% which means the company is most likely not generating any net profit for the shareholders and industry in which it operates is in decline stage which may lead to further erosion of GPM and losses hence parent company should dispose of it? Regardless of BCG or Ashridge, common sense says get rid of it, isn't it? Am I missing something here?
What u write for u answer for farm for BCG and ashridge?
@tayyabom said: Ok fine. Understood your point. So if I say, Company X's GPM is just 4.4% which means the company is most likely not generating any net profit for the shareholders and industry in which it operates is in decline stage which may lead to further erosion of GPM and losses hence parent company should dispose of it? Regardless of BCG or Ashridge, common sense says get rid of it, isn't it? Am I missing something here?Actually i guess there are several answers and yes if u justify ur answer well the marker cant cut you off?
Never want to jinx yourself but this paper was a goldmine.
Q4 cultural web, Q3 Harmons SI - PC Matrix ( a world class question)
Q1 basically S/W only .... 24 marks.... I will be livid not to pass this exam.
Very passable indeed!
@streetgold said: What u write for u answer for farm for BCG and ashridge?Dog and Alien.
There was no dog or allian
was the farm value trap?
Question 2: Co. Turnover, Market Turnover, Gross Profit
As StreetGold said, the GP Margin could be used to comment about the company's performance but BCG you gotta calculate the market share and market growth with two other given figures.
SwiftDale Farm I got Cash cow and ballast business. Was about to write alien but so far the company had done well in the group and only in recent years that NCBP had decided to stop the finance resources being provided.
Insurance Co , Question mark and value trap business.
And the Pait Technology Star and Heartland business.
I seem to have messed up the rationales when I checked my notes after exam. 7 easy marks or part of it probably gone. -_-
@acca6578 said: Just wondering how could the Farming company a cash cow? I know it’s has the highest Market Share, but both the market size as well as the gross profit margin is declining significantly over the years, how can the company be a cash cow when the market size as well as the gross profit margin is dropping so much over the years?? it should be a dog rather than a cash cowI strongly agree with you. The farming company is 'dog' since its turnover growth has declined considerably as well as its gross profit and gross profit margin. The decline is in line with the declining market sector turnover Such operations should be divest as soonest as possible. am i wrong?
@skyisthelimit said: Question 2: Co. Turnover, Market Turnover, Gross Profit As StreetGold said, the GP Margin could be used to comment about the company's performance but BCG you gotta calculate the market share and market growth with two other given figures. SwiftDale Farm I got Cash cow and ballast business. Was about to write alien but so far the company had done well in the group and only in recent years that NCBP had decided to stop the finance resources being provided. Insurance Co , Question mark and value trap business. And the Pait Technology Star and Heartland business. I seem to have messed up the rationales when I checked my notes after exam. 7 easy marks or part of it probably gone. -_-Just theoretically in case a company has the largest share on stable or declining market but has negative gross profit figure it is still a cash cow? Cash cow has to generate cash. Besides, the general strategy for cash cow is to keep status quo, which is not suitable in case of Swiftdale Farm.
For Q2 answer, Swiftfarm is Cash cow and Allien; CCB is Star and Value traps; Pait is Star and Heartland.
I explain synergy manager, portfolio manager and parental developer. I said Swiftfarm is example of portfolio manager, Pait is parental developer.
For Q3, publication is important and complex so Recruit expert reporters, the second is high important but simple, so automate by bespoke system, payroll is not important and simple so COTS.
Disadvantage of outsourcing:
- hard to reverse
- unexpected cost
- quality
- legal staff layoff
- success depends on others
Anyone agrees?
@klaudiuszfp said: Just theoretically in case a company has the largest share on stable or declining market but has negative gross profit figure it is still a cash cow? Cash cow has to generate cash. Besides, the general strategy for cash cow is to keep status quo, which is not suitable in case of Swiftdale Farm.I'm trying really hard to remember how the hell did I explain my answer but my brain has gone blank on the answers I'd given. Can't remember the flow I'd used. I suppose you have a point. Oh well, anyway. Whatever's done is done, now it's result time. Good luck everyone.
I felt NCBT were portfolio managers.
Anyone agrees with me? or u can share with me if m wrong, m quite nervous if I will pass the exam. I don't do quite well on Q1.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

