SBL*** ACCA P3 December 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Overall the paper was reasonable in terms of the topics covered, but struggled again with time management. I hope I did enough this time :)
The paper was reasonable.
Does anyone remember the marks for the compulsory question and what the questions were roughly.
For options I did questions 2 and 3.
Question 2 was financial analysis on 3 different acquired businesses of a corporate parent with BCG Matrix and Ashridge Model (18 marks). And also the 3 corporate parent approaches (7 marks).
Question 3 was harmons process strategy mix looking at three functions of the business (15 marks) and disavantages of outsourcing a department (10 marks)
Not sure what question 4 was- can't even remember.
Any ideas what question 4 was??
Q1 was s and w using value chain and variences. 24 marks. Recommend solutions to w. Budgeting advantages.
Q4 was on cultural web. How competences framework helps to recruit teachers.
Very unlikely. Thats a whole 25 marks gone. Whats the likelihood of scoring 50% out of 75% available. Slim
Its tough enough over 100%
Cultural web and competency framework
The variances threw me off balance as soon as I opened the paper. Attempted Question 2 first and then Question 1... didn't have time to finish the paper. I'm not happy with it. I suppose lack of question practice is what made it look so tough.
Not sure that I've scored 50% .... Good luck for results everyone.. :-)
Does anyone actually remember the break down of question 1.
I know part A was 24 marks for value chain and assessing it.
What about part B - addressing strengths and weakness or just one? It was just weaknesses right? Also how many marks was it?
Part C was advantages of budgeting, but how many marks was it?
Qn 1 part a-24
Part b-12
Part c -10
Q #2 wasn't bad at all.
wrote that the farm was a 'dog' company and a value trap business, the insurance company a star company and the last tech company a cash cow company and ballast business.
Thought that the parent company was more of a portfolio manager
Question 2 and 3 was much better...Thou I dint remember Ashridge matrix ,so used only BCG matrix...
how did you guys answer Q #1 part a?
Were there any strenghts as in i thought weaknesses were way more than strenghts
@mumbaikar said: Were there any strenghts as in i thought weaknesses were way more than strenghtsthe factory was on the river. sales were up. being 'green' helped marketing and sales.
Didn't do any calculations for q1, did good in q3, and couldn't finish q4. I think this will be the fist paper that I fail. ?
Were we required to do a flexed budget and if yes were the answers all adverse ?
no, i think you just had to use some variance analysis to help point on weaknesses.
@suf23 said: the factory was on the river. sales were up. being 'green' helped marketing and sales.Sales were up? In actual sense didnt they sell less and at a lesser price that reduced their revenue in total? However it exceeded their breakeven i.e they made a profit altleast
I had mixed feelings bout the exam, the question was reasonable its just bout the time constrain i was not really satisfied with my answers. I even didnt really know what i wrote lol my hand writing was like a 1 grade hopefully the examiner will understand it . A bit here and there not really analyzing it with the word because.. as need to move on to other question as time passed by.
@mumbaikar
I meant in the sense of demand.
their boxes were in demand for the 'green' factor.
Hey guys,
Q1 was ok but I did not do a variance analysis (not enough time to analyse the info, do calculations and write it up). Despite that - I spent far too long on part a (it was worth a lot of marks though - 24 I belive!)
But for b and c I did not write enough as I was behind schedule.
I then did 3A which was good as I knew Harmon's matrix. 3B was decent also.
But Q2 was not good (for me anyway). I was low on time and panicked a bit.
Part A was worth loads and I didn't write enough.
For B I squeezed out a sentence of anything I could think of for each of the 3 topics. Hoping to get a mark somewhere in that.
Sadly due to the last question I think it might be a second fail for me :(
How did you guys find Q2?
Best of luck in your results
@jassangha said: Yes, flex to reflect a budget for 8000 units instead of 10000 They were all adverse, I can't remember which is for which but I had the following Adverse (30000) (I think this was Raw Materials) Adverse (40000) Adverse (50000) (I think this was Labour) Total Adverse was (120000)Thats what also i wrote i guess
@jassangha said: Yes, flex to reflect a budget for 8000 units instead of 10000 They were all adverse, I can't remember which is for which but I had the following Adverse (30000) (I think this was Raw Materials) Adverse (40000) Adverse (50000) (I think this was Labour) Total Adverse was (120000)Those are the total variances but each of those can be broken down further into efficiency and price variances. Regarding the raw materials for example there was actually a 20k favourable variance (suggests procurement had negotiated a discount?) in the price they paid which means the usage variance was 50k. And on labour they used more hours than they should and they also paid more per hour (because of the overtime element)
The paper was really doable just that my only issue was time management. I did the whole question in section A but it sucked too much of my time. In section B I managed to finish question 2 but I couldn't attempt question 3 which was also doable. Though I didn't finish all I remain strong with a narrow pass. It's possible to pass with only 2 questions done particularly if you did question 1 in section A. I passed P1 back in march 2017 with only 2 questions attempted. Good luck guys.
I got a 40000 sales adverse,
20000 adverse raw material
Dint do labour variance
10000 favourable fixed overhead.....
Hope it's correct
Anyone know what the strengths of the HR department was in Q1?
@mark after skimming twice looking for a strength, I just wrote 'HR seem to have no strengths but the weaknesses are as follows:'
after skimming twice looking for a strength, I just wrote ‘HR seem to have no strengths but the weaknesses are as follows:’
strengths of the HR dpt can be the high brand image of the company. it helps HR dpt to attract and recruit high profile people.
High sales can also be mentioned saying that continuous high sales of the company help to offer better salary and bonus payment options for current or potential employees
The P papers continue to be brutal in terms of time. I did Qs 2&3. Neither were too bad, but because of time there were bits of all questions that I didn't get to address which of course is disappointing.
I also flexed the budget in Q1 so i could refer to some variances. I got raw material variance as favourable though so compared to the other replies here..whoops O_O.
Unlike P1 I thought the questions were interesting, time is my only complaint. Really hope I pull through and good luck to everyone else who wrote.
Edit: @sonyam11 - I got that 20,000 favourable variance too!
@jasvirdi said: The paper was reasonable. Does anyone remember the marks for the compulsory question and what the questions were roughly. For options I did questions 2 and 3. Question 2 was financial analysis on 3 different acquired businesses of a corporate parent with BCG Matrix and Ashridge Model (18 marks). And also the 3 corporate parent approaches (7 marks). Question 3 was harmons process strategy mix looking at three functions of the business (15 marks) and disavantages of outsourcing a department (10 marks) Not sure what question 4 was- can't even remember. Any ideas what question 4 was??question was about cultural web
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

