SBR*** ACCA P2 September 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@gt0707 said: for PPE i meant: Group PPE P+B+T——– **** land ———– *** plant —- — — ** total ———- ……… i have not this total here, but for each item in SoFP, i mentioned the working number, like say for PPE item in sofp i mentioned (w1)I believe you should be fine as you have referenced your working.
NCI was very tricky. I did not know how to calculate it aand that messed up my flow. The paper wasn't hard, was straight forward but require a lot of reasoning
The paper was okay for those who read and had done alot of practice. My main problem was time as I ended up not finishing the paper. Question one was not so bad compared to other past papers. The part for nci was a little bit tricky I didn't know how to calculate it. A question 2 was quite fair as I was able to tackle it. Question 3 was a disaster especially the part involving investment property. I had set my mind to avoid question 4 and that's actually what I did. I hope for the best and wish all who did this sort the very best.
@gt0707 said: hello guys i would like to know while preparing the working for conslidation, like group PPE, RE, OCE, & NCI, if we put the adjustment to be made in each working and don't compute total and put in the sofp, will the workings be marked. or will we be penalised for the total not included in SOFPProvided you indicated your working beside each adjustment it is fine. You might be penalized a mark or 2 for the totals but you won't lose much.
Hi. Were the below two issues in two different questions? Or as a part of one question?
- the one related HFS and Discontinued Operations (with binding offer)
- the one related to FX operations - purchase of retail outlet with loan.
Hi
P2 was ok, but tricky. Not sure if I was right but my SFP balance by Usd 490M.
Does anyone can confirm same.
Thks
Was it a joint operation or joint venture in Q 1? I did workings for a joint op, so added the share of assets, liabilities & so on. But now I feel their was a legal entity created which would mean it was a joint venture. Perhaps I am mixing the facts up!
were the below issues in two different questions? Or were they in one question?
- Held For Sale and Discontinued Operations (with binding offer)
- Purchase of Retail outlets (with FX gains (Peso) and losses issues)
@james1114563 said: Tax, meh. Mentioned the theory, temporary and permenant. There was a difference of about 3m or Soemthing, deferred tax liability?Tell me about it...felt the same.
@james1114563 said: I focuses more on ethics. Lack of professional behaviour, competence, integrity not disclosing. Mentioned about fraud, disqualification etc etc. Standard ethical thingsYea I remember mentioning that directors are not being transparent and it's not a faithful representation of FS.
@james1114563 said: About 1B, I said how the company may have a future impact from the decision not to restructure. It was also after the audit opinion, therefore is that bad? Said could be misleading if they've decided to not to do it etc. Also they incurred dismantling costs, therefore more expenses. .I thought this was bit of an open ended question too....I remember taking about how the provision needs to be reversed, if there was a legal/constructive obligation for already stating the redundancy thus seek legal advice and should provide for it as requires. Then when on to talk about how the company gearing is already high and they already spent money on restructuring thus if there is a problem with debt covenant (probably went off topic a bit). And also as mentioned before whether it is a adjusting period or not.
@ish123 said: I believe you should be fine as you have referenced your working.Ok thanks
Weird! Posted the above comment yesterday and it's showing up today.....won't even let me delete it.
@connieoduya said: Provided you indicated your working beside each adjustment it is fine. You might be penalized a mark or 2 for the totals but you won't lose much.yeah i did mentioned the workings.
Hi all
for question 2A,B,C and 3A,B,C
How many side of paper did you write for each i.e 1 side or half a side etc.
Regards,
I got a loss for the retained earnings figure for basil when calculating net assets, did anyone get something similar?
@tinaboy said: really?good for you.I found Basil`s NCI weird .I t was a full good will .Pepper had assesed the fv based on P/E ratio which would need to fall by 25% in order to make inmarketable shares on Basil marketable.the earnins were given.was it supposedto be calculated via business valuations (0.75 * 20)=p/e then * 40% in order to get NCI @ FV?? I alsolost it on restructuring.Instead I found IFRSs fair an exact opposite of youLet me know if the calculation below for NCI makes any sense. PE= Share Price/ EPS Given, PE=20 No. of $1 Shares= 21 m Profit for the year= 6.5 m So, Eps= 6.5/21; or, $0.30 PE= Share Price / EPS 20= x / 0.30 x= 6 Decrease it by 25% 6 x 75 % = 4.5 Therefore the share price is $4.5 NCI= (21m x 40%) x 4.5. or, 37.8 m
m
what is amount of the loss retained earning?i also get loss amount.
Found the Paper to be average. Any notes that proved to be useful?
Q1 - Was fine although the balance sheet did not tally, but i know where my mistakes was but was time pressured to amend and risk to loose time which can give me more marks.
I did Q2 + Q3 - managed to go through them but really straggled was definitely time pressured .
Q4 - although i knew the IFRS in question, i was not able to think of what i can talk about so just ignored it
now just cross fingers xx
Please tell me! In the first question there was joint operation or joint venture?
I've done like joint operation, but now I think that it was actually joint venture...
What have you done?
I've also done like joint operation, but now I'm not sure
Yes, Basil had post acquisition loss
And consolidated RE also negative
How many can confirm that Basils retained earnings ended up negative?
@tlobo said: How many can confirm that Basils retained earnings ended up negative?Negative for me too
My time management was bad and anxiety took over.
@wesbyss said: my understanding is that as long as there is not a seperate vehicle for the joint venture, It is always a joint operation.Yes, you also done as joint operation? I remember there was an entity Salt..
What everyone did joint venture or joint operation? Let's vote
i too found consolidation fairly easy not that easy if not prepared, mine nearly balanced with only 8 figure different. 1a &b i wrote well in a but b was on ethical issue but didn't write much.
Q2 on contract, i went head to list 5 levels and relating to the scenario in the question and recognition of the revenue in the contract, how and went to recognize .
down to Q3 only a i didn't write much but mange to explain the difference between financial liability and equity instrument.
Overall i was confident.
there was a joint operation, shares was giving, contribution, assets, receivable and liability, the joint operation was in losses giving too.
DOES ANYONE HAVE A COPY OF THE SEPT 2016 P2 PAPER?? THANKS!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

