Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBR*** ACCA P2 September 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin10y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA P2 September 2016 Exam.

*** ACCA P2 September 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** ACCA P2 September 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results

Post your comments about the ACCA P2 exam below

RRaymond10y ago#1
Was not easy, time pressured
PPalmy10y ago#2
I found the consolidation question extremely easy compared to all the questions I tried during my revision: no change in composition, no foreign subsidiary, no weird fv adjustments.... I finished Q1 in 1 hour with my SFP nearly balancing! Amazing. Q2 and Q3 however, are a different story: I struggled to identify the issues in almost all the scenarios and even if I wrote something for each question I am pretty sure that won't be enough to pass. I skipped Q4 as I found it uninspiring. I was really hoping for a dicussion on the recent developments in IFRS 9, maybe hedging accounting, which I know inside out because of my job but nada... I should have focused more on IFRS and their application rather than consolidation, now I really want to kick myself.
TTeo10y ago#3
Can any kind soul share what are the IFRS/IAS that came out & what is question 4 about,and Q1 is on SOFP or P/L?Thanks.
PPalmy10y ago#4
@tyjtht said: Can any kind soul share what are the IFRS/IAS that came out & what is question 4 about,and Q1 is on SOFP or P/L?Thanks.
https://opentuition.com/topic/the-final-push-for-tomorrow/page/2/
TTin10y ago#5
really?good for you.I found Basil`s NCI weird .I t was a full good will .Pepper had assesed the fv based on P/E ratio which would need to fall by 25% in order to make inmarketable shares on Basil marketable.the earnins were given.was it supposedto be calculated via business valuations (0.75 * 20)=p/e then * 40% in order to get NCI @ FV?? I alsolost it on restructuring.Instead I found IFRSs fair an exact opposite of you
GGT070710y ago#6
hello guys i would like to know while preparing the working for conslidation, like group PPE, RE, OCE, & NCI, if we put the adjustment to be made in each working and don't compute total and put in the sofp, will the workings be marked. or will we be penalised for the total not included in SOFP
PPalmy10y ago#7
@tinaboy said: really?good for you.I found Basil`s NCI weird .I t was a full good will .Pepper had assesed the fv based on P/E ratio which would need to fall by 25% in order to make inmarketable shares on Basil marketable.the earnins were given.was it supposedto be calculated via business valuations (0.75 * 20)=p/e then * 40% in order to get NCI @ FV?? I alsolost it on restructuring.Instead I found IFRSs fair an exact opposite of you
The calculation of the Nci in Basil was very similar to question 06/15 Kutchen (which is also available as revision lecture here on OT). I don't remember the figures but you simply had to adjust the P/E ratio by reducing it by the percentage given. Earnings, which were given, x the adjusted ratio = P, which is the total value of the sub. Since you want to determine the NCI you multiply that by 40%. So it seems to me that what you have done is right!
TTin10y ago#8
oh yes.thats what i did
RRock10y ago#9
So the P2 examiner decided to spare the lifes of the candidates this september? Ah i remember when i took the March exam this year, the consolidate account was so freaking alien and the adjustment is just mind blowing that you are not sure what to do with it well lucky back then i passed the paper goodluck for those whose taking this session!
AA10y ago#10
Does anyone remember the ifrs/ias for 2nd & 3rd question?
Uunderoath1310y ago#11
Consolidation structure was fine, but notes in that question were tricky. 1- which costs have u incl in restructuring provision? 2- how u deal with joint arrangement? I messed up my calculations and working, finally had aroun 100m difference in balance sheet
AA10y ago#12
Which ifrs did u identify for 2 n 3 question
JJames10y ago#13
Generally thought it was okay... Quick thoughts. SFP! Pretty simple computation. Few adjustments. I made a few silly mistakes but generally did most of them okay. Operating lease Joint ventures Deferred consideration Impairment Restructing NCI was a different formula. Other than that mostly fine. The theory on restructuring and the impacts on next year for b was okay too. Ethics was fine too. 2 was tricky. Was revenue, deferred tax and forex/assets. Managed to muddle through. Thought tax was the hardest 3 was tough. Had investment/ifrs 3, ifrs 5 assets held for sale and also ias 10 events after balance sheet date. Didn't know what to write for ifrs 3 question but other two managed to write a fair bit.
AA10y ago#14
@wesbyss said: I have Q1 – ias36, ias37, ifrs11, ias17 Q2 – ias21, a bit ias16 and ifrs9, ias12, ifrs15 Q3 – ifrs2, ifrs5, ifrs3 Q4 was about ias 8 i think.
For question 3 i wrote about ifrs 9( for the 2 options) because the first one had equity instrument but the second option had financial liability as there was an obligation to repay.
Bbennyakm10y ago#15
Hi Guys, Is any one remember the SOFP balance those who get it balanced?
Bbennyakm10y ago#16
have you remember the total of soft?
Llau10y ago#17
i get 46x.x?how about u?
IIC10y ago#18
Here is my two pennies worth; Q1 Seemed OK, although I may have messed up the NCI for Basil. For restructuring calculation I only took 9 (redundancy payment of 4 and 3 onerous contract) thus excluding operating loss, gain on disposal and relocation cost. Hoping I got it right. 1.b going back to restructure, can't remember exactly what I wrote but said it's a non adjusting event unless additional cost relates to prior period. 1.c where director created a company to get loan. Basically taked about how the subsidiary wasn't a 'business' as defined by business combination and taked little bit on ethics. 2.a was based on purchase of foreign PPE with foreign loan. Basically taked about how monetary and non monetary item translated and interest expense translated using average rate. Then done some calculation and then 31/Aug there was a revaluation which I translated to show imparirment which should go to p/l 2.b was deferred tax, was bit tricky as I didn't spend too much time on DT but done a calculation to show goodwill of 5 with DT liability of 1 on it. Tried to talk little bit on temporary difference but nothing significant. Also done calculation to show DTL/DTA for each assets and liabilities using subs tax rate this time. 2.c was revenue recognition, this was a question from past paper where you had to state 5 requirements under identify a contract and the other company does not meet the last criteria of "entity will probably collect the consideration". One mistake I did on this was I supposed to write non-refundable payment was a deposit liability but I said it was prepayment. 3.a I talked about how it is important to separate debt and equity. Defined both and mentioned "Fixed test" as an option to identify equity. Then said how the entity need to calculate it. 3.b talked about what qualifies as held for sale and the entity should recognise it as held for sale. Also quickly mentioned how it should show as one line item on SOPL and SPFP. 3.c Simply ran out of time!
IIC10y ago#19
@gt0707 said: hello guys i would like to know while preparing the working for conslidation, like group PPE, RE, OCE, & NCI, if we put the adjustment to be made in each working and don't compute total and put in the sofp, will the workings be marked. or will we be penalised for the total not included in SOFP
I'm guessing you mean like PPE(100+50) and then not adding up? If so that's what I did as BPP lecturers alway say don't waste time adding up and examiner isn't there to test if you can add up.
JJames10y ago#20
@ish123 said: Here is my two pennies worth; Q1 Seemed OK, although I may have messed up the NCI for Basil. For restructuring calculation I only took 9 (redundancy payment of 4 and 3 onerous contract) thus excluding operating loss, gain on disposal and relocation cost. Hoping I got it right. 1.b going back to restructure, can't remember exactly what I wrote but said it's a non adjusting event unless additional cost relates to prior period. 1.c where director created a company to get loan. Basically taked about how the subsidiary wasn't a 'business' as defined by business combination and taked little bit on ethics. 2.a was based on purchase of foreign PPE with foreign loan. Basically takes about how monetary and non monetary item translated and interest expense translated using average rate. Then done some calculation and then 31/Aug there was a revaluation which I translated to show imparirment which should go to p/l 2.b was deferred tax, was bit tricky as I didn't spend too much time on DT but done a calculation to show goodwill of 5 with DT liability of 1 on it. Tried to talk little bit on temporary difference but nothing significant. Also done calculation to show DTL/DTA for each assets and liabilities using subs tax rate this time. 2.c was revenue recognition, this was a question from past paper where you had to state 5 requirement under identify a contract and the other company does not meet the last criteria of "entity will probably collect the consideration". One mistake I did on this was I supposed to write non-refundable was a deposit liability but I said it was prepayment. 3.a I talked about how it is important to separate debt and equity. Defined both and mentioned "Fixed test" as an option to identify equity. Then said how the entity need to calculate it. 3.b talked about what qualifies as held for sale and the entity should recognise it as held for sale. Also quickly mentioned how it should show as one line item on SOPL and SPFP. 3.c Simply ran out of time!
Theory was similar I got an impairment of 0.85 in 2A. Thought was a detailed but nice question. 2C I mentioned the steps and said how it's a Performance obligation at conception as that's when R and R transfer. Howver if they can't pay and they knew that shouldn't take revenue at all. Something along those lines. Tax, meh. Mentioned the theory, temporary and permenant. There was a difference of about 3m or Soemthing, deferred tax liability? 3C was hard, fudged about trying to explain about business combinations. Agree on held for sale too. About 1B, I said how the company may have a future impact from the decision not to restructure. It was also after the audit opinion, therefore is that bad? Said could be misleading if they've decided to not to do it etc. Also they incurred dismantling costs, therefore more expenses. Did mention how they may get a credit in the next year though and additional revenue. But leaned on the more negative side. I focuses more on ethics. Lack of professional behaviour, competence, integrity not disclosing. Mentioned about fraud, disqualification etc etc. Standard ethical things Hopefully done enough! Made silly little mistakes which I hope don't cost me.
Former userFormer user10y ago#21
Did anyone get a decrease in net assets for basil and thyme? I thought the csofp was reasonable... until that happened, which I have never seen in an example before, but clearly plausible, so I went with it :-/
Former userFormer user10y ago#22
it was a balance paper this time
AAmanda10y ago#23
1a) -Purchase consideration for Thyme should be discounted for 3 years right? -FV NCI of Basil is somewhere around 37m. Got the price per share according to the PE ratio given and then reduce it by 25%. -Goodwill impairment of 10, split between parent and NCI. -Joint operation but forgot how to deal with the cash contribution. Added 50% share of NCA, CA and CL to the SOFP. Share of losses taken to RE too. -Overall net assets of group decreased. I got 1.7m only for RE :/ -Provision for restructuring 4m. This is wrong, I forgot the onerous contracts. -Sale and leaseback as operating lease. Gave an additional gain of 3m because CA is 15 while FV is 12 and sale proceeds is 20. 1b) Left it blank. 1c) Simply wrote what i can about integrity and professional behaviour. 2a) Talked a bit about IAS 21 on translating retail outlet and loan at spot rate at spot rate, depreciation and finance cost for 6 months(or 5 i don't remember) at average rate, retranslate them at closing rate. Retail outlet has an exchange loss on retranslation while loan has exchange gain. Exchange gain and loss taken to profit or loss. Don't remember imparing anything as i thought the CA of loan/retail outlet is lower than RA. 2b) Tough for me. Got a goodwill of 2m and provided DTL for it. Didn't bother completing the other stuff. 2c) Simply do not understand what the question is asking for. 3a) Talked only about the second option. Touched on disclosing the second option as contingent liability as cost cannot be reliably estimated. Then about adjusting event too. 3b) Just churned out what I remember for IFRS 5. Said the reasons for entity to not recognise NCAHFS is invalid. 3c) Question talked about investment property at cost model and capitalizing tax expense. I didn't write anything related to the IAS, just said the tax expense shouldn't be capitalized. Overall a tough paper for me. :(
IIC10y ago#24
@james1114563 said: Theory was similar I got an impairment of 0.85 in 2A. Thought was a detailed but nice question. 2C I mentioned the steps and said how it's a Performance obligation at conception as that's when R and R transfer. Howver if they can't pay and they knew that shouldn't take revenue at all. Something along those lines. Tax, meh. Mentioned the theory, temporary and permenant. There was a difference of about 3m or Soemthing, deferred tax liability? 3C was hard, fudged about trying to explain about business combinations. Agree on held for sale too. About 1B, I said how the company may have a future impact from the decision not to restructure. It was also after the audit opinion, therefore is that bad? Said could be misleading if they've decided to not to do it etc. Also they incurred dismantling costs, therefore more expenses. Did mention how they may get a credit in the next year though and additional revenue. But leaned on the more negative side. I focuses more on ethics. Lack of professional behaviour, competence, integrity not disclosing. Mentioned about fraud, disqualification etc etc. Standard ethical things Hopefully done enough! Made silly little mistakes which I hope don't cost me.
Tell me about it...felt the same about the tax. 1.c Yea I remember mentioning that directors are not being transparent and it's not a faithful representation of FS. 1.b I thought this was bit of an open ended question too....I remember taking about how the provision needs to be reversed, if there was a legal/constructive obligation for already stating the redundancy thus seek legal advice and should provide for it as requires. Then when on to talk about how the company gearing is already high and they already spent money on restructuring thus if there is a problem with debt covenant (probably went off topic a bit). And also as mentioned before whether it is a adjusting period or not.
JJames10y ago#25
@ish123 said: Tell me about it...felt the same about the tax. 1.c Yea I remember mentioning that directors are not being transparent and it's not a faithful representation of FS. 1.b I thought this was bit of an open ended question too....I remember taking about how the provision needs to be reversed, if there was a legal/constructive obligation for already stating the redundancy thus seek legal advice and should provide for it as requires. Then when on to talk about how the company gearing is already high and they already spent money on restructuring thus if there is a problem with debt covenant (probably went off topic a bit). And also as mentioned before whether it is a adjusting period or not.
Yeah, sounds good. Written I thought was okay! Just realised I forgot to spilt impairment between nci and parent, unbelievable. Annoying! I felt good about most of the written parts and did every part of the sfp, just not all fully correct. I accrued for half the loss on joint venture to profit and put half the assets in the sfp. Hopefully get couple marks for that sort of thing. Restricting I got 12m? 4 + 3m for onerous and then redundancy of the rest? Impairment I did the nci wrong but just ended up impairing goodwill only. With the balance sheet only other things were remembering to do journals for all the differences to FV. With the deferred consideration I just discounted to pv. I think you had to do something with finance costs and build it back up but ran out of time. Lots to pick at!
Aaffan2k110y ago#26
I write that ASSET should not be considered as ASSET HELD FOR SALE in Q 3 B.
JJames10y ago#27
@affan2k1 said: I write that ASSET should not be considered as ASSET HELD FOR SALE in Q 3 B.
I thought it was? Readily available, for sale, likely with 12months and also close to sale. Sale price close to fair value too
Llau10y ago#28
@ccoda said: Did anyone get a decrease in net assets for basil and thyme? I thought the csofp was reasonable... until that happened, which I have never seen in an example before, but clearly plausible, so I went with it :-/
yup, i also get the decrease net assets for two sub, how about the impairment loss?
GGT070710y ago#29
for PPE i meant: Group PPE P+B+T-------- **** land ----------- *** plant ---- --- -- ** total ---------- .........
GGT070710y ago#30
@ish123 said: I'm guessing you mean like PPE(100+50) and then not adding up? If so that's what I did as BPP lecturers alway say don't waste time adding up and examiner isn't there to test if you can add up.
for PPE i meant: Group PPE P+B+T——– **** land ———– *** plant —- — — ** total ———- ……… i have not this total here, but for each item in SoFP, i mentioned the working number, like say for PPE item in sofp i mentioned (w1)
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.