Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBR*** ACCA P2 March 2018 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin8y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA P2 March 2018 Exam

*** ACCA P2 March 2018 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** ACCA P2 March 2018 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about the ACCA P2 exam below (comments will open after 5pm UK)
Former userFormer user8y ago#31
I feel very stupid as i type this but i consolidated the 100% sub lol... just gotta laugh really
Jjohno1015308y ago#32
What are you suppose to do with it?
AAJY8y ago#33
What the hell is a government rate and official rate?? ACCA examiners are just totally weird set of people.. the exam was tough.. most of the questions were more of discursive than using the standards to answer the question or give advise.. never seen anything like it in the past papers or kit
Former userFormer user8y ago#34
@hollyqian said: Q1 consolidate SOFP I didn’t balance, total asset was 6392m, equity and liability was 6329m, but not much different, I think my problem I should not add Jam goodwill 20m in calculation. Anyone get similar figure?
Im pretty sure this is not a big deal! Im sure u you will get marks for all your workings etc. My taught and revision course was taught by a current p2 marker. She emphasised that it was pointless adding accross nd trying to balance. We get zero marks for that.. its all about ur working and putting wat u worked out on the right line... U did great dont worry about it not balancing
Nnataly19868y ago#35
@mathay2603 said: I think that part was about 7/8 marks. To be honest I wrote about fair value measurements in two questions but I don't think they were looking for that in that question. I may be wrong though. I saw someone wrote on here about using level 2 inputs for the building, I put that as a level 2 is an observable input of a similar asset (not identical which is what level 1 would be). Did anyone else decide this? Also, anyone know what the answer to the revenue from contracts question was or the question where they wanted to revalue NCI using share prices?
I had the same answer regarding Level 2 valuation as Level 1 wasn't appropriate for that property
AAJY8y ago#36
@usmanhassan94 said: have never seen a section B like this ever before...!!! 2 exchange rate in a same country where in the world do wee have this ..? section B was a disaster i wasnt able to calculate gearing for ifrs 16 i just wrote gearing would likely to increase
I don't understand how the examiners reason out these things?? It's incredibly hilarious when you think about it.. two exchange rates in the same country..
Nnataly19868y ago#37
@mjibola said: What the hell is a government rate and official rate?? ACCA examiners are just totally weird set of people.. the exam was tough.. most of the questions were more of discursive than using the standards to answer the question or give advise.. never seen anything like it in the past papers or kit
This is was one of the most confusing questions!
Nnataly19868y ago#38
@rangeuk said: I think they were getting at amortised cost method for valuing financial assets, does it pass contractual cash flow or business model test. I said if they buy and sell financial assets they have to use fair value method. Then went onto investment property being valued at cost or fair value method. If the business deals in investment property it might want to use fair value etc.
I ended up with the same answer, how initially FA are recognised @ FV and then subsequently are measured either at amortised cost, FVTOCE or FVTPL depending on business model
Jjohno1015308y ago#39
@kudzi123 said: I feel very stupid as i type this but i consolidated the 100% sub lol... just gotta laugh really
What are you supposed to do here? I just consolidated as normal, it threw me off so I just carried on as normal
Nnataly19868y ago#40
What was the answer for depreciation of leased vehicle that wasn't used? Was it correct not to charge any depreciation? How should we have accounted for consideration of 10% received later as part of the sale with all of these probabilities?
DDavid8y ago#41
@nataly1986 said: What was the answer for depreciation of leased vehicle that wasn't used? Was it correct not to charge any depreciation? How should we have accounted for consideration of 10% received later as part of the sale with all of these probabilities?
I guessed that this was inventory as this was the ttade of the company and assumed this shouldnt be depreciated. In regarda to revenue i have calculated expcted revenue and adjusted it at the year end. We were probably supposed to jusy yake the more probable outcome rather than expected value. But who knows...
DDavid8y ago#42
Waa goodwill impaired for the subsidiary not held for sale?
AAJY8y ago#43
Everybody keeps asking questions nobody has answers to.. P2 was a disaster!
Former userFormer user8y ago#44
@mjibola said: Everybody keeps asking questions nobody has answers to.. P2 was a disaster!
Perhaps, we shall just have to wait until mid-April.
Former userFormer user8y ago#45
wasn't the non current asset held for sale just supposed to be a one line item in current assets?
BBeata8y ago#46
I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks the part B was a disaster. The two exchange rates Q -there was something similar in communism systems- government rate and 'black market currency rate'- maybe that's what they meant ;) The vehicles for lease- I thought about IAS2 but never mentioned it... The business models question-very weird and highly marked. Also part c in question 1 was hard and for 9 marks -something about accounting policies... Level 2 for the investing property. Didnt have time to come back to question about revenue. The gearing in Q3 was 30% before and 33% after...Forgot about depreciation though... Overall- very disappointed! Do you think they want people fail and let them sit the new P2 in September... And fail again then? This was my second attempt for P2, this time I have put in a lot hours into studying but I feel so disappointed and discouraged now. The exams don't really test your knowledge or ability to logical thinking anymore. They are just tricky, testing small details and putting people off... Maybe that is the aim...
LLaura8y ago#47
Should the 100% sub held for sale have been consolidated? Think I messed up by not consolidating it. Regarding the lease vehicles in part B, my tutor did a very similar question and the answer was that lease cars should be held as PPE and depreciated if they are ready for use even if they are not being leased.
SSteven8y ago#48
My overall though is dissapointment. Not only my valuable time giving for this paper and the stress i got all the way till the day of the exam. You pay so much for a paper, learning and studying so long for a 3 hours exam and the exam is all about tricks and anything than examining the real content of p2. I do not want to give up but this force me to do it!! I am feeling so low and down.. Really upset!
NNaa8y ago#49
Hey Steven, Please don’t give up. It’s okay to be disappointed especially if we’ve put in so much work but I have failed so many of my papers in the past (and very likely to fail this P2 too) but in my lowest moments my family and friends gave me strength. So here I am as a distant friend and fellow ACCA student that Pls Don’t Give Up...it will all pay off in the end. And knowledge you acquired thru your learning is never a waste even if you don’t pass this time. Stay encouraged!
AAmanda8y ago#50
My first professional level paper..and what a disaster it was! Q1a - I did classify the 100% sub however I showed it as part of CA and not on its own. I did calculate a gain on the sub that they held but did not recognize as I thought goodwill can not be subsequently measured, only impaired so made a guess on that! The share options - I couldn’t figure out where the year 1 figure came from in the Q. I thought it would be 10k x 200 x the fv at the grant date?? 1B - I came to the conclusion that it was ok to classify as held for sale 1C - I messed up and babbled on about applying accounting policies to the one class and ethics Q2&3 - So difficult! Glad it was not just me! I really messed up! The lease calculations were ok and I got the 30 and 33 gearing as well. Foreign currency rate I had no idea and since read that there are special rules for hyperinflation currencies but that was not on our syllabus right??? Revenue - I recognized the cash and deferred income based on the most probable outcome - no discounting?? Messed up the others as well!! Maybe better luck in June for me!
CCarlix8y ago#51
So much hard the Exam was. How come There is a Business Model remeasurements and IFRS 16 leases. I have never found regarding these ini any of the past papers .... So much disheartening, hoping only to pass ini April...
Bbob8y ago#52
@nataly1986 said: What was the answer for depreciation of leased vehicle that wasn't used? Was it correct not to charge any depreciation? How should we have accounted for consideration of 10% received later as part of the sale with all of these probabilities?
I refer to IAS 16 to answer this Q, the PPE's depreciation start when "available for use" not actually put in use.not sure if its correct or not, time is so tight, I just throw into answer whatever came into my first thought......and my hand writing is just a mess hopefully marker can recognize though.......
Bbob8y ago#53
@elliereza said: SOME WHAT I REMEMBER Q1) a) CSFP- Sub 80% (name Butter) impairment (net assets recoverable amount) FVA adjustment of Unrecognized Intangible at Acq'n second sub (name jam) was 100%, GW cal, then IFRS 5 HFS, which also impaired Pensions and SBP Joint ventures and Operations b) IFRS 5 HFS and regulator approval and buyer commitment for second sub jam c) recalculating NCI of all previous subs and economic vs substance form and ethics Q2) ADVICES Forex and associate, national bank rate or Government rate lease rental cars and no depreciation, only dep'n when it given to customers investment property and assets different measurements, business models Q3) IFRS 16 leases and complex calculations IFRS 13 FV level 1 advice IFRS 15 revenue and complex calculations Q4) Discuss Assets and liabilities and Uncertainty, with framework Provisions recognition, and uncertainty Materiality IFRS 5 and investment property
For NCI recalculation for past consolidation, is this allowed? I thought goodwill cannot be changed unless impairment or disposal....for future consolidation I guess OK?
Bbob8y ago#54
@erathan said: So much hard the Exam was. How come There is a Business Model remeasurements and IFRS 16 leases. I have never found regarding these ini any of the past papers .... So much disheartening, hoping only to pass ini April...
I read "business model" and I quickly write about IEI and investment in debt....I suppose should be about IP and PPE right....
AAJY8y ago#55
How does uncertainty affect contingent liabilities, provisions and contingent assets including materiality? I just mumbled somethings on the criteria for measurement in IAS39 on virtually certain, probable, remote and possible.. hopefully that picks up one or two marks.. I think I've failed though What did anyone put?
DDamjan8y ago#56
Hi guys, Don't burn me alive but to be honest I don't think that part B of the exam was that difficult. Indeed it was different but not that difficult. There were plenty of marks related to discussion and I assume markers will be generous to give marks for the ideas supported with relevant statements. I assume most of you were preparing for calculations, but I hardly recall making 3-4 of them. I chose Q2 and Q4. There were 10 marks in Q4 for definition, recognition, measurement and disclosure of asset/liability, contingent asset/liability and provision. Let's be honest at level of P2 this was a Christmas gift. Good luck to all!
KKlaudiusz8y ago#57
@fuzzywuzzy said: Hi guys, I'll post what I've answered here and hopefully someone gets the same answer. [...]
Hi fuzzywuzzy regarding 3b (valuation of propoerty) and 3c (leasing) I have the same answers. For subsidiary held for sale I included separate lines for assets and liabilities from disposal group but I did not separate equity part. 3a (revenue) I considered conditions to recognize reve and concluded that reve should be recognized as base fee (41m) plus lower conditional payment i.e. 0.3m (3m*10%). I did not mention anything about discounting but conditional payment is within a year and potential financing benefit is immaterial. On reporting date I made no adjustments to recognized reve as 0.3m payment was still most probable (60% probability). Question 2 was very weird. In 2a (translation of a sub) I assumed that government rate is right as all business entities inlcuding this mentioned in the case may remit CF at this rate only. In part with average rate for P&L i wrote that as a rule FX rate from date of a transaction should be used but ifrs leaves some space and average rate may be used as approximation. However given the fact that FX rate changed only once it might be appropriate to transalte P&L based on this two separate rates as average may be poor approximation. In the end I noted that sub has only 2% of net assets of the group and is immaterial and average vs actual is a matter of usefulness vs additional cost of accurate calculation. In 2b (leasing of commercial vehicles) I messed up. Now I think that depreciation period may be different from operating lease period and asset should be depreciated regardless if leased or not. One expection will be if after lease period asset is intended to sale and in such a case should be presented at net realisable value and not depreciated. I 1c (NCI method) I assumed that NCI valuation may be changed retrospectively but now I am not sure. As somebody above mentioned perhaps goodwill should not be recalculated unless impaired.
Ttinatin8y ago#58
@beatab said: I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks the part B was a disaster. The two exchange rates Q -there was something similar in communism systems- government rate and 'black market currency rate'- maybe that's what they meant ;) The vehicles for lease- I thought about IAS2 but never mentioned it... The business models question-very weird and highly marked. Also part c in question 1 was hard and for 9 marks -something about accounting policies... Level 2 for the investing property. Didnt have time to come back to question about revenue. The gearing in Q3 was 30% before and 33% after...Forgot about depreciation though... Overall- very disappointed! Do you think they want people fail and let them sit the new P2 in September... And fail again then? This was my second attempt for P2, this time I have put in a lot hours into studying but I feel so disappointed and discouraged now. The exams don't really test your knowledge or ability to logical thinking anymore. They are just tricky, testing small details and putting people off... Maybe that is the aim...
In 1 Questions (c) - I think you should have written about IAS 8. I wrote that as the company was LISTED, IFRS for SME was not applicable, which states that NCI should me measured at proportionate share of net FV ONLY. This means that the company could have measurement ar fair value, however once you choose the accounting policy you cannot change it, unless IFRS requires so or it enhances fairness of FSs. As the company was listed and market was open for prices and valuing at reliable Fair Value, the company could have taken full measurement accounting policy, but the directors mentioned that they wanted this change it in order to maximize shareholders' wealth, which is not justified. It might mislead the users' of FSs. Moreover there might be some covenants under profitability ratios and directors want to manipulate with the figures which will address the ethical issues of ACCA Code of Ethics.
BBeata8y ago#59
3a (revenue) Real Property year end is the 28th of Feb 2018 whereas the sale took place on July 2017. The variable part of the revenue cannot be recognized for the whole year rather from Aug 17 till Feb 18 as you cannot recognize "future" revenue until it is earned. The advise which i gave to the directors is to account for the variable part of the revenue as of Feb 2018 and the remaining 5 months of revenue will be accounted for on a monthly basis as it is earned.
DDavid8y ago#60
to be honest the exam wasn't that bad, there was no cashflow statement, no financial instruments which are always difficult. It's not always about the numbers but the application on generally sticking them in the right place. I failed December because i didnt do enough revision which was my fault and if i fail this one then i'd have no one to blame but myself. Now on to P3 to try and pass that before the exams change in September and my P1 one gets cancelled and i have to do the Strategic Business Leader exam instead. Good luck everyone
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.