Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBR*** ACCA P2 March 2018 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin8y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA P2 March 2018 Exam

*** ACCA P2 March 2018 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** ACCA P2 March 2018 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about the ACCA P2 exam below (comments will open after 5pm UK)
Eeddie8y ago#1
what's your take on the exam guys? For me, I didn't finish as usual. section b was tough for me. if I pass, that will be a 50%.
SSarah8y ago#2
The questions in Section B were weird. Not the usual questions I practiced. Alot of it, I felt, was based around the topic of change in accounting policies and estimates? I don’t know. I found it really difficult.
FFrederick8y ago#3
There was a lot in the exam about IFRS 5. Several questions touched this subject. I am happy there was not too much about IFRS 9. Now just wait and see. I chose question 3 and 4.
Wwahidullah8y ago#4
Question 2 was very tough.
NNick8y ago#5
That was a pretty tough exam. I messed up the HFS part in question 1 as I couldn’t remember whether to consolidate or not so just showed net assets held for sale on SOFP. Hopefully that won’t lose me too many marks as feel the rest went okay.
Llisa8y ago#6
I feel bad about lease.
DDavid8y ago#7
Hi guys Couple of questions: 1. Was the subsidiary BU impaired? For me the CV of the subsidiary was lower than the recoverable amount? 2. What are the assets that ar not leased out recognised as? Should they be dpereciated? 3. Was it incorrect to take an average of the expected operating profit for the revenue question rather than the most porbable outcome? 4. What did you say about the exchange rate question? Should he use the bank or the goverbment rate? And is he allowed to use the average exchange rate for p/l. 5. Dis ur geaeing also only go up by 0.08% due to change of new lease policy?? Thanks
FFrederick8y ago#8
1. I had a lower recoverable amount compared to carrying amount, think it was about 80 M in impairment. You first have to do a fair value adjustment, then you apply ifrs 5 and compare fair value with fair value minus cost to sell. 2. dont rememeber this part 3. I took the weighted average 4. did not chose this question 5. Gearing went up more than that . think it went from 30 to 33 % or similar. Liabilities went up with 12 million
MMatt8y ago#9
Could someone please talk me through what needed to happen with the Held for sale in Q1? Also, the revenue from the retail park question - anyone remember what they put for that? The question regarding the exchange rates (government vs official rate) - I'm looking through a Kaplan textbook and googling the IAS 21 but still can't see what I'd write for this. Any ideas? Very tough exam I felt. I'd been smashing all the practice questions with not much of a problem and put in 140+ hours. More hours than for any other exam. I know I've failed sadly!! So gutted its untrue.
MMatt8y ago#10
Hey, Could you explain to me why the gearing actually went up please? Much appreciated.
NNawab8y ago#11
section B felt to be too dry compared to previous exam papers
DDavid8y ago#12
The 80m impairment was for the J one that was 100 percent owned But it mentioned the recoverable amount of the BU subsidiary that was owned 80 percent..was it impaired? Regarding the gearing: it said Net liabilities are blabla. So i dedudcted the right of of use asset from the net liability but added the liability for the lease payments...not sure
DDavid8y ago#13
Also it was from a subsidiary so all is translated using the closing rate anyways
Ttinatin8y ago#14
I have exactly the same questions and could not find anything about government rate! It is really unfair to get such questions.
FFrederick8y ago#15
Gearing can be calculated as Total Liabilities / Total Equity In the question we only got total equity and net debt.. Since the liabilities goes up with putting the lease on the balance sheet, this will increase the gearing
Aacca33368y ago#16
It’s a resit for me as I scored low in December. The examiner tested almost all standards . So the difficulty was that we should cover the whole syllabus. Part B I agree was too dry and somebody should study not only the basics of each standard but the small details e.g in q1b the sale of asset beyond 2018, the standard (ifrs5) permit sale above 12 months if circumstances arose that excuse it etc. I hope I have done enough to get at least 50 %
Uusman8y ago#17
have never seen a section B like this ever before...!!! 2 exchange rate in a same country where in the world do wee have this ..? section B was a disaster i wasnt able to calculate gearing for ifrs 16 i just wrote gearing would likely to increase
Aacca33368y ago#18
Genetics I got exactly the same numbers as you in both lease question and gearing ratio. I hope this is a good sign
Mmoozie8y ago#19
SOME WHAT I REMEMBER Q1) a) CSFP- Sub 80% (name Butter) impairment (net assets recoverable amount) FVA adjustment of Unrecognized Intangible at Acq'n second sub (name jam) was 100%, GW cal, then IFRS 5 HFS, which also impaired Pensions and SBP Joint ventures and Operations b) IFRS 5 HFS and regulator approval and buyer commitment for second sub jam c) recalculating NCI of all previous subs and economic vs substance form and ethics Q2) ADVICES Forex and associate, national bank rate or Government rate lease rental cars and no depreciation, only dep'n when it given to customers investment property and assets different measurements, business models Q3) IFRS 16 leases and complex calculations IFRS 13 FV level 1 advice IFRS 15 revenue and complex calculations Q4) Discuss Assets and liabilities and Uncertainty, with framework Provisions recognition, and uncertainty Materiality IFRS 5 and investment property
JJonathan8y ago#20
Venezuela. The question was based on that. Depending on what industry you operate, you choose which exchange rate to use.
Aacca33368y ago#21
I think the 2 exchange rates question was a little bit subjective the official rate was 1:15 and gov rate was 1:75. Huge difference therefore using gov rate would be beneficial but not right. The standard says closing rate (so assumed the official rate) . Thus, the answer is no not to use the gov rate. Ethical issues also arise. At least this is how i understood from the scenario. Whether right or wrong, the results will tell next month.
MMatt8y ago#22
Guys, the question with regards to the directors being unsure about how business models can effect measurement of assets. What where they referring to here? I went on to mention IFRS9 financial instruments and investments in debt. Is this complete nonsense? I just thought with the whole business model to just collect contractual cash flows etc
MMatt8y ago#23
@cfelicepace said: I feel the same way! Was putting an average of 4 hrs a day ever since January and had worked all questions since 2008 some twice or 3 times... gutted... horrible paper.
Yep ive never worked so hard for an exam and I'm just gutted. Don't think I can go on to the next without resitting this one as this just takes up so much time on top of work.
HHelen8y ago#24
Very hard exam. Hopefully enough to pass but probably not. Made a dogs dinner of question 1. The theory was good for me but not the business model one. I wrote about fv measurements since it mentioned measurement. How much was that part ? Do you think ACCA will credit marks for fv measurements in that question.
MMatt8y ago#25
I think that part was about 7/8 marks. To be honest I wrote about fair value measurements in two questions but I don't think they were looking for that in that question. I may be wrong though. I saw someone wrote on here about using level 2 inputs for the building, I put that as a level 2 is an observable input of a similar asset (not identical which is what level 1 would be). Did anyone else decide this? Also, anyone know what the answer to the revenue from contracts question was or the question where they wanted to revalue NCI using share prices?
Mmohammad8y ago#26
can any one please write what came in the section A and B. As I am planning to sit in June.
HHelen8y ago#27
I wrote level 2 also as it isnt identcial with the car park and tallest building. It should be hbu and level 2 as it is not quoted observable mkt price in identical active market. similiar. I wrote about fv measurement twice q2 c and q3. But in q3 it was about levels. ah god these exams are killers!!!
DDan8y ago#28
I think they were getting at amortised cost method for valuing financial assets, does it pass contractual cash flow or business model test. I said if they buy and sell financial assets they have to use fair value method. Then went onto investment property being valued at cost or fair value method. If the business deals in investment property it might want to use fair value etc.
Former userFormer user8y ago#29
@mathay2603 said: Hey, Could you explain to me why the gearing actually went up please? Much appreciated.
The gearing went up because of the Lease liability they had to record in the sofp. Liability = Debt therefore since debt went up nd equity stayed the same gearing went up.
MMatt8y ago#30
Thanks all!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.