Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBR*** ACCA P2 December 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin8y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA P2 December 2017 Exam

*** ACCA P2 December 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** ACCA P2 December 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about the ACCA P2 exam below (comments will open after 5pm UK)
PPaddy8y ago#31
Hi guys, I felt Q1 was ok but have realised I left out some key bits (probably to be expected from a consolidation question - just get the easy marks). I then did question 3 which was ok. I was not sure about some things so just make some assumptions which seemed logical. But question 2 was a disaster! I really did not know what to write. I ended up writing stuff about performance obligations which I am pretty sure is wrong but I had to write something! Overall I believe I have got a high 30s/low 40s mark. I gave it my best attempt so will take some time away from exams then start planning revision for the inevitable resit soon. What did you guys write for question 2?
HHamzaSupporter8y ago#32
@jsmp said: Hi guys, I felt Q1 was ok but have realised I left out some key bits (probably to be expected from a consolidation question - just get the easy marks). I then did question 3 which was ok. I was not sure about some things so just make some assumptions which seemed logical. But question 2 was a disaster! I really did not know what to write. I ended up writing stuff about performance obligations which I am pretty sure is wrong but I had to write something! Overall I believe I have got a high 30s/low 40s mark. I gave it my best attempt so will take some time away from exams then start planning revision for the inevitable resit soon. What did you guys write for question 2?
Q2 part b was easy rest was tough, I got JV In first part wrong. Last one was to recognize credit loss and liability. Q3 was
HHenry8y ago#33
Ive seen a few people saying the consolidation was easier than previous years. It definitely wasn’t For example, did you retranslate the PURP in inventory at the closing exchange rate? Did you add back the inventory to net assets at year end? Exactly, pipe down
BB8y ago#34
@voldemortsapprentice said: Ive seen a few people saying the consolidation was easier than previous years. It definitely wasn’t For example, did you retranslate the PURP in inventory at the closing exchange rate? Did you add back the inventory to net assets at year end? Exactly, pipe down
Q1a usually has a few very hard marks like the ones you mentioned. I think another one that will have caught a lot of people out is the Deferred Tax for the revalued portion should have gone to OCI against the reserve. Still kicking myself for not doing the exchange rate loss or gain, so stupid! Hopefully if I have to resit in March it will be a Statement of Financial Position. I feel a lot more comfortable with them and you get a lot of marks just for easy things like the Goodwill and NCI workings.
HHenry8y ago#35
No ones ever going to get 100% and shouldn’t try to. I got the basics right and that’s what matters. All due respect, deferred tax to OCI is a simple consol technique :) Mind you, it would be 3 marks at the max so who cares!!!
BB8y ago#36
@voldemortsapprentice said: No ones ever going to get 100% and shouldn’t try to. I got the basics right and that’s what matters. All due respect, deferred tax to OCI is a simple consol technique :) Mind you, it would be 3 marks at the max so who cares!!!
The change in DT for the year goes to the Tax for the year figure right? I imagine splitting out the revalued amount to OCI would have been worth 1 mark.
AAlison8y ago#37
People mentioning not calculating goodwill, you did need to as there was an impairment. Did anyone use partial goodwill for company L? As it mentioned measuring based on NCI of net assets. As it was a steo up acquisition, for the start of the reporting year. It said it started at 40%. That they then acquired a further 20% . Did anyone calculate this extra 20% as 20% of the remaining 60 and got 12 , there for company L owned 40%+12% which gave 52%?
BB8y ago#38
@alisonnln said: People mentioning not calculating goodwill, you did need to as there was an impairment. Did anyone use partial goodwill for company L? As it mentioned measuring based on NCI of net assets. As it was a steo up acquisition, for the start of the reporting year. It said it started at 40%. That they then acquired a further 20% . Did anyone calculate this extra 20% as 20% of the remaining 60 and got 12 , there for company L owned 40%+12% which gave 52%?
It was no control to control so I calculated the Goodwill in this way: FV of consideration for 20% Add FV of Existing 40% at current (When the 20% was bought) Add NCI Less Fair Value of the Net Assets
Jjasm8y ago#39
Tricky paper, expecting to fail. Better start preparing soon. :(
SSindy8y ago#40
Did any of you use the revenue and profit (over 10%) to say Tybull need to report seperately as an operating segmenton for Q1?
Former userFormer user8y ago#41
Yes, and both revenue and profit % exceeded 10% . How did you treat legal fees in Q.1? I adjusted it to p/l . Not sure that was right;)
IIain8y ago#42
I put IFRS 8 states that an entity should report an operating segment if it is how the chief operating decision makers (CODM) look at segments within the company. This would be discrete information used by management to allocate resources to that segment. So Tybull would only be an operating segment if it is segmented by management.
IIain8y ago#43
Also went on to explain the 10% of sales, profits and operating costs to disclose a segment and that you need to report 75% of turnover into segments.
SSindy8y ago#44
Thanks fore reply Tanza, glad to hear someone did that too. :) I am not sure about the legal fee. I think i put it in P&L but it should be only a mark? i hope!! haha..
Former userFormer user8y ago#45
Sure; But every mark counts;) Advise please how did you treat contract in part 2b? I put the principal (not agent). And regarding question 3 b about vessels i believe in the case of freight vessels with a remaining contract for 7 years it must be impaired to recoverable amount - value in use -PV of future cash flows, and in the case of leisure vessels - FV-CTS;)again not sure;)
CChris8y ago#46
Like an idiot - I also forget to do the whole year conversion of FX Gain/Loss as was considering it a SOFP item - idiot!!!! The rest of Q1 seemed ok though. I didn't split DT liability between P&L & OCI though. Think I misread part B of Q1 too. Didn't relate it back to the overseas sub - wrote general criteria and then stated could reclassify operating segments if more reliable and relevant information would result - also mentioned chief operating decision maker. Q1 - all adjustments seemed straight forward. I had a loss on remeasurement to OCI, quite a large deferred tax liability movement (i.e. difference between opening DTL and closing DTL calculated as Fair Value less Tax Base & difference between both years charged to P&L). Interco sales of 120/4 (av rate). PUP then circa $4m (translated) from memory? FX loss on Goodwill upon translation and impairment was at average rate. Can't remember many other adjustments in the question now! Borderline for me as Q2 & Q3 were, in the main, shocking! Q2 - not a joint venture (control was too one sided). The other part - 49.1% holding did constitute control though (first refusal of share sale of others), large presence on voting committee etc - i.e. ability to control, rights to variable returns etc etc. IFRS 9 questions - less said the better - if I got a couple of marks then I've done well! Q3 - nightmare. Operating lease and Finance Lease part seemed ok though. FL where "control" arose (in the 2nd scenario from memory). Also, as some leases were 6 months - 2 years, those below 12m could be treated as operating lease anyway. First example where lessor retained control I stated was an operating lease - they had substantial control (rights to direct where ships went, what cargo it held). I also treated as principal and not agent - inventory obsolescence risk, control over establishing prices etc. Impairment indicators - internal and external. External indicators present and therefore impairment likely to arise etc. Can't remember much more the questions to be honest - all a bit of a blur!!
SSag8y ago#47
For q1 b, has anyone mentionned the geographical aspect?? The paper looked ok but by reading all your comments there are so many little bits i think i missed...
PPhilippos8y ago#48
i found deferred tax 19.2 for OCI and 6 (credit) for P+L. Does anyone find the same??
SSindy8y ago#49
Tanza Its a bit blur for my section b.. is Q2b the loan question? that sold part of the loan to someone else which ownership of reward and risk are transferred???? Q3B, is that the one with impairment?? I think i wrote something about indicators – internal and external as well. >.< I really hope I will pass... Sagp2, I did briefly.
SSindy8y ago#50
Phil1990, >.< i dont rmb but I think i got something different.
Former userFormer user8y ago#51
Regarding Q. 3b me too i wrote about about external indicators of impairment - depressed prices and etc., and internal also. Hope this what examiner wants to see. Q. 2c was a loan question, but i am not sure about the right treatment,i wrote that as the company accepted the expected loss of 300 000, most probably 7 mln should be treated as a liability (risks not transferred)
Former userFormer user8y ago#52
Chris Question 3c about leases i wrote the same - 1st operational lease and 2nd right to use asset (in the case duration of the contract exceeds 12 months, not to be an exception)
IIain8y ago#53
I said the first contract didn’t contain a lease at all but unsure now. Thought the second one was an operating lease because there wasn’t an option to buy the asset (at a reduced price) and the lease term wasn’t an extensive amount of the useful life. Only a few years from memory.
PPhilippos8y ago#54
guys was it agent or principal? the standard says that the main characteristic is the control prior transfer to customer, so i choose agent...
CChris8y ago#55
Indicators of principal are rights to set price (which they had), risk of inventory obsolence (which wasn't there but arguably the arrangement was with the customer directly - the supplier was just delivering and therefore inventory obsolence would rest with them if returned). Also, I think there might have been some additional risk to manufacturer as the end customer had recourse against them. Additionally, there weren't just earning commission. The supplier just acted as a conduit for delivery - everything else was their responsibility so I said principal (in substance).
IIain8y ago#56
Don’t have a clue about that. That question was my weakest by a country mile. I left it until the end. Punted for principal on basis that they were liable for defects. If I get 1 mark I’d be happy.
CChris8y ago#57
About the same performance on mine on Financial Instruments!
CChan8y ago#58
When i read all of you comments, i realize that i wrote too little time..i only have 1 hour to finish Q2 and Q3. Spent too much time on Q1.. i was shocked when i saw SOPL+ OCI Question.. Is Q2c debt factoring? Q2b the contract with customer how come can write 7 marks..i only wrote reporting entity invoice customer, means have right to collect economic benefit. Reporting entity also responsible for risk of product so the entity have to bear risk...too little points Q2a not a joint venture, i think. Don't have unanimous consent in the decision making and also reporting entity acquired bond of Font, investment in debt, don't have shareholding on Font...is it correct?
SSag8y ago#59
Guys was Shipshap the lessee or the lessor?? Your posts are confusing me...
SSag8y ago#60
Yes I agree 100% plus the product was a specialised one which was designed by them.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.