SBR*** ACCA P2 December 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Is the translations of tybull results in a loss?
This exam was a nightmare for me. I don’t want to see the results. Will start preps for March sooner!
Was it fx? Andwas it p and l or bad sheet. ?
was the exchange rate to be used of year end ?
Exchange rate for P&L is the average during the year
Ihad a loss as well but i think i forgot to translate the impairment loss :( it was in dinars
I thought it was really hard. Also ended up with uk varient instead of international. Oops
Found Q1 OK but 2 was a disaster... hardly completed it. Q3 was better.
Don’t think I’ve done enough to pass but let’s see.
The first question was step acqusition, 40% and then 20%, with initial 40% fair value increase, and fortunately the foreign subsidiary was 100% subsidiary and full year profit, requiring less calculations. Compared to past question was less tough, mainly because there was no need to make consolidated SOFP also, only P&L and OCI. Adjustments were straight forward including the pension, revaluation, purp etc.
The second part was testing IFRS 8 rules - mostly theory and not application. Thank god LSBF Mock and Becker Mock had same type of questions.
Second and third questions were mixed bag testing IAS 16 - ship with different parts with different life, entity giving a loan and then selling it to another testing IFRS 9 with expected credit loss, IFRS 13 impairment testing rules for a company with leisure and cargo ships and slowing economy etc. The question on IFRS 11 Joint Venture/Joint arrangement was highly confusing and same was the case of IFRS 16 Lease requirement for a company hiring ships on two different methods, one based on payment based on cargo weight and other hired for 6 months to 2 years.
Overall paper as compared to past questions were not tough.
Jesus from FairPlay to you!! How did you prepare for this exam? Questions and exam papers ?
The paper was highly tricky! There were so many chances to put candidates in confusion. Some of the questions were drafted in very tricky structure. This was my 3rd attempt. Done as much as I could to get 50.
Let see......how it will be marked. Wish u all the best.
1. SOPL-OCI with foreign subs, deferred tax, Asso-Subs, pension, revaluation of ppe.
B. IFRS 8-operating segment
C. Ethics-Intragroup transaction and sale of holding equity interest.
2. Segregation n recognition of Joint venture n arrangement.
B. IFRS 9-financial asset, expected credit loss allowance
others: IAS 16, Cash generating unit, etc.
Tricky paper. NCI for 100% sub was 0? I believe? How did people do goodwill? I think i got like 7.25 for one and 22 or something for the other.
The PUP in dollars was 9.
Intra sale 30
No idea how to do the carrying amount and taxbase? Anyone.
I think i messed up a bit. Hope to pass.
All in all I thought it was ok
In saying that I can’t remember anything about 1b and I see people mentioned operating segments above and I’m now wondering if i missed part of this off - what was the question?
I can't remember anything about segments too. I am not sure if I miss this part, as long as I remember the questions was differences bt SME and Frs102. It might be additional to segments. But not sure
Did anyone use related parties disclosure on Q1?
I’m wondering if maybe Operating Segments was on the international paper and SMEs on the UK paper?
Mentioned related parties in the intercompany ethics part c of q1. I stated that related party transactions had to be disclosed in the single entity accounts and therefore even though the revenues are inflated it could be derived from the notes the amount of trading woth tbr parent but this still wouldnt highlight the mark up. Integrity of the parent in question as it was obvious sales were being manipulated to attract the highest possible price for the sub.
The rest of the paper didnt go so well!!
the exam was hard, managed to do the paper but living only 7 points behind...
the markers are very strict? thanks
Thanks for the reply. :)
Looking back now Q1 wasnt that difficult no mid year acq no NCI in foreign sub but the pressure of the situation takes hold sometimes and interpreting the question becomes half the battle. I worked out i got 43 but who knows....it could be 33 or 53 i think the marking is fair so im not holding my hopes uo too high.
I didn't know how to calculate the FX gain or lose in Q1. I translated Tybull's SOPL using average rate and then the impairment and depreciation and pup also using AVG rate- I'm sure it's not correct. How should it be done?
I found the exam all right but missed up on a simple things.
Not adding the 'profit the year in' when calculating net assets translation
Mistaking a cash based scheme as equity
How stupid of me!!!
I ended up getting zero for TCI for the year so sounds good that some got a loss or close to that!
Only small marks so not point in getting myself down!!
It was always gonna be a hard exam and that's why P2 is known for being the hardest exam. Well done on everyone even getting to the P2 stage
LIT LIT LIT
Yes indeed too many small and silly mistakes, but in aggregate it might be material lol
Part B was also hard. Too much blah blah is hard for p2 . I did q 3 and 4 as I found question 2 scary.
I don’t expect a pass therefore I am not anxious about the results. I didn’t practice a lot due to other commitments and limited time.
These exams are so under time pressure. It took me too long to finish Q1 and then started panicing a bit. That's why in the second part of the exam I gave too short and too vague answers, did not finish Q4 but calculated the cash share based payment as 1/3*(250-115) *46 (share price in 2019) .... I think...
Please can someone tell that did Tybull sub qualified as an Operating Segment or not?
Was it a DF tax asset or liability?
What did u guys write in ifrs8?
guys does anyone remember the amounts in q1 regarding revaluation?
tax base, fv and ca for both years??
Hey guys, i'm feeling so low, i really dont want to retake.
I thought Q1 was okish apart from part C, D. I had FX exchange loss for both Net Assets and G/will.
SEction B is load of shi*** what sort of crap are they playing at...confusing
Ehhhh I feel as though it was an okay paper but I just panicked. I literally did Ashanti past paper question yesterday which was very similar for Q1a but I forgot to do the Exchange Rate gains/losses as I got it into my head that that was a balance sheet item. I also completely forgot how to do Pensions so I just charged the service costs to PnL and got a re measurement loss. The rest of Q1a went okay I guess.
Q1b was some IFRS SME vs UK question which I didn't know, probably wrote a few sentences for it and Q1c I feel as though I got a hand full of marks.
I chose to do Q2 and Q4 as Q3 looked okay for about 15 marks of it but there was an 8 marker again on IFRS SME vs UK which I didn't know at all.
From what I remember Q2 and Q4 included IFRS 9 (a lot) where a question had you identify 2 different types of preference shares. I said the first one was a liability and the 2nd was equity with reasons of course. There was some kind of Cash settled Share Based Payment calculation and they were showing it incorrectly as equity. And something about a Joint Venture where one company had a lot more control but I said it's still a Joint Venture because it doesn't matter about the control split.Oh and something about a company having 49% stake in another company and accounting for it as an associate but it had first choice of share options, had 4 out of the 6 board seats and the other shareholdings were spread so they should have been accounting for it as a subsidiary.
I'm really not sure what to expect. Maybe 25 for Q1 and anywhere from 15 to 30 on Q2 and Q4 combined. So anywhere between 40 and 55 I guess.
At least if I have to resit in March I can book the International paper and not have to worry about the difference between UK FRS and IFRS but it sounds like you guys got some difficult Operating Segments question instead.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

