General ACCA*** ACCA P1 December 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
I want to express my sincere regards and gratitude to Mr.Mike Little. Honestly, I had so many personal committments and I had just focused on Opentuition material and Mike's lectures. I did really well in P1 paper yesterday and it was only because of Opentuition. Thankyou so much!
Hi All
In section B question 3, regarding the question to compare their internal controls to a suitable framework, I compared it to Turnbull's system not COSO as many people may have, is this still correct?
Hi I compared it to Turnbull's sound sysem on internal controls not COSO, would this have been correct also?
Q1. What is the brief of Nomination Comitee, how's the breif can be extended to benefit the company
My understanding asking about roles of the Nomination Comitee and how can it be improved
1)I wrote about enlarging Board diversity by bringing in talent from different gender, skills and background to promote constructive ideas
2)ensure balance of skills among key players
3)succession planning like training & standardisation of process to ensure valuable skills are not missing when they leave the company
What is accountability corporate governance in decide remuneration of executive ?
My understanding of this question is how the remuneration committee can balance Corperate Governance Vs ED remuneration
1) I wrote of include performance related payment to motivate the executive
2) I wrote of the benefits should be stretch/deffered benefits to ensure long term success of the company
components of well-designed package and their benefits to OG
What I understand of component are those bonus, share options pension. I introduce those components and wrote how these components should be set
Example bonus must based on performance. This is to ensure the key players are not rewards if they are not performing
Should O&G diversity
I think this is an open ended questions, it is testing the students critical thinking.
My answer is no
1) it would be riskier if they are venturing in industry that they don't have knowledge in
2) if the new venture is capital intensive, shareholders may patients enough to wait the rewards to reap. Thus this may result the share price drop
Since OPEC has indicated oil prices will be steady at $55-60 the company should not waste the resources in new venture. Perhaps expansion into upstream activity like petrochemical and fabrication which is less dependent on volatility of share price
OK, so it sounds like ACCA might have been a little careless in Q1 re the use of the word "brief". I have not yet seen the paper (and of course Q1 may never be released), but from the comments on here it seems that the nomination committee was told to find NEDs and told where to find them (and where not to find them, therefore). This instruction is a "brief". If I am right, then ACCA, with its international student base, would surely have been wiser in choosing words used more frequently, such as saying "widening the criteria" or something similar.
Of course, I have not seen the question and maybe there is enough in the story that should have made things clear. We will see...
Regarding queries on accountability, this is probably the most examined of the 11 corporate governance principles. I am surprised by the number of people raising it. If you do something or make a decision that impacts others, you should be willing to judged on that decision. If NEDs are setting executive pay, then they should be judged by the shareholders, and if the criteria they use are fair and reasonable, comply with law and ethics, and the NEDs themselves are good quality (experience and independence for example), then shareholders should feel assured. Therefore they will need to report on how pay has been set (and be open to questioning by shareholders), so that they have accounted for their decisions, and so shareholders can read and judge.
Risk questions often annoy me. There are an infinite number of types of risk, the syllabus only mentions a sample, and then the examiners test another one...on the other hand, let's be sensible:
- we all know what an entrepreneur is, right? No excuses if you don't, given you are training to be an accountant.
- well then entrepreneurial risk is that if you stake your own money, and work 24/7, on doing something new that then fails, you are broke. On the other hand, if you do not take any risk at all, you will not get anywhere.
I am not aware of there being an "official" definition so if you have taken a punt and said something sensible, you will be ok.
Oh, and it has been examined before by the way. June 2009. So I guess that makes it fair enough.
Guys, I think it is clear from the Sept results that ACCA is keen to get as many through both P1 and P3 as possible for the next few sittings. I reckon marking will be flexible, and as long as you are on the right track you will get given credit.
In short, if you deserve it then you will be safe.
Q2 and q3 for december is online now. Just cross finger that can clear but i doubt so.
Online where?
They are in the Sep / Dec 17 sample questions on the ACCA website.
https://www.accaglobal.com/uk/en/student/exam-support-resources/professional-exams-study-resources/p1/past-exam-papers/p1-global-glo-past-exam-papers.html
it was asiking IC framework... what that even is? I think examiner was tricking us, hence i have not attempted this question even though I was well prepared on IC (so I thought until I saw the question)
so what did you think of IC framework? I was not sure what was it hence I chose q4 instead which i did not like so much.
I think it was asking you to explain the elements of internal control. If you use COSO there are 5 (remember with mnemonic CRIME):
Control activities
Risk assessment
Information & communication
Monitoring
Environment (control environment)
So you needed to give a description of each of these and then say why it was important to Skydda.
You could have used other frameworks but COSO worked well. The bit I struggled with was relating it effectively to the case as there was not much specific information on the company's control system other than it was highly effective.
Interesting when looking at the Sep/Dec 2017 sample paper, Sep Q1 has quite a bit of stuff that then came again in December's paper.
And the repetition mentioned above re Dec Q1 seems evident in Sep Q1 as well to an extent.
If they have pass rate concerns, why not test a wider variety of content and just ensure the wording is very very clear?
But I have to congratulate them on one thing from Sep Q1.
Who would have thought that in training to be an accountant you would get to answer a question on why footie fans want an independent referee!!!
Class.
when did sample question appear on acca web? i looked few days back and i don't think it was there. q 1 similar in a way an q2 and3 same as in dec exam.
as to q2c its asking for threats to independence so not same as ethical threats right? i was tempted to talk self review intimidation but i dont think it was what was asked
@agnieszkamann said: when did sample question appear on acca web? i looked few days back and i don't think it was there. q 1 similar in a way an q2 and3 same as in dec exam. as to q2c its asking for threats to independence so not same as ethical threats right? i was tempted to talk self review intimidation but i dont think it was what was askedI also did same used intimidation and these but seems wrong as no link to senario!
Hello Everyone,
The question paper of p1 was easy according to me. Wasnt really confused in wordings.
I tried to discuss all the questions. One point I kept in mind was verbs do matter but the weightage would be to make understand the marker tat we have understood the question and discussed many points to proove that.
I answered all parts of all questions. But did ran out of time so had to fit few parts into watever time was left.
Overall it was a good paper as I knew the areas tat were asked in the paper.
All the very best to all of you.
My first p paper and I thought it was fairly easy. Much prefer that you have the option of 2 out of 3 questions on the p papers!
I sat the resit for f9 two days later and found that so much tougher!
Hi Chris can you go into more details on your time management technique please
@cr333 said: I thought it wasn't too bad. There weren't any questions that I didn't know how to answer. I chose 2 & 3 as my optionals - for 3 I did struggle a bit to relate my answer to the case so I may have dropped some marks there. I used Mike's tips for time management (plan your answers for 0.5 minutes per mark and then 1.3 minutes per mark to write) and these worked really well. Thanks Mike! I spent 45 minutes reading and planning and the rest of the time writing, keeping an eye on the time and being careful not exceeding it for any question part. I had finished every part of every question with a decent answer put down with 8 minutes to spare. I did rush the entrepreneurial risk part a bit and my definition was quite woolly but overall I'm satisfied. This was the first written paper I've done after doing all the F papers as CBE. As long as the marker can read my handwriting I'm confident I passed...Can you share further details on your time management technique please
Joy - I can't take credit for the technique, it was Mike Little who came up with it. A more detailed explanation is in this topic: https://opentuition.com/topic/final-revision-7/
ok
I have a straightforward question for all P1 takers, I took P3 in december and hopefully I would pass and plan to take P1 in march...should I expect some benefit by taking P3 just before P1 and limit my study effort ?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

