Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

General ACCA*** ACCA P1 December 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin8y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA P1 December 2017 Exam

*** ACCA P1 December 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** ACCA P1 December 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about the ACCA P1 exam below (comments will open after 5pm UK)
CChris8y ago#1
Thought it was ok - first question was really nice. Wasn't too sure on Entrepreneurial risk but guessed it. Somehow managed to run out of time, normally pretty good with time management so struggled to get everything down on time for question four - managed to bullet point main points though. fingers crossed and good luck everyone!
LLesbella8y ago#2
Do you all think that some of the question examiner are testing are not specific ? Look like trying to play mind game with us.
LLesbella8y ago#3
@spagnolm said: September paper was classified as relatively more straightforward paper than usual. A testament to this was the pass rate of 53% which by many standards was above normal. Hence, we were expecting a tougher paper for December.
I agree with you
Llavinia698y ago#4
Did not enjoy this paper at all. Not a disaster, but I do doubt I will have passed
NNoshma8y ago#5
I wouldn't say it was too difficult for a section A question. I preferred this to having a 50 marks question on risk. However, I ran completely out of time & only had time to manage getting some stuffs written for Question 4. Section B.... well... I didn't truly enjoy this one bit. Blaaah questions. I seriously hope I've managed to get 50% at least & get done with P1. Oh well, can't do much anyway, it's over now... Good luck everyone. :-) And those who have more papers left as well. :-)
Jjasealy8y ago#6
Soo. I kinda hated this exam. With the exception of q2 the questions seemed super dry and boring. I thought the 50 marker tended to blend in multiple areas of the syllabus but it felt like the examiner was just like: "BOARD COMMITTEES" and that was it. Also, did anyone else feel like their answer in Q1 part d was just repeating parts b & c? That terrified me. I mean part b was benefits on improving the remuneration package and part c was benefits of extending the nominations committee's criteria...then part of d asked us to tell shareholders how we were fixing the pay/performance correlation and how looking outside the industry for NEDs would help....how was that different from the benefits of the 2 previous parts? T_T And of course time ran out..I just hope I do ok.
JJennyfer8y ago#7
Attempted 65-70%....preparing for a resit mar18?
NNoshma8y ago#8
Yup.. I also found my points being repetitive... crossed check the question again but nope... the question was basically turning around the remuneration package itself.... And attracting those from not only specifically in the industry of O&G...
Former userFormer user8y ago#9
I am not sure about question 3a. Does it want COSO framework???
Nnick938y ago#10
Thats what i used to answer that question coso framework dont know if its right tho
Nnick938y ago#11
Yea i had that same probelm too
Ggaby128y ago#12
Yes Question 3 was COSO framework, but I found so hard to apply this to the case study as it did not have enough details and information. Not sure I will score well but hey ho I have tried my best
Ggaby128y ago#13
Question 1 entrepreneurial risk - I said is relating entering or extending the business on new markets as it was in the case study the O&G was trying to do mergers , aquisitons and venture capitalist investments. Not sure I have done this well but again I felt so pressured to write everything I thought is right
JJouma8y ago#14
Guys, I must be silly by asking this question but what did the examiner mean by briefing the key player did he refer to recruitment or induction. I just could not figure it out, and just made best guess how the company should recruit ie use open advertisement etc. Can someone advise on what the examiner meant by briefing? I think the paper was not that hard but the wordings were extremely tricky.
JJouma8y ago#15
.
JJouma8y ago#16
.
JJouma8y ago#17
@hill5538 said: Thought it was ok - first question was really nice. Wasn't too sure on Entrepreneurial risk but guessed it. Somehow managed to run out of time, normally pretty good with time management so struggled to get everything down on time for question four - managed to bullet point main points though. fingers crossed and good luck everyone!
Chris, could you please advise what the examiner meant by briefing the key players in question one?
JJouma8y ago#18
@jennyferz said: Attempted 65-70%....preparing for a resit mar18?
count me in :) time pressure and poor exam techniques. do you by any chance know what the examiner meant by the briefing word in question one?
LLukman8y ago#19
I was confused as to what the examiner meant by briefing. However, having read the question again I was able to pick up that he used the word “briefing” when talking about the nomination committee. It was something along the lines of only recruiting the best candidates from quotated companies. The question basically asked you to say why this method was not reliable and also suggest what could be done instead. I hope this helps
LLukman8y ago#20
Quoted *
LLukman8y ago#21
I answered questions 2 & 4 simply because I felt it would be difficult to apply the COSO framework to the case in Question 3. Overall a decent paper with a lot of repetition. The only problem I faced was with defining entrepreneurial risk. Having read through the thread I’m so glad that I was able to guess it correctly. Please let me know your thoughts on question 4 part C where we had to talk about the teleological stance with regards to the board ?
JJouma8y ago#22
@lukman94 said: I was confused as to what the examiner meant by briefing. However, having read the question again I was able to pick up that he used the word “briefing” when talking about the nomination committee. It was something along the lines of only recruiting the best candidates from quotated companies. The question basically asked you to say why this method was not reliable and also suggest what could be done instead. I hope this helps
Thank you very much for your reply, as this can give me some relief and would be able to sleep today, and that what exactly I understood too, and instead recruiting from the same industry, they should follow formal and regulate recruitment processes such as the use of consultant help and open advertisement etc. I hope I am correct as this has puzzled me in the exam and hopefully will turn a marginal fail into a marginal pass.
CChris8y ago#23
I thought it wasn't too bad. There weren't any questions that I didn't know how to answer. I chose 2 & 3 as my optionals - for 3 I did struggle a bit to relate my answer to the case so I may have dropped some marks there. I used Mike's tips for time management (plan your answers for 0.5 minutes per mark and then 1.3 minutes per mark to write) and these worked really well. Thanks Mike! I spent 45 minutes reading and planning and the rest of the time writing, keeping an eye on the time and being careful not exceeding it for any question part. I had finished every part of every question with a decent answer put down with 8 minutes to spare. I did rush the entrepreneurial risk part a bit and my definition was quite woolly but overall I'm satisfied. This was the first written paper I've done after doing all the F papers as CBE. As long as the marker can read my handwriting I'm confident I passed...
ZZainb8y ago#24
I really see concentrating and lack of diversity areas! Iam happy to know tgat iam not the only one who feels my answers were repetitive!! I wasted my time studying main areas environments , social footprint, main concepts transparancy and others nothing of theses big areas came!! I'm not happy w my performance. Wish to pass..
Nnaoying8y ago#25
I was struggle in Q1 A part What is accountability corporate governance in decide remuneration of executive ? What does it mean? Is it answer things like transparency, fairness, accountability?
Aaboluwarin8y ago#26
I almost attempted no 3 till I saw the framework aspect
JJouma8y ago#27
it is just crazy paper, I did so many shortcuts to be able to finish on time and I barely did with only 2 min to spare, I feel so bad about my self as I know everything but couldn't put it in the paper properly, just keeping positive.
ZZaur8y ago#28
Very general topics. No specific knowledge required. All preparation time wasted :) As it was very general I dont know to what they will give points. ALso new words like, Briefing, entrepreneural risk which never met before. B section question 2 was taken from F8 :) Did not get what was the purpose of questions, May be they tried to make it easy due to combination of p1 and p3 ?
Hhafsa8y ago#29
For the part of a of q1 i ended up writing how NED's should scrutinize a directors performance to make sure he was beung payed appeopeiately so shareholders get VFM. how they must make sure a director was being paid enough to attract retain and motivate them. Something they were struggling with. part b was a lot easier I guess with having to write about the components of a reward package, basic salary, pension, performance related bonus,shares and share options and benefits in kind. All of these would help them reduce the high turnover, lead to thhe implementation of strategies, overcone shareholder concerns of an unstable board. For part c I wrote that the targeted individuals should not be from such a small group. They should broaden their search and look for indivuals with skills that their current board lacks. Who should have an idea about divetsification, previous experience with mergers. lastly, the current NEDS were easily ignored and the directors who all were from the same background grouped up against them. so they shouldve bought in more key players with skills from outside that small group to reduce this problem. Because this was increasing the agency problem at OG. for part d, i am pretty sure i lost the professional marks. di) was a repition of how we would benefit from our key players staying. to make they stay we should give them the incentive of higher pay for performance. Had to rewrite most points but with different aspect for the scenario. dii) Was risks we were exposed to because of such an unstable work environment. I said we were exposed to the risk of strategies failing, having a bad example set for the rest of the co, discouraging employes at a lower level. Cultural risk in the sense that the new key players would require time abd understanding to understabd the culture of the entity. i twisted the scenario and said if we did not overcome this we may face financial risk ie risk losing our going concern assumption. diii) Asked if diversifying was a way to overcome entrepreneurial risk. i disagreed. as diversifying was a means to reduce the risks we faced in a single sector , so we entered new sectors, undertook new ventures . The very meaning of the risk. i guessed that from the word entrepreneur. So where it was better for the company to diversify given the low proce of oil however it was not a solution to overcome entrepreneurial risk. question 4 was a blur. a) Shouldve written how a board should manage limit uncertainity. instead wrote how jalka board failed to innovate, strategies, carefull aloocate its resources. Kind of mixed CG and risk. b) Wrote the risks it faced like strategical, financial, technological, the riskof failing to grow with timr and adapt to new environment. And i cant remember what i wrote more. c) it asked what teleological approach was and whether the board had breached it. and how? It had breached the ethical code as the consequence was bad. It ended in solvenxy with the loss to community. and explained this. Poorly for sure. q2) A nd b were easy. I had to rush in this question. c) i wrote safeguards, like segregation of duties(couldnt explain this one) having an internal control system, an audit committee, chinese wall ,rotation of firm not partner as the ceo was friends with the managing partner and if they cant reduce risk to just back off and end engagement. i studied p1 for a very short time.So i dont know if i performed well or wrote well enough to pass. I applied a strategy similar to what i used for p7. I just hope it works and i pass.these are my answers. It bothered me. I hope somebody can shed light on my answers. Praying for the best!!!
113318y ago#30
My first coloured paper. Guess what topic I planned to study but didn't study? Guess what topic was Question 1 and worth 50 marks? To say that I was shocked and regretful when I opened my question paper is to say the very least.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.