Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** ACCA F9 September 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin9y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA F9 September 2017 Exam

*** ACCA F9 September 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about the ACCA F9 exam below (comments will open after 5pm UK)
LLina9y ago#91
In Q31 the calculated dividend used in the cost of equity calculation will be considered D1 or D0 ?!
AABC9y ago#92
@heychi said: Hi, To calculate that you needed to find the dividend growth first before using the dividend growth model. Think there were 4 payments according to the table. So Dividend growth = cubed root of (the last dividend/first dividend). Think that gave me 1.04..so 4% growth. Then you times 1.04 with the ex.div amount/market value + 4%. This gave me 11% if i remember correctly..
OK....I took 2006 div as latest and 2003 as ref div and then calculated the growth? Then I calculated the Ke by putting the value of 2006 div and then multiplied it with 1+g/MV+g...was it right?
AABC9y ago#93
@heychi said: Hi, To calculate that you needed to find the dividend growth first before using the dividend growth model. Think there were 4 payments according to the table. So Dividend growth = cubed root of (the last dividend/first dividend). Think that gave me 1.04..so 4% growth. Then you times 1.04 with the ex.div amount/market value + 4%. This gave me 11% if i remember correctly..
what was your WACC? I got 11 point something.
DDennis9y ago#94
None of the working capital questions came for me. Not even as MCQs, anyway all MCQs were tricky. Long form questions, I got NPV, wacc as calculation. Then more writing in terms of questions like, difference between NPV and IRR, benefit of convertible loan note. For NPV I got something like 2.5 million with initial investment was 5 million. Tricky part was wc required at the end of each year as 5% of sales. Sensitivity was ok with only 3 marks. Variable bank was a problem, no idea how to consider that. Sure shot mcq were, shares sold in secondary market, LC issuance process, repurchase interest rate, market price of loan notes etc.
LLiberty9y ago#95
hi guys. the figures I got for npv and wacc are very much different from yours. NPV 20K WACC 12% All the same I passed
DDavid9y ago#96
MCQ 1-got A. MCQ with exchange rate forecast got option $/EUR1.2654. MCQ with 2 statements, selected none of them right. Question about factoring debt got 90k reduction of profit (A?). Q31. I excluded bank loan from calculation of wacc and added a note that can be ignored as the balance of bank loan represented only 1.6% of capital, impact should not be significant. I think alternatively can make assumption and use Kd for similar type of finance. Just because question stated variable %, did not want to make that assumption. In calculating div growth used (cum div-ex div), not 20X6 (not sure), growth was 5%. Got wacc 11 and smth %. Kd for loan notes was 5 and smth % through IRR. Q32. NPV was 10-11m. Inflated sales and var costs accordingly and used after tax nominal DF@12%. Payback ~2yrs 9m.
AABC9y ago#97
@gdjames said: There was on MCQ with answers of 11.2% and 11.3% and I went for 11.2 after about 5 minutes of checking the roundings! That was a cruel question for 2 marks.
I went for 11.3 because my answer was 11.29million so i chose 11.3.
AABC9y ago#98
@davea said: MCQ 1-got A. MCQ with exchange rate forecast got option $/EUR1.2654. MCQ with 2 statements, selected none of them right. Question about factoring debt got 90k reduction of profit (A?). Q31. I excluded bank loan from calculation of wacc and added a note that can be ignored as the balance of bank loan represented only 1.6% of capital, impact should not be significant. I think alternatively can make assumption and use Kd for similar type of finance. Just because question stated variable %, did not want to make that assumption. In calculating div growth used (cum div-ex div), not 20X6 (not sure), growth was 5%. Got wacc 11 and smth %. Kd for loan notes was 5 and smth % through IRR. Q32. NPV was 10-11m. Inflated sales and var costs accordingly and used after tax nominal DF@12%. Payback ~2yrs 9m.
I think terminal value was 5% of the initial investment if I remember correctly... So we should take 5% of 25mn at the end of 4th year
HHarsh9y ago#99
yes i got the same answer too..... decrease by 90,000
LLeah9y ago#100
Reading these comments making me feel uneasy. I just got so confused doing the NPV question and wrote lots of workings and hope to pick something up somewhere. MCQ's, guessed quite a few but a few nice ones in there. I completely flopped the WACC, I couldn't think! Not looking forward to results now :(
DDavid9y ago#101
@syeduzairnaqvi said: I think terminal value was 5% of the initial investment if I remember correctly... So we should take 5% of 25mn at the end of 4th year
Yes, I did the same.
DDEMETRIOS9y ago#102
I deducted also dividend for year 20x7.i found g=4.if u know the new dividend then it is definitely relevant with g.However this is only my opinion.I also choose aggressive for financing and in mch with irredemable I choose statement 1 is correct.In my personal opinion irredemable shares can be consider as share capital.Any opinions????? I might be totally wrong ?
AAbdiaziz9y ago#103
What were the circumstances under Wacc can be used to evaluate the project??
AAbrar9y ago#104
1) when project has same capital structure 2) project is a small scale extention of the existing company. So that WACC doesn't get affected significantly. 3) project should have the same business risk.
AAbdiaziz9y ago#105
Thank you so much. I gave the same answers.
LLucy9y ago#106
@demetrios21780 said: I deducted also dividend for year 20x7.i found g=4.if u know the new dividend then it is definitely relevant with g.However this is only my opinion.I also choose aggressive for financing and in mch with irredemable I choose statement 1 is correct.In my personal opinion irredemable shares can be consider as share capital.Any opinions????? I might be totally wrong ?
I deducted as well and got the same growth of 1.04 with the formula..so yes, g= 4. I also chose Aggressive for financing but i'm not sure too! I can't remember what I chose for the irredeemable question but I think I went for only statement 1 is correct as well. I just googled it and got the general sense it is equity. Fount this also on Kaplan's knowledge base: "Redeemable preference shares are preference shares which are repayable by the company at a specified future date. On this date the shares are cancelled and the shareholders repaid. These shares have the characteristics of debt. They are therefore classified as a liability on the statement of financial position." "Irredeemable preference shares are preference shares which are not redeemable. They remain in existence indefinitely. These shares are classified as equity on the statement of financial position." Hopefully we are correct.
DDavid9y ago#107
@heychi said: I deducted as well and got the same growth of 1.04 with the formula..so yes, g= 4. I also chose Aggressive for financing but i'm not sure too! I can't remember what I chose for the irredeemable question but I think I went for only statement 1 is correct as well. I just googled it and got the general sense it is equity. Fount this also on Kaplan's knowledge base: "Redeemable preference shares are preference shares which are repayable by the company at a specified future date. On this date the shares are cancelled and the shareholders repaid. These shares have the characteristics of debt. They are therefore classified as a liability on the statement of financial position." "Irredeemable preference shares are preference shares which are not redeemable. They remain in existence indefinitely. These shares are classified as equity on the statement of financial position." Hopefully we are correct.
Growth of divi is was 5% as 20X7 to 20X3 as i remember (0.45/0.37)^1/4 - 1=.0.05 It seems that you used power of 1/5 instead of 1/4. Check.
LLucy9y ago#108
@davea said: Growth of divi is was 5% as 20X7 to 20X3 as i remember (0.45/0.37)^1/4 - 1=.0.05 It seems that you used power of 1/5 instead of 1/4. Check.
Hey, I did cubed root of: Last dividend/Dividend at the start according to the table to get the growth.
LLucy9y ago#109
@demetrios21780 said: My friend Heychi.....https://smallbusiness.chron.com/aggressive-vs-conservative-working-capital-65216.html.This shows that for conservative current assets ratio must be around 2.the current assets were nearly the same with current liabilities and fixed assets were the same as the amount for long term liabilities.Irredemable shares are treated as equity. also i remembered this morning a mch about soft capital rationing...i choose the directors they dindt want to issue shares because they dint want mv of shares and dividend to fall down. there was a question about ordinary share capital.I found 312.m.any other multible choice i cant remember.......
I hope you are right as we have similar answers! For the ordinary share according to market values i got 396 or 369..something like that but I honestly can't remember if this is even the same question. I wish I wrote down all my choices but the invigilator took my paper so quickly. In limbo for for now but trying to focus on passing F5 for December.
LLucy9y ago#110
Here are all the MCQs I can remember: -Expected Value - usage i.e whether the company can use it -Expected value with probabilities calculation -Fisher formula question - which statement is correct? -Dividend growth with cost of equity - MCQ1 -Market value of shares -Value of rights ex market etc ( I never know the difference!) -Interest Collar -Efficiency is process, Economy is input. -Price to earnings question and PBIT? (something about valuating a small company --using P/E ratio). -Financial Management and it's place in NFP organisations -Working capital debate profitability/liquidity -Equity Beta (MCQ 2) -What government should do to stimulate growth (devalue currency). -Use of factor and the net savings amount. -Lead price and forward price difference for FEC -Job of the Money market re. Letters of Credit. -Aggressive/conservative approach -Profitability Index -Economic risk due to demand -Theory of behavioural finance -FRA $25,000 or $27,000 or something like that. -Statement about Irredeemable preference shares being counted as shares for asset -valuation. -Soft capital rationing - Forward exchange rates reflect interest parity - Efficient Market Hypothesis question God knows how I remember! Passing for me right now is 50:50.
AABC9y ago#111
@heychi said: I hope you are right as we have similar answers! For the ordinary share according to market values i got 396 or 369..something like that but I honestly can't remember if this is even the same question. I wish I wrote down all my choices but the invigilator took my paper so quickly. In limbo for for now but trying to focus on passing F5 for December.
How much WACC did you get? I got 11 point something.
LLucy9y ago#112
@syeduzairnaqvi said: How much WACC did you get? I got 11 point something.
My WACC was wrong because I didn't include the cost of the irredeemable preference shares. I couldn't think to figure out the interest % for that. Hopefully that and the real answer maybe worth 4/5 marks out of 11.
AABC9y ago#113
@heychi said: My WACC was wrong because I didn't include the cost of the irredeemable preference shares. I couldn't think to figure out the interest % for that. Hopefully that and the real answer maybe worth 4/5 marks out of 11.
Cost of preference shares was 250000/3100000*100=8.06% I think
DDEMETRIOS9y ago#114
very correct.Kp=8/06%.For the discounted payback period if u found the correct 2.75 years tha means that your NPV MUST be correct??????so if someone found the 2 marks question the corect result that means that he took 9+2=11 points!!!!!??????i think this thought of me is correct!
AABC9y ago#115
@demetrios21780 said: very correct.Kp=8/06%.For the discounted payback period if u found the correct 2.75 years tha means that your NPV MUST be correct??????so if someone found the 2 marks question the corect result that means that he took 9+2=11 points!!!!!??????i think this thought of me is correct!
Payback period was 2.9 approx.
DDEMETRIOS9y ago#116
I have found 2, 74 years..... Appr.2 years and 9 months
DDEMETRIOS9y ago#117
I have found 2, 74 years..... Appr.2 years and 9 months https://opentuition.com/topic/irredeemable-preference-shares/
SSatria9y ago#118
Payback answer will vary according to npv answer. There will be method mark as long you show ur full workings and calculations i believe
Sshafee9y ago#119
Guys can anyone remember what is the B question in the q31 wacc? Something to do with importance/instances of the wacc for the investment appraisal ?? A 3 marks theory question thank you
MMariia9y ago#120
Hi, guys! Does anyone remember how to treat variable rate of loan and how to calculate cost of debt in this case? I mean 31 question - 3 mln loan with variable rate. What is more they do not give interest rate to us - so it can not be used. My head is exploading)
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.