Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** ACCA F9 March 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin9y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA F9 March 2017 Exam

*** ACCA F9 March 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about the ACCA F9 exam below (after 5pm UK time)
Uusman9y ago#31
@pinkyjovin123 said: In 32 Q.Critically discuss the risk in invst appraisal method.
i wrote sensitivity analysis profitabilty index and risk adjusted discount rate i.e capm wat were urs..?
HSHarshil Shah9y ago#32
Q32 WACC is used 10% (the nominal one). What did everyone else use?
Mmanishjuddoo9y ago#33
what was the current rations?? 2.1 and 1.9?
SSalvatore9y ago#34
@harshil said: Q32 WACC is used 10% (the nominal one). What did everyone else use?
The same!
Mmanishjuddoo9y ago#35
@usmanhassan94 said: i wrote sensitivity analysis profitabilty index and risk adjusted discount rate i.e capm wat were urs..?
talked about ARR, CAPM, profitablity index...damn i forgot sensitivity :-(
HSHarshil Shah9y ago#36
Yes I got 2.1 and 1.9 for current ratio, I also calculate quick ratio for that question however i don't think it was necessary
HSHarshil Shah9y ago#37
for the risks in inv appraisal I wrote - Probability Index - Sensitivity Analysis - Simulation Wrote the adv nd disadv which I believe was enough for 9 mark
Ggerald9y ago#38
@harshil said: Q32 WACC is used 10% (the nominal one). What did everyone else use?
Same here. Used the nominal one
HSHarshil Shah9y ago#39
NPV i got $1m
Uusman9y ago#40
@harshil said: Yes I got 2.1 and 1.9 for current ratio, I also calculate quick ratio for that question however i don't think it was necessary
i got 2 and 1.9 aswell
Ggerald9y ago#41
@manishjuddoo said: The answer is 16 % i think
The trick was to use the Book Values instead of market values. I cannot remember the answer, but i guess 15% or 16%
Ggerald9y ago#42
@usmanhassan94 said: i got 2 and 1.9 aswell
I got huge numbers...4.% for the opening and 2.% for the closing of January. But i know i messed up
HSHarshil Shah9y ago#43
Yes key was to use book values and also take the post tax debt
Mmanishjuddoo9y ago#44
@usmanhassan94 said: i got 2 and 1.9 aswell
yeah got the same... if the 2nd current ratio is correct,it means that the change in overdraft also need to be correct..cant remember the figure.. around $ 475 K ?
Uusman9y ago#45
@manishjuddoo said: yeah got the same... if the 2nd current ratio is correct,it means that the change in overdraft also need to be correct..cant remember the figure.. around $ 475 K ?
dont exactly remember but i added the change(the change was 61500 i think) which i calculated in part b to given overdraft what was the value given in the question of overdraft..?
SSalvatore9y ago#46
@delamanisp said: For Q32, I think we had to take the cost of debt. The project would be financed solely by loan notes, meaning that WACC would not be a sufficient method, since no equity finance was used. I got around 2.3m NPV.
I completely missed the part that was only financed by debt... how many marks missed do you think? A couple?
Uusman9y ago#47
i found mcqs too tricky there were hardly 3 to 4 mcq on calculation in section A rest was all theory...!! and tooo many mcq from currency and interest rate risk...:( did anyone found the same..?
Mmanishjuddoo9y ago#48
cant quite remember.. i did a cash budget and listed all the cash movements and the added it to overdraft at start of jan 20x7.. don't know if that is correct or could have been simplified by using the cash operating cycle
Mmanishjuddoo9y ago#49
@usmanhassan94 said: dont exactly remember but i added the change(the change was 61500 i think) which i calculated in part b to given overdraft what was the value given in the question of overdraft..?
cant quite remember.. i did a cash budget and listed all the cash movements and the added it to overdraft at start of jan 20x7.. don't know if that is correct or could have been simplified by using the cash operating cycle
Uusman9y ago#50
@manishjuddoo said: cant quite remember.. i did a cash budget and listed all the cash movements and the added it to overdraft at start of jan 20x7.. don't know if that is correct or could have been simplified by using the cash operating cycle
i did exactly the same
HSHarshil Shah9y ago#51
I thought you would use WACC, doesnt matter how the project is financed as company has pool of funds and it uses to over cost which is WACC. I used that logic and therefore came to conclusion that WACC should be used.
Ppinkyjovin1239y ago#52
In mcq what was the payback period and Roce?? Is it 3 yrs and 25%
AAnca-Daniela9y ago#53
Question with total shareholder return: the prices for the shares were cum div? Did anyone extract the dividend from the shares' prices?
Mmanishjuddoo9y ago#54
@usmanhassan94 said: i found mcqs too tricky there were hardly 3 to 4 mcq on calculation in section A rest was all theory...!! and tooo many mcq from currency and interest rate risk...:( did anyone found the same..?
same.. theory questions on I- rate on fx risk are always tricky.. practiced the dec 2016 mcqs.. it was easier
AAnca-Daniela9y ago#55
ROCE 25% but at the payback period I got 2.5 years
Mmanishjuddoo9y ago#56
@adlupu said: Question with total shareholder return: the prices for the shares were cum div? Did anyone extract the dividend from the shares' prices?
GOT 27 % 0.45+0.75/ 4.30 correct?
SSalvatore9y ago#57
@harshil said: I thought you would use WACC, doesnt matter how the project is financed as company has pool of funds and it uses to over cost which is WACC. I used that logic and therefore came to conclusion that WACC should be used.
Well actually if we think about it, an investment should be done to maximise the wealth of shareholders. Gearing increases only the expected return due to increase in risk and therefore the WACC should be used. WACC only becomes higher due to taking on debt.
Kkabir9y ago#58
I got same. I add back depreciation
AAnca-Daniela9y ago#59
My calculations were different: ((5-0.45)-(4.3-0.25)+0.45)/4.05, something like this, I'm not sure anymore, so i guess I put 19%
SSalvatore9y ago#60
@delamanisp said: @Salvatore I am not entirely sure about the validity of my choice. I saw that it was financed solely by debt. I read that WACC is best used when you are financing a project from a pool of funds. Since the funds came from debt and only debt, I came to the conlcusion that I should use the cost of debt. No equity was issued whatsoever. Regarding the marks, (if I am correct) I would assume 1-2 max. I think that 3 would be too much...
Well actually if we think about it, an investment should be done to maximise the wealth of shareholders. Gearing increases only the expected return due to increase in risk and therefore the WACC should be used. WACC only becomes higher due to taking on debt.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.