FM*** ACCA F9 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
I don't remember at all, but I don't know the question for that answer pretty well, so my choice was to guess it.
Mcq 1-15 was ok however the rest was too hard.. i think i wrongly calculated my wacc and npv iv included fixed costs..
Could anyone explain why we shouldn't have included the fixed costs? Coz unless mentioned somewhere in the question, they must have been incremental as they were even nominal ?
The first three I select D then for next 2 c and for next 3 is b .9c.10.d.for 11 and 12 b.13d.14c 15 b.16d 17.a.18c.19b.20.a.21and22b.23and24.D.25a.26c.27c.28.a.29a.30i think d.please match and reply me
WACC 10.8%
NPV 1185000
guys plz discuss more about the tax allowable depn, who else put it in yr 0
give your opinions
Someone has answers I can finally relate! Those were my answers as well!
PI =(NPV+Initial Investment)/Initial investment
Also me too
hi all 32 question c: 2 way investment. I answered buy lease all right?
i inswered PI = investment +npv/ npv
i choosed same
Did you work out PI numbers from past papers or the revision kit? I could have sworn it was PV/Initial investment! But I don't know, I could be wrong
no roce, roe 20% but i choosed 19,4
i know but not possible ranking. So 6000+3000/6000=1,5 npv answered
I feel like I fail again. 6th time!!! I went for CBE option and it was total disaster. Don't think I made the right decision doing that. I felt lost between the computer screen and the scrap paper, also wording of the questions were not straight forward for me and I had to guess what the examiner wants and vise versa when question was clear the answers sounded misleading, also want to mention that the space on the desk was limited. When you are nervous these things matter.
With the questions where they specify how the answer should be rounded up, i.e. the one about TREP they stated that it should be rounded up to 2 dp and after my calculations when I got exact figure something like $9.8 it looked that this answer is wrong, first of all because computer didn't accept this figure and I ended up guessing (again there were no options to choose from, answer had to be typed in)
The money market hedge question led me to nowhere because I couldn't arrive to the listed options. I know this topic very well and I don't understand where I was wrong. I had an answer close to $205,... which wasn't there at all. Again ended up guessing, and as far as I can see in the above posts I made wrong guess ...
I found part C easy for me, and I probably could get full marks for them if I didn't spent so much time playing around MCQs. In those questions I completed the calculations but didn't have a chance to write theoretical part of them. I wrote only about capital rationing.
There were some other questions which I cannot recall at the moment.
But well, I can already predict the result.
I included fixed cost npv why not include fixed cost?
On the question with the agency problem, I too didn't see this as the answer coz I also thought the other seemed more plausible! I think it was D? I don't really remember the exact answer, sorry
The MCQS in section A AND section B were both tricky and hard to even guess! Wasted so much time doing the MCQS and at last, not getting the correct answer! I hope they are lenient while correcting our papers. It was a HUGE DISAPPOINTMENT for me. I practised all questions thrice and I was so confident, specially about the MCQs.
Section C was ok but for ques 31. WACC : what the hell was the rate 4% or sth on treasury bills? Is it risk free interest? I don't know. No clue. WACC I got 10.1? I cannot remember.
Ques32. NPV was Positive at 2238k?2278k? cannot remember! Theory parts were not too bad. Wrote whatever I could remember as I was totally confused and upset by that time.
I got WACC around 10.8%. NPV around 1189 it's called tax benefit when calculating depreciation charge. If there was no tax payable in year 1 therefore there couldn't have been any tax benefit. I calculated in a usual way. In money market hedge question I didn't mix euro with dollars and dinars. The home currency was dollar, the question stated, money market hedge, so I only used dollars and dinars for my calculation. I didn't look too much into other parts od currency exchange chapter but when you exchange dinars to euro to pay euro supplier and your home currency is dollar isn't it called netting? I am not sure I hope my answer was right.
But was the question not what was the value for receipt in dinars using the money marked hedge?
@dreamerSK 11 marks I think
F9 was fair...hope to pass
Rights issue 5 and capital rationing 4
Hi all,
This is my stance on question 32.
1. The tax allowable depreciation should be calculated as normal, but then all of the tax allowance should be recognized in year 1. The justification for this comes from F6 knowledge, and I had solved a question in BPP kit with the same trick.
The fixed cost should have been deducted from contribution, otherwise how would you charge corporation tax (certainly not on contribution)
2. The probability index calculation is simply NPV/ initial investment.
what was the answer to money market instrumnt one? was it treasury bills? and also the fwrd rate . i got 1.62. any one els got this answr???
@bandhi said: I believe you were suppose to have used Gordons growth model. So payout was 55% and ROCE was 20% therefore 0.45x0.20= 0.09, 45% being the retained earnings, and from there you just applied 0.45*1.09/2.45+0.09 = ... or something along those lines, but I might be wrong.is payout was given? I can't remember it was... or you calculated it by yourself?
@simchester said: F9 was fair...hope to passif so maybe you can you tell please the way you calculated the first question concerning money market hedge Many thanks.
does anybody remember this question from the MCQ, where you had to calculate the ROCe using average investment method. Monthly profit was $729000 and the total investment in the beginning of hte project was 1800000. I tried to do this: 729/(1800/2). But it didnt match with any of the given choices.
I can't seem to quote! Anyway, the money market instrument was commercial paper which are only used by large companies (the co. in the question was one!) Treasury bills are used by the government
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

