FM*** ACCA F9 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@caspian087 said: I think it was 13 or 31% Sales sens.= NPV/ contrubitionI guess it asked for decrease in Sales % to get NPV 0
Hi did any one remember MCQs answers I got few more A and D please share ur experience did attempt F9 so many times being bored with it to much and last exam to finsih F level
@aproop said: I guess it asked for decrease in Sales % to get NPV 0not decrease in Sale %... It asked decrease in sales VOLUME to get 0 NPV
@caspian087 said: not decrease in Sale %... It asked decrease in sales VOLUME to get 0 NPVCool.. Hope I pass!
I think cost of preference shares is 18.8%.
I recall clearly in the investment appraisal question stating that "Assume Depreciation tax allowance is PAID at the START of the FIRST year.
from which year did everyone start to realize the allowance?
Section C was like Merry xmas enjoy so not difficult.
but MCQ was like f***** it! I didn't have a clue so guess my way through them.
Because I guessed them had plenty of time to memorised them as below:
1 A 11 A 21 A
2 B 12 B 22 B
3 D 13 C 23 B
4 C 14 C 24 A
5 C 15 D 25 B
6 C 16 D 26 A
7 D 17 D 27 D
8 A 18 C 28 C
9 C 19 D 29 C
10 c 20 A 30 D
I also did noticed MCQ 27 partly answered one of the section C question on two ways of incorporation risk in to investment appraisal.
The answer was probability and sensitivity analysis.
for the NPV I had a very huge figure like never before which made me think I had done something wrong but looking at the NPV values of the subsection b which was about PI I concluded i was probably right.
My Wacc was 10.... something.
the business and financial risk wasn't quote sure what to write any one?
Hi guyes and girls today was f9 paper and my mcqs answers were that's 1.D.2D.3c.4c.5.c.6B.7b.8b.9c.10A.11D.12B.13B.14D.15c.16b.17d.18a.19c.20b.21a.22.b.23b.24d.25d.26b.27c.28c.29a.30c.most of my mcqs was guest. Npv is positive 134 and tax benifit is also in arresrs as like payment and in wacc I ignore bank and give note about bank.
@sa1pw said: How did you calculate WACC? For me cost of equity was 11%, Debt 5.7%, Bank 5.6% and Preference Shares 9.1% Wacc I think I got was 11.4%Cant remember the cost of debt i got but the rest are fine.. and ya wacc i got 10.58
@caspian087 said: I think it was 13 or 31% Sales sens.= NPV/ contrubitionBut it was mentioned sales volume so NPv/sales revenue Or NPv/contribution
Yes I share on my name as vikar
@beckyspace said: Section C was like Merry xmas enjoy so not difficult. but MCQ was like f***** it! I didn't have a clue so guess my way through them. Because I guessed them had plenty of time to memorised them as below: 1 A 11 A 21 A 2 B 12 B 22 B 3 D 13 C 23 B 4 C 14 C 24 A 5 C 15 D 25 B 6 C 16 D 26 A 7 D 17 D 27 D 8 A 18 C 28 C 9 C 19 D 29 C 10 c 20 A 30 D I also did noticed MCQ 27 partly answered one of the section C question on two ways of incorporation risk in to investment appraisal. The answer was probability and sensitivity analysis. for the NPV I had a very huge figure like never before which made me think I had done something wrong but looking at the NPV values of the subsection b which was about PI I concluded i was probably right. My Wacc was 10.... something. the business and financial risk wasn't quote sure what to write any one?</blockquote Ya i realised about the sensitivty analysis as well picked 2points for q32 from the mcq ?
@samh88 said: I thought I had done ok on section C until I looked on here! Did anyone else leave the fixed costs out of the NPV question because it was just increasing capacity not an entirely new investment so fixed costs would have been incurred regardless of if the project was undertaken?Please dont tell me ??
@samh88 said: I thought I had done ok on section C until I looked on here! Did anyone else leave the fixed costs out of the NPV question because it was just increasing capacity not an entirely new investment so fixed costs would have been incurred regardless of if the project was undertaken?Please dont tell me ??
even if we leave fixed cost (if it was not related to project only, which we could have assumed, generally i think it is assumption that unless specified, fixed cost relates to project), the NPV would increase (as decreasing cost). so, end result will be same.
@samh88 said: I thought I had done ok on section C until I looked on here! Did anyone else leave the fixed costs out of the NPV question because it was just increasing capacity not an entirely new investment so fixed costs would have been incurred regardless of if the project was undertaken?Please dont tell me ??
@dreamersk said: what was the answer to the MCQ about annual cost if you do not take the discount rate?What were the options?
can you claim tax allowable depn at the beginning of the first year i.e time 0 when there are no profits?
@dreamersk said: Options were 6% and 9% approximately.I think i got 9 It was tht formula of 100/100-d ^365/t i guess
@vikar said: Hi guyes and girls today was f9 paper and my mcqs answers were that's 1.D.2D.3c.4c.5.c.6B.7b.8b.9c.10A.11D.12B.13B.14D.15c.16b.17d.18a.19c.20b.21a.22.b.23b.24d.25d.26b.27c.28c.29a.30c.most of my mcqs was guest. Npv is positive 134 and tax benifit is also in arresrs as like payment and in wacc I ignore bank and give note about bank.The one is I select funded gap in dividend model I all three I selected.
@joashbill said: can you claim tax allowable depn at the beginning of the first year i.e time 0 when there are no profits?Well thats what i did I pray im right *fingers crossed*
Number A - 200 something...?
I also did not take into consideration fixed costs in q 32 and I used the tax -allowable depreciation starting with the second year. The optimal combination for investment I got to be ABCD with the highest NPV.
I know it was only this morning but my mind has already gone blank because I've gone into Christmas mode now that exams are finally over!!!
What were the 20 marks on again?
I know there was a WACC for 11 marks, the NPV for 8? Was it? Then the written parts were about explaining a rights issue, describe two ways to identify risk in an NPV or something (I did IRR and Sensitivity)
What were the others? Overall I think I did ok with section C - confident I could get full marks for question 32. Although I know my WACC was slightly out as my mind went blank about the cost of preference shares... confident on my market values though I think :)
For business risk and financial risk you needed to write about how business risk is measured by operational gearing (contribution / PBIT I think) and that there's always going to be business risk but it depends on the type of business etc. Financial risk is measured by financial gearing (debt/debt+equity) and I wrote about some of the theory's - traditional theory and M&M etc. - although not sure if I went into too much detail.. can't remember how many marks it was for but I'm confident I covered everything :)
In q32 b) you should choose the optimal combination from 5 projects that combined give the highest NPV.
For business risk and financial risk you needed to write about how business risk is measured by operational gearing (contribution / PBIT I think) and that there's always going to be business risk but it depends on the type of business etc. Financial risk is measured by financial gearing (debt/debt+equity) and I wrote about some of the theory's - traditional theory and M&M etc. - although not sure if I went into too much detail.. can't remember how many marks it was for but I'm confident I covered everything :)
@beckyspace said: Section C was like Merry xmas enjoy so not difficult. but MCQ was like f***** it! I didn't have a clue so guess my way through them. Because I guessed them had plenty of time to memorised them as below: 1 A 11 A 21 A 2 B 12 B 22 B 3 D 13 C 23 B 4 C 14 C 24 A 5 C 15 D 25 B 6 C 16 D 26 A 7 D 17 D 27 D 8 A 18 C 28 C 9 C 19 D 29 C 10 c 20 A 30 D I also did noticed MCQ 27 partly answered one of the section C question on two ways of incorporation risk in to investment appraisal. The answer was probability and sensitivity analysis. for the NPV I had a very huge figure like never before which made me think I had done something wrong but looking at the NPV values of the subsection b which was about PI I concluded i was probably right. My Wacc was 10.... something. the business and financial risk wasn't quote sure what to write any one?
@sophierayner said: For business risk and financial risk you needed to write about how business risk is measured by operational gearing (contribution / PBIT I think) and that there's always going to be business risk but it depends on the type of business etc. Financial risk is measured by financial gearing (debt/debt+equity) and I wrote about some of the theory's - traditional theory and M&M etc. - although not sure if I went into too much detail.. can't remember how many marks it was for but I'm confident I covered everything :)It was for 4 marks I think
I thought it was ok today but where the hell does he get some of those MCQ's from, particularly the wordy / sentenced based ones... I must have covered 300 during revision and still at a loss on some?
Again MCQ's were random and really hard, this paper is 60% multiple choice so no marks for workings, I have done so many test papers for mcq's and Kaplan exam kit but still these were hard, & really unfair
My WACC I got was 8.36% think I mucked up on pref shares as most ppl seem to have 10.6 %
My NPV was positive 1247 I think, and I did include the fixed costs, was I wrong to do so ?
Rights issue I talked about how it works and shareholders can sell right V doing nothing and how equity finance should be last decision in pecking order theory etc,
business risk I talked about obselesence etc finance risk I talked about capital structures in business and how poor finance management can lead to business failure.
2 way to measure risk I put expected values and probability index not sure if I was right their.
capital rationing hard external by banks etc soft internal restrictions etc
Again MCQ's a nightmare, feeling really deflated as I think mucked up on forex questions which I was fine with before the exam!
I am really hoping I passed as second attempt,
what did everyone get for NPV?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

