PM*** ACCA F5 September 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Omg... I have no idea what you guys discussing! Had completely different questions!!! ?
What about the cvp question was not sure about that one. Panicked!
@eazizli said: Q26 and Q27: $10 and 20% respectively?I've done 10 and then 16.67% as 3000/10 = 300-250 = 50/300x100=16.67%
@fadeya said: How did you come to this answer ? I dont remember getting those figures in my answers and I am a bit tensed now :(Budgets was 20000 unit and revised 25% so revised unit was 25000 which give u 20000-25000 = 5000@ 15 contribution So 75000A 25000- actual 23000= 2000@15 so 30000F
Anyway in exam I did wrong
@eazizli said: Q16: Payoff table. Answer 68?I did same
@snaher19 said: Anyway in exam I did wrongrevised was 25% of 96000 (as this was the market share) = 24000 wasnt it ?
@snaher19 said: Budgets was 20000 unit and revised 25% so revised unit was 25000 which give u 20000-25000 = 5000@ 15 contribution So 75000A 25000- actual 23000= 2000@15 so 30000FDo anyone of you remember, who opted for paper based version, what all options were present? Coz i have kind of forgotten which option i chose. Thanks in advance
@fadeya said: revised was 25% of 96000 (as this was the market share) = 24000 wasnt it ?I don't think so What about price variances planing was i think 69000 adverse Operational 46000adverse
@eazizli said: Q26 and Q27: $10 and 20% respectively?How did you get 10 i got something else?
@snaher19 said: I don't think so What about price variances planing was i think 69000 adverse Operational 46000adverseyes i got that one too
what happen if i forget to put question number in section c
will i lose all point
i did it like this. At first i thought of finding the value of a by using MR=a-2bq but then i went with the approch of P=a-bq placing 0 as value of 'P'
@mika84 said: Are you sure?what kit did you practice? Because, in this case there is no need in marginal cost whereas they give huge data fot it's calculation.I followed the revision kit of ACCA ..okay i know in the revision kit in some que they have given variable cost(eg 40) which they have said = mr but in some que they havent given variable cost ,so they have said mr=0 .but unfortunately while in the exam hall i forgot this stuff
What did anyone get for mos question and all cvp really messed this bit up
For the learning curve did anyone do for 999th - 1000 batches to find the 1000 batch?
I think I need more practice questions than publishing book as the paper was a bit Confusing and not that difficult. Attempted full paper but still not sure
Yeah I did I got £6.30 or something after multiplying t by £18 have no idea. It was something like 0.35 hour
I got 0.35 :(
@wert said: As for profit maximising price: P=400-0.0004Q, MR=MC, so calculate MC and equate to '400-0.0008Q', then find Q, with that Q find P - those are profit maximising.How do you think, if to start it as: a-800=mc, will it give the same profit maximising price? I did it as: Mr=a-2*0.0004*1 mln Then equate it to MC From this I've got value of a.
@manny1 said: For the learning curve did anyone do for 999th - 1000 batches to find the 1000 batch?Yes, I did the same.
Fingers crossed I struggled on the last question ROI other wise was definite pass
What is the marking scheme for Q31 (b) on price penetration and price skimming? The total marks is 8%. What would be a good enough answer to score full marks?
Q32 (a) I got Division C and E ROI = approximately 19% plus and 17.79% respectively. Both Divisions performed well as they made a profit but Division E although made a high profit did not meet the target ROI of 18% because of new investment of $2M.
RI = revised profit - (average net asset x 12%)
Average net asset was opening net asset +closing net asset/2
I messed up on the advantages and disadvantages of RI as I did not revise same and did not remember. After checking now I remember how easy and logical the answer is.
My MCQ were:
1.C
2.C
3.D
4.A
5.B
6.D
7.D
8.A
9.C
10.B
11.A
12.C
13.D
14.A
15.D
16.C
17.C
18.B
19.A
20.D
21.C
22.A
23.A
24.C
25.B
26.B
27.C
28.D
29.B
30.B
The paper was fair, however the questions are too lengthy and I always seem to have exam phobia and doesn't think well in the exam. I wish ACCA will make the exam questions shorter and to the point. I did paper base exam.
I agree the paper was not extraordinary, regular questions. however, in sec A they were really too long. It's supposed to take 2 mins per q to solve but it took me 5 mins only to read all the info
As for sales price variances , I've got 46K and 69K both Favourable
I choose $69,000 (A) not sure of the $46000 and I agree with you. The questions are too long which doesn't give much time to do Part C which also has very lengthy questions. The time is too short and it causes me to misread questions which I could answer better had they given more time to read and analyse the information.
@france125 said: I choose $69,000 not sure of the $46000Same
Question 31a has to be the weirdest exam question I have ever seen. How are we to calculate value for a when we don't know the current price and current demand????
The exam questions were very lengthy though!! I spent over 10 minutes just trying to understand what's happening in 31a. Even the mcqs too!!
i agree. They made the questions complicated. I could not attempt MC question and RoI question was also so twisted.
:(
that is exactly what i wanted to know between i calculated it as 500 what was yours?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

