PM*** ACCA F5 September 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
what was the value of a in question 31? how it calculated?
F5 was easy ! 50 marks were a piece of cake. No excuses for well prepared students like us. Only with Opentuition and a revision kit, you could write 70 and 80 marks at ease.
Athanasios, I do hope you pass. But I would not be so positive about it. At least they complicated questions about throughput in part B. Also ROI questions were confusing (especially with depreciation and what and should not be included in the net profit).
As for me Part A was ok, B - 50/50, C - not bad, apart the above.But will see on the 16th October.
Yes, it was a weird question. I did not calculate it based on the maximume 1 m batches. How did you calculate the learning curve fir the batches? Could u please show us how u did u calculate it?
Does anyone remember the answers to section A and B MCQ's?
How about Q32, I got both division performing above the target ROI of 18%. Anyone got similar answer? Lol
Not sure about that. Section A looked suspicously easy! Section B was not easy, and Q31 was a difficult one.
Que 31..In exam i didnt know how to get value for a..but after coming home i realised that at maximum demand price is 0..therefore 0=a-(1000000 ×0.0004)
a= 400....i regret i dint think during exam time
Yazeedi, Q31 first division I got 11% second got 23%. ))) I do not know whether it's right))) I do agree Q31 was the most weird!
Q31
P=a-0.0004*1mln
Mr=a-0.0008*1mln
a-800=Mc
Mc is calculated
Then,
A is found
Then put value of "a"into P=a-bQ formulae.
Please, who did the same?
Q32
In calculation of PBIT : only 70%is divisions depreciation, remaining should be added back to profit figure.Did you make the same?
As for new purchase, depreciation is already deducted as it was said:"depreciation which is included into above figures",so I didn't do anything.I now doubt this...
Guys, did you do paper version F5?? My questions were different!! Even people in one venue had different versions!!
Hi guys,
Could someone please tell me how did you solve the absorption question it was the second question in part A.
I was so nervous at the beginning then I just messed this up and just moved on to the next then didn't have time to get back to it...
Many Thanks,
Katalin
Question 25 sales planning contribution variance answer was 75000adverse and 26 answer was 30000 favourable but did in exam wrong
That's exactly what I did!
The way i have shown above once you get value for a which is 400.
Mr=400-0.0008Q..when mc is not given take it as 0(from revision kit question)thus mr =0
0=400 -0.0008q thus q= 500000..
P=400-(0.0004 ×500000)
P=200 .
@nasdik28 said: F5 was easy ! 50 marks were a piece of cake. No excuses for well prepared students like us. Only with Opentuition and a revision kit, you could write 70 and 80 marks at ease. How did you do que 31
I hope I pass feeling tense after doing this silly mistake
@bayu said: The way i have shown above once you get value for a which is 400. Mr=400-0.0008Q..when mc is not given take it as 0(from revision kit question)thus mr =0 0=400 -0.0008q thus q= 500000.. P=400-(0.0004 ×500000) P=200 .Are you sure?what kit did you practice? Because, in this case there is no need in marginal cost whereas they give huge data fot it's calculation.
When MR=0, revenue is maxi, I think Q31 asked profit maxi situation, please let me know if i am wrong.
Guys,I'm now very much worried, I realized that I didn't indicate problem number in subsequent pages, that is i indicated 31 on first page and didn't on the second,the same about 32...I'm so so disappointed. Will they deduct points?
How did you come to this answer ? I dont remember getting those figures in my answers and I am a bit tensed now :(
How did you come to this answer ? I dont remember getting those figures in my answers and I am a bit tensed now :(
@snaher19 said: Question 25 sales planning contribution variance answer was 75000adverse and 26 answer was 30000 favourable but did in exam wrong
@mika84 said: Q32 In calculation of PBIT : only 70%is divisions depreciation, remaining should be added back to profit figure.Did you make the same? As for new purchase, depreciation is already deducted as it was said:"depreciation which is included into above figures",so I didn't do anything.I now doubt this...Yes I did the same.
@mika84 said: Guys,I'm now very much worried, I realized that I didn't indicate problem number in subsequent pages, that is i indicated 31 on first page and didn't on the second,the same about 32...I'm so so disappointed. Will they deduct points?Milka, I agree with you Marginal Cost = MR, hence we needed to calculate marginal cost, we needed to find labour cost as well to show our skills of learning curve - that is why we were given massive information about it. They do not deduct points, even if you have got incorrect final answer, they will give some points for showing calculations, as far s you are going everything correct.
I think it said depreciation was managed but not owned by head office so it should have stayed in the division? maybe im wrong but i didnt deduct it
@avbosip said: Milka, I agree with you Marginal Cost = MR, hence we needed to calculate marginal cost, we needed to find labour cost as well to show our skills of learning curve - that is why we were given massive information about it. They do not deduct points, even if you have got incorrect final answer, they will give some points for showing calculations, as far s you are going everything correct.avbosip, I mean, do you remember, on upper middle cell on exam paper,you have to write problem number,like 31,then again 31 on next page, on next page so on...then 32,32 on next page so on.but I wrote only on first pages...do they have the right not to count my answer on subsequent pages?as there is no indication, what problem is that?
Milka, I did computer based exam. Well, I suppose they should read all answers and for each correct answer they will give point, if answer is not relevant they just won't count it.
Even i chose all three
Same.. Research about risk and uncertainty seemed most likely
Guys,
for me it was disaster what about the graph I was totally lost I think I blocked my self after I saw it ,,,,and what about the variances from part B?.....I will sit again in december....I thought it was going to be easier for me as I sat last year without styudying and I got 49 ....I think this exam was harder than previous ones
Does anyone remember MCQ 15? The one with perfect information? The question was very misleading.
Expected Value with no information was 168 and when you work out the perfect information you are willing to pay 210 (Ans A). Difference between them is 42 (Ans B).
The question was how much you are willing to pay for this information.
You are willing to pay 210 right?
If the question was - how much are you willing to pay extra for this information - that would have been 42?
I've spent like 15 minutes thinking.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

