General ACCAPaper P1 Dec 2010 exam was
Not such difficult questions but to answer was a bit tricky..Goodluck for the results guys!
Difficult!!!
First attempt at P1 and boy was i blown away!!!
Q1, Q2 & Q3 for me.
What on earth is an environmental audit?!!!
All I know was that Q1 was like an Enron type scenario, however I couldn't see in the case how long the auditors had been working with the company, but I somehow managed to mention the 5 year change over of auditors, whether it was right or wrong.
Q2, sounded like the BP Oil Spill, however I was looking for the presidents role in the scenario which I just couldn't find.
Q3. NEDs parts a & b were fine, but c, Best Practice of CG??? Is that the principals?
I just kept repeating answers in every question about the Committees! Oh well...enter for June 10 again!
Whens the question paper and answers likely to be released?
First attempt at P1 and boy was i blown away!!!
Q1, Q2 & Q3 for me.
What on earth is an environmental audit?!!!
All I know was that Q1 was like an Enron type scenario, however I couldn't see in the case how long the auditors had been working with the company, but I somehow managed to mention the 5 year change over of auditors, whether it was right or wrong.
Q2, sounded like the BP Oil Spill, however I was looking for the presidents role in the scenario which I just couldn't find.
Q3. NEDs parts a & b were fine, but c, Best Practice of CG??? Is that the principals?
I just kept repeating answers in every question about the Committees! Oh well...enter for June 10 again!
Whens the question paper and answers likely to be released?
with those long scenario, by the time you read and absorb it
my goodness, i still hope to pass, because i did write
my goodness, i still hope to pass, because i did write
its complicated to define, even I knew the answers but was feeling difficult to answer them, did my best but still confused
Hi alls..
Well, as usual, even though some of my friends said P1 is easy, I never trust them. This is my second sitting and I still find the paper tough. Yes, the questions were a little bit different in terms of the approach. It's like, "up to you how to answer it as long as you get lots of marks". So, i just write whatever I can remember.huhuhu... Failing mood is in the air but somehow, deep in my heart, please Allah, give me a chance to smile for this paper...:)
Well, as usual, even though some of my friends said P1 is easy, I never trust them. This is my second sitting and I still find the paper tough. Yes, the questions were a little bit different in terms of the approach. It's like, "up to you how to answer it as long as you get lots of marks". So, i just write whatever I can remember.huhuhu... Failing mood is in the air but somehow, deep in my heart, please Allah, give me a chance to smile for this paper...:)
this P1 exam was hard for me concerning 1 question only. I know nothing about investor's behaviour thouh i read study system several times and did not find info about it
If I am being honest, the reason why I thought it was a difficult paper was because I was not prepared for what actually came up in the exam. I relied too heavily on the exam tips from Kaplan, BPP, LBSE and ExP. I don't think any of them got it right.
Kaplan are normally quite good at their tips, and there is always some similarity between the QBD Questions and the actual exam.
Apart from the question regarding the speech, I was able to write something where I felt at least 60% confident that I was on the right lines. The speech though, I am convinced I messed up
Kaplan are normally quite good at their tips, and there is always some similarity between the QBD Questions and the actual exam.
Apart from the question regarding the speech, I was able to write something where I felt at least 60% confident that I was on the right lines. The speech though, I am convinced I messed up
see the result after in Feb then.
I thought is was a fair paper overall. The institutional investor part was similar to the one in the pilot paper. Institutional investors may intervene if there are concerns about strategy, operational performance, poor CSR, ineffective NEDs, poor remuneration policy etc.
Although there was lots time pressure. I did q1, 2 and 3. however I can't remember the stages in environmental audit but when i read the case i picked some ideas like evaluation of the company controls for envirenmental risk, impact assessment, I have no idea if that was what the examiner was asking for.
Anyway good luck to all.
Although there was lots time pressure. I did q1, 2 and 3. however I can't remember the stages in environmental audit but when i read the case i picked some ideas like evaluation of the company controls for envirenmental risk, impact assessment, I have no idea if that was what the examiner was asking for.
Anyway good luck to all.
I thought the paper was hard... hoping for a miracle though
i think it was ok, the requirements just needed translating into proper english as the questions weren't straight forward coming...I leave in hope
well.. i think it was quite a lengthy paper.. i attempted q 1,3 and 4.... seems most people attempted q2. wonder if i made the right choice.. i was too confused but the last part of q2 put me off so idecided to dig in for q4. anyways.. fingers crossed..lets see what the results will hold!
@mrdragon said:
Easy and common questions :) However it was difficult to answer!
Firstly i was confused with the insitutional investor's behaviour... 2 small easy questions by 6 marks each, but i didn't answer them from my best! What did you write in response to questions about insitutional investors?
its was about the SOS RAINS mnemonic
strategic, operational, socail, remmuneration , acquasition , internal controls . non complaince and succession planning
I did'nt Get The Stages Or Steps About Enviromental
, in question number 2,, please tell me the question and answer of this question,,,
, in question number 2,, please tell me the question and answer of this question,,,
Think the Enviromental Audit stages are below:
1) Agreed Metrics
2) Performance v Metrics
3) Reporting (On Compliance etc)
1) Agreed Metrics
2) Performance v Metrics
3) Reporting (On Compliance etc)
I think the paper was ok, but didnt have enough time to answer the questions fully. i could have done better if i have revised ethics more. I couldnt quite relate absolutism and relativism to the case. It was really strange but i did attempt it by forcing the situation to the theory.
Overall Question 1 was a bit different - hard to know whether I have answered well enough. Q3 about NEDs was good. Q4 - can't remember what it was but i remember it being the easiest.
Overall Question 1 was a bit different - hard to know whether I have answered well enough. Q3 about NEDs was good. Q4 - can't remember what it was but i remember it being the easiest.
p.s. i looked at question 2 and didnt even bother reading the case. the questions were specifically environment and ethic and i find these questions harder.
does anyone know whether ACCA adjust the pass rate according to how hard the paper is? Just wondering.
Guys, if you think that something was wrong with the questions tell ACCA about that!
https://www.accaglobal.com/allnews/students/2010/NEWSQ4/News/3381129
maybe it will worth 2 marks for us ;)
https://www.accaglobal.com/allnews/students/2010/NEWSQ4/News/3381129
maybe it will worth 2 marks for us ;)
I didn't think the exam was that bad, I'd say it was easier than the June one. My time management was poor again and I had a hard time getting answers down for all the questions but thought I could answer them all, which was something I struggled with in the June exam.
When are the exams available for download from the ACCA website? I thought it was the next day for the June exams or did I imagine that?
When are the exams available for download from the ACCA website? I thought it was the next day for the June exams or did I imagine that?
I think that the requirement in Q1 was to prepare part of the speach, not the entire speach. In this case, I think that the answer shouldn't be as a speach format, starting with:"Ledies and gentlemen".
Can we see somewhere some proposed answers? ACCA will show on their site maybe in Jan or Feb.
Can we see somewhere some proposed answers? ACCA will show on their site maybe in Jan or Feb.
The institutional investors question was not a technical one. It is a very topical issue as they hold over 50% of the shares in the FTSE 100.
Basically II's traditionally dont get very involved with the Board, they have been passive even though they have significant influence potentially.
So referring to the exam II's are more likely to 'interven' if:
* The co has been poorly run
* The co is not meeting CG standards (IE the CC)
* Pressure from individual shareholders who the II fund represents
* There has been corporate scandals or unethical behaviou (EG RBS)
This was not a clear area of the syllabus but it is not a difficult area for those that have a little understanding/interest.
Basically II's traditionally dont get very involved with the Board, they have been passive even though they have significant influence potentially.
So referring to the exam II's are more likely to 'interven' if:
* The co has been poorly run
* The co is not meeting CG standards (IE the CC)
* Pressure from individual shareholders who the II fund represents
* There has been corporate scandals or unethical behaviou (EG RBS)
This was not a clear area of the syllabus but it is not a difficult area for those that have a little understanding/interest.
The issue of intervention of institutional investors is treated in one page in the manual from Kaplan.
The paper was not friendly. Number 1 consumed like 2 hours and i rushed to finish those other 2 number.; overall the paper was hard. Its God to help us pass. I tried and wrote whatever came to our minds.
The paper was fair if one had prepared adquately. Quetion one confused me, didn't use some of the facts in the question though i could identify the issues didn't know where to use them. I pray i answered correctly.
the paper was hard i tried q 1,2,4 i escaped from "best interest" area, environmental audit is a new issue nothing much u can say about it, without standards set up, all was script from my head nothing in the text i can match it with.
enshalla i pass
cross fingers enshalla we all pass
enshalla i pass
cross fingers enshalla we all pass
The paper was bit difficult but I would say is too long to read the questions so you do not have time to go back again and prove read your writing. In particular with q1 with that Shazia Lo, just tried to attempt every question hopefully i did well. Thanks to open tuition who are the best (did not attend any classes but just used open tuition, i would recommend to every one )
Marry christmas and happy new year
best of luck to every one
Marry christmas and happy new year
best of luck to every one
look easy...but the question make us difficult to answer.
I did questions 1, 3 and 4.
There seems to be very little reference to the theories in the textbooks (either that or I'm screwed), most questions can be answered using common sense (that again or I'm screwed).
The questions seems quite random and the tips provided didn't help at all. I was glad that I read up a little on relativism and absolutism on the last minute. As for most of it, I bullsh!ted my way through.
There seems to be very little reference to the theories in the textbooks (either that or I'm screwed), most questions can be answered using common sense (that again or I'm screwed).
The questions seems quite random and the tips provided didn't help at all. I was glad that I read up a little on relativism and absolutism on the last minute. As for most of it, I bullsh!ted my way through.

