AAA*** P7 June 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
It didn't ask specifically for ratio analysis/analytical procedures, but the fact it was asking about them in the next requirement I just assumed that they might want to see them, so laid them out first and then the ROMM to follow.
If I get zero marks for the analytical procedures then I am in massive trouble.
Agree with Natalie. Q1 was too many issues that need thinking time. The time pressure is certainly not help to answer the questions in a time manner. Good luck everyone.
how many pages does the acca answer booklet have? cos i finished and asked for extra sheets even though i didn't complete all the questions. As someone resetting, its clear that going through the the technical articles helps a lot as question 2 and 5 had a bit of that. Good luck to everyone here, hopefully the pass rate will be way better than the last time.
btw, i didn't perform any analytical procedures in Q1, I don't think it was required.
Q2 B) It was about subsequent period.. I suggested it is giving indications about the conditions and thus to write off Inventory and deferred liability... Is that correct?
What was Q2 (C) about?
There was a 2c?
The professional due care i also write professional negligence and the 3 situations that owe duty of care, breach the duty of care, cause finanial lost. And they are contracted party, so have the liability. For the audit procedure, I write review the agreement between kowloon and bmc, confirm the deffered income received to cb/bs, review board minutes to understand the rationale, discuss with management to understand the reason, I forgot haha.
There was a question Chennai Co. about limited assurance report Vs Audit report, advantages and differences etc.
In question one debentures issue of 5Mil and Overdraft of 13 Mil was there but interest has increased only by 1 Mil. So risk of interest understated and profit overstated.
time was an issue. question one took much of my time. but overall it was a 50 50 paper
Overall the question requirements were the same as those in past-exam questions
But it was time-pressured especially section A, spotting the audit risks proved to be a challenge yet I was confident with Risk questions.
Time reached when I was nolonger thinking but writing following my instincts.
As for Qn 2(b), I didnot know what Accounting standard was relevant to adequately answer "matters to consider" requirement
I just answered the "Evidence I would expect to find" bit of it instead.
Just hoping my answers were up to the standard expected of the examiner's question requirements.
18th July will reveal the truth.
Anyone write Detection Risk as An audit Risk. The risk the new staff assigned to the audit will not be able to detect misstatements???
For me paper was between ok and hard.
Q 1 take lots of time as there is analytical procedures and audit risk both.
Q2 part b was easy. part a was easy too but i was not sure about the structure how to do it. so i do it as general.
Q3 forensic audit question was good but due to time end my last part not complete. that was expert witness (4marks)
Q4 was also ok it was of ethics and part A took more time than part b.
Q5 i left .
hoping for best score. God knows what will happened on 18th july. good luck to all
Yes gulam007 that was the detection risk. i write that risk.
Well, thats a relief for me as i have been going through this thread & see no one has mentioned about it
that was a clear risk and new staff recruit was clearly mention by the examiner. because there was no other detection risk and we cannot mention component auditor work risk as all of the audit (group and individual financial statments)was done by our firm.
@dinaattia said: Q1 First question was risk 0 A) importance of analytical procedures B) audit risk by using analytical - depesure share - disposla of subsidiary 5% - risk of inventory days and written off - trade recivable aging and days - trade payable - cash deficet and going concern - gearing - interst cover - capatalizing the redisign of wearhouse - new computer system - operating ratio dec C) i can't remmeberHow you calculate payable days because there was no cost of sale given.
@harsh444 said: Q2 B) It was about subsequent period.. I suggested it is giving indications about the conditions and thus to write off Inventory and deferred liability... Is that correct? What was Q2 (C) about?There was no 2c... just 2 parts part a with 13 marks. and part b with 12 marks. total 25 marks. please dont confuse others.
i forgot an easy part why analytical procedure necessary q1 part a, :(
i than just link it to audit strategy and plan.
Yeah i put 2 points, audit strategy & as part of identifying what areas to concentrate on as auditors do not have all the time to go through 100% of the accounts
Yes I did, that was staring right in my face!
Hi, it was very time pressured. Btw, I did not do much analytical procedures in q1 b. Was it required? I wrote common group risks like good will impairment, inter company transaction, unrealised profits? Will it be OK??? Im so worried right now
Starting to think my time management might have cost me dear... I left a lot of marks on the table with 2b simply because I did it with 4 minutes left! Did anyone else mention that the loss of the customer means the work in progress should be valued at NRV as it is specialised and probably can't be resold for more than cost? I did say that the wip was material so hopefully there is a point there at least!
Man I felt OK, not good but ok, yesterday now I'm not sure if I'll even hit 50. I was so confident going in too, probably the most prepared I had been for any of them.
dear 2b was a contigent asset as it was known on dec 2015 that customer was in financial difficulties so it need to be assumed that its virtually certain and the deposite need to be initially made contigent asset then on cancellation it must be realised as income.
Fingers crossed for all those juicy professional marks.
Exam was quite tuff
I manged write only 6 risk for Q.1 b had to move on. I m feeling so upset about it but cannot change it.
Thank God someone else spotted that one. I was starting to think I was imagining things
Yes, new recruits was definately a risk. Although there was no component auditors, i mentioned that using component auditor was not an issue, just to let the examiner know that Im aware that its a risk with group audit. Dont know if it will gain any added mark though.
Did anyone find and calculate that the tax rate is different for these two periods in Q1 for the analytical procedures?
no i didn't so it. but thats a good point
Extremely time pressured. Interesting set of questions. Hope for a pass.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

