Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AAA*** P7 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin11y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the P7 Exam.

*** P7 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P7 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P7 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Please note, the ACCA have asked us to allow posting comments only after 5pm UK time.
Eemmamc11y ago#31
No probs at first glance I thought the paper was ok but no amount of practice can prepare you for the real thing I found. Found it hard to string answers together and was also rushed on q5 even though I left the recommended time for it. Also found some of the accounting statements hard to understand especially the one with the 300 revalue upwards was badly worded or maybe it was just me. Was more like an accounting paper than an auditing paper but saying that p2 was easier ! Onwards and upwards tax Friday
Aabdullahzafar11y ago#32
@keyboard said: computerized accounting system was no MM..beacuse it had clearly writtern it did not cause any.. it was only there for ethical threat.. can any body confirm GC issue in q2... it could have beenadjusting event because manufacturing site was hit
There was a mm and business risk in implenting new system. There were no deficiencies in old system. But mm and business were there in implementing new system. Secondly, you are wrong GW was material as it was representing 3% of total assets. Total assets were in million. And GW was presented in '000 so we were required to calculate materiality carefully. Let me show you how it was given In question Suppose total assets were in question as 10million. Working: '000 Fv of net assets. (40) GW. 35 So we were required to calculate materiality by dividing 35/10000 or 35000/10000000.
Aadman5011y ago#33
For Q2 I had something like: a) Discussion of the Goodwill and the amortisation of it. Then discussed about the finance costs and how the 5m premium was treated, think I said something about discounting this 5m to the present value and then unwinding it but I think that is incorrect should have been amortised perhaps? For 12 marks had to be something more technical like this. b) was a non adjusting event as it was after year end, and should only have been disclosed (exact question was in Kaplan QBD) so it was wrong to add the contingent asset in (besides it has to be virtually certain of payout too) c) related party transaction made it material by nature and the removal of PURP on the inventory and inter company balances
Aadman5011y ago#34
@abdullahzafar said: There was a mm and business risk in implenting new system. There were no deficiencies in old system. But mm and business were there in implementing new system. Agree with this- I had it as a risk that there could be significant disruption to implementing a new system
SSachin11y ago#35
In question 1 b) Risk of Material Misstatement. I spoke about IFRS8 segmental reporting. Is that correct? They were a listed company??
Ttejal11y ago#36
@keyboard said: and for going concern since manufacturing site had had a hit... it was a adjusting event too being a going concern event!... well, if you're not sure about this, open up f7 kaplan book and read topic 'going concern' under IAS 10 chapter... good luck everybody..god bless
It might be a going concern issue AFTER year end, however I was under the impression that because it doesn't have to do with the current year end being reported on, it wouldn't require an adjustment, only disclosure. There were no indications the site had any problems before year end... Adjusting event: An event after the reporting period that provides further evidence of conditions that existed at the end of the reporting period, including an event that indicates that the going concern assumption in relation to the whole or part of the enterprise is not appropriate. Not sure if that's right though, just my thoughts..
Aabdullahzafar11y ago#37
@keyboard said: @abdullahzafar.. you're right! but requirement was to evaluate not explain dear brother, in evaluation we put figures on risks.. figures were proovided.. secondly for GW, iwas saying abt adjustment , if adjustement is immaterial we will not adjust it.... discussion of godwill materiality is irrelevant dear brother
For GW part, whenever question says matters to be considered we are required to Consider the materiality. Also its important to review treatment of goodwill that whether it calculated according to IFRS 3. Secondly, fv of net assets should be considered that whether it was measured according IFRS 13. There was a risk that the fv wasn't calculated as per IFRS 13. Thirdly, it should be considered that whether goodwill's impairment conducted by management as there is a risk of misstatement of it. Many many more points like these. Second last or previous technical article cleared that how questions like these should be done. BTW just take a look at bpp's solution of questions like the one which came in the exams . I hope you understand what I meant.
Aali11y ago#38
Paper was quite general no specific were really asked...
Aali11y ago#39
I did it as well and it was 15% of total revenue so clearly different segment in addition there was separate market and associated risks. So clearly it was Risk of MM.
Ddemashi11y ago#40
Hi All, Fair exam overall. However, when they asked about business risk does't that mean discussing the risks faced by the business under the 5 main sub-headings of business risk i.e. Operational Risk, Financial Risk, Legal Risk etc?...
Vvimis11y ago#41
this was a hard exam especially q2
Former userFormer user11y ago#42
hey guys.. the question paper is up now: https://www.accaglobal.com/content/dam/acca/global/PDF-students/acca/p7/exampapers/int/p7int_2014_Dec-q.pdf
Former userFormer user11y ago#43
hey guys.. the question paper is up now: https://www.accaglobal.com/content/dam/acca/global/PDF-students/acca/p7/exampapers/int/p7int_2014_Dec-q.pdf
Former userFormer user11y ago#44
With regards question 3 part a. I wrote specialisation and resources, independence, access to company records and mgt and auditors resp. It is ok?
Uunstopabl311y ago#45
Very time pressured, hope the examiner goes easy on the marking!
Former userFormer user11y ago#46
Hey people, Did anyone do question 2 about the intimidation-management thread that was hidden in the scenario ?
Former userFormer user11y ago#47
Am I the only one to have identified the audit client as a new client, since he said the following: " I have also provided you with minutes of a meeting I had with Maggie last week and some background information about the company" I put risks of opening balances and risks related to new audit client...
Aadman5011y ago#48
@dannie88 said: Am I the only one to have identified the audit client as a new client, since he said the following: " I have also provided you with minutes of a meeting I had with Maggie last week and some background information about the company" I put risks of opening balances and risks related to new audit client...
Yes I mentioned that as a risk and talked about new client fees being higher when it asked about discussing how the fee was set.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.