AAA*** P7 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
31 marks was:-
18 marks for audit risks
5 marks for additional information to be requested for the audit procedures
4 marks for auditing treatment of valuation of work in progress
4 marks for auditing treatment of government grant
Many thanks !!
Plz Wip ??
Hello,
In a exam I was given a question where I was given 4 headings scenarios and was required to answer
(i)……………., and
(ii)…………….
Instead of answering like how its shown below,
(i) Heading 1
Heading 2
Heading 3
Heading 4
(ii) Heading 1
Heading 2
Heading 3
Heading 4
I answered the question like this shown below:
Heading 1
(i)
(ii)
Heading 2
(i)
(ii)
Heading 3
(i)
(ii)
Heading 4
(i)
(ii)
This is how I answered the question, will it affect the markings?
@sublime88 said: they dont publish the exam papers anymore which is sly. i dont remember seeing anything about liquidation it wasnt on the intl syllabus i dont think. more marks ive thrown away if it was anyway!! I think it's only the new March & September papers that they've said they're not publishing.I can confirm. It was not in the INT paper...
For the liquidation q. I told them that with the extent of liabilities and already being giong concern... to review timeliness of contracts being executed and if not for foreseeable future if they keep trading it would be fraudulent trading and directors would be partially liable and see prison time. I advised to do a directors voluntary liquidation and then went through the steps of that process and the hierarchy of creditors etc.
Thoughts to my approach?
For Q1 I didnt state the risk of over / understatement of blah blah for every single one. Thoughts?
@gazeboz said: For the liquidation q. I told them that with the extent of liabilities and already being giong concern... to review timeliness of contracts being executed and if not for foreseeable future if they keep trading it would be fraudulent trading and directors would be partially liable and see prison time. I advised to do a directors voluntary liquidation and then went through the steps of that process and the hierarchy of creditors etc. Thoughts to my approach?as the company was insolvent, members voluntary liquidation isn't allowed as far as I remember.
@gazeboz said: For Q1 I didnt state the risk of over / understatement of blah blah for every single one. Thoughts?Me neither because many of the risks had no numbers to conclude on.
@macca said: Plz Wip ??I referred to the stage of completion
For question one, there was something about deferred tax not recognised for revaluation made...any idea of the audit risks that should have been mentioned here?
It was fair enough in optional part and a bit time constraint on ques1 2.
q1 requires so much in writing for the audit risk -23 marks with further information required - 5 marks and I am freak out on the procedures for value of WIP and recognition and measurement of gov grant, so specific - 4 marks each.
Q2a) going concern issue and procedures (a short scenario but quite a bit to write) b) kpis i didnt know what to write due to time constraint so I wrote recommendation instead (hope theres a bit of marks there) and audit procedures regarding KPI i did my best to squeeze what I could for it - 10 marks.
Q3) i did not choose it bcz the scenario requires very detail ias knowledge this time as compared to prev matters to consider ques in pyq.
Q4) advertising, intimidation, audit a company who is a competitor of client and also a client of a firm you just acquired. Fair enough that if you understand code of ethics, this shouldn't be much of a problem
Q5a)matters to be brought up to TCG and reason (requires ISA knowledge) b) roles and benefits of audit committee, fair enough if you understand audit.committe well - 6 marks.
Eesh! How many marks were forfeited there? That sucks!
@sbeeharry said: For question one, there was something about deferred tax not recognised for revaluation made...any idea of the audit risks that should have been mentioned here?I think deferred tax liability understated as not provided for at all. Difference between carrying value of sites (high due to revaluation) comparing to tax value. I'm not 100% sure that's correct though
@haadia said: I think deferred tax liability understated as not provided for at all. Difference between carrying value of sites (high due to revaluation) comparing to tax value. I'm not 100% sure that's correct thoughYeah, about same. I mentioned temporary differences and that it should have been recognised. I was not sure though.
I might have misinterpret that part. In brief what came to me as relevant is that stakeholders and shareholders need other information apart from financial and what auditors are able to quantify and these can be measured by kpi that the company deem important to their success. Something off the line I wrote on.
Part of the answer to 2b is in the first article for p7. So sad i didnt think of it. Was just so confused and didnt understand the question. P7 is my last paper, praying for a pass.
I did the Irish variant and as like you, I used International Standards. Here's hoping!! Question one ate up a lot of my time and that being said now that I look back I didn't do so well.
The audit committee question asked about recruitment wasn't it? And not pros and cons right? Or did I read it wrong?
@haadia said: For q5 on the delay of information I said no impact on audit report because they got the info at the end...But within Audit Report the auditor must disclose any issues with management. I said I would let the AC know about the failure to provide sufficient documentation and consider whether to disclose in the Audit Report the issue.
What the threat you all comment on Q5b about outstanding fees? I wrote my answer as intimidation threat due to the financial director trying to influence the auditor decision in order to pay then the outstanding fees and self interest threat because auditor will trying to compromise to audit client for the outstanding fees.
Q5c only conflict of interest threat will arise? 6 marks is seen so much to discuss one threat!
How many points to write for audit risks to secure 18marks? I run out of time to wrote revaluation(IAS16) and deferred tax consequences... It's hurt so much!
For Int Version Question 5
wasnt the leasing aspect material to the company? the leased asset made almost 4% of the company asset .
Hi,
Base on my calculation was immaterial to both profit and financial position because well below the threshold. But I concluded that it was immaterial in isolation.
If the leases should recognised as finance lease instead of operating lease, depreciation and assets will understatement and when those misstatements in aggregate might be both material and pervasive. So adverse opinion should then be express in audit report.
This is how I answer but not sure whether it work or not!
@wayhern said: Hi, Base on my calculation was immaterial to both profit and financial position because well below the threshold. But I concluded that it was immaterial in isolation. If the leases should recognised as finance lease instead of operating lease, depreciation and assets will understatement and when those misstatements in aggregate might be both material and pervasive. So adverse opinion should then be express in audit report. This is how I answer but not sure whether it work or not!Thanks, yeah i too said adverse opinion due to the same reasons, but i considered its materiality in respect of it being 5 million and company having total assets of 101 million.
I considered a the WIP a construction contract under ias 11 since it is made to the clients' specific needs so i used the % of completion and i spoke about the revenue recognition and deferred income
@ahcompany said: Thanks, yeah i too said adverse opinion due to the same reasons, but i considered its materiality in respect of it being 5 million and company having total assets of 101 million.I thought was 500,000 not 5million for the leases assets wasn't it?
The exam questions were fair but time pressure and evidenced by my colleagues.
I managed to attempted all 4 questions.
Q1i just wrotwle about 8 points within 60 mins with points like fx risk, cg risk, materiality risks, credit risk, cash risk etc.
ii. Like review board minutes for the approval of the grants, obtain the respondence letter from govt., etc.
Q4 i wrote conflict of interest, confidentiality, self interest, intimidation, objectivity, independent, integrity etc. Use diff engagement partner and team, ...........
Q4 I wrote abt discredit to profession, members, luck of reputation, lowballing for and overdue fees will cause poor quality of work. Fees could be over the threshold of 10% for PLC and 15% for private. There is something like the no. Of members of 51% before they can be called charteredand under take the work but forgot to write iit down.
Q5. I remember it was subsequent event and whether the report should be amended. Forgotten what I wrote
It was 500 000 not 5m. So it wasnt material.
Yes it was quite long. Demanding. It's these games the examiner like to play. It's a trick to see how quickly you could move on to q2. If not you will be playing catch up. Unfortunately she had me. Not sure you could call it a fair. Boring maybe. I am tired of this game.
That was q4.
I got q5 as immaterial lease to financial statements too but said chairman's report is not consistent with companies "growth" for the year so you should add an other matter to the unmodified audit report.
Q1 was heavily time pressured. I chose Q4 and 5 which I thought seemed ok question wise but I had to rush through them so not sure how I will do.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

