Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AAA*** P7 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about December 2011 P7 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** P7 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user14y ago#31
and i think this is the best comment ever regarding sweat P7...i love this paper but i wanna hate this paper because i dont wanna face it again..such kind of papers creats mental torture in the form of time pressures..paper was quite easy but there was nothing to regurtitate..each n every point needs to b specific which needs some time to b thought out....
Former userFormer user14y ago#32
I started from q1 then q5, q2 and last q3.
spent almost one and a half hour on q1 and kept on explaining the part a. But still I didn't explain the web site development and gave the conclusion.
Then attempted q5 and did not remember the requirements,then q2; the first part was attempted good but a weak performance in other three issues due to time constraint. I pray to Jesus Christ that he makes me successful in this attempt.
Aamanda778714y ago#33
I managed to attempt all questions, thought I did ok after I left the exam hall. However, after reading the above comments, I feel it is a 99% fail.
I have missed a crucial point of Q1 a) requirement with regards to preliminary analytical procedures. All I focused was audit risks based on the information available. I calculated two random ratios just to support some of my points but that was it.
I'm so gutted :(
Former userFormer user14y ago#34
For those who had problems with Q1...i did the following
1) The question spoke about analytical procedures and audit risk...important the question asked for AUDIT RISK AND NOT BUSINESS RISK. Those who did financial statement risk is fine since financial statement risk is a function of audit risk. That is Audit risk = (Financial statement risk) X detection risk
The question had plenty of audits risk not just share base payment (IFRS2) and leases (IAS17)
1) A doubt of Going concern – significant decrease in customers and poor liquidity ratios the acid test ratio was 1:1.04 (if not mistake) while that of the previous period was 1:2.04. the bank overdraft which was around 1.2M (while the maximum amount allowable for the overdraft was 1.5M).
2) Misstatement in cost of sales – revenue decreased significantly while cost of sales remained stable. This doesn’t make sense.... normally a decrease in sales leads also a decrease in cost of sales
3) Trade receivables – another possible misstatement is trade receivables while sales declined significantly, trade receivable increased. This can mean two things: one there is lack of controls or controls are not working properly (ie control risk) of the trade receivable balance is misstated (financial statement risk)
4) PPE – the PPE was revalued by independent expert... however two factors that lead to impairment (IAS 36) are significant decrease in sales and profit before tax. Oak Co had both. This can mean 3 things: a) the independent expert is not that independent
b) the expert lacks experience and competencies
c) the expert valuation is ok but no impairment review was done on PPE
5) Website cost – Intangible assets (ias 38) more specifically interpretation SIC 32 Website costs states that only development costs should be capitalised. This should be capitalised only if it meets the PIRATE criteria. Therefore there is the risks that advertising and planning cost were included in the amount capitalised leading to Overstatement in intangible assets and overstatement in profit before tax.
6) there was also the non separation of long term loans. Loan term loans have remained the same from last period, however the half of the loan term loan is repayable within one year. This means that non current liabilities were overstated while current liabilities were understatement. This non separation of the long term loans can be indication of earnings management.
There was the two other issues of share base payment and leases.
As you can see Q1 was very long and this is only half, we had to do the analytical procedures first.
Former userFormer user14y ago#35
@david1983 said:
For those who had problems with Q1...i did the following
1) The question spoke about analytical procedures and audit risk...important the question asked for AUDIT RISK AND NOT BUSINESS RISK. Those who did financial statement risk is fine since financial statement risk is a function of audit risk. That is Audit risk = (Financial statement risk) X detection risk
The question had plenty of audits risk not just share base payment (IFRS2) and leases (IAS17)
1) A doubt of Going concern – significant decrease in customers and poor liquidity ratios the acid test ratio was 1:1.04 (if not mistake) while that of the previous period was 1:2.04. the bank overdraft which was around 1.2M (while the maximum amount allowable for the overdraft was 1.5M).
2) Misstatement in cost of sales – revenue decreased significantly while cost of sales remained stable. This doesn’t make sense.... normally a decrease in sales leads also a decrease in cost of sales
3) Trade receivables – another possible misstatement is trade receivables while sales declined significantly, trade receivable increased. This can mean two things: one there is lack of controls or controls are not working properly (ie control risk) of the trade receivable balance is misstated (financial statement risk)
4) PPE – the PPE was revalued by independent expert... however two factors that lead to impairment (IAS 36) are significant decrease in sales and profit before tax. Oak Co had both. This can mean 3 things: a) the independent expert is not that independent
b) the expert lacks experience and competencies
c) the expert valuation is ok but no impairment review was done on PPE
5) Website cost – Intangible assets (ias 38) more specifically interpretation SIC 32 Website costs states that only development costs should be capitalised. This should be capitalised only if it meets the PIRATE criteria. Therefore there is the risks that advertising and planning cost were included in the amount capitalised leading to Overstatement in intangible assets and overstatement in profit before tax.
6) there was also the non separation of long term loans. Loan term loans have remained the same from last period, however the half of the loan term loan is repayable within one year. This means that non current liabilities were overstated while current liabilities were understatement. This non separation of the long term loans can be indication of earnings management.
There was the two other issues of share base payment and leases.
As you can see Q1 was very long and this is only half, we had to do the analytical procedures first.


I thought along the AR = FR x CR x DR lines too.

I just basically wrote some stuff about going concern with the closure of part of trading or whatever then wrote something on each of the notes in the FS and their treatment. I think they were all wrong so I had plenty to write about. Assessed the adjustments for materiality and threw in further evidence of going concern issues through review of working capital requirements (after transferring half the LTB to current liabilities) and about ability to repay and loan if extension even agreed and stuff like that.

Didn't bring in anything about whether the amount of the errors meant that there were poor controls in the company or if the directors were intentionally massaging cos of the trouble.

Hope I've answered the rest the way the examiner wanted even if I drop a few marks for not mentioning that last bit.
Former userFormer user14y ago#36
The exam questions themselves were fine,but the time pressure was massive. I allocated my time for every question and stuck to it, so managed to answer every question, although not 100%. Fingers crossed I managed to get 50%.

Q4 was on fraud and arguments for and against prohibition of providing non-audit services to audit clients.

Q5 - section a) research and development issue, other information issue.
section b) couple of audit report issue - ethical/professional

Good luck to all of you
Rrafay_ali14y ago#37
mekaal said 1 hour, 37 minutes ago:

freinds these kind of papers have now become like a one day cricket match.a best all rounder might be out at zero at the first ball..most important thing we shud realize is to treat such papers like one day cricket match if we got out at the first ball..we shud give a sweat smile and come back to our homes…


Seriously the best message ever! I wonder what am I doing with this qualification. The whole system is cracked I mean any loser with some luck can pass 1rst try and some one who hadn't slept in 2 days studying can't muster the pressure.
And why all the weirdish changes THIS time.
I am hoping a pass, I didn't do well on q1, maybe I might score 5 - 7 marks on it but even if I do I think I will pass. Rest depends on judgement on examiner IF THEY THINK I LACK THE PROFESSIONALISM.whatever
Rrafay_ali14y ago#38
The careful "cynic" selection of tricky words in q1 part a got me.
Perform ANALYTICAL review...OK APs come to mind but on What? the financial statements, or the adjustments..
oh gee what a sucker. that totally had me. I realized what it was all about but, already too late. Did some bits and moved on to the next. Thankfully did every other part of all other questions. hopefully a pass :( If only I could just put some damned % variances up :(
Rrafay_ali14y ago#39
did any one else observe the UNMODIFY EMP OF MATTER / MODIFIED EXCEPT FOR MATTER too often in q2 and 5??
Former userFormer user14y ago#40
Usually preliminary analytical proc would include:
-Revenue Falling , cost not falling in same ration , obsolete inventory provisions? or lower selling price which also show provision for obsolete inventory
-Operating Cost Would have included operating lease ( wrong treatment)
PBT ratio deteriorating and finance cost remains same even tough we took some od this year, and Fiance CHARGES for LEASE!
Check asset figures for reasonableless , OB+Revaluation+Lease ( if it was to be treated as finance lease - depricaton) shows reasonable asset figures,
Inventory figures and reciables increasing despite the fact that low sales and chances if inventory provisions
-cash depletion (going concern at end)
-Website cost , low sales shows impairment may need to be provided for
only development cost can be capitalized and not web hosting and server rental charges
-no proper lease disclosures ,into long term and short term liability
-lease wrongly treated , pv of minimum lease payments show be around the fv of assets , which was not the case here,
-Company to pay long term loan next year , didn't speared it in current liabilities and long term liabilities also no cash to pay , bank OD limit at end!
- NO taxes deffer tax or current tax recognized in BS even for the revaluation of ASSET, tax havens?

That i can think of for the time being
Former userFormer user14y ago#41
Cant remember how many marks q1 part on analytical procedures was for
Mmuneebnawaz9014y ago#42
Q1 was mainly about audit risk .. it was like wat audit risk will u identify if u perform preliminary review of financial informations and notes
Former userFormer user14y ago#43
I stuck to time on each question and was able to answer all parts of the paper, however for some parts i know what i wanted to say but couldn't put to paper. I answered in order q4, q3, q1 and q2. Hoping for 50%
Rrafay_ali14y ago#44
in the last five mins I came back to do the APs, calculate profit and sales % variance..
i found aabout 5 or 6 aud risks but mostly they were general (first year audit, blah)
not really ALL about the matters but I talked about LEASEs, Dev Cost, New Business and Warranties..

I know I missed like 80 percent of the whole thing there :(
Former userFormer user14y ago#45
Anyone else say that it wasnt a finance lease as ownership didnt transfer after the last payment?

Also Q 1 it was 23 marks for analytical procedures and audit rights "identify and explain." Hoping I got 11/12. Time was very tight in the exam. I got everything done but didnt have a second to spare.
Former userFormer user14y ago#46
yes, i thought the Q1 lease was actually operational lease too, and mentioned that in the answer. hope to score some marsk on that
Former userFormer user14y ago#47
Does anyone remember the mark allocation q2, got a bad feeling I missed something
Former userFormer user14y ago#48
I also stated thought was operating lease due to payments less that 90% of value and also no where near its full EOL. I also mentioned that they had created an asset but could not see the liability for the payments. Did i miss this?
Also with regards to Q?? about checking the work of the expert, it stated that the objectivity and capibilities had already been checked so I went down the route of actual checks on there work, ie, obtain calculation and understand/confirm the workings/assumptions of the calc.... anyone else?
Former userFormer user14y ago#49
I said operational lease too.
I said that the directors may have been opinion shopping with the valuations as they seemed massive and came at a very convenient time to add some weight to the balance sheet.
Former userFormer user14y ago#50
I Q1 +Q2 was 64 and I think Q1 was 21 +8 + 6

That leaves Q2 with 29 marks and I think it was 15 + 8 + 6 but not certain.
Former userFormer user14y ago#51
Thanks I remember doing the 15 marker for q2 and the 8 marker was on audit committee I think, can't however remember the other 6 marks I hope it's not because I've missed it
Former userFormer user14y ago#52
Q1 39 Marks. Q2 26marks Q3,4,5 18marks each
Former userFormer user14y ago#53
Q1 Was 39 marks (23 plus 2 prof. marks for PAR & risks, 8 for Analytical procedures, 6 for quality)
Q2 was for 25 marks (3 issues @ 5 marks each plus 2 prof. marks, 4 other issues at 2 marks each)
Q3 & Q4 were 18 marks but i can't remember the split.
Q5 was 18 marks (12 for part a (Think it was called willow, had GC issues?), 3 for each of the two issues raised by the partner in part b).

Ballsed up Q1 like everyone else it seems! Guarantee to see on the examiners report "Question 1 part a of the exam was answered badly by many students..."
Former userFormer user14y ago#54
it is really a issue about time management. I remember last time, I spent too much time on the first 2 question, only had 30 mins left for the lask two question.So this time I just wrote down the time period for each question,such as q1(10;15-11:25),q2(11:25-12:15)it really helps.
I have taken 3 exams in June, with the better time management the other two passed ,but audit failed.
Former userFormer user14y ago#55
I thought it was a tough exam. Hopefully passed, very time pressured but fingers crossed. This is the last one for me so don't want to come back in June!!

Good Luck
Former userFormer user14y ago#56
Some one please explain - i went for a full course for this paper and went to revision classes and no-one never mentioned doing ratios in this paper so why was everyone doing ratios in q1? I did no calculation for q1!
Former userFormer user14y ago#57
The latter 'P' papers always draw on knowledge gained from the Fundamental areas, ratios are not a main part of paper P7 however, they do form a prelimenary area of analylitical review techniques. It is these simple ratios that can enlighten the auditor to problems with the financial statements.
Former userFormer user14y ago#58
@greenpepper said:
Some one please explain - i went for a full course for this paper and went to revision classes and no-one never mentioned doing ratios in this paper so why was everyone doing ratios in q1? I did no calculation for q1!


Same here. I approached like this:

I saw 7 notes to accounts and 23 marks for question. To me that was 3 marks for each note. Seemed reasonable if you tackles 1) what the matter is 2) assessment of matter highlighting audit risk inc materiality 3) investigative auditing analytical procedure/evidence gathering. Also though there'd be a few marks for bits of calculation and/or identifying relevant IAS.
Then it asked for other matters - 8 marks. There were four headed issues to discuss on the next page that were emailed over in one of the notes. Can't remember them all but one of them was the non-disclosure on loan to director I think. 2 marks each I thought. One for identifying problem and audit risk, one for suggesting what to be done.
Did a few little bits of analysis like warranty/sales etc but I didn't do analysis of the financial statements.

Anyway it's done now, passed or failed. I just pray for 50!
Ppriyak14y ago#59
hai,
have anyone recognised that que 1 is almost the same as que 1 of dec 2008 paper named Bluebell with slight modifications?
Former userFormer user14y ago#60
hey, I feel so stupid now. I mean all that financial info in question one, i should have calculated some ratios. I totally ignored ratios. However i did calculate some stuff for leases and i referred to figures in the financial statements.
For once, i didnt feel so time pressured and was done within time.

I need some reassuring regarding q5 though. I made references to subsequent events and events after balance sheet date more than focusing on the application of IAS 38. Was that the right thing to do?