ATX*** P6 June 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Exactly!!!
I went over the kaplan kit, ACCA past exams
Mock exams, hybrid paper for last exam
You name it........
Extremely difficult! It felt like the questions were just so involved - like it was impossible to answer one part of it without having answered the previous.
When you're short of time this makes it difficult to skip one part if you're not sure and move on to the next.
I even wrote a note to my marker for the Bonus and Dividend part, saying that I'd run of of time to calculate the figure to use, but let's work on the basis of £200K!
Praying for a miracle. :)
ACCA should see before examiner makes paper if they have any problems in family. If so, they should not be allowed to make paper for that attempt.
Hi Guys,
I agree with most comments this was a horrible paper. I received an email from ACCA - it was a survey asking for feedback for the exams which they apparently will take into consideration before marking. On there it allows you to post comments on how the P6 paper was. If anyone wants to complain, you should complete that survey, maybe that might make ACCA be a bit lenient when it comes to marking our papers.
I am astounded and not surprised that no individual has a comment about how reasonable this exam was. Every individual seems to say difficult. Above comment ''impossible to answer one part of it without having answered the previous'' seems to be spot on. ''When you’re short of time this makes it difficult to skip one''. How do you manage to move on in this case.
The examiner who has written this has not given consideration to students who have worked through past exams papers and have wide knowldge across syllabus ( An important tip to succeed from my BPP tutors). However your knowledge is not even tested. I used BPP text book- excellent book to succeed. yet the questions were unambigous.
You can complain to ACCA through email and I think there is a way of informing through your ACCA account. Or ask ACCA personally.
Are there any students who liked this exam. Any others feel this exam was not fair.
For anyone interested, the sample paper for March/June 2016 is now available on ACCA website
My opinion - misleading questions.. hard to understand what they want us to do!
it was my 3rd attempt with P6 - 1st - 44 points, 2nd - 44 points again (in spite of 3 weeks studying doing past exam questions and then I saw weird things on the March exam) - what I mean weird is - only some small elements of syllabus might be tested in full, some of them you might have done many questions will not appear..
This paper was tricky, Question 1 requirement - fine but I started to calculate every year profit separately and adding dividends, interest to get the numbers and then I found the profit numbers and tax liabilities.. so I was stuck in the middle and I wasn't even sure I was doing that in a correct way!
b) CGT - they complicated the things as usual, but generally the tips given in the question were not intuitive and I couldn't find the real sense of that advise.. (like splitting gift, ok, but maybe it would be better not to suggest by the examinator the possible answer, but let us advise and mark it as correct if what we write makes sense!!!
2) I felt totally lost with that question.. Yes, I think in one transaction there shouldn't be a degrouping charge as it was the company selling the assets leaving the group, not the other way around
Bonus vs dividend, I just calculated the numbers with taxes but I didn't know if I done that correctly
3) I regret I didn't pick that question, at least I should have picked some marks for small calculations, however I was not sure of that as it needed a lot of calculations and I was afraid of getting lost completely in the middle of that..
4) I chose that one, but I lost time, I didn't know what the examiner wanted from me! The requirements were too general and if it was more specific I didn't know what to do at some point to get these marks.. I wrote some things about losing the allowances if they have huge loss and so on but I couldn't find more arguments they wanted from me..
5) I think it was the easiest one to do, quite fair question, at least I knew how to do one of them to complete..
However, I left the exam hall upset, I didn't do as much as I wanted and it didn't cover the whole syllabus.. I spent so much time on revision but I'm not sure if I succeed that time!
This exam may be so tricky even if you study a lot you might get completely weird question with the problem to solve found somewhere in the middle of syllabus!
My friends and family don't realize how it;s possible I cannot pass that exam that it's not objective at all! You work so hard and get b...it after!!!!
I couldn't agree more!!!!
Hi @dannyw1984 I wrote the same about DG.. that it was the company selling assets leaving the group
I can't believe I studied so hard and did every single question in the p&r kit.
I did well on mocks and was really ready.
The exam was an epic fail, I couldn't believe the profit and tax was given to us in q1 - surely that is where we score marks!
The wording was so confusing in all questions.
Core subjects were studied to the standard we were told to expect.
All in all, very sad this was supposed to be my last exam and I feel let down.
Even if I could have had an extra month to study or had the exam paper at home I wouldn't have been able to understand the question.
Horrendous, not like any other p6 paper.
What can we do?
@dannyw1984 said: Did anyone else say that a degrouping charge wasn't needed in question 2 as the Zorro building had been sold to A Ltd - which wasn't the company being sold DG only occurs when the sale of the shares of a company happen within 6 years of receiving an asset - which doesn't apply to company A.Yeah, that is what I put aswell. Although, there was no mention of Z Ltd being a trading company, I have just had a look at the March/June paper on the ACCA website, and it states in the opening paragraph: "A Ltd and Z Ltd are both UK resident companies paying corporation tax at the main rate." Does that imply that Z Ltd is a trading company?
This is shocking - if acca doesn't want churn out a lot of graduates then they should set the entry requirements high
Rather than frustrating everyone
Some of us our jobs/promotions depend on these exams - so just setting silly questions like the ones we just sat - is annoying to say the least.
From my experience with acca - I will not be recommending any of my colleagues to pursue acca
I will recommend CIMA - period!!
What a waste of a lot of people's time
Well all i can say agter reading your experience is that i dont remember any $#!t i did so lets go to sleep :D
I sat the Irish variant and it was not only time constraining but the questions were based on tiny portions of the book that no one could be expected to remember in great detail. It was without a doubt at least twice the difficulty of the December paper and I reckon the hardest exam I've sat. rest assured the same disgraceful questions won't come up in December. fairness needs to be introduced into these exam questions rather than make it feel like a scam of for your money.
I do think that ACCA have been money motivated as 106 pounds + a paper and rising every year is surely a concern. Yet there exams questions are silly in order for you to fail. Peoples jobs rely on these exams and students work hard to pass and obtain job satisfaction. Examiners just see it as a joke to make us fail.
I do think that too many people have been taking these exams as it is international and the entry requirements are not high.
My lecturer once said that if it wasn't challenging many people would be gaining this qualification. However the exams have become purposely for people to fail. Why don't they increase there requirements like having a degree, this way the acca would be open to another market for high education students and examine the questions on quality rather than quantity and high fees. its a scam I agree. The questions set should be key exam areas of syllabus and not little bits of study guide where you cannot surely remember in exam amongst so much of P6 text which is massive. Why not reduce syllabus and examine in more detail with difficult questions requiring mix of calculations and explanation. For example the degrouping and question 5 which tested knowledge and theory with a little bit of calculations.
I do not remember the questions exactly, but if something is not stated clearly (is a company trading or not) then you just have to consider both situations.
I agree, that this exam was very different to previous ones. And it is unfair, as ACCA's main advise is trying past papers prepare you best. It was not the case here.
However, If I had 2 more hours for analysing the questions I would write for pass without any problem. The questions were not very difficult. Just written in a way impossible to digest in such short time.
Agree with all of the above although I have different words come to my mind instead of just douc bag. ! I don't feel I want to be part of a body that treats his students ... and here I will be "professional and ethical" and not finish my sentence. Even though this is my last paper, I've had enough. Sooo much work, so much money, I don't want to throw more good money after bad. It will be interesting to see the results though, but probably within the range they are always in lol. Goodbye and lots of luck at your next try. Just remember, it can't be any worse, or could it ...
@g said: I am astounded and not surprised that no individual has a comment about how reasonable this exam was.My post did say i thought it was reasonable. Thinking i've missed something here now! Have had a look at the hybrid March/June 2016 paper and still think that Q1 all you had to do is work out payments on account, class 2 and class 4 NIC - think that was it?! The rest of the question - i stated investing in inventory will not impact tax and the additional equipment will reduce tax due to writing down allowances of AIA. Voluntary VAT - thought we needed to see taxable supplies. Unsure. Also mentioned how it would be more expensive if customers weren't registered. CGT - worked this based upon a 80k gain and took off the AE of 11k. Then stated the payment date and at 28%. Stated that we needed the rate of tax in foreign company to deduct DTR. Stated that the additional gift of painting should be made ASAP to utilise loss @ 28%. Stated shares should be gifted after marriage, but in hindsight should have recommended a part disposal to take up 11k annual exemption. Question 2 - all we needed to do was use the template given and amend figures. A couple of obvious mistakes - use of incorrect indexed cost, dividend of post tax proceeds being calculated using chargeable gain and not the proceeds less tax. Then, part b, it was just a case of using whatever bottom line figure you got to (think mine was around 350k!!) and then grossing it up for a dividend or using a bonus figure and show the tax difference. The VAT question was tricky, but not impossible. I forgot to disallow the lease payments 15% but did state you could only claim 50% of input VAT rather than the full amount. There was no VAT that could be claimed on purchase outright but there was WDA @ 8% which was available for tax relief. Working out which option provides most tax relief was just thinking about which expenses are available for tax relief. I did the question about the corporation tax too and felt that it went ok - i struggled with the enhanced capital allowances, but there were three relatively easy marks for the loan, and then explaining how the capital allowances could potentially be claimed wasn't too shabby, given that there was plenty to talk about. I'm probably missing something massively here, but everything on the exam was well within capabilities - cue a fail!
My post did say i thought it was reasonable. Thinking i've missed something here now!
Have had a look at the hybrid March/June 2016 paper and still think that Q1 all you had to do is work out payments on account, class 2 and class 4 NIC - think that was it?!
The rest of the question - i stated investing in inventory will not impact tax and the additional equipment will reduce tax due to writing down allowances of AIA.
Voluntary VAT - thought we needed to see taxable supplies. Unsure. Also mentioned how it would be more expensive if customers weren't registered.
CGT - worked this based upon a 80k gain and took off the AE of 11k. Then stated the payment date and at 28%. Stated that we needed the rate of tax in foreign company to deduct DTR.
Stated that the additional gift of painting should be made ASAP to utilise loss @ 28%.
Stated shares should be gifted after marriage, but in hindsight should have recommended a part disposal to take up 11k annual exemption.
Question 2 - all we needed to do was use the template given and amend figures. A couple of obvious mistakes - use of incorrect indexed cost, dividend of post tax proceeds being calculated using chargeable gain and not the proceeds less tax.
Then, part b, it was just a case of using whatever bottom line figure you got to (think mine was around 350k!!) and then grossing it up for a dividend or using a bonus figure and show the tax difference.
The VAT question was tricky, but not impossible. I forgot to disallow the lease payments 15% but did state you could only claim 50% of input VAT rather than the full amount. There was no VAT that could be claimed on purchase outright but there was WDA @ 8% which was available for tax relief. Working out which option provides most tax relief was just thinking about which expenses are available for tax relief.
I did the question about the corporation tax too and felt that it went ok - i struggled with the enhanced capital allowances, but there were three relatively easy marks for the loan, and then explaining how the capital allowances could potentially be claimed wasn't too shabby, given that there was plenty to talk about.
I'm probably missing something massively here, but everything on the exam was well within capabilities - cue a fail!
i think when he prepared p6 ppr he ws beaten so he ended up ruining up lives
I spent at least a good 15 minutes reading the requirement for question 1! Very unfair!
Firstly, the exam should be to test the knowledge of tax and not whether the student can understand the question or the secenario. After all this is not an English exam!
I have two young babies, yet I studied so hard for this paper, this meant early question practicing at 4:30 in the morning and again after the kids has gone to bed til 1am in the morning! I honestly thought I was so prepared for this exam from every angle.. clearly not!
How unfair!
Having done 13 papers so far, I understand time pressure during exams.. hence why papers should be set in a way, you come on read the question, pick up the pen answer, stop, read next question, answer, move on etc. But only for this exam. I spent more time trying to understand what he was actually asking than planning my question!!!!
Like many have written, as unproffesional as it sounds, but Acca should check the personal status of the examiner before allowing him to write a paper.
The worst paper ever!
And completely demotivated with acca after this sitting!
Having seen the paper and the above student mentioned says "think that was it' makes him still unsure if the wording of question was right. Question 1 was the first question and 10-15 minutes wasting time trying to intererpret examiner is destined for fail. A whole question for 11 marks which is a very small area of syllabus is very unfair with P6 being a massive paper. I agree it was within capabilities but examiner has confused individuals with way he has written it throughout most of the paper.
Giving figure for Income tax liability & taxable profits is a deliberate attempt to confuse. I find this exam technique shameful. I took P2 which is similar in size and asked lecturer for guidance, he gave me article and hints- my hard work paid off because I answered difficult questions which were clear.
Also are we expected to remember due dates and payments and every single detail of syllabus. If revised well this minor area then yes exam was OK. However it was 11 marks shocking and deliberately to waste time. Major areas was not tested.
It seems we have to assume a lot and state the obvious. Voluntary Registration was also small area of syllabus and the answer was not even in lecture notes. This is about testing tax and accountancy knowledge and unfair to use bits and pieces from study guide. Thank you examiner for wrecking peoples career prospects.
Could you give a link to this hybrid March/June 2016 paper? I cannot find it. Last ones I see is September/December 2015.
This is the wording from a requirement in question 2:
"Calculate the additional tax and national insurance contributions due, as reduced by any corporation tax savings..."
What on earth does that even mean?
Isn't it IT + NIC liability in respect of received bonus or dividend of Gail less tax saving of the business (A Ltd) made on payments to Gail as a bonus or dividend?
Very vague and what corporation tax saving, by A or Z. A does not pay any corporation tax on dividends received from Z as dividends are not taxed. UK and overseas dividends are not taxed and therefore there is no saving by A. The questioning is not clear.
Yes, there is not tax saved for A if it pays Gail dividend. But paying bonus is allowable cost so there is tax saving for A. Because Gail owns 100% of A, tax saved by A is good for Gail. So the question is (as many in Revision kit) - what net amount can Gail receive (being the owner of A) taking into account both Gail's personal taxes/NIC and A's CT
Can I please urge everyone who has taken the exam to complete the Acca exam feedback survey- which you would have received via email a few days back.
The more who completes and express the point, the more chance acca may look into it.
anyone say Z and A were in corp tax group etc thus upper and lower limits divided by two?
Glad ppl are sharing there experience with this exam
Ive completed the acca feedback can anybody who hasnt already do so it can make a difference for us
Wish more voted and commented on this page though

