Post your comments about June 2013 P4 exam.
How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?
Vote in our Instant Poll

AFM*** P4 June 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***
@decky67
where did u get the mv of debt and equity
Q1 was a really long scenario & extremely difficult to complete in the time!
Q2 Synergy & Valuation before acq & after acq - using Free Cash Flows / P/E ratio - was pretty hard
Q3 Hedging - Matching question wasn't too bad
Overall found the exam v.tough to complete in time - and as always scenarios overwhelming under exam pressure!
Q1 (a)
used MM model to calculate ungeared Ke of Competitor firm. It was 11%
Q1 (b)
Used 11% calc above to dicount free cash flows before and after BAhari project. The firm value was around$ 550 Million. Value of Bahari project was calculated using APV method. It was around $ 10 M.
Q1 (c)
Asked Whether the unsecured bond holders will accept the debt to equity swap or not.
The debt was 10 yr, 13% coupon, nominal value $40M (please correct figures if theyre wrong)
According to the swap these bondholders will get 10% of the co's equity shares after listing.
10% of shares would be 550M x 10% = 55 M
This is to be compared against the Market value of debt. Which I calculated using 7% Discount rate.
Q1(d)
Calculate the range of initial share issue prices assuming 100 million shares.
I simply divided 550M/100 = $ 5.5 per share
Assumptions in calculating share price.
Reasons why a company would want a listing on stock exchange.
wawwww
I could not concentrate and so for me was a disaster. Our exam hall is too packed 100 to 150 students, so much noise chairs and desks scrapping the wooden floors. Pens and calculators dropping on the floor because the desks so small. My neighbour couching consistently. Mobile phones going off in peoples bags despite being asked to turn them off.
Hey ho back in December then and P3 next week!!
How much marks would be cut out of 12 marks in q 3 as I had no time to do forward rate and money market hedge , I only did the options part , so how much I would be getting out of 12 marks . I don't know may be I was in rush thts why forward and money market went out of my heard , just didn't occur to me that I had to do those things other than the options . This was the only qs in which I could have scored good marks and I blew it , Damn !!!!
I used the APV method to work out the bahari project. As I used the APV and FCF to work out the value I took out the value of the debt. Was really confused about the share price question. Don't know what happened there.
<cite>@mat3myh said:</cite> How are you supposed to de-gear the cost of equity with out the ERP to find the beta??it was M&M (2) with tax formula
Q2 (a)
Discuss the different type of synergies.
Which of these types are relevant to the acquisition of Strymon co by Hal co
Q2 (b) What is the premium on acquisition that Hal co would pay on the equity value of Strymon.
There were 2 methods to calculate equity value of Target co.
P/E method AND the other involved ROCE and using 3 years earnings into perpetuity or something, didnt know wtf that was
Q 2(c) Calculate the gain on a share of Target company in each of the following case
...Cash offer of $ 5.xx / share
....Cash offer of $1.x per share + 1 share of Hal Co for every 2 share of target co.
... Cash offer of $1.x per share + convertible bond of $100, paying 3% pA, for every $5 nominal value of target co shares. The loan is redeemable at par in 6 yrs OR convertible to 15 Hal Co shares
Q1- did anyone else use M&M 2 (with tax theory) formula?
Q2- Value of combined co was new p/e x combined earnings + synergy benefits?
The paper was horrible. Especially for question 1. I used a lot of time trying to figure out the cost of quite to use. I finally used the m& m preposition to find the cost if unguarded company .
Don't even know if I got this right
never felt like this at a paper, and i had the impression that everybody in the room was at same level. very very complicate! will go again in december wishing in a better paper.
<cite>@coolbreeze198 said:</cite> It was the most horrible paper in my whole acca history. :X Im a straight passer with all papers attempted in one sitting but this paper just threw me off completely. Does anyone else feel it was a disaster, or is it just me?Same Here.... Passsed 12 Papers till now.... 11 Papers 1st Attempt.... 1 Paper 2nd Attempt.... Attempted P7 nd P4 both were difficult but the winner is P4 WHAT THE HECK WAS THAT......
<cite>@thehardone said:</cite> Q1 (a) used MM model to calculate ungeared Ke of Competitor firm. It was 11% Q1 (b) Used 11% calc above to dicount free cash flows before and after BAhari project. The firm value was around$ 550 Million. Value of Bahari project was calculated using APV method. It was around $ 10 M. Q1 (c) Asked Whether the unsecured bond holders will accept the debt to equity swap or not. The debt was 10 yr, 13% coupon, nominal value $40M (please correct figures if theyre wrong) According to the swap these bondholders will get 10% of the co's equity shares after listing. 10% of shares would be 550M x 10% = 55 M This is to be compared against the Market value of debt. Which I calculated using 7% Discount rate. Q1(d) Calculate the range of initial share issue prices assuming 100 million shares. I simply divided 550M/100 = $ 5.5 per share Assumptions in calculating share price. Reasons why a company would want a listing on stock exchange.WOW. I just remembered.. the first question companies were both mining ones i.e same business but different financial risk which meant ungeared KE could be used as cost of capital.. right? At any rate, my numerical answers match yours but my discount rate was different (assumed) since Q1 (a) was a part I just could not solve, completely panicked. Assumed KE 15%
@mat3myh. I did the same, obvioulsly it was wrong (not for 9 marks for sure)..
<cite>@mat3myh said:</cite> How are you supposed to de-gear the cost of equity with out the ERP to find the beta??Use ke=kei+(i-t)(kei-kd)vd/ve formula i guess
Does anyone think that the reading time should be increased? It takes forever to read questions properly,and with understanding. 15 mins is not long enough. I was probably through 3/4 of the paper only when the reading time was up. Then you have to read the questions again, as you forget what the details were!
This was my another attempt, i passed all other exams first time, but P4 is just not happening. I was pretty happy with questins at first but then got confused and wasted a lot of time trying to figure things out and look for info. I feel so depressed right now.
One last exam and i cant get it out of the way!!!!
most horrible paper in my ACCA History.Pls all I need is50 and not more!This is supposed to be my last paper
A complete disaster!!!!!!!!!!!
I have read about paper P4 being perhaps the toughest in the ACCA qualification scheme. I NOW KNOW IT IS! One of the toughest papers I have ever written. So time pressured! So confusing! Passed 9 papers first time so far. This is the first time in an ACCA exam that I am wondering whether I have passed .... and it is supposed to be my last paper.
All the best to you all!
I don't know if this is just an urban legend but I have heard if the exam paper is hard and so many people fail then they tend to push up the boundary. Does anybody know how true this is?
This is no longer an accounting qualification... Textbooks are useless, past exams are worthless.
This is not testing knowledge, this is finding the needle in the haystack of information and applying "exam technique", where exam technique means that you are unable to complete a problem, but you are good at inventing answers.
I'm just tired of what the examiner wants, what's his impression on the subject, etc. Nothing like in real life on Q1.
I have better chances at winning in the lottery than passing my last ACCA exam in this style.
How is one supposed to pass that?
<cite>@hitenrabadia said:</cite> I don't know if this is just an urban legend but I have heard if the exam paper is hard and so many people fail then they tend to push up the boundary. Does anybody know how true this is?I guarantee you that this will be one of thehat he lowest pass rates in the history of ACCA. And the examiner will be pleased because he will be asked by BPP, Kaplan,LSBF on how to update their textbooks. And you''l buy them (revised), spend another 10 months studying, pay another chunk of fees, re-sit only to see what how the examiner changed his mind and invented something new :) Everybody wins, except YOU.
<cite>@maryoasis said:</cite> most horrible paper in my ACCA History.Pls all I need is50 and not more!This is supposed to be my last paperOK! The examiner just informed me that he'll give you 50 marks by default :). He has only 9 wild-cards remaining. Hurry up! Limited offer ! :)
<cite>@carl29 said:</cite> A colleague of mine used to be a team leader for a bank of exam markers 2 things he told me 1. The exams are not tested prior to the students sitting them, hence it is not known whether the exam is in fact doable in the time allocation 2. As a result of the above, if the majority of candidates have struggled, the overall pass mark is adjusted down. So you still need 50% but the overall 100% is less stringent. He never told me how that is determined I assume he wasnt lying. He also told me some things that didnt fill me with confidence over the whole marking process, its certainly not the millitant operation the acca makes it out to beIt's true. But not for ACCA. Other qualifications take this into consideration (CFA; CIMA), but here is not the case. Anyway, if they say 38% passed, who will check them !?! There is not a real interest in passing final exams. It's just not profitable. Really, it's not. See other accounting qualification pass rates.
Have I done this wrong? Or was it a bit of a Eureka moment? Having studied Mr Malde's previous papers, he can be a bit sneaky and make you think about some element of calculating the gearing. I had looked at M & M's calculation which is on the formula sheet, literally just before sitting the exam and the Ke to i was ungeared equity - so used this to work back. Question 1 section 1
I think I messed up on other bits of question 1 but may have got that. Attempted about 90% of the paper and did Question 1 last - just hope I have got 50% as I'm with most people on this paper not lookig forward to re-sitting again.
Hey-ho P5 Thursday - good luck to everyone anyhoo
Paper was toooooooooo difficult and lenghty still attemptd 80 marks needs a miracle ...
ACCA is no more profitable.. (
This was my second attempt :'(
and I just want to pass..... Damn.... :'(....
I always work so hard for the papers... but....

