Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AFM*** P4 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about December 2011 P4 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** P4 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user14y ago#1
It was an easy paper for well prepared students
Uuid019114y ago#2
love the paper today
Rrballiram14y ago#3
What came?
Former userFormer user14y ago#4
Q1 Investment Appraisal on FDI (NPV & APV)
Q2 Interest Rate Risk Management(futures,option,collar)
Q3 Bond Valuation
Q4 MBO
Q5 Triple Bottom Line reporting
Mmoshi14y ago#5
Paper was easy for me as I did prepared it very well but the time given was very less
very hard to complete
and I din't complete
May we all pass :)
Mmrxamag14y ago#6
it should have been a 3 hour 30 minutes exam..
Hhesrat14y ago#7
Time was not enough to complete all questions..... Luck will do the rest :)
Former userFormer user14y ago#8
relatively ok paper but time limiting factor =S though option questions were disaster lol
Former userFormer user14y ago#9
1st exam (and penultimate) that I have struggled to finish! Didn't see that coming either, 3BL rubbish. I was relying on the narrative question too! Other 2 options were OK though, 9 out of 18 was quite achievable for both.
Former userFormer user14y ago#10
fair paper.
Former userFormer user14y ago#11
paper covered familiar topics, very much in line with revision kit questions...couldn't manage time though .. spent 2 hrs on 1st question itself...
Former userFormer user14y ago#12
paper was as tough as expected , management buyout question was almost copy of bpp kit question, but time was not enough , it was too lengthy. examiners should consider of increasing atleast half an hour more
Former userFormer user14y ago#13
I agree it was fair but time was a challenge
Former userFormer user14y ago#14
too hard to complete paper in the given time. q1 is fair as compare to past papers.
q2 was also time consuming ....in req fall nd incrase both asked instead of a single req
q3 was so easy and also not time consuming but I feel req b was little difficult
q4...my friend attempted not me nd he said it is just like vanilla flavoured ice cream
q5 was on tbl. very nfamiliar topic for p4 students so easy ..nt time consuming.....but few students know what is tbl...

overall paper was same as compare to last attempt easy but time consuming. .which makes it hard...


in the end I want to say that I hate vanilla flavoured ice cream
Former userFormer user14y ago#15
I attempted 100 marks full paper.......wow
Former userFormer user14y ago#16
Q1 was a long text with some figures, no paragrafs, no space. It was no easy to see all the figure uder presure of time. :(
Former userFormer user14y ago#17
i messed the options completely!q1 too lengthy!!
Former userFormer user14y ago#18
no doubt an easy 1 but time is the factor n also this may easy from examiner?
Former userFormer user14y ago#19
The general consensus is that time is a limiting factor to which I endorse. The paper was a challenging one...Question 1 in particular took some time to evaluate. I would like to know however if within question 1 part a. the evalution of the decision to stop the production of the X-IT immediately required a Black Scholes calculation since what I understood was that the decision could be one to abandon which is akin to a put option and would need a Black Scholes evaluation. ANY ONE INTERPETED THIS ALSO????
Former userFormer user14y ago#20
i thought p4 was challenging as always.Howevver i attempted all parts of the four questions Praying that i will pull through. last paper for me. Thanks to open tuition for the continued help. q5 was WHAT? TBL DID NOT ATTEMPT. Q2 nice question but made some errors. Q1 time consuming. Q3 and Q4 tricky.
A word of advice to persons wishing to attempt p4 next sitting. Start listening to open tuition lectures and course notes from now. dont waste time.
Former userFormer user14y ago#21
fair , can do paper . Leave it to the Almighty now .
Former userFormer user14y ago#22
@melly1982 said:
The general consensus is that time is a limiting factor to which I endorse. The paper was a challenging one...Question 1 in particular took some time to evaluate. I would like to know however if within question 1 part a. the evalution of the decision to stop the production of the X-IT immediately required a Black Scholes calculation since what I understood was that the decision could be one to abandon which is akin to a put option and would need a Black Scholes evaluation. ANY ONE INTERPETED THIS ALSO????

from my view we does not require to calculate BSOP as the information for BSOP is limited eg : no volatility available
by the way try to look at question name AVTO in the BPP Kit. the question is similar to this
Former userFormer user14y ago#23
@melly1982 said:
The general consensus is that time is a limiting factor to which I endorse. The paper was a challenging one...Question 1 in particular took some time to evaluate. I would like to know however if within question 1 part a. the evalution of the decision to stop the production of the X-IT immediately required a Black Scholes calculation since what I understood was that the decision could be one to abandon which is akin to a put option and would need a Black Scholes evaluation. ANY ONE INTERPETED THIS ALSO????


There's not enough information to calculation using BSOP. Just use normal NPV taking into account the lost contribution will do.
Former userFormer user14y ago#24
questions were fair and topics pretty much expected as per articles on student accountant. i was happy through the reading time to see familiar areas being tested but Q1 took awful 2 hours of time........ what should i expect now. quick scanning of my answer sheet towards the end gave me some hope of 50 marks though....... time pressure must be addressed by examiner...... i mean at this level what's the use of including too much arithmetic just to consume time..... spread sheet is available at work....... c'mon examiner!
Former userFormer user14y ago#25
@melly1982 said:
The general consensus is that time is a limiting factor to which I endorse. The paper was a challenging one...Question 1 in particular took some time to evaluate. I would like to know however if within question 1 part a. the evalution of the decision to stop the production of the X-IT immediately required a Black Scholes calculation since what I understood was that the decision could be one to abandon which is akin to a put option and would need a Black Scholes evaluation. ANY ONE INTERPETED THIS ALSO????


I believe it was an APV calculation, especially as we were given enough enough information to ungear the equity beta. The loan subsidy was another clue.
Llincon14y ago#26
..Im not an Expert but just a student - that paper was easy yet impossible for me to complete.... I think answering 3 questions in this paper will be more fair for us Students. I hope ACCA does something abt this in the future...otherwise the paper was simple just time pressured...
Former userFormer user14y ago#27
I agree.... the first time I've had to leave questions out of an exam. Time just disappeared! I fear another attempt in June will be necessary :(
Former userFormer user14y ago#28
I found the paper challanging and time presssured. I attempted all questions and was strict with time allocation but had to leave them all unfinished... it's frustrating when I know I was reasonably well prepared and would have done much better with more time or not so many questions...
Former userFormer user14y ago#29
I really appreciate the new examiner Shishir Malde. His question style for the past two sittings are very fascinating and they give new insight and very nice model answers, which I really enjoy. Yet the past sittings questions are quite time pressured and a bit unfair for people who can't process information quickly.

But this time it's a fair paper. I am hoping to read his model answers, I always get impressed to read his answers, clear and well explained, logical and to the point.
Former userFormer user14y ago#30
Shishir Malde also is an examiner who sticks to the P4 syllabus and not like Bob Ryan who's tired of P4 syllabus and wish to show off and introduce higher level questions which are out of the syllabus at some time probably but I do not know the whole picture.

I think it's really a balance to strike for ACCA to consider. If more minutes are added to administer the exam the fees for paying invigilators, premises, or even for the markers (because they will need to spend more time marking longer script) will be higher but we students will suffer more if we retake because we need to pay for tuition fees maybe, if not on self study, new book if syllabus revised etc and settle for lower pay again because of under qualified. Yet if ACCA wants to raise the bar on the quality of the affiliates through exam questions I sincerely think ACCA should include newer skills and knowledge forming just a small fair percentage of the exam questions and separately included as a 3 mark or so in a question so that well prepared students won't get stuck in the middle of interpreting this hard element in order to continue the whole question therefore making them fail. And so that this proportion of knowledge act to distinguish excellent students from weaker students, but do not fail the ordinary, reasonably well prepared students. This will be included in revision kit question bank and let the students learn new insights, while staying within the P4 designated syllabus.