SBL*** P3 June 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Hi
Please can some of you tell me how today's P3 exam went and what topics, questions you had?
I was meant to sit this exam today but only realised 2 days ago that I never registered - yep, too bad but it's too late to get angry about it. So yeah I am being curious.
Thanks guys.
It was ok - Time pressured but overall a fair paper.
Decision Trees came up for 14 marks which threw me a bit.
Also popping up was Porter's Diamond and Ansoff's Matrix.
I kind a mess up the decision tree. So which option should be chosen X or Y?
14 marks for a decision tree T___T
I went for Option Y as it had the greater probability of a positive return on investment and had a lower intial capital outlay. Not sure if i'm right though!
I went for option x. I got that it made a profit of 0.6m where as option y made a loss of 0.1m.
I could be wrong as well though!
I think when there is 0.8 chance of something happening and then it splits off into 0.5 chance of 2 posibilities you have to multiply 0.8 by 0.5=0.4
Been a while since I studied these in depth so I'm not 100% sure.
The paper was time pressured but I got something down for all parts so hopeful of passing.
Q2 was issues with controls surrounding Information technology and Information systems.
Also ethical dilemma of investing in a country with not many regulaions
Q4 was Porters Diamond about investing in another country
Q3 was POPIT model which I din't know so didn't answer
Just ensure you read the entire syllabus so no surprises.
Hmm I got the expected value of 0.6m for option X but I got a higher profit for Option Y.. So I choose option Y. I am a bit confuse on the low demand. Not sure if I did it correctly. Due to the time pressure I am scared that I pluck the wrong figure :(
14m is really quite a lot for the decision tree :(
Anyway what do we need to do in question 1(a)? I kind a loss there as well :(
The questions for the Case Study is quite lengthy >_<
For question 4(b) the strategic, organization & operation problem. What do we need to highlight there?
does anyone remember the cost of option y?
I think x was 6 million and y was 4 million. not sure whats the order but im sure one was 6 and one was 4
I had the same workings as you, but i got net profit 1.8 for x and 1.82 for y ( the one with the lower intital investment). so i think i went to select y
below are my workings
h. l
x. 2. 0.5
y. 1. 0.75
x cost -6
HH 0.2(2*6)=+2.4
LH/ LL (0.8((0.5*3)+((0.5*(2*3)+0.5*(0.5*3)))=+4.2
x=0.6
y cost -4
HH 0.2(1*6)=+1.2
LH/ LL (0.8((0.75*3)+((0.5*(1*3)+0.5*(0.75*3)))=+3.9
y=1.1
I messed up, I included the initial outlay of 6m/4m in each in each outcome, which I guess isn't correct.
The high high outcome was the joint probably. I interpret this as if you get one high ie 0.2*6 you are guarenteed to get a high next go ie 1*6 so xP(x) is 7.2. However I then took off the initial 6 so my answer was 1.2 for high high, which is wrong.
I dunno, past papers seem to suggest most of the points are for the discussion rather than the tree itself, I'm trying not to worry about it because I wrote quite a lot so maybe ill pick up marks there
Tough but I think I will scrap through 50%
LH/ LL (0.8((0.5*3)+((0.5*(2*3)+0.5*(0.5*3)))=+4.2
Are we supposed to use 80%x50% first and then 0.5 or is the above working correct?
My 1b answer same as you.. fivedollar
Q1(a) im not sure what im writing, hopefully i could scrap some marks from it
(b) decision tree, looks ok, some calculation, and some discussion about the weakness of trees, like the option X and option Y risk is different ..Due to the high demand cash flow and low demand cash flow, option Y has more steady cash flow
(c) very long and lengthy question
original receivables is 49 days and payables 24 days , adjusting it both to 30 days will realised about 589k from receivable , 134k from payables, add retained earning 775000 and will only gives you around 1.5m cash, which is still far away even cheapest option Y, since gearing ratio only 32%, pumping 1.7m cash into the company will become 60% gearing ratio, looks ok since 55% is the standard rate
stock issue is not an option because shareholder against it , they want retain control
however, even when loans of 1.7m has taken , only 3.2m raised , still 800k left, so the only last option is to persuade the current shareholder to buy more shares, in order to raise fund and retain their power
Q2(a) Wonderful question for those who is pro in IT, simply suggest solution for the weakness
(b) corporate governance! first CG question appeared in P3, the issue would be since the SRO website is relying on sponsored link and advertisement for revenue (keeping the website alive) , but it doesn't actually gives feedback to those company who advertised it , or sponsored link, since the scenario says the online shopping has grown number of unethical seller ...it only evaluate FEATURED company..not from the avertisement or sponsor link
another ethic concern will be moving to foreign land, this may lead to worse condition , unethical trading is even worse as corruption is bad, unauthorised payment could be paid
Q4(a)
Portal diamond
Factor condition
skilled labour, easy access to building materials
demand condition
strong presence of market for Engin
Supply related industry
Theres problem finding environment experts
Rivalry
This is the STRENGTH of Engin as intence competition shape Engin into strong competitor , before they are ready for global market
Thats all my 2 cents thoughts
Ugggh I didn't see the numbers to make the calcs for payables days etc. Big fat fail then
How should we answer question 1(a) Forgot about the question but something related to the Quadrant B C D? & Ques 4(b): Strategic, Operation and Organizational Problem?
1a related to new product development on current market, new market development with current product and related diversification (new product on the new market), all have to be connected with SWOT analysis provided and comments from the CEO.
Hi there. How did you draw up the decision Tree?
I'm pretty sure Q2b was regarding only the ethical concerns for the company moving to foreign land ... as that's what I answered ?
Again not proud od myself, not even going through correct answers, for example I concluded that in Q1 b option Y is worthwhile, so probably not a good choice... don't want to bring myself down. All I can say it was all in syllabus, so I can only blame myself. In 5 weeks I will be one stressed lady...
For question 1 I pretty much was leaning on a new complementary product range for the existing market for b. For c I was looking at exporting and acquisitions for d. Was anyone on similar lines?
Agnescu, dont worry, somebody tryied exam in fourth time, like me?
I've choosen for d quadrant joint venture or licensing to\with conditioner supplier, since acquisition is not wellcomed by shareholders and lack of expertise on export in the past.
If I not mistaken, the marks are as followed:
1) 18m
2) 14m
3) 14m
Prof marks-4m
As SRO did not add disclaimer that it only evaluates FEATURED company, so people would have false trust on SRO that anything that pasted on the website is a good company
Lengthy exam! I am not comfortable with such type of exams! i choose q 2 & 4. Regarding the result we will see it in the 18th of July!@@@@
@alistarr said: I'm pretty sure Q2b was regarding only the ethical concerns for the company moving to foreign land ... as that's what I answered ?As SRO did not add disclaimer that it only evaluates FEATURED company, so people would have false trust on SRO that anything that pasted on the website is a good company
Decision tree was asked for 14 marks. I was not prepared for that. I attempted q2 and q4. Q2a was okay. Q2 b was tough.it was asking ethical dilemma. I could not find one reason for ethical dilemma. Q4 a was easy. Porter diamond. Q4 b was horrible. I might fail.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

