Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBR*** P2 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share here with community your comments about June 2011 P2 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll

*** P2 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user15y ago#61
I did not attempted that particular Ribby question
hence no advantages to me.

My whole q1 can be said as a failure

I hope I can get at least 20-25% from there

and get 25-30% from Section B

Iionela200915y ago#62
I have to agree that first question was manageable in terms of time and requirements, but still I could not balance and I did mistakes with the new 10% acquisition. In my mind was coming only gain and I calculated the gain which si totally wrong, but anyway.....
question 2 industry question was quite horrible, first time when I read it I was thinking of skiping then I saw the last question and I could not remember to many things about financial instruments and I thought the second question is a better option for me. The topics were quite mixed here: IAS 37, Research and development costs (I still cannot remember the standard number), IFRS 3 and IFRS 1
question 3 to me looked like Alexandra is a very stupid girl: first of all she messed up with the employee benefits, then she recongnized totally unacceptable the revenue and she discloses to related parties only what she thinks it should be not what the standard requires. and finnally that bond was on the top of everthing: anyway, I am not sure waht was tested there, maybe substance over form? anyway, the legal contract was to repay the loan and accrued interest, so i do not think that it should still be in long term liability. for me it sounded like the waiver is just for the interest part but the legal clause in contract should be first. I am not sure about it.
Overall, I hope I will get the passing grade.....it is a huge area to be tested in P2, and I have practiced some questions and watch videos here, but I feel that i still need some practice....I feel like these topics should be digested over time with a lot of practice, meaning actually being involved in the process....I found the Deloitte IAS plus tool with scenarios quite good for preparation of the exam too.
Let's hope for better...
Former userFormer user15y ago#63
in question 1 part c i put about human capital management and how whilst employees/staff are assets to a business, they are not capitalised as they don't meet the framework condition, i.e. a member of staff can leave at any point, it is not a resource that an entity can control.

i also put that brands can't be capitalised by a company if internally generated but if acquired as part of an acquisition they can (?????????) but in this case as the company was arguing they already knew the customers it was not clear if this should be taken into consideration of the purchase price etc....

also for anyone that did question 3, did you put about provisions and contingent liabilities in part a, as Alexandra had an 'obligation' to pay the loan and interest in full...

I NEED 50, no more no less...
Former userFormer user15y ago#64
was the foreign sub not 52% owned or have i made a school boy error.
Former userFormer user15y ago#65
Question 1 was ok. Not the perfect answer but very similar to June 2008 question. Nice one Graham Holt. Section B was very very tricky. praying for a pass. Overall.....the paper was just ok.
Former userFormer user15y ago#66
Foreign sub was 52% owned.
Former userFormer user15y ago#67
gilidy was talking bout the 40% cost and expenses in $ and remainder in dinars

something like tat
Former userFormer user15y ago#68
yes that is what i was talking about the cost and expenses.

And the loan in ques 3. that was default i made a silly mistake i think it is an extinguishment of the original financial liabilty the terma of the payments were modified...........
Former userFormer user15y ago#69
well lets hope for 50!

30 marks (hopefully) for 1 and then 20 somewhere else!
Former userFormer user15y ago#70
@tzxsean said:
gilidy was talking bout the 40% cost and expenses in $ and remainder in dinars
Oh that. I don't think it had anything to do with the consolidated SFP. I used it to answer the first part of Q1. 40% in $ but 60% in local currency dinars so dinars functional currency as it is majority. Hope it works for me. Hehehe

Kkizrr15y ago#71
Basically, this paper was "easy" if you had revised all the past papers and taken into account the tips your tutors gave you if you went to a college. martin from lsbf pretty much told us what was coming up. IFRS 9 and foreign sub....

it was hard if you didnt do much basically.........

peace
Former userFormer user15y ago#72
very predictable paper with the exceptions of Q2 n Q3 which were confusing.Hope i need enough to make it through..insha allah
Former userFormer user15y ago#73
I agree. It was Ok, but wait for the examiner to make his final decision.
Former userFormer user15y ago#74
Group Consolidated with two subs and one was foreign.

One had increase in the control.
Former userFormer user15y ago#75
waz an ok paper..exchange Q waz expected ..and it did come up ..rest of the Qs were as normal p2 specialty..ifrs 9, financial instruments, post balance sheet events and so on...m quite satisfied with my progress...
Former userFormer user15y ago#76
Consol was easy enough however i can't manage to balance it. overall paper was gone o.k. but still confuse whether or not i can achieve pass mark.
Former userFormer user15y ago#77
For this paper, I felt I could do all the questions, but I still couldn't complete.
Former userFormer user15y ago#78
i really hope for a pass paper here after resit for several time.

i did all question except Q4, last part. for Q1, i did not fulfill Retained earning figures when i found the time allocated to Q1 ended.
Former userFormer user15y ago#79
it was predictable and the exmanier him self said that IFRS 9 will feature in da exame (PQ magazine) but we should be careful da marking my be tough, i dont like this kind of examas i would prefer it difficult and to struggle for marks then marking would be gentle on us, i just didnt like it, im not feeling comfortable about it
Former userFormer user15y ago#80
I think that there is an excess of confidence in some commentators.
If you find an ACCA paper easy it will probably mean that you have not picked up some tricky issues that were put in the middle of a sentence with no apparent risk.
This is particularly true in P2 where Mr Holt is an specialist in hiding standards.
Former userFormer user15y ago#81
@marquitus said:
I think that there is an excess of confidence in some commentators.
If you find an ACCA paper easy it will probably mean that you have not picked up some tricky issues that were put in the middle of a sentence with no apparent risk.
This is particularly true in P2 where Mr Holt is an specialist in hiding standards.


that exactly what i am afraid of and makes me feel uncomfortable, it just like there is still much to be done in my answers and i cant figure it out
inshaalla '7air
Former userFormer user15y ago#82
Q 1: ok but a lot of ambiguity in the other sections, in the real world accountants can have discussion with clients …why hide the standards… paper very academic not relevant in the business world….
Former userFormer user15y ago#83
In Q2 the part on Provisoins - did anyone have project 2 as a provision & project 1 disallowed to be provided for ?

Also in Q2 the part on Intangibles - did you use the criteria MAATIE ?
Former userFormer user15y ago#84
can anyone remember what was in the Q3 part (c)? Thx
Former userFormer user15y ago#85
I agree Section B is really tricky, and really confused. i messed up.
Aahoatran15y ago#86
Q1 part c..... wtf? I read this over about 5 times. What were they asking?!
I wrote that its normal in business to try and buy something for cheaper or up to a maximum of what you are willing to pay.
But the owners dont have to sell if the price isn't right. What was the ethical issue here?
Former userFormer user15y ago#87
Q1 was almost identical to Ribby. What were the ethical issues in Q1c? Questions 2 & 3 were just too confusing.Strangely he revealed the standards in Q3.
Former userFormer user15y ago#88
i wrote that the acquiror should measure the aquiree net asst at fair value, not underestimate the acquiree and to add some flavour i mention objectivity, integrity, doing the right thing "the parent company's management may perceive buying a sub as a bargain is doning "the rigth thing" for their company, meanwhile it is not ethically acceptable"
im not sure :(
Former userFormer user15y ago#89
pehle 42 number to halwa ta yar
NSnicky shaw15y ago#90
Truly speaking the examiner was generous even i cannot i passed.i made a lot of mistakes because i panicked.P2 is alsways terrifying